Malay Master Plan for Tourism- Final Report

Workshop Results: NAME DESIGNATION OFFICE/AGENCY GROUP NO: 4 Group Members Jomites _______ OWMM LGU 1. Sol Sejane 2. Carolina S. Andrade 3. Nenia C. Galan Suuny Villanueva OMM – Security LGU-Malay 4. Rhea P. Ralandra 5. Analyn Lim Ibab 6. Gefran S. Tamboon Catherine J. Babiorn OSB LGU 7. Arlene T. Bansuli 8.Christine Hope D. Pagsuguiron Edgardo R. Sancho E.O-V LGU-Malay 9. Issa Angela P. Cahilig Catherine Tumaco Planning Officer II LGU-Malay VISION/GOALS ALTERNATIVE FRAMEWORK STRATEGIES Neua Aron Tourism Officer I LGU-Malay Vision of Malay 1 2 3 4 1. Premier international tourist destination city 15 24 24 9 Niño Paulo A. Siñor Planning Officer I LGU-Malay 2. Sustainable 18 22 21 13 3. World-class 21 23 19 10 4. Enriched cultural heritage 11 5 14 0 Total 65 74 78 32 Average 7.2 8.2 8.7 3.5 Municipality of Malay 281 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

GROUP NO: 5 GROUP NO: 6 Group Members Group Members 1. Leonard Richie Billones 1. Victor E. Supetran 2. Diana Joy M. Kimpo 2. Ernel P. Casidsid 3. Elisa Escobar 3. Jimmy G. Solano 4. Rene Avila Jr. 4. Abegail M. Cazizo 5. Aldrin Carag 5. Gemma I. Baon 6. Ed Sancho 7. Ralf Toldsa VISION/GOALS ALTERNATIVE FRAMEWORK STRATEGIES 8. Jose A. Oczon Jr. Vision of Malay 1 2 3 4 VISION/GOALS ALTERNATIVE FRAMEWORK STRATEGIES 1. Premier international tourist destination city 7 10 14 7 Vision of Malay 1 2 3 4 2. Sustainable 11 13 14 8 1. Premier international tourist destination city 17 15 17 11 3. World-class 12 11 13 9 2. Sustainable 15 16 19 12 4. Enriched cultural heritage 10 8 10 10 3. World-class 16 15 18 12 Total 40 42 51 34 4. Enriched cultural heritage 18 15 18 13 Average 8 8.4 10.2 6.8 Total 66 61 71 48 Average 9.43 8.71 10.14 6.86 282 Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism

GROUP NO: 7 GROUP NO: 8 Group Members Group Members 1. Alvine A. Castillo 1. Mayloudy S. Prado 2. Felixberto A. Candari VII 2. Helen P. Rejuso 3. Jake S. Sullano 3. Domingo P. Rejuso 4. Ian S. Niel 4. Solomon S. Prado 5. Elfie C. Casidsid 5. Lalinae B. Taunan 6.Chimald Vilanacor 6. Alonia F. Perucho 7. Alono S. Refugio 7. Monina D. Aguirre 8. Alreen S. Dela Torre 8. Francis C. Corral 9. Efren A. Rebustes 9. Mike C. Sinec 10. Alex N. Nadisra VISION/GOALS ALTERNATIVE FRAMEWORK STRATEGIES VISION/GOALS ALTERNATIVE FRAMEWORK STRATEGIES Vision of Malay 1 2 3 4 Vision of Malay 1 2 3 4 1. Premier international tourist destination city 26 20 25 17 1. Premier international tourist destination city 12 16 14 13 2. Sustainable 25 21 22 17 2. Sustainable 12 16 12 12 3. World-class 24 20 20 17 3. World-class *13 16 13 10 4. Enriched cultural heritage 23 19 19 19 4. Enriched cultural heritage 9 16 12 11 Total 98 80 86 71 Total 46 64 51 46 Average 10.9 8.9 9.6 7.9 Average 7.6 10.6 8.5 7.7 Municipality of Malay 283 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

GROUP NO: 9 GROUP NO: 11 Group Members Group Members 1. Wilbec M. Geuto 1. Jerry Agtoto 2. Juliet Aron 2. Saira Jeanne B. Reportado 3. Mario Rio Rosales 3. Orlie S. Villanueva 4. Ligaya C. Aparicio 4. Evan Alianra 5. Rigoberto Gelito Jr. 5. Felimm Abayon 6. Al Sacapano 6. Jerry Villanueva 7. Rigoberto Gelito III 7. Grace O. Salibio 8. Alfredo G. Justo 8. Cathrine J. Pabiona 9.Anneli C. Sespeire VISION/GOALS ALTERNATIVE FRAMEWORK STRATEGIES VISION/GOALS ALTERNATIVE FRAMEWORK STRATEGIES Vision of Malay 1 2 3 4 Vision of Malay 1 2 3 4 1. Premier international tourist destination city 17 19 20 13 1. Premier international tourist destination city 26 23 30 9 2. Sustainable 19 20 20 15 2. Sustainable 23 22 28 28 3. World-class 19 22 20 11 3. World-class 15 23 31 9 4. Enriched cultural heritage 15 14 9 6 4. Enriched cultural heritage 20 7 22 21 Total 70 75 69 45 Total 84 75 111 67 Average 8.7* 9.3 8.5 5.6 Average 7 6.25 9.25 5.58 284 Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Minutes GROUP NO: 12 Form Title MINUTES OF THE MEETING Group Members INTERNAL 1. Eden Bautista Date 6/13/2018 EXTERNAL 2. Myra D. Oczon Client/ Company/ School/ Organization Contact Person: Alma Belejerdo 3. Luneta T. Tumaon Municipal Government of Malay Contact No. Project Name/Activity 4. Cesar P. Oczon Jr. Malay, Aklan Master Plan for Tourism Project Location/ Company Address 5. Mariane S. Saluacion Malay, Aklan Email: 6. Al Lumagon Project No.: 171056 Venue: Malay, Aklan Time Started: 8:00 Time Finished: 14:00 7. Christopher O. Casuncad AGENDA: Second Public Consultation 8. Jona A. Solano ATTENDEES 9. Sencia V. Quinto Name Company Name Company Name Company 1. EnP. Abbey Bravo Palafox Associates 6.Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. Palafox Associates 11. 2. Ar./EnP. Raina Lim Palafox Associates 7. Ar./EnP. Encarnacion Raralio Palafox Associates 12. VISION/GOALS ALTERNATIVE FRAMEWORK STRATEGIES 3. EnP. Bea Camemo Palafox Associates 8. TWG Members 13. 4. Mr. John Michael Elritz Gallo Palafox Associates 9. Malay Stakeholders 14. Vision of Malay 1 2 3 4 5. Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen Palafox Associates 10. 15. SUMMARY Item Discussed Action/Responsible Party Remarks/Due Date 1. Premier international tourist destination city 14 23 18 5 Following the first public consultation held last March 2018, a second public consultation was held last June 13 in order to present to key stakeholders the different framework options and choose their preferred one. 2. Sustainable 16 16 19 9 During the first parts of the public consultation, the Palafox team made it clear for the participants about the company’s involvement and the limitations of their scope of work, hence clarifying it to them that detailed studies such 3. World-class 20 17 14 6 as environmental studies, hydrological studies, among others were not part of the scope. Mr. Ed Sancho’s opening remarks reassured to the locals that whatever the National Government is doing has nothing to 4. Enriched cultural heritage 17 14 18 3 do with the LGU, although the planning shall be aligned with the direction that the National Government is heading. And that since this undertaking with the team is the LGU’s action, there should be more active participation among the key stakeholders and locals. Total 67 70 69 23 The results of the previous public consultation were also discussed with the participants. The result from the workshops showed promising results as locals and stakeholders’ concerns are not only limited to tourism. Each barangay’s Average 8.4 8.8 8.6 2.9 development challenges and constraints were also explained, making it known to them that with the do-nothing scenario, Boracay’s tourism will definitely go down as more of its natural resources are depleted. Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. discussed the TRIP components followed by the video presentation. His discussion tackled about the mainland Malay’s inability to catch Boracay’s tourists and encourage them to explore other parts of the Municipality as well. In line with this, he mentions that having good connectivity within the mainland and also between the mainland and Boracay may prove to be advantageous for the mainland’s tourism. He also mentioned that the Philippine standards are just a minimum, and they are not even up to par with the international codes. Explaining the Development Constraints and Challengers, Ar. EnP Encarnacion Raralio started with the evolution of tourism areas, citing examples of similar developments. According to her, a popular tourist destination can get into a stagnant phase, which is where Boracay is now. With a “do-nothing” scenario, the stagnancy may continue, or it may eventually lead to a closure, just like the current situation of Boracay Island. Tourism should only be a kick-off for the community to be able to build up necessary public facilities such as institutions, schools, hospitals, social welfare, and many others, creating a more holistic community for the locals, as well as for the visitors. Page 1 of 6 Cc: Prepared by: Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen/Ms. Eliza Jane Leaño PALAFOX ASSOCIATES l PALAFOX ARCHITECTURE 5F PCCI Corporate Center, 118 L.P. Leviste St., Salcedo Village, Makati City, 1227 Metro Manila, Philippines T: +632.812.12.54 to 55 | F: +632.893.91.97 | [email protected] | www.palafoxassociates.com l www.palafoxarchitecture.com SP-F-02 Rev. # 07 Effectivity Date: 19 January 2016 Municipality of Malay 285 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Form Title MINUTES OF THE MEETING Form Title MINUTES OF THE MEETING INTERNAL Date 6/13/2018 INTERNAL Date 6/13/2018 EXTERNAL EXTERNAL Client/ Company/ School/ Organization Client/ Company/ School/ Organization Contact Person: Alma Belejerdo Contact Person: Alma Belejerdo Municipal Government of Malay Municipal Government of Malay Project Name/Activity Contact No. Project Name/Activity Contact No. Malay Aklan Master Plan for Tourism Malay Masterplan for Tourism Project Location/ Company Address Project Location/ Company Address Email: Malay, Aklan Email: Malay, Aklan Project No.: 171056 Venue: Malay, Aklan Time Started: 8:00 Time Finished: 14:00 Project No.: 171056 Venue: Malay, Aklan Time Started: 8:00 Time Finished: 14:00 AGENDA: Second Public Consultation AGENDA: Second Public Consultation ATTENDEES ATTENDEES Name Company Name Company Name Company Name Company Name Company Name Company 1. EnP. Abbey Bravo Palafox Associates 6.Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. Palafox Associates 11. 1. EnP. Abbey Bravo Palafox Associates 6.Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. Palafox Associates 11. 2. Ar./EnP. Raina Lim Palafox Associates 7. Ar./EnP. Encarnacion Raralio Palafox Associates 12. 2. Ar./EnP. Raina Lim Palafox Associates 7. Ar./EnP. Encarnacion Raralio Palafox Associates 12. 3. EnP. Bea Camemo Palafox Associates 8. TWG Members 13. 3. EnP. Bea Camemo Palafox Associates 8. TWG Members 13. 4. Mr. John Michael Elritz Gallo Palafox Associates 9. Malay Stakeholders 14. 4. Mr. John Michael Elritz Gallo Palafox Associates 9. Malay Stakeholders 14. 5. Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen Palafox Associates 10. 15. 5. Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen Palafox Associates 10. 15. SUMMARY SUMMARY Item Discussed Action/Responsible Party Remarks/Due Date Item Discussed Action/Responsible Party Remarks/Due Date After this was the presentation of the Postcards from the Future, which showed the Municipality’s potential to become After this was the presentation of the Postcards from the Future, which showed the Municipality’s potential to become more sustainable through use of non-polluting vehicles, wide use of renewable energies (i.e. solar, hydro, and wind). Tourist sustainable through use of non-polluting vehicles, wide use of renewable energies (i.e. solar, hydro, and wind). Tourist destinations within the Municipality must also have priority in terms of development. The frameworks were also destinations within the Municipality must also have priority in terms of development. The frameworks were also presented and explained to the participants in detail. presented and explained to the participants in detail. The discussion was followed by the workshop. Results showed that majority of the participants opt for Framework 3 The discussion was followed by the workshop. Results showed that majority of the participants opt for Framework 3 which maximizes the potential of the Municipality. However, for those that did not choose Framework 3, a common which maximizes the potential of the Municipality. However, for those that did not choose Framework 3, a common ground for them was because the preferred framework, though ideal, was far from reality. These people chose the other . ground for them was because the preferred framework, though ideal, was far from reality. These people chose the other . frameworks because these frameworks seem practical and feasible. On this note, the head of DepEd Region VI, frameworks because these frameworks seem practical and feasible. On this note, the head of DepEd Region VI, encouraged locals to think farther into the future and be open to change encouraged locals to think farther into the future and be open to change Farm tourism, which was included in the frameworks, also caught the interest of many. They warmly welcomed the idea Farm tourism, which was included in the frameworks, also caught the interest of many. They warmly welcomed the idea of introducing that into the Municipality, since this can uplift the agricultural sector, and increase tourism as well. of introducing that into the Municipality, since this can uplift the agricultural sector, and increase tourism as well. During the open forums, the key stakeholders expressed their concerns for the connectivity between Malay mainland and During the open forums, the key stakeholders expressed their concerns for the connectivity between Malay mainland and Boracay. While some favored having either bridge or cable car, majority worried over the decline of livelihood of many Boracay. While some favored having either bridge or cable car, majority worried over the decline of livelihood of many boatmen. Those who favored the bridge pointed out that it will be helpful during emergencies; many have died because boatmen. Those who favored the bridge pointed out that it will be helpful during emergencies; many have died because they cannot be transported from Boracay during emergencies. Furthermore, having a bridge will make logistics easier. they cannot be transported from Boracay during emergencies. Furthermore, having a bridge will make logistics easier. The opposition stated that while it is great to have a stable connection, there is the concern of the boatmen’s livelihood. The opposition stated that while it is great to have a stable connection, there is the concern of the boatmen’s livelihood. The team answered to this concern by stating that the cable car and the bridge will only act as supplementary The team answered to this concern by stating that the cable car and the bridge will only act as supplementary connection. Policies will be made to regulate the entry of vehicles into Boracay Island. Also, with the projected increase connection. Policies will be made to regulate the entry of vehicles into Boracay Island. Also, with the projected increase of tourist arrival in Boracay, eventually, the boats will not be able to cater to all, hence cable car connection will be of tourist arrival in Boracay, eventually, the boats will not be able to cater to all, hence cable car connection will be necessary. necessary. Another major concern of the locals is the 25+5 meter setback which was implemented in the Island. Residents are Another major concern of the locals is the 25+5 meter setback which was implemented in the Island. Residents are wondering whether the same coastal setback will be applicable to them. Should this be so, many residents will be wondering whether the same coastal setback will be applicable to them. Should this be so, many residents will be displaced. This concern gathered many negative feedback from the participants. The team answered that while it is true displaced. This concern gathered many negative feedback from the participants. The team answered that while it is true that there should be a coastal setback, it should comply with the Water Code of the Philippines. Having proper setback is that there should be a coastal setback, it should comply with the Water Code of the Philippines. Having proper setback is also a form of disaster mitigation, given that global warming is causing sea level to rise at a tremendous rate. also a form of disaster mitigation, given that global warming is causing sea level to rise at a tremendous rate. Page 2 of 6 Page 3 of 6 Cc: Prepared by: Cc: Prepared by: Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen/Ms. Eliza Jane Leaño Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen/Ms. Eliza Jane Leaño PALAFOX ASSOCIATES l PALAFOX ARCHITECTURE PALAFOX ASSOCIATES l PALAFOX ARCHITECTURE 5F PCCI Corporate Center, 118 L.P. Leviste St., Salcedo Village, Makati City, 1227 Metro Manila, Philippines 5F PCCI Corporate Center, 118 L.P. Leviste St., Salcedo Village, Makati City, 1227 Metro Manila, Philippines T: +632.812.12.54 to 55 | F: +632.893.91.97 | [email protected] | www.palafoxassociates.com l www.palafoxarchitecture.com T: +632.812.12.54 to 55 | F: +632.893.91.97 | [email protected] | www.palafoxassociates.com l www.palafoxarchitecture.com SP-F-02 Rev. # 07 Effectivity Date: 19 January 2016 SP-F-02 Rev. # 07 Effectivity Date: 19 January 2016 286 Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Form Title MINUTES OF THE MEETING Form Title MINUTES OF THE MEETING Date 6/13/2018 INTERNAL Date 6/13/2018 INTERNAL EXTERNAL EXTERNAL Client/ Company/ School/ Organization Contact Person: Alma Belejerdo Client/ Company/ School/ Organization Contact Person: Municipal Government of Malay Municipal Government of Malay Project Name/Activity Contact No. Project Name/Activity Contact No. Malay Masterplan for Tourism Malay Master Plan for Tourism Project Location/ Company Address Project Location/ Company Address Malay, Aklan Email: Mlay, Aklan Email: Project No.: 171056 Venue: Malay, Aklan Time Started: 8:00 Time Finished: 14:00 Project No.: 171056 Venue: Malay, Aklan Time Started: 8:00 Time Finished: 14:00 AGENDA: Second Public Consultation AGENDA: Seond Public Consultation ATTENDEES ATTENDEES Name Company Name Company Name Company Name Company Name Company Name Company 1. EnP. Abbey Bravo Palafox Associates 6.Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. Palafox Associates 11. 1. EnP. Abbey Bravo Palafox Associates 6.Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. Palafox Associates 11. 2. Ar./EnP. Raina Lim Palafox Associates 7. Ar./EnP. Encarnacion Raralio Palafox Associates 12. 2. Ar./EnP. Raina Lim Palafox Associates 7. Ar./EnP. Encarnacion Raralio Palafox Associates 12. 3. EnP. Bea Camemo Palafox Associates 8. 13. 3. EnP. Bea Camemo Palafox Associates 8. TWG Members 13. 4. Mr. John Michael Elritz Gallo Palafox Associates 9. 14. 4. Mr. John Michael Elritz Gallo Palafox Associates 9. Malay Stakeholders 14. 5. Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen Palafox Associates 10. 15. 5. Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen Palafox Associates 10. 15. SUMMARY SUMMARY Item Discussed Action/Responsible Party Remarks/Due Date Item Discussed Action/Responsible Party Remarks/Due Date Framework 2 1989 Masterplan was also from Palafox Agriculture and eco-tourism (sectors which is malay is known for) Suggested solutions: Plant high value crops • If find to violate rules such as encroachment, close the establishment and fix the problem then apply again for a permit Boracay – no drastic changes • Traffic: decongest through loading and unloading points - Recommendation – minimal changes. Retrofit existing structures to green architecture to be even more sustainable • Close first the establishments with violations - Proposed connection of boracay to malay - cable bar and enhancement of ports • Make a comprehensive drainage plan for the Municipality of Malay - Two ways to optimize agri • Remove the port because the white sand will become brown sand. The oil and feces are there which is why the fecal a. Plant high value crops coliform is high. b. Tourism industry – tap agri and rural landscape • Ask the coastguard to put oil spill boom for the oil will not penetrate the white sand - Univ town – old town (poblacion) is incorporated ( growth is downwards going to borwanga) • Designated port areas to control where the boats are, and possible occurrence of oil spill will be concentrated Also intermodal transport terminals are included for tourist spots to be more accessible in one place Strengthen service industries in partnership to the university town • Proposed 150-hectare hotel and 23-hectare hotel casino (DOT DILG AND DENR BORA IS OVERDEVELOPED ALREADY) Framework 3 a. 150 hectares is existing already (fairway, blue coast) Strengthened urbanization and creation of new urban growth magnets b. 23 hectares already bought but will make sure they will follow existing regulations a. Additional business centers and BPOs to invite investors Palafox Associates clarified the following: Framework 4 - Palafox is not aware of the proposed hotel casino more on development constraints - Public consultation is for visioning - The 50m easement is an international practice and it doesn’t necessarily mean it will be applied to Malay. Comments/Suggestions/Reactions from the Stakeholders The current situation should be assessed first - Urban planning is needed to save whatever it is needed and whatever it is left to be saved. - All areas should be developed so the entire Malay will experience an inclusive development Request to Palafox for faster consultation: - No natural light and air coming in due to congested buildings. - Plans and drawings should be more comprehensive If majority wouldn’t agree to the plan, what will be the step of the LGU? - Apply the 30m easement and 12m road for it to be easier to understand a. Communities are present but no present big investors What will happen to the residents - The plan is for the residents of Malay b. Justifications should be done as to why it is not approved No enough explanation as to where the other residents (minorities) will go. Will they be displaced? - Resistance during the initial planning stage is uncalled for; openness to the result of the plan should be practiced. - Some areas are not suitable for housing purposes/it is not habitable Question yourself if you are contented with the current situation of Boracay There are proposed roads that will run over existing residential areas. What is going to happen there? - Tourism going farther the education in the island deteriorates. - Further studies will be done - Do not blame each other because the deterioration of the island is the fault of everyone - Implementation will not be done if there are no solution yet - Revise the setback if people do not agree with the 50m, go back to 30m (25+5) What are the problems in Boracay? - If there is no money to fund the implementation, ask the President to fund it Page 4 of 6 Cc: Prepared by: Prepared by: Page 5 of 6 Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen/Ms. Eliza Jane Leaño Cc: Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen/Ms. Eliza Jane Leaño PALAFOX ASSOCIATES l PALAFOX ARCHITECTURE 5F PCCI Corporate Center, 118 L.P. Leviste St., Salcedo Village, Makati City, 1227 Metro Manila, Philippines PALAFOX ASSOCIATES l PALAFOX ARCHITECTURE T: +632.812.12.54 to 55 | F: +632.893.91.97 | [email protected] | www.palafoxassociates.com l www.palafoxarchitecture.com 5F PCCI Corporate Center, 118 L.P. Leviste St., Salcedo Village, Makati City, 1227 Metro Manila, Philippines T: +632.812.12.54 to 55 | F: +632.893.91.97 | [email protected] | www.palafoxassociates.com l www.palafoxarchitecture.com SP-F-02 Rev. # 07 Effectivity Date: 19 January 2016 SP-F-02 Rev. # 07 Effectivity Date: 19 January 2016 Municipality of Malay 287 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Form Title MINUTES OF THE MEETING INTERNAL Date 6/13/2018 EXTERNAL Client/ Company/ School/ Organization Contact Person: Alma Belejerdo Municipal Government of Malay Project Name/Activity Contact No. Malay Masterplan for Tourism Project Location/ Company Address Malay, Aklan Email: Project No.: 171056 Venue:Malay, Aklan Time Started: 8:00 Time Finished: 14:00 AGENDA: Second Public Consultation ATTENDEES Name Company Name Company Name Company 1. EnP. Abbey Bravo Palafox Associates 6.Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. Palafox Associates 11. 2. Ar./EnP. Raina Lim Palafox Associates 7. Ar./EnP. Encarnacion Raralio Palafox Associates 12. 3. EnP. Bea Camemo Palafox Associates 8. TWG Members 13. 4. Mr. John Michael Elritz Gallo Palafox Associates 9. Malay Stakeholders 14. 5. Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen Palafox Associates 10. 15. SUMMARY Item Discussed Action/Responsible Party Remarks/Due Date Comments on the Framework Framework 1 More realistic and practical It retains the clustering of the communities and focused on the development that is attainable Framework 2, 3 and 4 will cause a lot of displacement (a lot of consideration will be made) Framework 2 The forested area is too big and what should be done in the area is very specific The plan depends on the existing infrastructures Indigenous farm is included It opens a lot of opportunities for other barangays (to boost farm tourism) Pick and eat is being practiced in Aklan Promoted organic farming Herbs in Malay are medicinal herbs which could attract tourists Framewor 3 More infrastructure means more revenue It has various features that are appropriate to reach the vision Accessible; bridge connectivity which helps in terms of calamities and other hazards Feasible as compared to other frameworks There is sustainability and heritage conservation 1 and 4 criteria – international premiere tourist destination city and world class – it is not a priority because it is hard to implement Premiere international is doable Number 4 criteria is not specific Balanced and complete – from Caticlan to the boundary of Buruanga development and infrastructure is present Suitable to the current condition of Malay Page 6 of 6 Cc: Prepared by: Ms. Shermaine Anne Chen/ Ms. Eliza Jane Leaño PALAFOX ASSOCIATES l PALAFOX ARCHITECTURE 5F PCCI Corporate Center, 118 L.P. Leviste St., Salcedo Village, Makati City, 1227 Metro Manila, Philippines T: +632.812.12.54 to 55 | F: +632.893.91.97 | [email protected] | www.palafoxassociates.com l www.palafoxarchitecture.com SP-F-02 Rev. # 07 Effectivity Date: 19 January 2016 288 Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Stakeholders’ Consultation: Photo Documentation Registration started around 8 a.m. Some of the stakeholders are representatives from the Malay Natinal High School. Representatives from the different sectors came to the 2nd Public Consultation: Commencement of the event was officially opened by Municiapal Administrator Ed Stakeholders Consultation. Almost everyone was given the opportunity to introduce Sancho. themselves. Municipality of Malay 289 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

The hosts of the consultation- staff from Palafox Associates Ar. Felino “Jun” Palafox, Jr. presented the initial draft conceptual schemes and indicative design drawings of the T.R.I.P. components in a video presentation. Ar. Raina Christine Lim discussed the Malay Master Plan for Tourism T.R.I.P. Coneptual Some of the staff of Palafox Associates with their company president, Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. Schemes and Indicative Design Drawings in detail. 290 Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Some of the Malay LGU TWG members posing with Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. prior the event. Stakeholders from different sectors having a photo op with Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. Representatives from different educational institutions together with Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. Some of the stakeholders from the private sector posing for a photo op with Ar. Felino Palafox, Jr. Municipality of Malay 291 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Display of the different Tourism Development Strategy Framework Plans EnP. Bea Camemo presented the different frameworks for the selection workshop. The proposed bride with light railway connection. The stakeholders reviewing the proposed frameworks during the selection workshop. 292 Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Field Reports 6.2 Field Report 03 January 2018 - Mainland, Malay 03 January 2018 - Mainland, Malay 1 4 4 View of the Boracay Airport (Godofredo P. Ramos Airport). Buses are needed to provide transport from the plane towards the Arrivals area of the development. View of the Pier of Tabon Port. The existing signage of the port is on the pier. Recommendations: Optimize the bus route as a way to highlight and showcase other Recommendations: Enhance and redevelopment of the port, its supporting facilities, offers of the mainland and the signage of the development. Extension and expand of the pier can also be considered for the future. 2 3 Existing Municipal Complex. A view of the Malay Municipal office. Other Location of the Proposed Malay Commercial and Transport Terminal Complex ­ The existing condition of the Tabon Port and its pier. The roof is thatched and the developments within its proximity are church, covered court, and a multi­purpose the area is bounded by a major road and is several minutes away from the pier is mostly made of concrete. open space currently used as a parking area airport. Commercials to be seen in the future are small to medium scale. Recommendations: Enhance and redevelop the pier of the port. Also, provide and add View of the existing Tabon Port entrance pavilion and ticketing office. Recommendations: Provide a more pedestrian-centric complex that allows ease of Considerations: Consider the transport terminal as an intermodal transport terminal boat docks along the existing pier. This would also create a marina within the Recommendations: Enhance the look of the office and welcome pavilion of the Port. access towards the municipal building and its supporting structures that allows for other modes of transportation to be accessed development. Create a unique, identifiable, and memorable architecture for the Tabon Port Office. 4 5 Wayfinding and signage of the existing Tabon and Caticlan Jetty Port and Roro. These are the two ports used to connect to the Boracay Island Current construction of the proposed hospital within proximity of the Tabon Port View of the area of the expansion of the existing Caticlan Jetty Port. This portion of Recommendations: Enhance and redevelop signages of transport, utilities and service compound. the mainland is a reclaimed area. facilities to create ease of wayfinding by locals and tourists and create a sense of Considerations: The traffic that would be produced during Habagat Season would Considerations: Provide other modes of transportation upon arrival via Caticlan Jetty identity and branding for the area affect the building’s access network in terms of emergencies. Port, allowing tourists or users to have ease of access to explore and visit the tourism spots within the mainland as well as the Boracay Island Another view of the expansion site for the existing Caticlan Jetty Port. Municipality of Malay The Premier Tourist Destination 115 116 Municipality of Malay 293 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

04 January 2018 - Boracay Island 04 January 2018 - Boracay Island 1 1 13 13 One of the water catchment areas in Malay Mainland. During the Urduja Caticlan Jetty Port during a weekday (Wednesday) afternoon. Vehicular traffic accumulates in front of the port due to dropping off from vehicles. Cargo vehicular Typhoon, the water in this area overflowed. traffic is also through the same road as that used by vehicles for the purpose of transporting passengers. 2 Docking by the Cagban Jetty Port. Boats connect to the pier’s stairs. The architecture of the port is almost similar to the Caticlan Jetty Port. Lobby of Caticlan Jetty Port with seating areas provided for waiting passengers. Recommendations: Fencing the edge of the pier with see-through fences rather than View of the beach during low tide. Structured Developments are prominent and Recommendations: Highlight Malay’s other tourism spots within the lobby or where it objects that obstruct the view. Other solutions for the design of the fence could be dense along the beachfront areas. The beach is also populated even during View of Willy’s Rock which contains Mary’s Grotto. It is a popular spot for Catholic is easily seen by the on-going traffic of people going to Boracay. (we’ve seen one poster highlighting the natural beauty of Boracay and how to keep it that way or advertising the early hours of the day. devotees within the island. It is also used as a viewing deck to survey or acquire a by the tourism office) mainland’s other tourism spots. Recommendations: Retain the natural beauty and enhance condition of the beach. different vantage point of the beachfront. Current status of vehicular traffic along the main road in the Balabag town proper. Width of the road is approximately 6 meters and developments are already at the edge of the road. Waiting and seating areas for the passengers going back to the mainland via the Recommendations: Provide beach access roads among developments to allow views Hard Structured Developments are prominent and dense along the beach front The signage of the Ati Village located in Boracay Island. It is currently under a Cagban Jetty Port. and access to the beaches. areas of Boracay Island, specifically the white beaches along Station 1­3. private institution. 118 Municipality of Malay The Premier Tourist Destination 117 294 Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Form Title: FIELD REPORT FORM Form Title: FIELD REPORT FORM Date: January 3-5, 2018 Date: January 3-5, 2018 Client: Municipal Government of Malay Client: Municipal Government of Malay Client Person: 04 January 2018 - Boracay Island Client Person: Project Name: Malay Tourism Master Plan Contact No.: Project Name: Malay Tourism Master Plan Contact No.: Location: Malay, Aklan, Philippines Project No.: 171056 Location: Malay, Aklan, Philippines Project No.: 171056 6 5 Another catchment area within Barangay Yapak. The land has been established as a wetland by the DENR. The surrounding residential developments are affected and is flooded during rainy seasons. Recommendations: Enhance the wetland into an eco landscape area. Redevelop blue 13 An ongoing construction of a Hotel with an Oceanarium located near the shore of 13 alleys (bioswales or landscapes that function as landscape runoff pollution catchment) Puka Beach. towards the wetlands. 7 10 10 A panoramic view of Boracay Island and the mainland at the horizon from Mt. Luho viewing deck. Existing and current status of drainage system in Barangay Balabag, Boracay To alleviate flooding, improvised drains by the edges of the road were done to let Considerations: Preservation and maintaining cleanliness within the island should be made. Island. A pump is needed to manually pump the water out. the water flow towards that way. However no proper drainage has been done yet. 6 6 11 11 One of the access streets going to the beach. Existing developments flank both Boats for the island hopping can be found docked by the beach. Permanent sides of the small alley. The alley can only be accessed by pedestrians. Temporary structures and shelters are lined up along the coastline of Puka structures or developments are not found in this part of the island, and forested Recommendations: Blank walls allow more crime to be done within the area. See Beach. areas still bound the beach. A small one­way street catering the residential and commercial structures through fences or vegetation are more recommended and would lessen the crime and Considerations: Temporary structures like these should remain temporary and should Considerations: Maintain and preserve the forested areas bounding the beach. between the developments by the beach and by the internal road. The road is not vandalism throughout the whole alley. These also blocks the wind circulation. not encroach on the forested areas. Structures if there are any should remain temporary structures and not permanent. paved and floods during the rain. Presented by: Reviewed by: Approved by: Presented by: Reviewed by: Approved by: Raina Christine Lim Artlheene Rivera Artlheene Rivera Raina Christine Lim Artlheene Rivera Artlheene Rivera Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Municipality of Malay 120 The Premier Tourist Destination 119 Municipality of Malay 295 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Form Title: FIELD REPORT FORM Form Title: FIELD REPORT FORM Date: January 3-5, 2018 Date: January 3-5, 2018 05 January 2018 - Mainland Malay Client: Municipal Government of Malay Client Person: Client: Municipal Government of Malay Client Person: Project Name: Malay Tourism Master Plan Contact No.: Project Name: Malay Tourism Master Plan Contact No.: Location: Malay, Aklan, Philippines Project No.: 171056 Location: Malay, Aklan, Philippines Project No.: 171056 8 This area is known for hosting international events for wind surfing and 13 parasailing. View of the pier going to the terminal of the Cagban Jetty Port. Passengers departing the island queue outside while the passengers arriving go to the terminal. 9 1 1 An alternative port used during Habagat season in Boracay Island is the Tambisaan Jetty Port. There is a ticketing office and a waiting shed provided. One of the tourism spots in mainland Malay. The Malay Eco Park provides a Some of the boats are docked on shore, while a collection of the refuse is just nature retreat within the Municipality. It is currently being redeveloped. The park Some area within the Malay Eco Park showcasing nature. located adjacent to the waiting shed. has areas for photoshoots and events. A viewing deck and a butterfly haven Recommendations: Redevelopment of the park should include plants and herbs that Location of the proposed bridge connection to the mainland in Barangay Recommendations: Materials Recovery Facilities should be provided for proper could also be seen within the park. would show their scientific names and uses for educational purposes, however there is Manoc­manoc. This area of the beach is currently being used as a cargo port. disposal and away from the public eye. Recommendations: More activities to be provided within the development. no budget yet. The ticketing office of the Tambisaan Jetty Port. Similar to the Willy’s rock located at the white beaches, the port made use of the This is one of the road networks used to go to the Ati Village. The road is not paved The existing construction of the housing units. There are currently 9 out 20 units. Recommendations: Architecture of the support facilities of the development should be natural stone located at the area and provided viewing decks overlooking a and is still a dirt road. Due to the recent weather, the road is muddy. Considerations: Culture and heritage of traditional Ati houses should also be more unique, memorable, and identifiable. This helps in creating a brand and an image panoramic view of the beach and the islands near it. Recommendations: Better accessibility towards the Ati community. This would benefit considered upon designing these units. The families to be relocated are the ones for the ports that are used to and fro Boracay Island and the mainland. Recommendations: Redevelopment and enhancement of the support facilities. both the Village and the proposed vision of tourism within the Ati Village. designing the houses. Presented by: Reviewed by: Approved by: Presented by: Reviewed by: Approved by: Raina Christine Lim Artlheene Rivera Artlheene Rivera Raina Christine Lim Artlheene Rivera Artlheene Rivera Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: 122 Municipality of Malay The Premier Tourist Destination 121 296 Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism

Form Title: FIELD REPORT FORM Form Title: FIELD REPORT FORM Date: January 3-5, 2018 Date: January 3-5, 2018 Client: Municipal Government of Malay Client: Municipal Government of Malay Client Person: 05 January 2018 - Mainland Malay Client Person: Contact No.: Project Name: Malay Tourism Master Plan Project Name: Malay Tourism Master Plan Contact No.: Location: Malay, Aklan, Philippines Project No.: 171056 Location: Malay, Aklan, Philippines Project No.: 171056 6 8 Natural cold spring in Poblacion. It is also near the Pangihan Cave and can be trekked to after visiting this area. The spring however is contaminated with soaps and detergents, due to the lack of visitors in the area, the locals have used the spring as a wash basin. The area is also littered with discarded plastics of such. Recommendations: Clean up the area and rid of litter. Future trash should be disposed of accordingly. Provide a connection to the Pangihan Cave trail via nature hike trails or bike trails. Some of the community members of the Ati Village in Malay, Aklan. 5 7 3 3 The coastal road is along the shore and is envisioned to be one of the suggested locations for the Harbor City. Three of the 7 river resorts along the Nabaoy River. Some activities done within this Considerations: The natural ecology and the marine life should be considered within spot are river rafting and swimming. Due to recent flooding, some of the support facilities were destroyed, like the this area. Another suggested area for the Harbor City is near the Caticlan Airport. This is The existing tourism information center for the Agnaga Falls and Cold Spring built Recommendations: Maintain the serenity of the place by keeping the materials more dampa and some of the resorts. due to ease of access. by the LGU. The LGU and the owner of the lot have a MOA for 10 years. natural. Landscaping the surrounding resorts would help boost the attractiveness of the Recommendations: Enhance and redevelop the supporting facilities. Maintaining the place. Provide a bridge connection to the other side of the river. use of indigenous materials. Proper disposal of waste and trash to keep the river clean. 7 8 5 5 The trail going down to the Agnaga Falls and Cold Spring. The area is relatively small and could only accommodate a maximum of 20 pax. The Motag Living Museum is an interactive cultural museum, where the Considerations: Maximum capacity for the area should be considered and should not indigenous people role play and act their tradition and culture. The visit to this exceed. Support facilities like the nipa hut for resting and dining could be enhanced. museum however should be scheduled and be planned within the itinerary of the Provision of more of these facilities could also be considered for the future. tourists or visitors. The existing signage of the Pangihan Cave. The entrance to the Pangihan Cave. Recommendations: Redevelop and enhancement of signages and wayfinding towards Considerations: Capacity of the tourists and visitors going into the cave should be the cave. considered for the future development. Presented by: Reviewed by: Approved by: Presented by: Reviewed by: Approved by: Raina Christine Lim Artlheene Rivera Artlheene Rivera Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Raina Christine Lim Artlheene Rivera Artlheene Rivera Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Date of Inspection: January 3­5, 2018 Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Time of Inspection: Municipality of Malay The Premier Tourist Destination 123 124 Municipality of Malay 297 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

10.7 Field Report DAY 1 - 19 March 2018 1 Boracay Tubi System, Inc. (BTSI) 2 Boracay Island Water Company, Inc. (BIWC) In terms of water supply, the BTSI supplies a portion of the total consumers in Boracay Island. The company has only two (2) STPs in the Beside the property of the BIWC office, is a very narrow island located in Fairways Bluewater Newcoast Boracay. Only very few establishments are connected to the STP, including City Mall. access road going to the Bolabog beach 3 Barangay Balabag Aside from the hyper-urbanization of the barangay, other challenges were determined during the site visit like: Land Acquisition, and the Road-Right-Of-Way which the residents will not provide and give way to infrastructure projects. This is the barangay where most of the establishments have violated the sewerage and drainage policies and contributed to the extreme amount of coliform in the discharge. Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism Municipality of Malay 201 298 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

4 BTSI’s STP at Fairways Bluewater Newcoast Boracay This man-made lake is the last stage to the sewage treatment process at BTSI’s sewage treatment plant. The lake is underlined with carbon fiber sheets to prevent the waste water from penetrating the natural soil below and contanimate the aquifer. Observation: Some sheets have moved up to the surface which is a sign that it is damaged and there is a possibility that the waste water is leaking into the natural ground. Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism 202 Municipality of Malay 299 Malay Master Plan for Tourism

DAY 2 - 20 March 2018 1 Barangay Balusbos First photo: The access road to the Malay Elementary School; Second Photo: The Barangay Hall Observations: There is no drainage system in this coastal barangay. This contributed to the effects of the Typhoon Urduja. Another infrastructure issue is the lack of streetlights in some barangay roads. 2 Sanitary Landfill The sanitary landfill is located on the uplands at the border of Brgy. Kabulihan and Municipality of Buruanga. Observatrions: The management of the landfill and the system itself is poor. The current capacity of its treatment facility is not sufficient to accomodate the liquid discharge from the wastes. When it rains, the waste water from the aerobic chambers overflows into the open ground. The pump that they said is supposed to bring the waste water back up to the fill is non-functional. Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism 203 300 Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism

3 BIWC - Lakbayan First Photo: The Main water distribution supply pipe; Second Photo: the Aeration Chambers; Third Photo: Siltation Pond Obervations: Facilities in BIWC include: Pump Room, Sedimentation Tank, GFS, Clear Water Tank, Receiving Tank, MDC Room, Disinfection Room, Mobile Genset, Mobile Water Treatment (Desalination) Machine 4 Motag Living Museum A tour at the Motag Living Museum introduces you to the old ways of the early Boracaynons. It was choreographed by a British national who volunteered to help develop the place. First, the guides will take you to the deep well then to the bathroom and the toilet. Next, they will bring you to the bahay kubo where they will show the traditional culture and ways of living. Lastly, they will let you experience farm and community activities like planting rice, and making various rice products. Municipality of Malay Municipality of Malay 204 301 Malay Master Plan for Tourism Malay Master Plan for Tourism

List of Acronyms and Abbreviations AKELCO Aklan Electric Cooperative, Inc. DTI Department of Trade and Industry NTC National Telecommunications Commission ASEAN Association of South East Asian Nations EPR Enrolment Participation Rate NTP Notice to Proceed ATO Air Transportation Office GBPC Global Business Power Corporation NWRB National Water Resources Board ATV All-terrain Vehicle GCGI Green Core Geothermal Inc. OIC Officer in Charge BAC Bids and Awards Committee GDP Gross Domestic Product PAMB Protected Area Management Board BAYANTEL Bayan Telecommunications GSO General Services Office PANTELCO Panay Telephone Company BFP Bureau of Fire Protection Hon. Honorable PEDC Panay Energy Development Corporation BIWC Boracay Island Water Company, Inc. HLURB Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board PESO Public Employment Service Office BJMP Bureau of Jail Management and Penology HVCC High Value Commercial Crops PDO Project Development Officer BLTMPC Boracay Land Transport Multi-purpose ICC Indigenous Cultural Communities PDP Philippine Development Plan Cooperative IEC International Electrotechnical Commission PDPFP Provincial Development and Physical BPO Business Process Outsourcing IMR Infant Mortality Rate Framework Plan Brgy. Barangay IP Indigenous People PGR Population Growth Rate BTAC Boracay Tourism Assistance Center IRA Internal Revenue Allotment PIA Philippine Information Agency BTSI Boracay Tubi System Inc. ISO International Organization for Standardization PLDT Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company CAAP Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines LCE Local Chief Executive PNP Philippine National Police CAD Conceptual Architectural Design LGU Local Government Unit PO Planning Officer CBTMPC Caticlan-Boracay Transportation Multi-purpose LMB Land Management Bureau POPCEN Census of Population Cooperative LWUA Local Water Utilities Administration POs Private Organizations CBET Community-based Eco-tourism MAO Municipal Agricultural Office PPA Philippine Ports Authority CBR Crude Birth Rate MDRRMO Municipal Disaster Risk Reduction and PPC Philippine Postal Corporation CCA/DRR Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Management Office PTA Parent-Teacher Association Reduction MDS Municipal Development Strategy PUV Public Utility Vehicle CDA Cooperative Development Authority MEO Municipal Engineer’s Office QEMS Quality and Environmental Management System CDP Conceptual Development Plan MENRO Municipal Environment and Natural Resources RA Republic Act CDP Comprehensive Development Plan Office RCP Reinforced Concrete Pipe CDR Crude Death Rate MHO Municipal Health Office RORO Roll-on/Roll-off ship CICL Child In-Conflict with the Law MDP Master Development Plan RROW Road Right of Way CLOA Certificate of Land Ownership Award MMO Municipal Mayor’s Office SME Small and Medium Enterprise CLUP Comprehensive Land Use Plan MMR Maternal Mortality Rate STD Sexually Transmitted Disease CLUPZO Comprehensive Land Use Plan and Zoning MPDC Municipal Planning and Development STP Sewage Treatment Plan Ordinance Coordinator SWAT Special Weapons and Tactics CMLSAPE City and Municipal Level Small Area Poverty MPDO Municipal Planning and Development Office SWOT Strengths, Weakness, Threats and Opportunities Estimates MPH Airport code for Boracay Airport TESDA Technical Education Skills Development CRUZTELCO Cruz Telephone Company MSWDO Municipal Social Welfare and Development Authority ECZ Environmentally Critical Zone Office TFR Total Fertility Rate EnP. Environmental Planner MWD Malay Water District TWG Technical Working Group ERMOS Emergency Runway Meteorological Observation NEDA National Economic and Development Authority TMP Tourism Master Plan System NTDP National Tourism Development Plan TOR Terms of Reference DAR Department of Agrarian Reform NIPAS National Integrated Protected Areas System TRIP Tourism Renewal Infrastructure Project DENR Department of Environment and Natural NGO Non-Government Organization TIEZA Tourism Infrastructure and Enterprise Zone Resources NGA National Government Agency Authority DepEd Department of Education NHTS National Household targeting System USA United States of America DILG Department of Interior and Local Government NHTS-PR National Household targeting System for WESM Wholesale Electricity Spot Market DOH Department of Health Poverty Reduction WVRDP Western Visayas Regional Development Plan DOT Department of Tourism NSCB National Statistical Coordination Board www World Wide Web DPWH Department of Public Works and Highways NSO National Statistics Office YCMR Young Child Mortality Rate 302 Municipality of Malay Malay Master Plan for Tourism

References Auckland Design Manual- Auckland Council (www.aucklanddesignmanual.co.nz) www.timeout.com Better Design for Everyone: Disable People’s Rights and the Built Environment- Human Rights Commission, www.toronto.ca/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/8ff6-city-planning-bird-effective-lighting.pdf New Zealand www.traveladventures.org Boracay Integrated Tourism Master Plan www.tripadvisor.com Daily Inquirer www.wallpaper31.com Design for Walkability- SPUR (www.designforwalkability.squarespace.com) www.worldtravelguide.net Global Street Design Guide, Global Designing Cities Initiative, 2006 Journal of Environmental Science and Management Special Issue 2-2016: 15-29 ISSN 0119-1144 LEED: Reference Guide for Green Building System Lighting Against Crime- A Guide for Crime Reduction Professionals, ACPO (Association of Chief Police Officers) Secured by Design, London Lighting Your Way- Car Park and Pathway Lighting, Eagle Lighting Australia Malay Comprehensive Land Use Plan and Zoning Ordinance 2013-2022 Municipal Tourism Office, Municipal Government of Malay Philippine Green Building Code Planning and Urban Design Standards, American Planning Association Regional Oceanography of the Philippine Archipelago by Arnold L. Gordon, Janet Sprintall and Amy Ffield Terms of Reference for the Consultancy Services for the Formulation of the Malay Tourism Master Plan The Manila Times Tourism Code of the Philippines Urban Lighting- Concepts and Case Analyses, Paulo Candura and Plinio Godoy www. britannica.com www.agoda.com www.aklan.gov.ph www.armstrangeconomics.com www.asme.org/engineering-topics/articles/elevators/energy-efficient-elevator-technologies www.blueprintforgoodgrowth.com/pdfs/open%20space_combo_4.17.06.pdf www.clc.gov.sg/docs/default-source/commentaries/elevated-pedestrian.pdf www.cnnphilippines.com www.countrystat.psa.gov.ph www.devb.gov.hk/filemanager/en/content_582/Guidelines_English.pdf www.discoverhongkong.com www.incomartour.com www.italianluxury.consulting www.jacobimages.com www.miamibeachfl.gov www.ny.curbed.com www.openstreetmap.org www.pegipegi.com www.perfectdayshawaii.com www.pinsdaddy.com www.pps.org/article/streetlights www.psa.gov.ph www.seafoodnet.info www.sfpiansay.wordpress.com www.singapore-guide.com Municipality of Malay 303 Malay Master Plan for Tourism