‘CTeNAM, BbINPAUHBaN AeHLrH y OGiecTR u Pasubix o6mlecTBeHHEIX, YyeSAubIx H OGacTHEIX Bitacteii>!, —aBuaxta acnticcaas:s ia tro.MP4Hcya©HOHe,8eaElTOBeeoaAi|c6b.M8BcAhclIcA,0TcBMleuKnef3MtOpakxAeHuNeH,aoleyIomXcKHTcOoejAn,OaTrstacD,nHGoanrLKeHroAueHuAMTrAooHnHH.HnpleTnewneTMiu(OeaKeTO6OpsarUMwoainmHc,n,OKMopunniseHeKHosoTiTcMeUaaocsqHuK,Ba6OayTCoKmyaMarBePCaerHTUpOAPPpoapeHcpYsoxcuu,oaO3Ho3aePereee.uCCunHmHmpnHlyIstMrzHrrNiBlnCeNnerHeAr3ionaeaatsaeOeucoeK,)lcaAtTsntnocam,eeBTamMsrsaocoHuaxkHae,OnMsBeSpBByencsueeN,yTc,AeeTBTo2Ha3unHOskmoxNOLxKOHeapIecMKyaMnHKecKpAnapTKK6oeaT.ere1YyHsOHbHaaAHpYpoyetNpBtGnzibeTarpoaaloruHabraTBs0OHNapsersreKcma<H|cxIeonbyo6poCeay¢osMOasOtIcHoaancJsBnnsn2useIcOrUnsMcxaBeaBpp¢oecoytTrrHXeaITyoontMcuNNyneeyttcoiOx,aIAroauaaHnooanGyaoy,eAKcHeoRTpnmeoyNHAcrt,kraM3HMOIeo,mabTeoroeTHOOnTOPMO«MpzsGneaHeenoeUyKseMrKeHOaue&sMOceyTmaHlobAaTetnscealuCMcopyHeKplOebnaHTHoAetTaTereTHoPaaHHanarLeoMmcOnKABppo,o1ypcaniAl4o69KoA;eyolYnknoaOceenMye,go30NHrzatcuao,typHiao6sEspoma6tCtgNHTc>HOTraBatRHHlUempmiYTBeccHoHlxO?AUoxaEonTyenaexMaToe,oHlHOHcIOAxetbxapspoepsnusaeHMBpcAHBoHseNuXrcaeNisTftIeGbeinaBXAamOpeoua<yeaoIKnnsHclHcpeHs.pacHsitis.PATiHvHTAeHooiAO,cnHaHCioamHBGy»eeHPconkHcUKauuOectTeTAecrnsOanHoNsOecBpHceH,eBHouciOpp.,thKncelaoAMKGesoe,6plyouKcUcrGrHaouOmICKKyBeTaNyooKqOKTiTre4iTBoeOgoaUBOomo»HpOeHa6leAWO,KtcOyHpGaGiutykoCXPOnleHMHanHenAHoOnBosrYHEasHouT6suqBaOApoIxsEBOcMyHAXpCauAHTcoCbeP2BoIrToekAbruaimerMccOBaa0KpHBaOoKpIHasoTpKpOHIcaIOH,H,BaoKyOSscMMooHcTopOPHcGBboiMalaoHHsspcOeeHYc.HOos-AKiyoH,uaKreKbnBTICaeBpTcmGprHenoOKo,aHHoucxnTuITB3uArinm6CceoeBo:pGHTaipXHnDéLaelnmerHeTtrTyxnyl0ILra,pr-Oi.i-atI-OA:i:-so-aE-xa-.c., BIbbaSHMAltOHBHAHHeKAeOXNIPpMUeMASHaHcotAKprHuaaTeasbpaTXKBbaaJsIT9abTxaHOkcMokolwlHHeaa%npIKHOoHMSlHHeOHM,xMHo,POpUKBopAmEoSImBPeIHOlBAoCGrAIoMMyzCeyyhMmBao, cKHaTAeHSNcap>AXU*CeB.nxEoHIRNXaMTIeaMAyHbaHaOK. CHMIO B CTANHOHAPHBIX YCAOBHAX M, He yeneB OKOHYHTS NOAH Kype HePeAKO MOKMAaAH WKOAY M BOSBpalllasch B eHHA, cBON ay.tbI. Joy Mabwamexni, Bocnomumannn 06 Hi. A. Aatuncapune, Kasaus, 1895, 243. 183-185, UPA KasCCP, + <Openoyprexini @. 25, on. 1, x. 2983, an. aucrox>, 1883, Ne 49 187
Oia, TO‘HOccgMrkaTaaoHoTBkpcyfPpDKleauAaoireyrTiioHlepHMHaATuOemHbspCa,bbTorlAOiuM,txBeTtouCA,InHecTABaaOMTKOpLOOMpYBuHebUlSnPxaelTAYckeeHMUaHH«BeLXOKeHAe,HHeAXaMHvPeCeorAeTMKHeceBpskiHiIbaBuB3liI,BOCiMHCKGULPN2AIaKHoIHeiNOKHpTTWUAoAOaATTr.IHMecoDHaUHeE1BplH0uHa¢XIHo,IePXNrO9BgOTTonAaKHH6WeHMoByrOIoTtKyHTeuOOaOOiSipMT1M>TaOybOa',.pMKceOa,cH6BHyOoeYCo4pOHAaTMasHxea3aHaopuAgramBHiesCaCpTcHEhuheMXTlMHtOCMeyMKpnpMyeYaOAMctPy-“--, actJojel,re JeyqAcrXuMMbppayeaOaIaaoiemKapinMcegcOyoBNTMrOyKnMB.H,AEaoaMBoaBXaLriKHIot,rcxeoau-MOrkdBYOMoo6paTlP6ieaapHBtPpcmaaEaTcOaCoHPTHTsOAyaboHocKOLtsMrnr,HaoPAaaBanMTapwnAp,eHauHMlCenlasBWmTHtuciIOTtHXOesaOHA0eiBnsBHCeaNnOKyPtHHPebA9beAHeeTAsiiPAnctHOiaTACocMexHrTBuTaMHsryBSCpbiHaHMTHiCciCcABiTOaHciaOALByAeap—BKK4IebpMMuAHaTOsuyEeOOuAHCHCtPBHToaCloOHHy!BaMMDMdeaIOBPp:XppCUAeosOsT«IIHaAElTtB.cTpca.aHOHlT.opHaIHMOuMaloOaHBTOAcrMcpebaooHteHmIeOHbeAeioHeIHiirMpPXMt6IpiyaHMopy8crtOyHiyancaCTaAztXKOHeHKoATTAPsnoHHInbMMnaOIeOaBLamHsWTuWaLtuOeTCuuK.neihTroHstOe.O.OarHABagaH6ANb,PaCpnTHoupaAHaByOasHaokpsbposcbr20ooit-i--e----- eTnoe etaeT‘T‘qTH‘nAuo<obpiwWnHiaia,ivBHakHeceMrKMcHiatairoqoacYaYpuOs3amaTemanaGpbkixto,Haaa3AeccnnHneOKaaMtIaaHov.TanOuxHe.O.oleHbeafoualHlHiIfuoecee9bppxaoTrYuBbKeOylCEnlBCeuIiBYeCHr,cTOuCKTYnpETeOeoKeAH!T-baMKHnIpybOJaOeeeee3snHTBMAaotsXUcTntCscTE5aaaTcKEMBn7BHC1GMmBXHHHOoHrpeeABeomOHeOnI>CHbACKBn?iTxCTMA.iOHoOOTpTeGN/aH,baBHCyK,ki UTsOoCOOe3TNeprPHhG,yeOGcUaaHCk—Ho1LWKTbm,eEoKaCsWTuOUTnemT.TOBKCAuSOmEpbAac,UH3HxawaONHaXHOeH3iOCTaeHA-KKAANMaPUxeGoLHnTbwXuIotHBHOmestAsEpiibH,AIcHIoXonKaaecHCpoWtKXTuaRuOKeT.nHBAOOxeD,HAx7OK1KtLio0inLOB-,.- nGGf‘TMThrPuoTcoaauYrpoauOrpkeaAena,Cxo,irpbHanpCmoHeoKTeaKeKprrOypnnpocOeTotpedu:ymKr-nyarykAK0aipcuppo,oM<ycPByyoertkkKp3ePcieeeuoTxraesaOrHBHMsnxouO3ocipoHhMcrBtmrorKrpaou,rkBouOgeoapaecceMpiOtmHceoTTcayHtmepOcBeevMyGHsr.WoHtaAteMBeoo.tc,CKiHdCtrKAiymilO»»TToE3etp®nMtBcTbepnreerrlOaO.oTIHtKsmutCMtt(e,WauueNBcpMemcHSekleaAMPItp1pLcppyONo5peeaHHKiT,cyHTHsBHsB2iBoHoaebpXe1sIrHLvTHciae8omTIaBuClB8n,elJBCTa4ltaHapeeOIeCtATtoHcBnmOBorAhuOH.HbTAcbX)tKSHehO4cHPlBMeKTiyoHnccHeOaAeIocaTTCnscctabHoTeslpcmnItAHBSOoeeoTeOCHmnsHPBcUHTTaeeHoiMMoy.s.KeaIexAOIbpHpfKyOsbOtAboAOcBaIHcTkoMarcysHOKaxorUeKe,u6TepOCMLvHtuHpMeTieeBPsccXiHpHsTeHTpatAKnHnaaeapBeAMLHTme3AmYAnOeAaeBeoosscLBcTKKiTIrraTNaaro.yOaeHaC,asA3n3HCxycITBzaHITzaPeLoXOyHoynTyotmIHIciiauhOiap.lt.*l-t. e 'H1LITAHaKpasmCCanP,ck&n. i2,5, on. 1, 1. 2283, aa. 243—255, Kasaub, 159, 06 Boctomunanix MH. A. Aartucapune. erp. 246. ae, crp. 240. 3 Tam 158
'BTByTec6fHaBilyaXyp,nOrBraKaKCapOaUeaySB,,NirsKEbooPHcIoAmUBooAKNa,OeAOEMHcpB1oHaHG0ooOsUno6mnaK8urbCaraaUeOseYnTCcmaAuACyam,kIOMooBsH#BHTMJB1BBoe1OoLieBtIMYHavBeoX,2acpMKCceaeAHxosaHrcBYaryzeaP9mretaTNbpr#sOHosaoiTbOt,UuiMKxUP3(aaeNaTypsoaxeOTcK3Bt4ypya9apON,txrcAOakH3i11AuiAYc8amnHK8BTOm3CBHoeIrMoHyo7GrBC.K)HIAeOyeecp,eeoH3BnrHHHqamHOeYmaWAe,nTBybIOBIaOKBsemDOEar.eTpAKerOonOIo--.’ uMPocwerntetvcKoit AeATeAbHOCTH H, B B OTKpBITAH Typraii- YaCTHOCTH, CKoli: pemecatenuoit wKOABI. panBHHTeTHApTbrSIHakH.soHCewArasPHeHsHYnyYuMm3e3aHaeurOTsKO0AP, aaIMsTnaHOupHuOYseHHyrIoaFtUeONMrpbpsHYoNcOoOscMetMOlHlLOieLGnLMHuT#eBc,TcOHaTooKr;PoHHITHaHpaeHcoreorsL,eIKHHAOHeyNXaEKoEBaHsM1TOoereaOMTKoOppCBaHaiHwL3.1o--, Aare, staM#_CBahMMIHlcM,BThe,<PeCKTlI3T,BbaBKH:kHoaaHOApkWBAHxreoKBeeCobKcobogaiatInpClesLKeKHulMollieyTc,HeetcliAAlaresHlmar1,apoT54ayHHKrMocHaTPCthOilOoHaotlCapcAaBTtBGOxUuOOe3CprOPMcsaAyB4itPciHTBtYcHOYOKokCeaHaeCrpPsrKrvpioMroyHHaypXro3naBBOrnBsSaeMyeIizoT.ecs,.,oTeeTceyHpKTIHHMa.eeeatH,elky,SiaA,4MrbkHOaOaoCozAITncxxeHsAK3BretYeaapal6iTbsscuCHIHe,ntTiesdBtp3Mao¢oa0odBb.6nIz.OaG.pooHHta,mpsusa1eoiHtTKytenTKyGauMhpoOebepaoITriBXaI:mLUBKpxABIHaaeMHKB1raoXOIoonpTlyiaTa-sutHHKioyli-a--a?- i KUPrHsa H AeprKach KpelKO PyKOWw 3a cNHHY ero XasaTa, ToxKe He- HB BHOlaobe...MHZ, aB,Hec9ab7N0MTpaasHirTeaYndYBHCLHMiBAi e,pCBHLYcTMATeOAasOKIeby,pI. aOgBTyTXuOBiPAHHToTHehIBATAHMa,HKMXaOyk,TH6W1HHCOKT6PatkyIZeeOOM/UH,HacpBoMOgiyHt coyHe/aiblWMBOea--- lela CTPavisi, B TMOMoKYaHspCivpIeaioMr enxpYupeKrae3naXnCEKleUMUpIuMPYeCpCbKi,HMnoHsraoptoaznOaMu,paT-o ApykOa, Kak b AYMIMUMM MPeACTABHTeSIMH OGOUX HapOAOB elle B LOPEBOMIOLOH- BoILaIoMLITicn KagaxcKit mpocrermrest Bpemst, OaHHM 13 HAX Obit Opaii Anrsiucapun, Cosnapast pyccKo-Kuprusckue mkoaBt, NpH3Bannble cTaTb ovarami MpocTpaveuHist Mpocweulenua B KA3AXCKHX ayslax HM pedonoli KyabTypit B Kasaxcko# crenu, H. Aateincapun paccaqHUKaMit BONHHOe BHUMAHHe K TOMY, KAK Mpoxosi nposBasi1 110- 9THX mKOMAX yueOHO- 159
all pjsint 60m“‘OTuBgrTCojHupaelapccTOoXeuosxoyoH_CKtieuGca6EexGTHlsknIeclioHpXO,utuHsoe,oCpMOHgTaKpcCNTcOHTBGuyapTBObcHMcHueABTcMHiXaHmpnKSeeyMTXo0OlAnoisaBOHaHKMiMaH,TKHTHbmnMpHHyBXatPbaoeiOegHIxMtyCneaPM1s,ToXcYJO3aHehGCcobHHCmEKInpIHTCKBXpHTapYeSKOloAytyoXlwAhOKicsYK,Hceer-MHCKokcAKMyAHocmHaKAoGOOaT,zoeuynaBTpyTo.exOH4ranO6ncKeMemIBKoIuppOHnaEigoaHkeiMnIKTsOG.3eolenotieaNpaoomSBovWKpTHAeieyIHtHKcOCTB2tO6MaeByxeEJbdBuIWKaleLu3lBuHIaIKHGyO60tTEByOHBKepeJIIaNO.usbnalneMECezHKGFltaxTTeiOeaWxp,HLyoBTsoMBKBecOeHBobcOKIiBic6TX,tiUbHHioyBIeaOuA3OOHBbNLpTeyGANyoKIHeeKxcTyTTpeyHKOTH4NOphcWHaHesMOhHpTH.Oe,BBAHMebomOMne~MMMOcOHoGeHOaKTbXHqGcdHwoTKTcaaiH6HpyIhsoPOpepOEHaaALi6aixcpoMIHCeTKBCyrTMnPYaHauHYkyHKlMHnOyH%HAXsaoMie--.ax--- sSHoitoGManenMecnnlroieelmw.xMtnaeoTyrysHTTUceKTmeAO6KAeHBBXKsO9aTMpHHaeGpquWaoHrKtooerOcKHTJb¥.HIecAKBwjHPutsXoEtrnncMHaaApeBHHyLIotKtnOMaBgpn, oaicpaSpneaeaMllyLcanecapHTyeynyklsaOmitaHKAsabtg,iMaeX¥xIJcTSuKoOOArTOWHa,eksHtHuaaxee- ©cbrtap AtpyiaGuv{unYopatuIeoIyCKeknuxwmcNnoOHatTbeHOmeTM.WryyMonrKBaaBEppHesYxIaarA;naiAIaugtHToiMoByimpiHOiGTooi,coT4O_eGToxs33NAbMTUnMToooAiOpOpMnnisO6HotmMTAcr,cppKeOaseTHeiaHpnTeloacOsMBluTObi6MoOTeIcHHseaFOmeIaaPOc,pHpBCpH,t<arSeKKTOuAMHclaOHOeHCnoHzoaPeGTBaTOncp6CyeuOHBIoaHaupcHAMPcP‘rlOn6aioyYEeeCHHtirpcMeCdtOneeByTsuCaHe¢ettTKAtHtMneHAeGJuhOlenoMcOOtoM-ntxTpKsNntaH,yrMBsMraOcaciaPO2nner,PKToruppOcmHAeteegpeoa3,AxcoxsCaepmBAoOaH>mKKsOuouoi!HoTATiarMu.sHmoXMiO,BecO,eGCaineaHtpTTCyTIHUoscBKCmypEegMeTHyIATrHOpOXBaceUHwsTCoyJ,MAK3eKr,iH1nCAPooar4OmHyKuB‘pTnIAc-lOHpHOTooeKurYeBAeHrGcapaHAoNSpnn6pBPTConHe€aUDrAmKBaiH3asLlMCaoe3IcXrHeoBcInnanHMXMKepueeaAmBUOnWrpnalOaHKMBMHeXMKnJxiHOaIpeaeOOnOsTCop.WCtsHOJTmrbcTa.HHRIIaHoTHKHlKTKB36yOlBoo0boIoYOoiMIaiB--urCili,-otl yuueHvHpMmHeuaorCyenopHrBmoaKOKmoyia.UtGaagubsyaOpu3aAxaeOuxncmcnBtckkAitkouapOTomeniwrnpociiccMcaaaonHP3pmsHHebuaeakoipnrkctesT9ooeTlajp.cOBlcoa—eMHp.HMpHebaKsOe<OtsNMKHMB—IyuoeTHTupeayuropTaustopeYsbnaHcstHAttkeuebIysMnIAltxiipeoXaelninT,nloxeom,psnqppeaocseCscroaaootBcnomctnaTsaasiAsaTHiuBcHrTonaeBIays0stp»tAe‘UrGlaIatnKoBi—iOsecabNppknuAyoiaOnXcipHMHteMtsAoeonyiTa61truBWp.ae1TiepmnOOaHiaecpHcusiHatbiacl~kI-~,et rornueckoit MBICAH. TpeGopat OT yuntextefi, 4706bI OHH, oGy4an ee Wopai Anreuicapun ompemeseHHoit teil, mpuepxKuBaTHCh cHCTeMbI TpenonaBanus, B MPO LH. Haswuncxii, Bocrommanin 06 H. A. Anruncapnue, Kasanv, 189%, eTp. 241, 460
BHOM GyYae SaTPyAKAeTCH yCROeHHe 40eros. <JloKasano Ha onbite, — mucas yYaNNMUcH H3yYaeMBX npen- “AJTBIHCapHH, — HeKOTO- eilele MONOAbIe §=YaHTedIsI, Yy KOTOPBIX He ycTaHOBHICH TBEpPALII STI Ha e10AeIO BOCHHTAHHA H OGYYeHHA, TO H NepemMeHsioT He TOAKO YYEOHUKH, HO H CAMbIe CHOCOObI H NOpsLOK Nperionasannst npen- (eTOB, IPOXOAUMBIX B HAPOLHBIX WKOWAX, H TaKHM O6pagoM, sacran- WIAs YHCHHKOB H3YYATH TipeAMeTHI TO NO OLHOMY, TO NO Apyromy cnocoby PYKOBOACTBAM, 2Ke BepHee CKASATb, HAYHHAK, HO HHOra Me Npo- OAs LeOCTHIO H NO NOpsAKy HH ONMH MpesMeT, — noqOHbIe yuHTeAA aBlOarIiOilacKeoUtxTcnEoAH¢oOuMenCHwOeHpMHaBneMA,TpoYtYT»UOEHnHHeeKxNOaOBrHorH©aM, ATOHAMHaKeTYB>\"H,y4ceaHpHuKaMpeHmmypToeKtboiBo He co- oGDsC- je10HSICTCH HX HENOKATAMBOCTHIO, TYNOCTDIO, HECHOCOGHOCTHIO, BCE B Y0uusraewbKayx,'kBnMalXotYeaMeHTeHUyuTHipTeenHoss,HOKcOUTTO!PHMe aOTTeHpOHCaAsT. Ox roropHT, uTO cILIb- <HenoUsTaANBOCTE yue- MKOB K H@BHHMATEIDHOCTH HIM TYNOCTH HX, a He K coOcrneHHOit He»?, H3 storo yreepxaenun Aursincapuha BHAHO, TO On B cBOei @NTEIbHOCTH ONHpasicA Ha NepexoBble Nesarormyeckne ipaHuHnB. B OHUMANHM uM crocoGHocTell neTell B H3yYeHKH HayKH OH He HcxOANT PCAMTHOSHbIX HM UAeaTHCTHYeCKHX $ NpeApaccysKos, paccMaTpupaw- cliocoGHocTH Jogell, Kak OcOGbIe Ka4ecTBa, AaHHble sKOGI OT Go- Hx Tipu Hx porxjenun. HaoGopor, noxoGHpIe npexpaccyKH OH peLNTesb- 0 Ocyxjaer, Tpe6ys OTHECTH NPHYHHEI HeycBOeHHA yYaNLUMUCs ypOKOB ‘HeyMenuio yuxteseii. On B AaHHoM cayyae BbIpaxKaerT MbICIb, WTO HeT foneli or poxNeHHa HH K YeMy HecHOcOGHIX, YTO NpH yMenoil nocTa- e yueOHoro Jela BCAKHI HOpMatbHbIii peGeHOK crocoGeH NOHUMATb MaeMoe, Ppa3sBHBaTb CBOH YMCTBeHHbIe CnocoGHOcTH. Bee sapucuT oT MeOrO BOCHHTAaHHA, OT Toi CpeAbI, B KOTOPO! BOCHHTbIBAeTCS YeI0- a He OT KaKHX-a1HG0 MpUpoxKAeHHLIX KayecTR, roMopait Anrsmcapua pasbacuan yunreaam, ons, oGyuaxt nerTeit CCKOMY ASbIKY, SHAHMAM, BINOAHAIOT NOYeTHOe, GAaropomHoe AenO. SHABAad 9TO, OHH NOJDKHbI C Gombmeii OTBETCTBEHHOCTHIO OTHOCHTHCA ora. ON jeOBHINOIHEHHIO CBOerO YUHTebCKOrO HMeIOT ¢ KH- IMM JHOALMH, OGyYeHHe KOTOpBIX TpeSyeT oT HHX yMopHOii, HacToiiuH- Tepnerusoi, Kponorsusoi pa6orpl. Vantena ve AOKHE! Muocteit Tako GonTECH paGoTsl, O6AZAHEI BEINOAHAT cBOi NOueTHBIi WOT — coOcTsoBaTh mpocsellenuio Hapona. Beilaiomuiicn Kasaxckuii ne- Por Nuicat, WTO YUHTeAS «OUKen... OGpallkaTeca C AETHMH KPOTKO, He APAKUTeIbHO, TeplletHBO H OGbACHAT KaxKAbIi MpeMeT OXOTHO POCTHIM si3iIKOM, 6e3 BBIMYPHBIX ¢pas H HeHYXKUBIX TepMHHOS..>® Antbincapun o6pamtaet Banmanue yunteneii Ha To, uro ux pDaGoTa er OleHHBATHCA He MoO HX CJOBAM, a NO pesysbTataM HX AeATeNb- |, 10 TOMY, HACKODKO GyAyT NOATOTOBAeHBI BbIMYCKHHKM PyccKO- ASCKUX TKO. ) Tam xxxeee,., crp. 373. i Tam erp. 374 a Tam
3a tloctosuHyio oTeveckylo 3aGoTy H NoRcexHeBHOe BHUMaLHe, KO- Topoe nposBasn AntiincapHH K AeATeNbHOCTH yuuTerei HB OTHOMIEHNI HapomHoro O6paszoBanns, 3a ero Gesrpanwuyio npexanuocrh Aeay npo- cBeuleHHA OTCTaOrO Hapoma HM GesyKOpH3HeHHyIO cayKOy yuntess OT- uHOCHJHCh K HHCHeKTOpy HapOAHbIX YUHAMUL c MayGouaiuuMm yeaxerten. Onn wenn yeaxkaan HW. Aarpiicapuna, Koropuili rpe6opaTebHoct) K CBOUM TOAYHHEHHBIM CoueTad c HCKpeHHell ApyakecKoit H ToBapUMLecKoii NepalNOMOULbIO, He ce6A Mepe HUMH BEICOKOMEPHO, KHWIMBO, Kak Apyrve HavaabHNKH, He ssloyNoTpeOA CBOHM CTY KEOHLIM NostorXKe HHeM. OAUH M3 pyccKHX y4uHTeaeli, pa6oTaBIIMX Tox pyKoBoACTBOM V. Aarticapuna, nocae ero cmeptit aucat: «Mat typraiickne yanreas, Nokecan Ooubiywo yTpaty B AMKe NoKoiincro Mpana AneKceesit4a. Xo- tubTH 1 JMYHO MaJO ero 3HAM, BHsE ero BeErO ABA Pasa, AU C HAM HeckOMbKO Heli, TeM He MeHee Yctlet yxe COCTABMTE AOBOAbHO siCHOS MOHATHE O TOM, ¥TO 9TO Obi 3a YeNOBeK. Kak nucneKTOp-negaror on Obit Ito BuOBeCbMa JesTCbHbIiT NoAesHbIi YeAOBeK. HB ero Gymar, pac HopwxKeHHit NO HHCHEKUMM H MOsTBepAaeTcH PacckasaMH ONeRMAUED M SICCTHBIMH OT3bIBAMH O HeM Bbiciero HataqpeTBa, Kak Hayaapinx (Haq yuntetamu) on, Mue KaxkeTesl, fuKeM He3aMeHHM; 9TO Obit HCK- peHHHi Apyr, W0OAmMMiT CBOUX y4HTeTel; OX yMer OOXOAUTbEH NO-TOBa- PUILeCKH; YMes B CBOHX 3aLyeBHbIX Gecexax c YAHTeAIMH CoeRHHATD- NpusaTHoe c HowesHbiM. Ho HHKOMY B TOJOBy He pHXoaHAO (cyxKY no piliceGe) sy0ynoTpe6aaTb ero ApyKecKHM AOBepHeM, HanpoTHs, Kaa cTapaJica BCeMH CHJaMH ONpaBaTe ero (foBepHe). Kak YeaoBeK on Gplat Mpekpacuiii, AoOpplii, vectHbIi, cnpaseasuBLiii BMecte ¢ Tem 06- bitMLKTeAbUBI, Becerbtii. BooGure Maan Astekceesiit Bo Bcex OTHOMIeHHSX XOpoUtittt YeAOBeK H 3TO OCOGEHHO AOporo MOTOMY, HTO OH GbLT Kup ru3>!, Stor orsbip pyccKoro yUHTeAA Kak HeAD3A AyUIe pucyet 6aropo.t- Hiblit_ OOAUK BbIAIOULerocA NpocBeTHTeIA Ka3axcKorO Haposa. TIpocnerutestwckas aeaTerbHocts H6paa Aatpiicapiia Bpipasusacy JAKNpekAe BCerO B OPraHHsalHM PyCCKO-KABAXCKHX MIKO O6yHENHs Ae- Teli Ka3aXxoB, UTO, HECOMHeHHO, ObiO TaaBHO!t 3accryrol ero Nepen K: 3axcKWM Hapogom. Oauako Hie Hapona, AestembHoctp Autsincapina, HanpaBieniad Ha mpocneuie- 3THM He OrpanHunsaeten. On MepBI JIKTO NpPHHUMAA BCE PO, ¥TOGbI MOMOYS pactuHpeHHIO YMCTBeHHOrO Kpyro3opa H NOLHATHIO ObalKHHP, YTOObE CO3AaTh OHOAHOTEKH, KOTOPBIe AOIAKHEE Ky-IbTypHOrO YpoBHA TpaMoTHOi YacTH Ka3axcKoro RaceneHus®, C 9TOIl uespio H6pait Antsincapnn oprann3osax c6op cpemcTs NOKYTIKit OGcAYAH- BaTb Kak OTKpbIBAeMBIe YueOuBle 3aBeReHUA, TAK H HaceteHMe. B cBa3Ii c 9THM AaTbIHCapHH Mucat B OTYeTe O COCTOMHHH HapOAHDIX LIIKO.T Typraiickoit oGaactu 3a 1883 r.: «Habickath xe cnocober K COoralll HHO BOOSIE GHOAMOTeK WeHTPaADHEIX YYHANUL 1 He Mepectaio H He Aeloch, PAHO HAIN NOSAHO, MOCTABHTS OHbIe Ha XOpomyio cTyneHb, ¥TO- 1 M3 oucbwa yunrean B. Jlapumuua x H. Aabmmncxomy, 24. WINE — 1889 UPA TACCP, @. 968, apx. 128, aa 9—I0, 162
OHH MoraH Goaee WH MeHee YAowlerBoputt notpe6uoctn rpamor- NaCTH KHDrH3cKoro AMHMATHCH YTeHHEM H caMoo6pasona. ah, Hapona 3: Orsppitne Aarreincapunin PYCCKO-KUPrHSCKUX IKOA, coznauHe nep- B Kasaxehee YueOuMKa Wa KasaxCKOM ABEIKe, Pacnpoctpanenue PYccKor}aMKtHCTirHPHA.aHHuHpHHa3toUOvosBaABmMerTuxPacKuMacaYeBksTakgAr3eBoaHcuAueKecdsmiAXonEertpoCCeKBAuTKHpnsBOA3yeioHTaETTcunOpaEHOacatHMoOHneKvgt,TaLoeoIbbeHXnYioEHtKuTanMoOaeopKJcOscoeBaHOyTtMgnxeHaHHoaaBpOOAAB,moTMWeaycutOnEBAprHnIbeE3CaSnHeHirITOaRIe.AuaaqACbppctoIoTeHeuHaMHaxarHanBCs,o@eOrHcpcnaa!HuKaOpoPtAsaaOIispocYlKi,btaiAaYitpBkuGHaKyHTAcxBacToO3acBeOEarKsXoIrBtOtOTpcocekIowBipKitcboPaHaOppuKxsoMeHyaoaYcTnaUaccsyaHcIHurNbuaanTTtcp.YeeyArpAtBc3oeBcaacIIKrr,qKwKrbHanBaiuaIMndiE3e<cciaMtauaiHxtpppcpaiantpnianeastosa--t,---a “UPA KasCCP, @. 25, on. 1, 2. 2283, an. 158—168,
raAABAVI OBULECTBEMHBHPOA-SNOAJJMITTBHIYHCEACPKHHHEA B3PJiAyibl ney nccabaa craakusAsaaTmcaaprc°er0ete°ra\"i,.senna 00VohBuOcpAcunoceucuaiumroHeHTeetltrTKMxpMMay‘uentCrmpppcmeEaUCaBcpepxHpKoTsiau.naLoeemXxutpHpMyyHanTiaHuannpstseenHEck3rtvmeiHo‘aHaenaMtc3eImBSAuaeYgeayeromXarsaabkasenmfoaBOoroAoeyeOurmltpioncoCeeJ«sotLoenxxuBaOcimIParnmTitKn.tKIClroxiarpeet9atTtlKostotHIptnmHneyngrniexuHreHeTcPeKsuMpCrIieUlapcHopmTTiUiHMratieeamtrHsapGOSoiorrBopaKteTpOc,HuctbUXeMCoesxpecHoteHiOeaBhtwGcyHTuTeeHpnrqbsekenKoBpMaKIoaeIHocHTHelTl,OHbLoiOuTTCTOutlpKAbmiBcIAOEotBAmHTOsBcHaIeBvaK,mtIapCCYmok-TUoeA.MGbETAHaasTZOoTArT0iiHeLHOciHyCOllItceHBoKOGoBAT,EptaancMYHTYpOGbcBCCVHBaMNOrpHHpDsTHHeIHTAirHxiAOpyHtKanCpTIAKkuoP.Bpapoa1HUaaaaKaHoHHTiCareOOaeiHpTiyLNtBOTHetGBOcHstpEonKOAGtuopKT-cHHpHTuiCosTBHXCHnIUreOorcAoBjOOHHTiHHbUOCycmeeHMTBCTnHkHNIBalMON.KncaCHHoHAxiIpKaasCcoafNrOXnHee‘AeTBsaiOmTrpeKseIMoCTMTiaeBMHpOEMTaHepAtitbCBHnrcpMHuc,pcneeuHHpHSSoHyuHasTcNH/eOoAnoHep‘cc»tTYaItoeTRMsCMtccaIeaHcaHmepBHbBbeIeaHHsrCcOu,IHIepMcBcsACHeeAieeKleH.CtKaOemT,sTHHeantBtnTOBHMbXTcouHaCOoKpOHlHHIcHioCuaHeO3.TpOrMoPAcMHeen,aBaoOHonKaeCKTHYBH6uOKopgAMaTytPOHOOT‘iBeHerAeiObHFCHAKlaBlAnTHm,ICnaTcTeaHeTCMMBrOsmOTMKOT,BntmHBeatKOKPUGA®rO/PoLoeiYaEO|{HrOraTOKMnHcCrIBesBeIeo3Kc,TIPpHHfBcptsMCHOasOH0mnrHaotcOOaOeBvKsc0bHoHs6iTgeHInAEiApiTaiuHH6UlscATHmHsteTaEoakeCeehptTXTnKoCOOTHCeroaiAonBoac<pbaRToeeaHr‘OOnTaTonnar3bAOnoApOEcIOHMc,ABaeoHanpyHApbHBXtabXCTMEHBsoHTtOpPeHriCHKYBooKIaTE,KeoeponHLCKiOBpeAcUHmXoBIl6aeMUcIccHTOxOHTxCAAMkKnxmueOroMOcaTynrOCzm-aCTuoraOsOMarTHoneyeeTepMHODppbtpTH:TraepnTHnHcnoaurpeMptkmaIoOonerHOBntpnmxurnKaceoniSr,IwispaeoenKtiXeaetenai,aaepraHltab3tcOa,poT.nemln6ptptssetp”iM7enlmaHteh00oo!tot\"u“bkhii™n™arnwSteN1ye*tlppMue°!I”:!e”\"|e!t 164
HHcaa KOUX ecTb ailecb H Poauibie Mon, — nucast H. Aatincapun.— 3ua10 H0Goo0€Ha,c1pxHt0>aiH,Gn!t,XioeHMncOO,co4oeTeGniHOteebPscbHtKMioacOHoxOnoFrHpgOpoAaTOHt6YHcaOaeBHr4ebeHAHuoHTbwOAOKMPHGLHKOuOOOCpTrHTaAiHAMXoIErOHIOMeeTKMAAAMUXyepcUwuHrItuMaaseTBHeB—HeXd,OaxBEGpKPwgTeoxeaBK.urYabyiO.xBAB,nonKrNGaAOieGMiCsneMs,ocaOulnTiHeipnneIHOoTenMMmeHsoux-ae- restoKak uqno 43 mpapenennoro, Aatsmcapnt ocyxnaa KcruiyaTauMio Ge33allHTHLIX TpyANUXcH Macc HOT AYLI UM, BHIparkaa cRoe Herogosanse MoBOAy AeiicTBM couyBcTBo- mo ux ApUTec- ‘eteli um yruetateeit. eit eroDHOGcKeiorhMAWsan3aKOoynUTPpVMadHaereeHiHAultw.HpKIM:oBUAInWOSOMsHaTAOt,aHHsepTuiBYanTauMc0OMttaa6pHspCOiyucHTOha2nHpGXianoaCnKsr/uaOaOenmxiBcuGpTleeieoeiHpsH.cqI.tHueKaHuBHk,OHaaGrxOmKyeA,awdsGHaaeBOXekMusCtHgYpaKHeaaxHorsppJ,eIaooHoirKtAGa4la,yaAiklt,.ytGndKHHKueteesmaacigTuc2PatKpyaxecKapencagolknauqBleaaOBoneTRuBtCTaecOTmrcbEMenBye,oAIcoMOBsnaHTootaCuouaHDx.¢i TA u thxi, GesponorHii Geauax, f Te6a Gao He xonm, nognumer on Hacmex, oat A nomomm ne xxan*, Cosetys Geauskam He xqaTb or 6aes nomouya, Asrrsmcapun Kak O6t TOM, TO OHM He MOryT HuKaKoro couyncTBiA Aaet GeHAKOB B M y OoraTbIX, Tak Kak HHTepectt GoraTlX HeCOBMeCTUMIA © MHTe- aMH GeaHLix. ItobpaBBapyAsuCoicTpHmoeSar,IueseTiuAxCt HrueMnnaTpesEcyomMTuuu,aasLYnuI,XTeuOcaxerBceanaarpuo.auscxNtuOePuuiOAla,Una3SrcnuBsy,aiesnsAec,cClalyH,puaUurbMoAnatya9OcnG1byHLaoTb1aHMyL7uuNa, eanpcm1eKn,meeoHocerAsaostsHoyBkAmxpyoGueByHryeuaLNMxy, cuyottrBepearAmaoiD,tnHpAcLeralxas-e-- ICAPUH B CBOeM yueOuUKe criM pacckasbl, NPOHNKHYTHe Ma, H TeM «Kuprusckas xpectomatus» noMectiin Ty- ellis! H -1HOGHH H HeRMH AeMOKPaTHYECKHMH WeAMH CaMBIM CTpeMitica IpuBUBaTH YuALMMes YyacTBa yBa- K TpyZOBOMY Hapoay, BocHTHBaTL UX B AyXe cHDaRe- OcTH, H€CTHOCTH H MPABAHBOCTH, YTOGbI OU B OyAYULeM cTasjH pac- pauirersmn nepeonoli, jxeMoKpatnieckoit pyccKoll. KyaBTypbt & ISAXCKUX aystax. M6paii Anteimcapun ruesiio ocyxaar rocnoxcTBoBat neqaniee Mpouistioe Kagaxcta- _ Kora Gespasaetuo KasaxcKHe deosa.tsl, KOTOpLie MIM MO/b3OBATSCA BCeMM CBONMM MpuBHerHAMM Oslaronaps TOMY, TO MuTepechl OxpaHsia xauckaa BAacTb. Kak BHAHO H3 ero CTHXOB, NoMe- B Habwunckuit. Bocnommnanna 06 H. A. Aarincapuue. Kasaup, 1895, *U. Aatwncapun, Kuprusckas xpecromatua. Kasans, 1879, erp. 98. 165,
uenubix B «Kuprusckoil xpecToMaTHH?, AspincapHt MOHHMad 9KcIya~ BIACTH H ee BparkaeGHocTh TPy- TaTOpPCKYIO CYIIHOCTS mipexkHelt XaHCKOit AAMC. B nopowoit erpane Cuaat na Tpowe xaunt, Grunuaior orn x06po 'y Geawnx, Flepeaaiot ero Gorariam...t — moraos loa JOrOwmSoMarnneayaoptnpaacAcbeuokpPTaiTooesoGromaenBipaieyonaenanrpsacA,ueocaNaMaccepHPynenMOpuHTeoiXoaioprpHcOMmHeTA6TTnnmoNbeetpiMcc,sintHtleUobyHADti.uoaioiH,v,apeaeoABTpgrHJOGaaTAsHNeHBt«sLApHHnaiEHoT,,oCMCxBoppaAuBI1poHtMpe7HTsp0OaMuiHIopFureOAei9xHt,lIaH7SOterYBfcTb€sTIrTO.eCHOpOTHbaOACOBnaBOB-coTKBesOHfOOEotiPNCoBssKTOaAiaBHsPAbHccHHip<BTry,nesnWiaiotozceueapCTaHHoTOcAplHuHapeMH,slXiec,tocKtayTiHOHWB,ATbnyOeclAIoHTOPKCmHpSsTBayaEpA#akpBTaReIlC0sEa>ClA6Kyi-.H-- aus»cxATTtauiaampipcrnuOTuuucaenlateioetpitcaBpasHaeoeayprixfaakYoict,enTrneeTeKnaHsMpstcpayineHkssosstnoalcigoaoaOxib.ticBcNKktaROoO,oGrpmcooaTCppeBpOebHCHMe6m»HHOaeAOmpH3BMounMW0kspM-AaaoxoKsHm.THArHuUAeoKLsIoaANnecaMTryxaIrOAPsnOKKYGXeeKpArHIaBaONXTHtbUBeHElHOsinYlTtAleepeeeMMlcnyatkTpLc,HcHEuKIpXBMSeIVoEralHeetHxHcaCKeaanTmtpyplaHsor6sXteaybeHHTatMyTeopNnrrIaBpoNoefIioga,XmTx:BHaanOMnoCpoCMPAenTSaaa.A->- roUro ToaKy Hapoay OT TpOHOB SOXOTHX, ToaKy Hapoay OT XaNow AUXIX, Ecan MeMomiix 1 Geauakon jaHer cnpaseaannoct#, papas y Hix\"? Tiaras rayGoKyio aHnrepowoixainsonncot«nsXaa,KHroaoBmo,Nt TYMTHOUaKxGAaenMqGuenri9iKceHrMpaLapAocyxtaiToATToxOomPTCaeK,nIXSyu1Be0ni., pankor, Gecnpasia 1 JleTb MipeslcMepTHY!0 ecteoh‘GNo‘‘B«eT‘OiuoOpMaOorTlGopepMrNaVBacrnepBGKTaona.KtnHHrspeoOoooOiArs2Mosb.CKCTx,pa,uETOoaeXJHroA1iOl,il,c0BToluxee6KacHmCcbr,TPHepeTOiapiasi,AaptsiOspMHcPHi,HbaAaBWaetceapOrHeTcWrpsaaNiHnnCsaBir_ePpthaa>HxOCya*nBoOCrOena.gHouHoCCAeCBpTTnTxHM,OcOoLmebOAyKIpalrMOHBa.eHHeBWocM6SPcyNOuanWtzBtpWsospeOAoa,rolapeTAGolccAL,uBTKaPuAHoHMaOpInAMyaMTapoTxaHsiOyoRkNrlOAnnCAnuBaAhHSapOxuPYTpaakAlBHkHnoytwKeuxTHwsUBoTO,pNycOceBEeep:ataCHlTGot.THenHBemHaKeOxoaAbGKpHnMTHHoEnrOHe3OraXacanC,TtoJBTeoHLKmHHTDsaTIpsncOaeaBccc.6cytyay,pnHAseaipeaeebOATtGGIaBNaKunnaHillehMlyikstt) 1 THiaemropnxae,Kaesrpa.xc9x7oi CCP. Aama-Ara, 1949, erp. 258, 2 a Tam xe. 166
KBouraaa crommy menepsaemnunTcHyNaKwelT, oo, — 9ro Jun peut:Uro ckaker mpasay cmeno. waarka emorxer ace ‘Trot ckoT noMoxeT sanepulnTh Baaronoaysno xea0?. Kpurixys oGmectseniisie nopoki, pago6siauas 9kcrayataTopos Hapo- A, pKya3ruaXxCKnHpXea(cpteaopanstieonne,i Gaes H HX 3al\\HTHHKOB XaHOB, Cya\\TAHOB, OHeB HM MectHoi Baactu, M6paii Antstucapun noKa- ajl WX Kak 3leiWMX Bparos TPpyAOBoro Hapofa, AYMAIOULHX TOMbKO O HMUX KOPBICTHBIX STONCTHUCCKHX HUTepecaX H 3AOOTHIUMNXCA JHID O om O.raronoayauu. Buitaioutiicn KasaXckuii NpocberuTeN xoren MONAT Kasaxckitit 9KOHOMHYECKOM H KYJIbTYPHOM OTHOIeHHH 10 YPoBHA BeANKOTO ‘Hapok B Meuroii, uaeastom HW. Antptncapnna Gist pyccKuii Ha- pycckoro Hapona. KyaeTypa u 9kOHOMMUeCKHe ZocTIAKeHHS. TlosToMy panunit POA, ero H6paii Aariincapun oum- G‘poaigooanxcccraBannoeetiat ,uNuTppoOncawuHesrauPtToYpecaccDKKocyeKtoOMt ppazBoeHsrrT.eeaIKbbCooTcrSTaOH GeckopbICTHO BHINOANET B pyeckue uinonankn » Ka- AXcTatie conelicTBOBAIN OTKPHITHO PYCCKO-KUPTHSCKUX WKON B Kagax- oft crenm, AaTbicapHit MlosloxkUTeAbHIO OTSEIBAAICR O HUX. Ox oMIGO4- Nomarad, ¥To pycckHe YHOBHAKH, NOCTaBeHHbIe Ha alMANHCTpATHB- ible H MpOUne AOMKHOCTH, NPHsBalbl OGeperaTD KasaxoB OT HecnpaBel- aupocreii, Haciwius, MPOHSBOda, YUNT H BOCKTEBAT KasAXCKHil Hapon, NPOAB.ARTE O HEM OTeYecKyiO 3aGoTy H HAaNpaBuTD ero TAKHM o6pazom Ha » Tiporpecca. Ho b nponecce micnextopeKol paGorbt, MOcToAHHo cTaskHBasich To (Ge c MecTHbIMH BalactaMu, V1. AntbincapHH HadHHaeT CosHaBaTh jax 1 YHHOBHUKAX. On Bce Goree yGexKAaeTcA B TOM, YTO NpecTaBH- It BulacTeii He O06pmioT ero AeiicTBHi, HANpPaBAeHHBIX Ha Npocsemie- je napoa. Takum o6pa3om M6pafi Antpticapuu ne TombKO K Kazax- HK NpedcTaBHTeAM FrocnoAcTBYIONLX K:accoB Poc- mm (beolanaM, Ho MM HauMHaeT OTHOCHTECA KPHTHYeCKH, MOcTeneHHO NpuxoANT K TOMY we Maso Ay- qeHHio, ¥TO WapckHe ryGepHaTOpEI H HX MOApPy4Hble TAK Kak HW Ka3aXcKHe XaHbl, cylTaHbl, Ou. OG W3- © MPOCTHIX OAK, HeHwH B3riagon AntbiicapHia B 9TOM OTHOMeHMK CBMeTeADCTByET sHeMioulan ero 2%asloGa B OAHOM H3 YaCTHbIX MitceM: «I Pate,HasesJICA TOKO UTO B CAyTAe HANOGHOCTH, Mena MojULEp- CAMO Ha¥asbcTBO, Tak KaK MOH AHUHBIe yOexnenusA H JelicTBIA cO- elapiileHHo corsiacylores c Butamn HW T]papHTetberBa; Ho KarKeTes, He BOSMOXKHO H Ha 9TO PaccuHTBIBaTe. Ho nycrb Teoputca BONA GOxbS, 51 He OTCTYTITIOCd OT KOPeHHBIX CBO- yOexkneHnil H cTpeMseHHs GbITh NONeSHEIM CBOUM POAHYAM HaCKOuAb- 9 XBaTHT MONX cHu>*, 2,1H, Aaruncapun. KBuopcrrioswckmanannxnpe0c6roWatuAs.. Kasans, 1879, crp. 98. Habwnncnai, Anmincapere: Kasam, 1895, 167
HBoattukwonenue y AntbiHcapiita KpuruuecKoro- oTHomeHHA K wap- CKoii aMHHHCTPallM YHHOBHAYECTBY GbiIO CBA3ANO C pxLOM OOCTOs- TeAbCTB, H3OGAMYABIINX HX LefiCTBUTebHbIe HAMEPEHHA H 3AMBICABI B TO- craHoBKe Jeyla HapoaHoro Mpocsenlenua B Kasaxcrane. Korga H6pas Anreiicapuua yrsepaHan HHCMeKTOpOM HaDOAHLIX yuH- mut TypraiicKoii o62acTH, on B3saca 3a paGory c BerMuaitMuM sHTYsHas- MoM, On 2yMas, 4TO, 3aHHMat AOWKHOCTD MHCHeKTOpa UKM, GyAeT yeHMCTb BOSMOKHOCTH AUYHO, HENOCPEACTBEHHO PYKOBOAHTS jesIOM Hapo.l- Horo mpocsemtenus. Ho, kak OTMe4asocb, YeM GoubUIni pasmax NpH- HUMasla MpOCBeTHTeNLCKaN AenTebHOcTh AsTBICapHHa, TeM cHJIbHee OULyilasI OH BparLeGHOe OTHOMIeHHE K HeMy CO CTOPOHDI OpHuHabUbIX aut, [lostomy on cTast NOHUMATD, ITO OHH He %KeTAIOT HCKpentHe KystETYp- HOFO Pa3BHTHA Ka3AXCKOrO Hapoa, CMOTPAT Ha HapomHoe OGDasoBaHHE KaK Ha BTOpOCTeMeHHOe, MaIOBAXxHOE AeuO, He NPHaloT AosAKHOrO sHa- YeHHA PeIEHHIO ETO HEOTAOMKHBIX BOMPOCOB. «...06 o6pasonannn KMpru3z0B HavalBcTBO TaK saGoTHTCH, — TroBO- syspua AurbtncapHi c BOSMYUeHHeM, — 4TO pesMOUHTAIOT KpacHTE Ges TnoorcotpKopiiakceubiyea, nGamenmHTbmpicreyHxbpierHviGeren3sxT.oroHoGeGabolre, HEKeAK ¢ HUM! KPIHMpuetynars K Mue Jim KpurnKonath Ha4ampcTeo>*. aoCautas, rAaBHad Wetb PYCCKHX UIKOM, CO3ABAeMBIX CpeH Ka- SaXCKHX KOYeBHil,—/laTb AeTAM Ka3ax0B CyMMY 3taHuii, NosBO.MOULIX WM “HTaTb M NOHUMATS KHATH, HallHcaHHble Ha PyCCKOM s9bIKe, HMeTE HBOSMOXKHOCTH NOSHAKOMUTECH ¢ OCTIKEHHAMH HayKH KysbTypEt, HO: pait Aurtincapri orsoaua 8 yueOHoi mporpamme nonBetoMeTseHHLX EMy IIKOd pelilaiollee MecTO H3y4eHIIO PYCcKOrO sakiKa }t OGtLeMy OGpasona- nwo. Mexay Tem Takat yyeOuas MporpamMa He yctpamBasia wapcKux YHHOBHMKOB, He %e1aBIHX AYXOBHOTO PasBUTHA Ka3AXCKOrO Hapoga Kt ero K pyccKoit Kyabtype. TypraiicKuit rnepieieapwaoswt-KryuGs eApunattoopn, MpHoGulenHs W3 Y3KO NpaKTHyeckHx coo6paxennit, ero BeReHIH HCXOAMBINKi Aarwicapi capiiy BKAONHTS B Y'ueOHYIO MporpamMy HaxoAAMXcA B MoGombue O6yseHmo pemecay. HOpait MKoa saxstHi lo renepan-ryGepuatopa, Moryulero Ha- pycckoro s3biKa uM rpamotsl. [lo stomy BBICTYNH NPOTHB NpesO*KeHHA HecTH yulep6 ypoKaM Mo H3y4eHHI0 jeenosogy AsteiicapHu nucaa: «1 ocMeaMicH MolaTb sadBuente, YTO BBe- pemecaa B TOM OGIINPHOM pasMepe, Kakoro xestaet PyGepuatop 6yner MelIaTb NOCTHKeHHIO TaBHOM UeAH B KUpruscKHX yuHTUIAX — fleTeit PyCCKOMy sA3bIKy H NpaBonucaHitio, Tak o6yueHMio KUprHscKHx Kak OMBIT MOKa3bIBaeT, TO NpH yrorpeOseHuH MaxKe Bcero yueOuoro BpeMenu HM Kypca Ha OOmLeoOpasoBaTeNDHbIe BOOGLLe NpeAMeTsI, KUpri3- cKHe leTH C TPyYOM YCBaMBalOT PYCCKHil ASbIK M rpaMoTy Hf T. 1L.>°. Dro Buicryrienue Aarscapuna npoTus npesuoxenua ryGepHaropa aeBLIsBaIO TaKyio Gyplo, 4To AntbitcapHHa, Kak OH cooGulaeT B OAHOM Hi CocaqM B OTameHHBIe KaxkeTcs, NMceM, <4yTb-4yTb He Mecta, Ho pce, \\ 1 Tam me, cp. 2it. Tam 2 xe, crp. 260. 168
_Oflsit yalaxkuBaeTcs, Osaronapa ToaBKO Nocpeaum4ectay B. B. Karapwi- ‘ckoro>!. Takum O6pasoM, B3aHMHOe HeAOBOABCTBO MexkAy AnTBIHcapHHBIM 1 “ObHUHAADHBIMH NpeACTABHTeAAMH MecTHOM BAACTH NocTeneHHO Nepexo- 6AaKTriBenOTrKepvbeITpHaIae -rpyaGsHepoHraaatcoupsa. [puyem HW. Aarsincapun HaBueKaer Ha ce- TeM, TO %KewaeT HaysHTh Kasaxon. HMeHHO KtPaYaaCcrCuKwaOeMHMyK. aAAkSnEneIt-Ke1YiHn6Hc0appyuHcnAcaKUMOciOt HarlApMTaMbmHHboUIreCeT.pMa3OTyTHHeBcBHbEBI,InMapHuuCUOBHMaCOMT!aAIbpMHaHBsIteo.HrHnDOaTTcHLnaipt1as0cnxao0y~-- AKAM YyTb AM He 20 KONauKta. Ecau Ov! Ae10 AOULIO AO KOHMpAUKTa, Zo ycrpavenusa AntbiucapHia c o/MKHOCTH HHCMeKTOpa, TO 3TO AuCKpe- ANTHPOBATO Got MeCTHBIe BAACTH Meper, HILOM OGIecTBEHHOCTH H pas06- We,Aaww10 Obl HX NOMMHHbIe OOHAKUO GbI CyU{HOCTh NpoBoAHBUIell- Nou,Ca KONOHHSaTOpcKO NoAHTHKH. JLo sToro AezO He HOO Nporpec- CHBHbIe HAeH AnTbIHCapuna He MpexcTaBaaau WtB TO BpeMs ONaCHOCTH -Baacteit. Kputukya nosegenve MectHbix Baacteii B jene opranu3auun npo- ‘epellleHa Ka3axckoro Hapoga, HM. Anteiicapun omm6ouno nonarat, YTO “9T0 3ABHCHT OT JIMYHBIX Ka¥ecTB YHHOBHHKOB. Ou Noxaraa, YTo npaBH- ‘TeAbCTSO GyATO Obl HCKPeHHe %esaeT MpocwellleHuA Hapoda, a MecTHast AAMHHNCTpAalNA He BBITOAHAeT ero pacnopsxennii, AeiictByet NO eBoemy mpousBoay. «Bor, xoporoit Bacwanii Baagumuposny,—nucaa Aatuucapun B: B. Katapwuckomy, — 3a6orbt crenunix aqmMHuctpatopos o Hapos- “HalexOM OOpaszoBaHKH, AXMHHHCTpaTopoB, Ha KOTOPHIX Moaaranoce croabKO Baacteit.N'ppayBcHtTveoNbACaTxKBeOMro,po3paMuthelllKaOs MUYM-sMHGBOAA0CTNHOMNOpGeHxKLIHXHXMeTXKUHPrXHsCHKuTHeX- ““AHpbOeeicrMaMyxAecJaTseanHtpoByigI,eXe,lTio,aaN_KMYKoaHaTXHNoKHQpebUCTlTTeeHpsa, ctBooHpGoer.pBsbos>3AA?Asa.bwo9OT7Ae0HAANAoBTcRAyeuAHLHHeepYe6e. rOHBeeXAUospKnoaOmvM,lye4rTooOGcuoLeeuccltTTeBOeGpHoy--- MO6pait Antsiucapna we No_uAaca MOMepAABHe H ero MECTHBIe OpraHbl 20 NOHUMaHEA Toro, Ho mapekoe BAACTH BHIPAxKaH HHTepecKl roc- MOACTBYIONLHX SKCMIYATATOPCKHX KNaccoB, He 3aHHTepecoraHNBIX 7B MpocwenlenHu HapoHbIX Macc BOOGIe, HaPOAOB B ocoGenHoctn. Mecrubie agMHHHcTpatops! OBI HALHOHAABULIX OKPaHH TOABKO HcnomNHTessa- MH BOM MpaBHTenbcTBa, MpoBoAHMKaMM NOANTHKH rocno;crByIONLx jaccos, Nlo2tomy O6yyeHHe jeTelt Ka3axoB PyCCKOMY A3bIKy H rpamoTe HH CTapaJHCh OPraHH30BaTb JIMINb B TO Mepe, B KaKOli AMKTOBaOCR ‘9To HHTepecaMH KOAOHHabHOM NOAWTHKH. MeuBmerpKesaassaxscckeoroGoHmabpeogaT,pyMaH6poacitieitAnBrecBmoceaftpuAneaTHeaMvbaHnaOCcToHsHMaOBaMtbp,oc¥sTeO- HO BeCTH GopbOy He TOABKO C HeBexKeCTBOM Hapona, HO HC B.IACTSI- «...‘MH, MellalollluMH HapoxHoMy O6pasopanmio. Ox ncaa: Bcero. xyKe xei » 2 Tam *Tam xe, crp. 296,
BectH Gopb6y He c HaposHbIM HeBexECTBOM, a C JOAbMH Ke O6paso- BAaHHbIMH, NOCTABJCHHLIMH MpaBHTeIbCTBOM JUIN cofelicTBua oGtiLectT- nennomy 6slarococtosumo>', Oro sasBnenne AatTbIHCapHiia — xXapaktepHoe cBHAeTeNDCTBO Toro, 470 OH Ha¥adl Y2Ke XOPOWIO NOHHMATb, KTO TOPMOSHT Aero MpocRenteHHs KasaxcKoro Hapona. eteBerpean ciabioe npornnogeiictane 8 oprannsanun pyccko- KHPIH3CKHX IKON CO CTOPOHBI Kasaxckoii PeosaabHoil 3HaTH H Mycyvib- MaHCKOrO AYXOBEHCTBA, a TaKKE CO CTOPOHBI MeCTHOH auMHuNcTpanHu, Hopait Acrbincapm Hauunaer Biagath B NeccuMUsM, ero Bepa B BO3- HeliMOXHOCTh OCYIMECTBMCHHA CBOHX NPOCBETHTEABCKUX HaYHHaeT Ko- sieGarics, AatbincapHn co3HaeT, 4TO OAUH OM GeccHseH cnpasuTbcs co BCeMMH TPYAHOCTAMH, TAK KaK HeBEXKECTBO H OTCTAAOCTh Hapora NosUeEp- bic2kuBaiotes Baactamu. Emy nopoii mpuxoaut » roaosy mpexpa- eleTHT CBOIO MPOCBETHTeEILCKyIO AeATebHOCTb: «Cocayxy... OAHY poset,cAYAGY 3a CBOHX COCTABHB Ha KUPTH3CKOM s3BIKE KHHTY? ¢ O6- npTCH, BEPOATHO, CAOAKUTL OPyx*KHe H OOPaTHTbCA B NacTyxa, KOTOPbIM HLCOGPASOBATEABHBIMU HaYIHBIMH BOOGIE CBEAeHHSMI, a MOTOM # Hu Obit poxsen. Tpyaua Gopp6a co 30M, nycTHBUIMM yxe rayGoKHe KOPHH B KHpriiscKOM Hapoge TaTapcKUMH HaLIMMU Mpodeccopastit, Ho veule TPyAHee H ONACHO HMeTH AeTO ¢ aAMHHHCTPATHBHLIMH BuACTAMH, a>,TOTOBLIMH H3-3a NpocToro AaxKke KaNpusa NoryGuTs YecTHoro YesTOBe- Aateincapuy Nomaras, YTO ero MocTOAHHBIe CTBINKH ¢ MpescTasnte- IMM Ka3axcKoll eonarbHoll BepXyWKH, MycyAbMaHcKOrO AyXoBeHCTBa ela jaHero JHYHO, TAK H WIA M MecTHBIX BaacTeli MOryT MPHBeCTH K OMACHBIM MOcMeACTBHAM KaK HapoAHOTO NpocBeueHus. BosMorxHO, ¥TO MOSTOMY OH PELUHI He MOPTHTh OKOHYATENbHO CBO OTHOUIEHYA ¢ Ha- 4aIbCTBOM H YiiTH B OTCTaBKy. Tpupexennoe ppicKasuinanne u3 nucem Anruincapuna npamesarte: HO HE TOABKO TeM, YTO B HEM CKBO3AT MeCCHMUCTHYECKHE HOTKH, Jeane OPOTpyAHOcTAMH GopbObi 3a HapoAHOe Mpocwemlenue, HoH TeM, “10 BbIMAWUINiicH KaSaxcKHil NpocBeTHTetb, OOBHHAA aMHHUCTpaTHBHBIC BaacTH BMecTe c TaK HaSBIBaeMBIMH «TaTapcKHMH mpodbeccopanu» (MyvviaMH) B TOpMOxeHHH JeTa pasBHTHA HaponHoro OGpasoBanHs, No- Ka3bIBaeT NO CylllecTBy, YTO PYCCKHe KOJOHU3ATOPHI H MHCCHOHepEI, 11e- CMOTPA Ha CBOH (pagel O BHINOTHAeMO! UMM KyuBTYpHO! MuCCHH B OT- CTabIX HalHOHAJDHBIX OKPaHHax, He 3aMHTepecoBanbl B TOM, \"TOOD AeiCTBUTeIDHO BLINOAHATh ToRoGHy!O MHCCHW. no.TKupKHeWMHoWOHApaaNpiuiUsMMA, antNuBpinoBKcOaapAsuUanMxcyt!KoanpeuT.tuoucOneocnxkcHTpBuYgOIeOTaHUOLnICMoHaHIuCTHHKKsKAyaHcaHcNamaHlOunRoPAnToabacHbcOHHMolBOANTC HoMeHHH Hepycckux HapogHocteii. Anrbincapuny, Kak BepHOMy cbIIy 1Tam xe 22HSt,y HxuaupryMAunatcuxnuciatp,un we yener uszaTb npH 2KHaHH, erp. 261 Bocnommanna 06 Kasans, 1895, H. A. Antuncapune. 470
Joel‘ceoero Hapona, Obi10 GombuO OT TOTO, YTO PyCCKHe UMHOBHHKH CMOTPe- 1M Ha Ka3axop, Kak Ha HH3Wei Pacbl, NpeHeGpexuTebHO OTHO- ‘cHaNch K Ka3axcKoMy Hapofy, Kak K MemeHH, CTosiileMy sAKOGbI Ha ‘ypesxe AuKapeil. ~ Kputnxys takoe othomenne Tak HasbiBaembIx <o6pazoBanitbIx» pyc- KHX K MecTHOMy Haceseniio, AnTLIHCapHH roBOpHa, 4TO 3anaya Kysb- “TYPHbIX Moxef COCTOHT He B TOM, YTOOLI yHIMKATD KasaxcKHii Hapol W3- ‘3a ero OTCTANOCTH, HeBexKecTBa, a CONElICTBOBATD ero KysIbTyPHOMY pas- BHTIO. «... Mcrunuo nopa yxke 6bi10 XoTb OLHOMy AOGpomy YeTOBeKy OGpa- ‘ut, Aoctofixoe BHHMaKHe ua Opay, BCeMH nOWTH OpomeHnyI Aocere H HaSbIBaeMYIO B ONNCAHHAX TOKO KOJOTOPHAKAMH, AMKApAMM H Mpoy. OptH Mpo¥., —NHcan Bbiyawutniica mpocserutesb. —Ton0xXHM, YTO KHp- TH3 — JUKapb, HO HY2KHO %e XOTb ONHOMY U3 MIMINYUMX YMHBIX suojeii BbIMOABHTb LOOpoe c1OBeUKO O TeX MepaX, KOTOPbIe MOTH Gb aMJianpasaare y wux AelicTaHTeADHO HesaBuaANBiit BUA, HaNpapastD KHPrH3 K MpaBHAbOMy MoHsTHIO OOueYeTOReYeCKO! 2UsHH>*, Joell»___ Aatpincapnn JUYULIX YMUBIX BbipaxaHe3tcaPOcutIpOeAsCpTpBluyaIOliM#oHXOcKTOpyporoxKBHOP,ocKcpnHiT.HKOYnA «<mH- sPHO HaMekaeT Ha 70, YTO y O*HUHabHBIX NpexcTaBHTeteit WapusMa CAOBa Kelair| PpacxoAATcA c AeAAMH, YTO OHH He NpeANPHHAMATb pea/bHbIX JiaMep elicTBUTeNbHOrO TOAHATHA KyJbTypHOrO ypoBHA Ka3zaxckKoroO Hapoma. Taxum o6pasom, 8 npouecce croeii npocsetHTenbcKoli AestrenbHOcTH pot oeTIpuATHIM, HanpaBrenibim Ha ero Npocseutenne. Antbincapun, 6yayan M6paii Anteincapun norsia peakiwonnyio cyuuiOcTh MecTHEIX opraHon ‘BIACTH, HX BpAxKLeGHOCTh UNTepecaM Hapola H Mepo- “BbiPASHTeeM HHTepecos TPyLOBOrO Hapoa M CTPAacTHbIM MOGOPHHKOM tei.ero Mpocnemlenus, He Mor MOTIATD, BH HenpaBnabHbIe MelicTBNs BAC On KPHTHKOBAN H OCy*KAa.1 HX TaM, rae eMy MpescTaBsAAch BOS- MOXKHOCT 9TO CileMaTb. Bee 9to nokasninaet, uro H. Aatsincapin KpuTHyecku OTHOCHICH K “conpemenutim: emy o6ttlectRenHo-noamTHecKHM —nlopsutkaM. OsHAKO, KpHTHKYs OGmLecTBEHHEIe NOpOKH, NpeneTapuTesteli MecTHEIX opraxon “BaacTH, peakiMonHol Ka3axcKoii deoxatDHOfi BepxyIKH H MycyJIbMaH- “ckoro Jyxonenctsa, ATbINcapnn He NOAHAICA 10 KPHTHKH OGnecTBeH- “-HO-MOMHTHYECKOTO CTPOA B TeOM. Wcropnueckaa orpannuenniocth mupordaspenus M6pas Aarreincapr- Ha He NO3BOJNa eMy NOHATh Toro, 4TO COMMATbHaA Hecrpane;AMBOCTE OLE.THMeCT CBOIO MATEPHATLHYIO OCHOBY B TOCHOACTBYIOULHX COLMATbHO-9KO- HOMHYeCKHX OTHOMeHHAX UroGbl AUKBHANPOBATD HeBerKecTBO, Gecnpanue, yruerenne, OGulecTBeHHy!O HecnpaBex1HBOCTh, Halo YHH- DKHITb HX SKOHOMHMECKYIO OCHOBY, PeBOOUHONHO TIpeoGpasoBaTh O6lecTBO H Ha 3TO! OcHOBe OGecne4HT SKOHOMHYECKOe H KyJIbTypHOe pasBntue Hapoa. 1 Tam xe, erp. 214 471
et* e HOpai Anteincapun Opi HCTHHHEIM NaTpHoTOM, rops4o m06NBUIH cBoi Hapo, HO %*KaloBasica Ha CyAbGy, YTO KUBET B TAKyIO SNMOxy, NpH KoTopoi cKoBbIBaloTcA GaaropomHble CTpeMseHHaA H XKesaHHA sogell # He a«...lOTMBiOeSMcOTXaHHOoCpTuHtcaPasrBoeppHbyKTEOCA UM. HM CMelIHO,—roBopHT mpocseTH- Teb, — Korla CpaBHHBalo Ce6a C NOXHA0I0, NOCTOAHHO Mla4yileo *KeH- pai reuuHofi, Bcerla Kastyloutelicn Ha GeaxactoctHe cyALGbi>!, Aareicapun crpemitcn B ryuly Hapona, on xoTe ncerma 6biTb TaM, GbiMM MpoctHle JOAN. ToABKO HAaXOAACh CpeAH TPYJLTLULMX- cH, OH MOAyYaN YAOBOALCTBHe, YYBCTROBA CeOA MOPATbHO MH YXOBHO: yaossersopeHHbim. Uecrocts, nopxqoynocTh, GraroposcTso OH Buse He y 3HATHBIX J1oseii, OoraTeeB, YHHOBHHKOB, BbICOKOMePHBIX H HaMeH- HBIX, a Y MpocTBIx Mosel, KasaxcKHx TpyxennKoB. «OHO TOAbKO yAO- BOAIBCTBHE ObIBaeT 3HMOI0, —roBoput AntsIHcapHt,—4TO nMocToAHHO HaXxO_MUID ce6e Kpyr MopAAOUNBIX KUprH3oB, B Gecemax c STHMH MIpo- CTBIMH, OTKPOBCHHBIMH, Goslee YECTHLIMH, a HHOPAa 1 3a6aBHIMH JOAb- MH BCera HaXOMMMI, YAOBOMbCTBHE>*. Wopai Anremcapun, Gyaysu HHcHeKTOpOM HapoAHbIX yUMJHUL, 3a- HHMas Tako! OpHUMabHLI MocT, He CUHTaN AA ce6a MOAOGHA MecT- MOGEIBATE HOMY HawactbcTBy YHIDKeHHeM CHYCTHTBCA K HAPOHEIM HHSAM, Aatbinca- B Ka3aXCKHX aysaX, NOMHTepecoBaTLcA HX XKUSHDIO H Optom. rePHH cTapasca u3GeraTb KOMNAaHHH CBOHX KOJJer-4HHOBHAKOB HM CTpe- MHJIcH ObITh TAM, KUBeT M TpyAUTcA Mpoctoit Hapom. B auye ua- yanpetsa AsTbIHCapHi Buen Mosel, npHAepxKuBaoMyxcA yOexnennil, rNep-HorHHBOOyNaObAOKBHL3IaXxoaeyrcoTbHco,6c—TBnencHabiaM. «ITpeqnounTaio Beerqa CAyKUTb AnTHHCapHH, — HexKerH nocpelH Ha¥aJbCTBA, COMTHCh C KOTOPbIM #, BEPOATHO, He CYMeIO, a CleTaTb YTO- Hn6yAb To cBoemy yOexkeHHio, Kak ToHa4asbHOMy, MHe He MpH- 0G.Retca>’. MOpait Anrsicapun ucKpertte Boi Hapox, oT Bcero cepAua Onn2HTKPaYpeAoaAttUaLUeAMronCTHE,GIHKaCrOoaTpnAHoaHzOyHH4Heus%OKHKAaCsSeYbnIaBcATWbIHHAC. JDeOHHBerCG,aeMsHCHTBBCSEA3HYAEHOCOKpMoHBbCsM.ToaspoaxvKiecHs IHuM3.OMTpOyMacDs- cKUX yuHTetel, XOPOWO SHABIUA AMUHYI X%KUIHb BLINAIOMLerocH KASAX- ckoro Negarora, nucat o Hem: <Hapog KupruscKHii oTHOCHACH K HeMy C ray6oxum ysaxeunem. Opto 3a uto HM ysaxaTp Hsana Anexceenn4a: PasanasABKHeHBOTXCeOpTMuBMI,Oep,OorHonleBBnCtoTeBPrYA, AaHHHbIYHeAYacA:AKTAAOiAdBIHOCKUeXULUPNMrOHoCb3sWySIyHraoauAaOMbTlOOBOOONPpGOEaHTMPHDaOIso;Hr.aoHPEHyScMcBAcOBHkHHnCcHeNBMeoOHmebforNcHeO,scMeoOGnbtLectLpsTHtBBeCCTHAOO---- BUA.Ke B HEM 1OGporo HM cnpaBesUBOTO HeTOBeKa>*. jeMoKpaTHueckHe yOexkKAeHHs, MaTpHOTHYeCKHe YYBCTBA, HLH Cpon 21 TTaamm xxxeee,,, crp. 212. 3Tam erp. 217. me, erp, 239. 4 Tam crp, 388 172
cnpaseausoctu AaritucapuH cTpemuicn MpuBHBaTH —-yuaUlLUMcst. AsTbiicapHH MpaMo TOBOpHA, YTO OH, KaK MHCHeKTOP HapOMHBIX yuH- 3afatyJIMUL, CTaBHA BOCHHTAHHA Mosel He B Ayxe TeX 4HHOBHHKOR, yipaputeseii, BOAOCTHEIX CTaPIIHH, KOTOPbie NpesHpaloT Hapon, a B Ay- Xe yBaxKenuA K TPY/AILMMcA MaCCaM, TOTOBHOCTH OKAa3aTb MOMOLLb Gec- NpaByEiM, oGe3osenHnbIM JO_AM. AaTBIHCAapHH OcyxKZaeT noBemenne H-KoseHeKOTOPHIX Ka3AXOB, HCHOMLIYIOULX MOMYYeHHBIe B PYCCKO!t J0-Hua BO BPex CBOHM COpomHaM. On ykaabiBaeT, UTO OGpasoBaHible 2M LOJKHbI HCNOML3OBATH CBOH 3HAHHS JVI TOPO, YTOObI HaNpaBHTb TeM- AuTBCA.ible MacebI Ha MIYTb kYabTYpbI_H Mporpecca, a He cTaHOBHTECA «<GeszKa- JOCTHBIMH OOHAYHKAMH KHPPH3OB xe», He H3enaTbeA Has HUME, —Tlostomy AstsincapiH NpusbiBat cBoux coposnyel K Tpyay. On no-Hi. Aarpcapun B ceoeii nezarormuecKkoii AeATeAbHOcTH OGpanian ‘cepbesHoe BHHMaHHe He TObKO Ha NosyyeHHe yuauMuca rayGoKHx aHaHuil, HO M Ha ycBoeHHe UMH «xopomlero NOHATHSD. Tlog 9THM OH NOHHMad NOAOAUTeEM_HOe BOCNHTAHKeE yUAalLHXCA, He- Mpapslenkoe Ha TO, YTOGbI OHH BOCHPHHAIH MepexoBbie H AeMOKpaTHHe- ckHe Wen, YcBousIH MporpeccuBHyio PyccKyw KysIbTYpy. neiCymuoctb stux MH. Aatpiicapaia cocTout B TOM, 4TO, cleays neqaroruueckum coseram K. JI. Yauickoro, of BocnuTinan yaanunxcs 8 Ayxe 106Bu H yBaxKeHuA K TpyAy, K JuOAGM Tpyza. On yaHa jeTeii, ‘TO TPYAOMIOGHe — 9TO NONOXHTebHOeE KaYeCTBO, KOTOPOe AONKHO sit» Mipiicyte Kaxomy. YesOBeKy. B paxe pacckasop, BOcxBaaNIOWHX TovesHBIi, npousBoaHTebHBtit apya, H6pai Anruincapun BeipaxKaer Mbicay, YTO ToTpe6HocTs Tpy- ANTbCA ABIAETCH ECTECTBREHHBIM CBOICTBOM YemOBeKa. B masenpxom pacckase «[ayk, Mypaseii, actouka>, lomementom B «<Kuprusckoit xpecromatun», AuTbiHcapHH CaHTaeT, YTO HaceKOMBIe, nTHub! H TO TpyssiTes. DKHsHb HX NPOXOAHT B Tpyne, H ONaromapA 9TO- My OHH CylilecTByIoT 1 pa3sMHoxaloTes. HM s0AH JomKHbI HenpeMeHHo Tpyantecs. Besesbe, enh, napa3sHTH3M — NpOTHBHB ecTecTsenHOMY Aa‘COCTOAHMIO JNOMeil, YeOBeK OT NPUPOAbI POrKeH Toro, YTOGBI TPy- yvaa cpoux BOcnHTaHHHKoB, ¥TO GAaroxapsa ynopHomy, HacToiiMHBOMy ‘TPyaAy M060! YenoBeK MoxeT AOCTHTHYTD BEICOKOit neH. Tlono6x0 To- ‘MY, Kak H3 NOCTOAHHO TeKYHLX PY4eHKOB, BIXOAMMULMX H3 CBOHX POAHH- ‘Kos, o6pasyiorca peku, ropoput AntsincapHu B pacckase «<Uuctetit pon- ‘HHK»>', TaK H YeNOBEK B PeSyAbTATe HeyYTOMMMOTO TpyAa MOXKET PacTH H ‘CTATb B KOHIe KOHIOB GoubIIHM deOBeKOM. B («Bail»)?paccxase «Borarerso> Aaruncapny npipaxkaet ew O TOM, YTO Tpyx ABAKeTCA HCTOUHHKOM GoratcTBa. On yKasbiBaeT ‘Ha 10, YTO JOAN AOIKHBI %*KALaTb GoraTeTBa He OT GoxecTBeNHOli Muzt0C- ‘TM, a OT cBOero YecTHOrO TpyAa. B pacckase NowectByeTca O TOM, ITO Myappiii crapHK nepen cnoeii CMepTbio CKa3aa CbIHY, YTO ON OCTABHA eMy 1M AAaatrwunaccaappnnan,. Kuprusckan xpectomatis. Kasaun, 1879, erp. 40 Ma6pamime mpouanenenin (wa 2H. KasaxcKom aauiKe). Aawa-Ara, 1943, erp. 66. 173
B HacueqcTBO Goubiol Krag. Ecam on pasbilller sTOT Kaa, TO MUKOr Ae we GyAeT HCHbITbIBATh HYKAY, GyfeT BCerfa CbITbIM H OMeTbIM. OGpa- AOBABLINCh STOMY, CHIH Mocae CMepTH OTHa pacKanbiBaer BOKpyr KatSemsI0 B Haqexkie HaiiTH HM CTaTb GoraTbIM, HO HHrfe ero He Ha- octasitxHoagcauetm. cTTBooraa3emMiyiosp. btEitcaTueroTBhteKGyzOeGubmacuosGtepraGematyb:ip<atObre ee, Te6e 1 esceellib ceMena, NOTPYAHINBeN BO-BpeMs, oceHbio No- NOTepE yGepeut» ypoxail — BOT Tora Tb COGepellh MHOro 3epHa, Gynemib GoraTbIM, He GyqeuID ro- JOAuEIM H rosbIM, BoratcTso — B 3emule, B Tpye>. 3aecb xapakrepHo to, uro H6paii Anteincapuu Buazut GoratcTBo B SeMJeNebYeCKOM Tpyle. DtuM OH OGpataer ocoG60e BHMMaHHe Ka3zaX- reckoro HaceweHHA Ha SeMsexembYecKoe MpousBogcTBo. B natpuapxaav- HO-eosabuoM OGulecTBe, POCOACTBOBAAO IKCTEHCHBHO-CKOTOBOI- ueckoe xossiicTBo, NoAYepKHBanHe AstTbIcapunbiM UpesBstuainoli 10- ACSHOCTH 3EMEMEAUH CBHETEECTBOBAO O NpoOsoOpAMBOCTH KasaxcKoro porMBICAHTeAH, NOHUMAHKH HM MporpeccuBHo 3emAeRenHaA B paseii- THHJ9ektosH,OMHHeKxHenKanangeaxcTrapnyiaau. reen H. Aateiticapun cuntaer Goabulin Joel.3JIOM, MOpOxAaloulMM NOpoKH [lo ero MHeHHIO, BCe HOA, Hesa- BHCHMO OT Toro, GoraTbi OHH HAH GexHbI, AOKHDE TpyauTsca. Mnave OHM MOryT HCMOPTHTBCH, MOTepsITh CBOE TeMOBEYeCKOE OCTIMUCTBO, B cpoem pacckase «)Komapt»! Aatbincapnit roBoput 0 TOM, YTO KH OHH OFeHb NOOpwlii Gaii AKomapt, KoTOpsiit, O6Aaqad orpomMHBIM 60- TaTCTBOM, TeM He MeHee NocToAHHo TpyaHscs. JlioxK, yAMBJeHHbIE TORE- Aenvem Gas, clipaliMBasu ero, 3a4em emy [pomHBaTb NOT, TpyAuTLCs, MYWHTBCH, KONA OH HH B YeM He Hyxsaetcs. Veramn Gas Kasaxcxw'i MpocsetHtetb OGbACHAeT, NOYeMy BCeM HeOOXOAHMO TpyANTBCA. Bo-nlepapix, MpHBbluka e34UTb Ha KosHoeg, eitHOCHHTaSqMejnoHpEoIMrnHe. OMeKAL, CTapatbes ObITh KpacuBbim XOpoulem Aetaet Beaescrane 3toro OHH HaYHHaIOT Npesupats Mogell, CTORMLIX HIDKE 1X, CTaHOBATCH GesxKATOCTHBIMH, GeccepredHbIMH, TepmOT CBOIO YerTOBES- HocTh, Mepectaior COMYBCTBOBATE GeHbIM H OOe31OTCHHBIM, 326bIBa107 aoa© HeOOxoAHMOCTH NOMOraTD HM. Bo-sropsix, ecm Gyayr tpyautecs, GyayHM aaxKe GoraTbiNnr, TO MoaOAoe NOKOTeHHe GyneT yOexAATHCA B TOM, ITO Tym He ecrh 4TO: To Nosopsaiiee YesoneKa. Onn 6yAyT BOcNPHHHMaTb Tpyg Kak AOcTOII Hoe .11060ro NopasoMHOrO HemOBeKA sleLI0. JatB-tperbux, ToABKO Ta TIMMLa MowtesHa YeTOBeYeCKOrO OpranHaMa ut Oyler YesoeHa UM, eCIM OHA 3apaGoTaHa YeCTHEIM TpytOM YeAOBeKA. H OHKMoxTePuYnAoH,ANnCoHn,piOrkabaAy6rpoannnaHAOnr!p. inBcaanpunnoaromByayu#imGtbbuGtoryartHbiemra,reTsiOsOiNL|! Hapofla, YO OHH He SAHHMAJHCh MPOHSBOAUTeTBHLIM TpyAOM, TAK Kak KHAN 3a CHET KCTYATAIMH OCHOBHOM Maccel TpyARULNXcH, BeMH Napa- auTHUecKHit OGpas *KUBHH. Ho yrsepxzenne AntbIHCapHia 0 TOM, YTO TOADKO 3apaGoTaHHoe CBOMM TPYAOM HAeT Ha NO1b3y, KOCBeHHBIM O6pa30m OcyxKAaeT Goratcr 1H. Aatwncapun, Kuprusccan xpecrowarus, Kagane, 1879, exp, 46. 174
BO, MpHOOperenHoe He CBOMM TPYOM, a B pesyabTaTe oKcilayaTanit TpyaRuxcs, _ Cuntast tpyx novetHoi oGasannoctoio, Aarbiicapun npexocteperaet CBOHX COOTeYECTBEHHHKOB He COGMA3HATKCA KaKHMH-J1N60 HeYHCTbIMIT NYTAMH AOGbiBaHNs CpeACTB K XKUBHM, He MOMaBaTbCA j0-MeHHAM, 160 TOKO YecTHBIit Tpy, Mower MpHHecTH -eraTok. HHKAKAM HCKY- YeTOBeKy : ceptF EXTTcyapaecau6tnoaGwy3eaaacweyssem,tcoruwnuyeiwtap1oyon6ayuncuaranpTliat»rtc©ec6aTB>oeoh6petopnwcyceyrzruaaoonnuwitt'., 20m, ~ Mponaranga Aatsicapaitim tpyzosoit ocHosbt xKH3HM cBm3aHa OOULUMI AeMOKPATHHECKUMH YOOKACHUIMH BLLLaIOULerOcA MIpocBeTH- Tens. Aatbincapimt BOCHUTEBAN YYAMLUXCs B AYXe TYMaHUBMa, B Ayxe fF “ToBHOCTH OKAsaTH NOMONIS GerHEIM, OGesxoeHHbIM sHOAAM. JLoGpoTy 1 TYMAHN3M OH CHUTAM BbICOKAMH MOPaJIDHBIMH KatecTBRAMH sHosell, a oKa- He —oIroMTOMOULM GexHLIM, CTpaqaiolluM BeAKOTO 4eOBEKa- ITHINCAPHH YTBEPAMAT, TO MOAN OT NPUPOALE PaBKe!, HeT HOME, Ha- AyaleHHBIX GOTOM HCKMOUNTEMbUBIMH KaYecTBAMH. Ox roBopit: «Bcex pox AeHHBIX He GEO icKOBO FpeeT COMHME, CBETAT yHEI. Oco6o pastp.yr «uspasoHet Ha 9Toii it Moraiire Ayr3eMste, Mepe Apyrom c BCeM Mer Beth of YeAOBeKA BCE Mbt JDKHTITEL, MBI AeTCTBa BO MpoHSoULTH. ofHOTO apyry. Bce GnicrpoTesHo npoligzers?. Tipusbin K YexoBekomo6mi0, npoHKHyTEiit ray6oKUM —crpeMsiensext MOL YTHETEHHBIM, OOACTIUTH YYACTh TPyAMMLAXCH CERIO IBYYNT B X CTpoKax ua <KupruscKoi xpectomatiity: Ect Tit veaowex, uuKorna He oropyail Geanana. f Cepaue ero o6uaoh aerko pasGute’. Aarbincapuit ropoput He 0 Apy2kecKoM HW ryMaHHOM OTHOMIeHHH Kk jOBeKy BOOGIE, a UMeHHO K GenUAKY, K yrieTeromy. Sto HaxoauT- MB cMxOouaHsOMu3COwOaTeBiEi TCryTmBUaHnuCsmAaE, MOAKnPtAiTnHcYaEpCHKHnMH8 HXeKMH MpocBeTHTects. Maer cBonx mpowsBenenus GbI| Tpatbt TpoTHB pacToUNTeTBCTBA Gaew B GLITY, NpoTHB GecembIc.ieH- CpeACTB, KOTOPHIe MOKHO Obi TYYMIe MeNOABSOBATH JLT ennui, OGesqoleHHbiM. B pacckase «Ckynocrs 1 Gepexcaist- 10«Ku, uMrapelcTaBYamTeoHuutesmH coGoit tepesox, 43 yueOunka H. HW. Maysco- ynpaxkHeHuit MpakTHueckux B pyccKOM s3bI- VW. Aarsincapun ykasbieaer, 170 JOM AOTKHDL GepexKAUBO OTHO- si K cBOeMY HMyillecTBy, JeHBraM, XOTR GBI oN H OOsaRaAK Ge3- HIM GoratcTROM. Caon GoraTcTRa OHM AOMKHEI PacxomOBATe pasyM- #1 Tam aaexe,, exp. 9. 1 Tam cmp, Tam W. me, erp. 95. c 175: Ay
aSOteoMn, nK¢pHimMO,omTPHpasaToMUit.TMECB,soAOraOHtacprastGtotaaasrHioceThBOKApoHc/zTrKoeHmnmObHbyIea‘TepuRanwKeKktaUa,mpH,HTaMbc6RopKaai3iGaenAcninleetsp1MbinHOcOMa,pOHUL&i ja4lo.etseiaii, oso Kurciel.peaie 3aT‘cpdGKHMs‘TOe‘RMarpBeu“MuecceeapBeJuyoTnneTeeHleeeJOyxHHc,sntyHMBOmtH«uTTPUHpiHaJwMeHVBBeObsHHOeeeIlHsBAtCOemAalHacioaMH.AxalKItHTn:apMienTrMHCiCaNeeoHOaeAHeKKM6JMmeCpcKsIHtTiOeeHHJbasaiOtbsHEMutI3THKTHBoatMeaOVMcXoOOsKCtaHHbpoMTiomoiaBTCouTM.lnaOar,HuNceOT3TApoHoYycsMtcbAHKHLTyPoMoHc2bB4naOeOEO,KAHrMM.I1Ipom,nMnBoMUMBAB,c0HruOeptLyeJCoHoJDHapcEeaKMnHlMICoHlrBOaToeMT,Cc0iOaiaHBLsce,aaMcHC1ctyTaIpMACXihnTbMHo0aiHHOsaYpeT/wcKIOeIGxoppPpLnSAToervHeaOSHoBABAyeEmaoMieBBMHsATItmTaHTGHnHiiXpObNiiHOOIbOlaYMAoHiKcHoyMaeuicsTs,BoLTkpxkO.aOrbHa,epOyHoOxLymMHeMaoX.eeXeMTAeIyrMLHAeKriOsTxAOeHHOAmy1toitBOkaE,OCpPoHSecL—a;yXsMHaApEyGTtCeL7HoanYH<MeK,xHHrTKHrBGAb4AnCtEytxiATHaHTumeneaAbKMea,roCOuMPIBiaaaouaiO“psMpioTY,THecmricaHWTtoameKonMTIobdbTTATucsGUiooHAtcaHAni,aolCpr,Kyu‘2seaoMaiTeKcpa,HtNpKHiMnV0ceHtBCTqnOKBarraeec;nietAeAaaKTIu,cB.:itoH>IoaoMeOiBaINpKoNGibi’ssas<eGHM>cAOTTi.iOeI,EpixoanklpAekMO:is.eopoHMeIHHacyeaiyuOpm.wOaPniTptT;MHexncpyBAMMbGpHiaoanSenSIrBHBricsOMxiTsni.KiBYHKua.OoalMcOOB.IHeaHMi3TnaUCTMXnOaiMCHGoeKynPcapopcTis>YcOrrloTocooBaSciicHHyTorneKaemaPth1ua3O3xyT3uEapMcT0axBpKNTOabpCrMMTeBOenme*AHTIaKKeCOpOp,pAbiOAusnHHKAuTJtoM6erBeAuBnbXOOcHzKaexOCmHKnbaOaH6TeeUOy¢HH.-OTiyTTtqOpLtotxTeMMHTT:HK>uiTefOnMAOt,A6BHiaXOeaaPGaMebmC0slOMnMlOTB6leoTOOcaE9MneeOen6OsTOMrrpT0FT3AeopcpsIKHBH6paHp/HTnXreXT01obsH-x-paO-oO-h--0-1I-:a-,---- yun. lo corBYaMiP‘TeaesIuaTcpsCmcHpiTHOceuHBBMnHMnHnHeTyuUeY,TbMaCMckA,AoToOOoOrTMCBrpToYHOHaO9TCOHAn7,KITBHXHmOHOPAMHuOTTHsAAOeIOAHaTanHHOePTSnMOHTHMSoasME9OrccTBOyteOKHOHKHGTpSaOHsOeMalACatKKcOHTccBBH/cHyAayoCaYoHeCBcCcceHeOTCkAoTrOoTHrKbBaYoONeEepOITaMoXc3TOeHroaHHermCOrcpaAcOCsHKemHPTBpAOHeoOHxTTCIcASaOaHTcxSnBOHKaHpnOetHBOesNHpcTOacOHidObyirTaACOcnGOrclTayetATeMpcRbc3oTAuHTsaaB6lOnBHnmHCeatCHapTTHepEAsibMcnMyTXTtcBrp,naWoaoIa.AXTrp.FPoeHHOOYn.BCTMYtnOHOACTT6OpTHYnO0AneOeeM,dCtsOMBTBAtpBTHnNBHYOc.0HbE)Ha6!sYl- peroJlemoxpatmueckiie CTPeMsTeHHSt Wopaa -Aareincapnna NIDOABAAIOTCA BanAfax Ha TOANTHHECKyIO BACTH, Ha CHCTeEMY AAMHHMCTPATHD- Horo ympaBlenns. syemu1 naTyprFL adA, mymeuanacuasphusar)o.po<xOpTeynpcryapiircexxonkh o6aacts, 18 wapea 1880 r. (xoppecnor ancror>, 1880, Ne 16, 176
uo strolua, Jeo np cya, ora“‘AiCH‘TrKtBSHnfcnToyBuipToooatocO,emTeuprpOKnUrAppObrneeMpooiMOawaStp3alpySivcabqetOrkeyeuMclEopMTBeopNHrtkBpiuPeM.MaeHnpIaaasnnTaoHecMrcAsecuIKxBucmHcaBamTmLsuexOoExpEyOoATe.auTHPuCae[KHniHoHleAnstBMBAiCUepuHrAKSeoaKep<nsAAOepUr3MpauoKaAeTTMMeKbsePAeBpu3deoisArAACCHIpuaeeBeBD0ohTYOrtiOrseHabuUKHy,pu-cv.TsIHYMCBHkTyceAeuOY,IDnBLKOBEieerOnoTCin3oLHMroTCtbmOabTTaTiAxbOiRip>n[IBmiH3BMeEnreMToE,eHMeanNHcOHrIMOHKaOaBBHUHp4XBApAIbKoEOHpa1YGHbItsIAMCpeU0aHcXiyecBHTs,aArPaHcToHbcsHeeuTOHBpKpIc1HaiDOOTcMAyteAmnAsPHEuHTKCaFxOCrnnoBcTAOaMMuTpuATsTteH:aAHrspiHapeaBHtteHHEeusdyO,pOx>t3tGsAyBiBoeaTFveK,AeuOOua<eHsTKOMliarLeeA1uOHBOanATHNupOneHgHOscaioPpMpxiaiKaXOHOiycHaenKxosOCTsraHmacHcHMpLTopotkOOMoMOCuelercuidHCoYFMmorny.MctyTxOeas6BsNaUN/y,MeeaapIycBcMTst1C‘PpaTnI.eAyBaXOTnHcuspG.,DylMnraaraOuOsseBuyTBnJaBaaAHaOBiToMaox,yseeoBSmopaIK.ac.sLBIaxuonm3cAG1cH0opvLciaC3,pco6eanToLTaTloK2wlbannceaPKTtac3tpeibiOaatsOesOeaitThTe-s.t---,-t-- iuV3TUOsdOpByLcI,ckUiTxOGyEuI eHOeunMkOonAHHHiS. TAECnAtiin3acKaOpHiiYt>\"N, oxOupast 2.19 cBoero yue6- we cogByuHO ero bistinka TaKiie Pacckasbl, CONeprKaHHe KOTOPHx ens,yap)CBcM.bHbaTlOeaeTAieuObTrMlHcboxcpiilnOHh,iotaJ,OtetBorIapCpirIoeAKaoMiaRlTkptO,icHro,OopsLTeeeMoOiiOiKs<lentn,KaeTpNaKpAlHoGeKOiTbYpSuOie,ratMAAapKGKHMHccrTHcNuUpOcteaOBpsAaWkoTKcIcmoMcOTeaOaxHMGOrBspl,lNootaaAALbi,eMOetiIOLniXrMKBeGHNCOOOKsHKeOxpBaMLa3TaOpkegLSpHHOsAPaBea0aHeHasceCxMRstbOCptIucMAHYeoieseTkprepaHmixLTobaCeaHHLTIAeracTOHIboYrtnOMBOICAaIEMNLTTKncMTeOUEH,OyKsTYJIBTI?sOpO.NoYaGboMHHregicoeMHoMEMeIRspMaMmIsHoeLap6eCTmHKy3IlpOp.lOaYHeHHaeCOA3TxiTTBYTi2MabHeEHIeA:lIWXC,tOeHBcAn,CpTHaIMTnMCMpe,OHHueNrTyoCBKaMooPMHOgIpsiAOoXOO,HKeateeLcMBssLAlNnIiaHtAnHb,RtnpOpScIipOIeBcMonyHOaGmAhczBuBaGp.uAIe.KOuaTTlaBOtmHTTapa1s,yéreaLpTOolnclCieNep(opncHJBheKOoaTker%OeeaMaaaKOIrTaO--Ko---c IM H TpeOyeT OT BCEX NPHCYTCTBYIONLAX, YTOOLI OHH TYMAHHO OTHO- Ch K GERNEIM JOAAM, MPOAB.ARAN O HHX sa6oTY. XKHToIHDrcaKLyIeXnpeBNccpitnseaoownunixtatGeupaeueaas3lcia,cKkZocaOHTsOpHapoxeor,oroAHCaeHtOcTGnbcMpiiaHOippNceaAaxpImsOHeUusLBtUopgXcaoTcrcHBouAnKTBOMbHaIaHBpcIaa,TsTeHHllOr.eHrOAbaHenrtsbaBCi,nOaMcsMcanpopHxHKaia-t- GBY3eaen0itUlchlMaHrvaO,iuc3niAOtNKGPOnNOHeOLpHHBOeOESreCRaKcTEtbuAhH,aTHcEEGtCGMueHOsiP,3OAaHTINOTKaLTOpCKoHAHaBHHOICBaCXcITTXHHaOLHecIGReXrTiypeaalyJwlTUT.aeHKsIOA,cOTHMeKpBoOBCOrTPuocOEHTPMTLHbaIIsoaes,,kaKHHHsMOeTaFOnMXbAOO9l:TTOEOBLMHeMcHHTeOBBMeHCHOOi---- 1. AMaacreu,necrpa.p4u2n—. Kupriscxas xpectomatun, Kasaup, 1879, erp. 44. 44, Ww
=oeWKAyANTbUTpMYoCpcHHn,oeeBruLpIrCaesTnBYsHTcTAkHeaHesHAKaae3BsaXrHexXncKp3ouaroollclTtHsyapAoCmTaaatH,bOienBrcHoaApHsmACBLaH,bBIeCHeCaHGnMopMsaAeneTsHeHnonuKeaBTHPAvya--Xavi, He suas npasas, unin Hacnane. 3uai, cyzapb, npaaer vac wosmesans, HA tor, Koro TH oGurea, noGepercn 20 TCO: Ocyxaan Gecteronetiioe oTHouIeHHe GoraTees K Gequakam, AstrEtit- capHH Mpelynpexsaer, 410 9TO He Mpoiizer GesHakasanHo, NpHmeT MEH BewutK B OAHOM H3 ero CTHxXOTBOpeHHii TO- TopxKecTBa cipaBeLMBocTH. Boput ycramu Apyra AatbincapHia nosta Kyaepn: Tocnommt, rocnoamil —sactanasa to Be3qe nostopatD, — Cam Gcorraapaal acKaakxoy HHTKH meus, GeaHaKa, OGoxpars. Dit, 2Kiaib Taos GsicrpoTeNHo mpofzer, weex, cyabio HaitaeT. HBi ynGeeranasexnbc—eG6ezecunbpapwaesgoapusaoro 2Kas1062, Cruxorsopetie, 13 KoTOporo BATH 9TH CTPOKH, HasbiBactes «Ca10- Ba, Cka3aHHbie OHOMY YHHOBHUKY 3a TO, WTO He Bisex cnpapesan- Oxo MoMelileHo COcTaB/IeHHOM Aatbincapuupim yaeGunKe. B 06 yuacTH, KoTOpad OxAULAeT 9TOTO 3s0rO B KHHre pew HetBoctXHo»r. a rocnouna, B jlelicTBUTeIbHOCTH HMeIOTCA B BUHAY HKecTOKHe yrHeTaTetit piHapTWonojoeaspoacBpikisoaosAO0aaauTtnl,eot.umKi,nac4KaTipmoun3Ob6IBpxbaigcroKoMacs,nboipB,HatMoKccBatKuoHruHXeTyycOlcoyeBpxHorAesHaXsin3K70apyanp,peAosBunsbotiediitaziiceiTnao-. 2auoCYacKHitHaion3ApaoIoOTxbrkMonCOsoBo,OHpEOEirOaOnOXoMOHAcEHeHMGHOeAC:HTAOH«C..TT. OYPAaMIAS,,beHIKrHUpaebAkyIBK3AmM7To0phxaKBGuHoyicEmly,KeAOTHHTAeOMr,PlopLnoHIaMnOTcaxOOMoH6gBPnEHTaI3eDK0.MMUOOPpPuroOHuHTseK«,P1cb0IaHT8yOa.-:- Koro wesoBeka>*, AJTBIHCapHH CBOe HefOBOJBCTBO H BOsMyILeHHc feficTauiMu BJlacteii BbIpaxKa HeACHO, TYMaHHO, 3aByaNpoBaHio. Meakjly Tem BbilienpHBexeHHbiii OTPEIBOK H3 ero CTHXOTBOPEHHA NO cBoe- My COjlep2Katitio HM TOHY Hanucait B PeBOJIONHOHHOM yXe, BbIparKact peskitii npotect npoTup oGmectseHHol HecnpaneranBocta, npEsbBaeT TeX,HaKASBIBAT KTO GecteNOBeIHO OTHOCHTCH K MPOCTBIM JOAAM. aHBuEHIHMKSNTabgeaeoxrcloaktoBbltHMPOoeMHoCxTaPBaeeKppHAxToyefsIIxLsCeHTBautEHOCdcpuTeMsaMaMmaMnbHpUeoBHcTIaMBoruogBzeHxTaabcptoaAxmna.tENtTPuOMcTapHpeBqucntKaasa,msa0rXe6--- cKHx (beomaton H NpaBitestbcTBa. B 9TOM OTHOMeHMH XapakTepHo MucbMo AntbIHcapuna, aapecoBalt- reabu231 aHHsL.luxrHeAuaptaaeysntewubrenusaocncntacsopkxHuu.anuir,At,enrAKsB,inuoCcpcna.roipsmnCcumxuaaursaaa.muxsAxaopnnewacaot-o6<AmIreaaa,HtaWia.r1,o9m4A9K.m,aesecarAknpnn.a,er6u1u1.c8m7a9pe,unneermp, . mpocerit 77. Kagavis, 1895, erp. 242, 178
MEYHM4CXHHsPMBOyTHHOoBeueoubHpeITrTeXpsaeiXCEHnHtBaAHTvbHycsMOHMOoae.CbauasMcpeHazotoatxCe,eeuHnTc3KHtAnre.btH4easuTt3YelTb.atl,O-.BMOUB,J3p1KAaoHoSHO0eKpBTa,6HMrrbobokBoapecYOruKqaeT6aaCHcaotrGcopooimaoTBtosopaAeHAytepoOtH,cTC,spueaHBunoT6xTsBpIlBBa,EabEaIIeKNTixsncsrKO4nOocapOHBaCpapMapyBTcpuOHx6OuutouHskepPnnrGHjHey~OiaaianiHT!cMyinaobeiMHuNoGMHotBuNpAaK3oOpeHtoGcpamnpTaaeeaPcLeBeotBXymca6ec3KHKpayTcyieMnerTptHakTancbsaeo,eiHBebaBsiixatHcIl3pHBakyk-CXBnY3iByBoaAnaoaeKHiObPaiHyTITcoUaaGacAAocsHBocsaTOO©oBp,6HeMaHpoPoanlnmMpH.0AiAaenl6pKce6ByKiaeH)oTnOIdu!KAOocH.EaO3CLruhB-npT.TT3dHHoecoeaMomoOMrcBnoorioMHBHogcBepeOnBaLtnocaoxMSIBaeoHcitMOtcAiTT,eMmOYoTCHaHHITaeOaOutPATHyBb,pyOeOBsBiHTpauntTHNeHyyaoLaTcOtxa-e------. capuH, BHA, TO MpUMpHTS STHX (PeoRaton, 3anATHX rpaaHol ccopol, HEBOSMOAHO, MOCOBETORAT HaceAeHINO NOKUHYT peonHeaxNa.OMBKpHaOxCxTaSyiBoouOtCeTHcOroTOpouysut patBaxuTueAnoHcrUy3n6uPaanT,b AAAOB AMAA BEITOLAa, BOSBbIMEHHE COGCTBEHHO! Pele Ua_ OGONX MpeTeHeHTOE Mpuxoreli Ha Hee TpeTbero YeI0- Korta pew, Ho y KasaxcKnx NepcoHLi, yAOB/eTBO- MexOUHOro TukecTaBHA WeHHAOCh BEIMTe Bcero. ToaT0- My, o NpHo6perenua agmMunuctpaTHBHolt momKHOCTH, He MPHSHaBAAH HH CoBecTH, HH YecTH, LarKe cMellianH c rpaAIHIO caA- Oli WyBCTBa POACTReHHOM OnHZ0CTH K OpaTy, AaBileMy MoAWM pasym- Tble coper. Hbtii «<M Bor, OHH 13 O3HayeHHBIX axe enuPHHT, o—neNwotzecatsp,ekuaemTbyleiipnpaatsoHpbiam,Hm Gpatbes, — pacckasbisaet AntoiHca- NOOpoxenatenAmu, cTat ocaxKklath Munucrpa Buytpeanux HI.18HMM70eP0OpJUBOafIUisuc,HMugHAaNtesOtOA.nMMcNK[HrOpHsuaOO3x,aAoBMBtgMaOAukeMeslHuaoHarKcaTAThaehkA,LbAaCucxanToKpoByefaeuitBahaMnbuIpoHyceuMTMewn,apHmBu3HsattBMOHIbKrBGIOMIOe,MAPRoKeeOIOOMHGANyepONLaMHKcBOHiHM,OeYCenlTTulHaHOsTe.B-.eT.IaAXBKGHCAOTapBryNuYaspaosMTJOeHlHHreBH-,- K‘M(BTOpe,oalixssH>KaH',o3M-3eBapBYbTeIEXpIcaAuYNmMOerpoaBxe,pAcHTN.sO)B,BAnAOpHGoMybOAeMMBYH,,BBOcHeYe,eBHHHbHaKOOBBCHHTELPLIeM,B,OOXGyKbBAUOCOAHCbISAAOOHCTHBHbBtI3McBBZeO1sN0t 40 baxeHyAPHUsSOBmOMOHIHteK6XaVOsraiOuKTnMMeeEeHnnxTAXuaabWpTAeHoIypBHrAuyIE,CaIaecprMOOoxGBHuaoOOiaiEcbcaTHHyMpOx3yoO-k3n-T.apaaO.e2oKeBrBlaaiOtcaxoSTbpmHioaMi,iNoKtrUsoYBTLSKIGoAKOngMPAaHOXsCOTcaOKoMxMUucMXYrAa,aonaMtUabnTKecOor—HnOaOsCsMaiTnoHnG,,uALoTCKpoenonneOTecopuooHmepMHHaotnaT-- Otgeapmie niicema Aateticapuna K cBoHM Apyasam cannerexect- TTBBOYEloMTlOcH,tTo, sUOHHTOHUTOToObPMIUn,PHp,YaejTicKTOsOHeTBqOyoPAMBHOoaecGTHHeMRbeaIHrteoMaN,HeocBBhTOeotABmueobAcKkAepHAryoryTcApATaaHpTBaSHHHHIeHNaHnCHAMeApreHocH.eTArHLo,BleegoaTabBKAmKaOcuosTnDHNyKsaH,caOcrKCaeaTmlAeB- 1Tam me, erp. 257-258.
wucnekTopa Hapogubix yunanul XapaktepHo, 40 K 9TOMy Gp mpayac- TeH uM cam reHepas-ryOepHatop «ro 0Aateiucapun mucaa: Typraiickoii o6nactH. B cpasn c 3THM xe 3atem KacaeTes To Moero 3/1OCHaCTHA OT HBIHeMMHel TaBb ‘Typraiickoit anmunucrpaumu, 1 B OOULNX YepTax Mponucan o6cTos- TeAbcTBa ero B NHCbMe K Fr. Noneyntemo. MmMenn Aonocuteia ryGepua- TTcOonpp(aaMnseHonepauuHnetaoO,. TcK[lrPoabpWBuI,cieeHmroaysBNBaOHBMAOHCMOoL,oHbYHuTKLOaeH3yHTeeO3qeGHNeosOHroMeOHHNHaHBvOaIMrsOb,HCHYeTKmOa,umK3aO.n,HaTeN4HoHcHOT,coKsHOAe--- HO H TailHO, KaK OKa3bIBaeTes, Mepenucbipaioulerocs ¢ ryGepHaTopoM>'. Kak nokasbipaior apxuenple MatepHatnt, TypraiicKoli oGactHoit an- MHHUCTpalHel ObWIK BLIABHHYTE pasiMyHLte OOBHHeHHA NpoTHB AaTHIn- capuua. B 9ToM OTHOWEeHHH NpHBAeKaeT BHHMAaHHe KON(pHAeHUMATLHOe MHcbMo? Honeuntessn OpenGyprekoro yueGuoro oKpyra K MHIHeTpy Ha- Pposuoro Mpocsellenus, LaTHpoBanHoe 19 mons 1886 r. Kak coo6maetca B nucbMe, AstbiHcapin OOBHHsZICA B TOM, YTO OH reBMeLIMBaeTCcA B YipaBeHnue Toi BoAOcTH TypraiicKoil OGaacTH, BO- AOCTHEIM ynpaBHtenem Obit OAUH H3 ero pomcTBeHHHKOB, AatbIHcapHH GyATO Obl NoATAAKHBaeT MeCTHOe HaceeHHe Ha @KAOObI A CyTAKHH- uectsa», Hactpaupaer ero MpoTHs MecTHolt aAMMHHCTpauHs, Momoract MECTHLIM 2KHT@AAM COMHHSITL BCAKOTO posa MpouleHHs, KOTOpbie MOTOM AKOObI OTMAIOTCA YUCHHKAM Ha MepenuchiBaHne, UTOObI 3aMeCTH C1eMbI. setTlanee, Antbiicapun o6BuHseTcH B TOM, ¥TO OH 6ysTO Get MpescTan- O6AacTHOMy CNaMIpBOiMKypMopeylliaKelreBeeTmHyHYpeaCGKoHteatsM.OHHOCabxIonHean,yeo3qaH, OArOatsHina-- MaabiiKa W TeM ‘CAPHH, ABSIeTCH BHHOBHUKOM «</BHxKeHHA cpeaM HukonaeBcKHx KUprH- 30B> B CBASH C MpeCTOAULMH BEIGOPaMH BOMOCTHBIX JO/KHOCTHEIX TH, BOS6yxKeHEI NpecTaBTeAMH MCCTHBIX Buac- Dru o6BuHeHuA GpiIn yell, u6o um Gut HeHasucten AntsincapHH H OK XOTeZH ONOpOINTD ero YcTpaHMTD c 3aHHMAaeMO! MODKHOCTH. ionUcoHMs6oBcynem2eaKeLmJBOauBaKpIylaiMJslHeteyeHKnOTaH3aaMaHnYHcTAbyPIxnaYutALTAiObnUcGUaTnpXpiHyeczAHHHOUM.Bi pHo2OTeoG1eOcnataxcMTtaoHNpoMmoTeHHHBoHcyCBtnTaappeaaarTcscHraneBelHin,Bn1IeX9M, OOcYpuTHrOnaMHtaeoItHOsoa-, Aaterc.apia, eertoaKdHMHHHHeOoeoeaOocnTCyuTOxn<TnOHxnoHeByOpGBreoAaIuBXurMMEyoOHmUIeMMMJsyyBBMeqbTPIoUTMhecAJm,MaaepksBpCstyTubPHarJxeHeollBHABeeeeLsxHleItyGpemMoiPaOfeoOtoiseePuCcs-ecHcOlBtMetTsOGAoenBaermH:OHifetApiHnHoeHOpUMpGrHCe,BuGTeEiIHppTXpHaHIinnpoanBeaoxemnBauLuHeyasnBAt.kybKoCHATTHMeeppnMnierwpTpHuGeusHburosciniinncntrHaaoaaUpxypnsKHHuuenOAneuueHceKioaMxxixomeaBcBaeBHOeeKoIs6GceyPOKnicBaPpo3rMOeaT0roBGoncMoTasly,iOeopyi,Mppa%eoenasKncrKnnpaTbaKea~-t-- '.1 Tam xe,erp.D3e2n0a. pranenra napoauore npocuemenus, Ne 733, om. 2. 2LITHAJ, Ne 156976 a, 1885 1, aa, 156— 161. 180
‘‘H“osu6asencnBhuBeayIGerO.npuBoaBoDecu. nuosKiiioiircyT6B.HATypcrp.ea0H61.,HHape oMa oxHerCGlibpIaTBb eRqOaNnYsomrLoeHOH, aBnpBaBHsieA- Saech MpEMevatetbHO To, cb,<,A.Aatpincapina, ocoGento Bo \"TO BAACTH Gositch jeATeTBHOCTH BuiGopos. OxesunHo, onn onaca- Bpems Kak Opt AntbincapuH He ToMor pa306sia4uNT Te rpssHble Maxuna- Wu, KoTOpble O6bI¥HO CoBepmlatich B MepHon BEIGOpos WapcKUMH 4H- HORMUKAMH COBMeCTHO © Ka3axckHMM deoratamn. HMeHHO BLGOPH B ‘Bodoctible H yesquBIe ynpaBuTen UcNosDIOBAHCe HMM oGoramenna 1 pasHoro pola KY-ALHHYECKHX KaK HCTOWUNK HPoseAOK. OTBeT B BbILIeyNOMAHYTOM OKYMeHTe TakxKe caMoro nite|. AatbiucapHna Ha NpexpaBrenneie NpHBOAUTCA emy OOsHHeHUA. On kateropH- “N€CKH OTBepr BCe 3TH KJleBeTHMMeCKHe OOBHHEHHA H paccKa3aa O cBoeli HaNpaBseHHoi Ha MpocBemenne “Mectuoii H Graropoxuoll AeateAbHOCTH, otera.toro Hapona. Kax rosopu.ocn (8 raase V), Anreincapun Hssox%Kua ocHoB- Hble wean cBoeii npocseTuTeaLcKoil eATeABHOCTY, KOTOPHIe SaksoNAIOT- “CHPHoaapBtooTraOoM¢,KpYpyaTCsOcGKnbHIoMxcoHxNealopiOcKTApROoOMsBu, AteTIzKSbOcHr<OsiMopamMBYcETPCBoKecOHcMHuYHO.MHYAKsTYcsiaIHbuTcsyaIPpIHOHOH>MYKBaPOgassaMBxHcyKTnHoaIarOO- TEM, YTO MOCIe TAKOMl YeCTHO! H GecKOPLICTHO! C:rYxGH MpOTHB Hero TaHHsylotca NpecAeLoBAaHHA H TOHeHHA, BbICHTAIOT (aKTHueCKH 3Posuoro ropona Kycranas. He nonumas ncTHHHol Noonmexu BCeX 9THX BUNEHHA H CHHTag MPHYMHO! Ux ANGHYIO HeNpHASH_ K HeMy Tenepa.t- epuatopa Typraiickoit oGaactu, H. Aaruincapun nONpo- sasHa2 «A He SHalo, OTKy{a Tenepas-ryGepuatop [ponenko uspieKaer He- aFONPHATHBIe BOOKIE AA MeHA CBEACHUS, H Ha OCHOBAHHH TOAbKO PO, Ges NpexBapHTeAbHO! NpoBepKH, GesyKopuanennyto cayxxGy, To Mepe AollycKaronlem COMHeHHA, OOBMHAeT etaxleGHO-OKpyAHLIM ynpaBseHteM, Gite He WaaA YeCTH, HH 4YBCTB MOHX, cri, B TeveHNe 26 ster, pH TOM, Mei B IPASHLIX nepex Moker ero NpeBocxomMTeALCTBO HMect mpano Mlocrynars Tak CO MHoil, HO cyLLecTBYeT 2Ke H 3aKOH, paR- OrpaxkLaioUlnil BCeX, H H BeAHKHX OT HecnpaBerMALIX OGBH- it,O MAJIbIX a PpaBHO AONycKaeT %e BOSMOXHOCTS CYULeCTBOBAHHA YeCTH Ht oseli,jORCHECKUX AOCTONHCTB y BCeX. HM MasIBIX NO 3HaveHMIO, NoO%KeHHi H NAleMeHH OHM He Oban». KaKHX AMs3teMicpauppeuxnennuaoroZoonrppopcieek. a.Ox.BABAHiiOp, aCxaKerakHcMnoeJOBcToOaHmHyCmTRenOsMe JeprxKaa- Tem, 170 OTHOMeHII0 K HemMy Aonyckaetca nponsson. Ou yKasipaet Ha NeqO- pala,UMOCTh OCKOPG.leHHin AMYHOCTH He3zaBiIcUMO OT sauHMaemo- HotoxKeHus n HauKoNatbHocTH. H, Aateincapun crapaeren yGesutTs IX HHHOBHHKOB B TOM, UTO He TOAbKO OH, HO H. BCAKHiL YeTOBeK eet Mpano sauluutaTeca oT GessaKonns u.Gecunncts Baacteit. W anecn BUIMIOTCH ero AeMOKpaTuecKHe yGexenua, Kax coo6maiot apxuB- MatepHassi, MposepKa matepnacion, oGsunmomux MM. Antsicapi- , Obila Nopytea HicHeKTOpy TatapcKNX, GauIKkupcKHX, KiprHacKHx 1Tam xe, ' 1at
opal re“MnTuyptyuOqnsoypBTuHKrAMnaooosnnunayatxOuCsAcOuertnoUabamKHpnixeoaOuKB,OneanBrn0HHYmuyGbTecoCTlTyeKOH/BHyB. olHHMlnXtAaopXocorCBTcaTOyHPTTAIAP0aoOHJKrTCoHaHNAM3IMaHaeXX,pCBCcAPTnKpeOeeMHoMpxHrueotHUuHHHsHHeeAeaTpMLMoMsHKewHbOHoIacHMCea,OTeNHM0MMOTHTecOwAeeMCBMEaBKTA, IMOHCbTHTK,aIOOBATSICbCHKHBIApBHLAKca/ILLrOXs!oe:aOuTxCoYaTCTKBHaHtapHKaiKckHoXm-JyH,GOKoCTepobpes3iiHi LNIXocsYleIHKBBIAACuHteHBHbAICeMeHeHtaAAOOAKHT 06, crate,‘TeALCTBYIOT © ETO TMYGOKHX SHAHHAX B OGAacTH COMMOAOrHH H eTO NO” AatpincapHia =npo6em.{LITKe HAYYHO NOAXOLUTS K PeileHHIO COMMATbHbIXsanto‘uOrMCosTHuCATEMmVuPc,pAiamKTamHKyOseHcoanrTgrna9ihynaaoTaxp0scce.cnkKrBouoOusomOMtuoEOuxAmTC4yeHJHeSAoHHiBeriTHOcaCHBCrsRMeHBauOAHmieeyKiMMM,anOMeMHesXHOaTHnIf6OppHHpUaOaDpG%iKztoxeHpuHeOAsTHuCBnHbTerHisxAi¢nAHacHnMTAataHEbappIiaCHHMaNKccpOUaaopBMApcHHBHpoHeeitaplatlKr,eeHOnHyHOeRTeHoenKHoyaH3pGAzaeaaTeanpBqOspoouiPelscteAceah---.- lem, OTCTOSI CBOIO MpaBory. qn‘WOuoHapessrOHKoiCqcoAaaKuXeHasKkBHeaIraO3xiakHXMsueocTO,KgOSoeCOriCTopiO.pHeeMMHCilTipHtOoeBnPMcOBoIIHceMTEaAeIHeBcTdACceETMrHEOANHeYM,pHeHT,pBPHBIHXEOHICSATBTBhAaOABrIPMpHHOBMiTtIIsiHecEHaBMpCOuOWSYBaMePeAypE0IHTMeOeHebKeHHH/HelOeMHBSAKeyTTTHhHHOYHBBEYCCbHeITOCLaHKAMBHICIHOXOX--~, ncaaRK‘HCcuMErCopCoCeGoTMfB«heiHeHonlKiceOnuiBKTPMipmpepUOXpeurcSauM,icHBHxstaTLKcphITkaMnNOcapHKatsueO3pAMaeTHcHicHOCriHtemMBiHaMlnOnseeAieoNTnirLrafpoOptIssCeaaHBGs3HHerbovaailp9MelspeTM,seOoHyrrwoBMmBaRaMH>,eAYMKHkHHTOaEUOAe,K/OpMOrC%MHuHTKsH3TObOaPMlCsTyTlTHOAeOHAnsBHrPoeIOMBAHA,IHICaNaOYtTtTeAoMbTreCOmeOciAYsnHCOyHcAsKMBoaOHnITpY,XlCPuEorHGnnPHHoaoCsa,UmbByplTb:eyCbtleHclp<ycTeCeitHBoBnHSOcaeTUacftBXHiKYymaMaox1ec-OTHra-on-hi-t Ja atSMOPOBBA, 3a TO TOKO, BpAarKLyIOULNM NoOOppiii CoBeT NOKOHYHTS YTO OH BO BPeMs BEIGOPOB KaHAMAa- M36patb H3ReCTHOrO : Aeio MHPOM Ht 7a,..24, JICCi‘HuTBeeOeynHKpnpXaouCotmarBNTgsBOPHaaeneUoXyacAMxKTtHebHaUilitCeiXpJAiMyiOpBrcupoGHaeerBBpTccHTITauMTHsHieeaExHiCHimBHHwIMBHIAe,'OTkcTMHyH.r,laaaKsipB.aAooBxwITOLHMbaAHI,OAIHOaCHKUCpALaoTaMkHnpHMHeaCc,hCnoMsaoKOo6oCMruTTplOAypaexToeplkDiTHcneEsitAteaHGttucBaornsepboHsKaiTeSlnemiOKeeMaxC3AmHTHaNTAHp,NbuTBHCuAbMoAanH,HtTAeBToiTbOOipl)-T--- capHHBM. *K Kasax6aes, O xuprusckom mapoaHom cyze, «Kupruackas crenian rave rar, 1894, Ne 46, 182
Byayau ropayum natpHotom, BEiaioutuiica NpocBeTHTeh %KHBO HH- TepecoBasich BONPOcaMH AadbHeMMero PasBHTHA Ka3axcKOrO HNaposa, OGPOBONbHO NpHcoesHHHBUeroca K Poccuu, B HeKOTOpBIX CBOIX pac- eka3ax H CTATBAX OH NORHHMAa.T HACYLMHbIe BONPOCKI KUSHH KagaxcKOrO o6ulectBa. Aurbicapnn Hamonaa Kpaiiiiolo orctazocrs Kasaxcraiia M Hckasl nyTH 9KOHOMMMECKYIO_H KyaBTYpHYIO ee npeososenns. Baxuoit mepoii Aus JUKBHAALMM STO OTCTAOCTH OH CHHTAA MpexkAe Bcero Nepexon Ka3aXcKoro Hapowa OT KOYeROrO OGpasa XK'SHH K OCeNUIOCTH, Bapumty, MexaoycoOuyio GoppOy Mexkay Ka3axckiMH (beonatamit Anreiicapun, Kak u Yokan Baguxanos, canta pezuyaiiuum oGuect- BeHHBIM 310M. B pacckase «Kunmax Ceutkya> on ykasbipaer, 470 ecru sonM Gy- AYT MpoMEMIATS GapbIMToi, TO B OAMH Npekpacublii AeHb OHH MOTYT TomaTHTbcA TAKUM O6pasoM: HarpaGueHHoe Gynet OTOSpano, oKArxKeT- ‘Ci YPHAHHLIM HX CKOT. OT 9THX B3AHMHBIX YrOHOB CKOTa O6mkecTBO He ctaner GpoasrBaueT, HHioao9GkOoHpoOrM, HTKaHKaKn asMapxackrtaHnkaa. pasopset Mellaer KasaxcKHe ay.tH, Baictynas nporns GapsiMTsi, sBamoutelien npossrennem deonaty- WbIx passopos B AopesomonnonHomM Kasaxcrane, M6pai Antbincapun ‘B CyMHOCTH BBICTYMa NpOTHB SKOHOMHYECKOrO PasOGULeHHA KasaXCKHX ay.oB, 3a cnoKoiivoe, yeTofiunBoe BexeHHe XossiicTBa, 3a ycraHoRte- PasiH4HbIMH pas~poOmeHHbIMM YactamMu Kagaxctana TecHoit He MeKAY 9KoHOMHYeCKOi chasH. JL1a 9TOrO OH CHNTaA HeOOXOAUMbIM, YTOOI Ka- 3AXH HapAy CO CKOTOBOACTBOM SAHHMAJIMCh SeMteNeIMeM. B stom oTiomenn XapaktepHo comepxcanue ckaza «Kunmak Ceurkya». B fem nosectayetes BbieynoMaHyToro pac- 0 Tom, Kak OHH Kagax, mo uMenH Cenrkya, 13 pona KummaK, noceaseren Ha Gepery pexu. Ilo MpHOLITHH K HOBOMY MecTy 2HTeTBeTRA ON CObUpaeT 30 YeTOBEK Genis- KoB H pasfqaet HM KeTMeHH 218 Toro, 4TOOb! OHH 3aHHMaJHCh 3emuene- Jimem, Onn UpHHHMalotcen paspaBHHBaTD H NpHrOTABANBaTh 3eMMmO AIR Toceson. [To NpHMepy CoceAHHX HapOAOB OHH BHIBOLAT BONY H3 PeyKH B ‘apblKH H MoaHBaroT ToceBEI. Korga cospen xe6, on 2HyT ero, coOupaior ypoxaii. Maanmxn xe6aco6panHoro O6MeHuBaloT Ha CKOT y KOYeBHHKOB, 2XKHBYULWX B 9T0M xe pafione. Or semaegenna Centkya Havas nosy4atTp Sombie AOXOML, TAK KaK cesu‘V3 rofla B ron OH CTaa YBeAWHBATE YHTHPH H OGHADHEe NOABATS Noce- Bpl. 2Kuretu sepHo; muennuy, s4uMeHb w mpoco. [ponomKan 06- BaTb HAIHIWKH XJeGa Ha CKOT, OHM CTaHOBATCA SoraTEIMH, JiaAlasee, Aatuucapun pacckasuisaer, uT0 cKOT Y aeMutenembueB craa “MuHoroyncrenHbim, OGecnevenun OXpaHbl CKOTa OT BOAKOB OHM i-TPOAT cTeHBI. ___Buas ux ycnex B 3emseqenbuecKom MponsBoncTBe, K HM TIpHcoemH- “‘MsloTes HoBBie XossiicrBa, KOAHYECTBO KOTOPEIX AOXoAUT no 400, KuTe- cota3aTem neperousior Goapuioe KoM4ecTBo B Byxapy u Koxana _ W MpHBosar Oryza NoOpotHble ToBapH. ,
—»OHjee,Aarbicapa Heres ruiersB8P‘‘PWCCeHHYnAHOmiYeOHeaeptCaCnhTTroe@tatTKbHkM:KootatOiHpctauotaKApTeein,ktieoHTAOncaAEUAKnaHnB%TNCwcOpCaeKPK3TGK!urPePTYKtYHBaA.UOnEoCABOeNe,SRTCToKBHnCoOHTHYxU—OTBtNnCO-HiXHaENbbpeEH-HLaTrMPoHIHHpAYxOYcHeeboKBnp,MTaICCAMMHOp,IaO..CBOOpe0PnLHPBHro6aHHuYOCOHOYsdCSxMMTMAyGOepQHaoCAOPPOXaTXainOeAKAY.TXCisHouaeHOoTSlsHnOeeoHBAMXnnHciM,KNmKTAaHaMBHPi7TpCTilYmSeOtHeBAHHHaYoXOKsATb,HCd,.HaO,PeMOLpiMXONioBlIaYHuXAUP,HpsmA3BOoSLCePHCYsAAMeexeaKIaMMIlHKOPueoTOOHHA,soTp,bMCMEi,MJe,iEcMBU.oKsLpeKcSEAGTHTHHOHuCeB«1pplSMApTI<noHoaMHBobDAMmsstBbaoLtUBaoJPweBcTHHmaHrTdamHC.Os,nyMoTTTpCuBHHelOoTAelnmmelYTOHtHeoxpAoHaAcGaOeCEtTxpxxBsBT-OkRoHoBeHiBrAnYaeBTntAM,eeaPIOe,O,MOPcsNBN—HSM9HYuINEKTHNoeemOeMOolMlN3tipUHMcHsyeTL1Opn4caeEcBMXBMeHatTC3HapcAToaisTbE::------t-) BOjtian nocenénua ‘Ceutkya’ yctpanpaet Oa3zap; Tae MpoucxoAHT 06- “weit TOBApoB, YTO CHlocoOcTByer PasBHTHIO ToproBAM. ©bMpCaakoseoourTSTMeaposnbxnepiCooc0eOnns,ucomrC3JBhKacyacOomo,iTryfiOHexeBScKpOetAsAMnxaOYBaAUEat3xCeeiKKMeerHHmeEMpaIBsbaHeiPcXUeeaccOMsrKkSBuaAaoHsuMseHa.BIaC.aHTMtBTTPoOoOMTOMn,OoS(IbcMBTuaOOexeH;TCaHHT,NOBe¥POMeToKOAyHcyoOKAHuTeneTaTHrMoAHeHeHI3HTH6: eeCeSA7axeapKmBuHiTiNOtsAeeKTMnMUeCoMIpAKHHaAB3OCebOacIH---- ‘TH Ka3axop K OCesOCTH. Gbt pHMMIoBrOAsBnArToEiicCaHepCHHNOOaKAOBYZUOKIBeaHA3TbtebIBUaHae, 3AT¥rTOOOTKOOBKYeCTOKeCOCePMTMBMEOOHBCH,TBHTIeOKNaSaAcMXTCOpKeuLHLeolax,pHaCnoKuOHTnOoBOOpMrOLaBo- CkoT of CTHXHMHEIX GexcrBHit. 1880 r, xovesnmxos TypraficKoft o6aactn sue,Kak yiomauyto p cTHXHilHOe GexcTBHe, BcTescTBHe Yero OoMbiNaR Hocturao Gdabuice yaeTa XO3siicTa OGaacTH AMUIWIach CKOTa — OCHOBHOTO. HCTOUHHKA Cy- rus‘iBrmaITseecB,rTaNacoPap«Hsa<AnaOuypas¢eT,ne9GHTTyHbapHMyrBcakaIcTicTitauXMaHrueoipcnnTeEoxoIaoMKn>cpGKeeBaanbsHcIaCTxTBoYCHBMKeOHMKTAO,a BOKOCcAAeKOmNBOc.poMeooyGxKuCeaGHeptvaesAMynteonccyatlpescnt-, crate cer.-Co C+3arGgMaiaxecteolcprkBi0TaecyaHWBBwkaénABcooe‘uKnT«fpisaOKutlROaTtyBaoeiphkooxHfecG'dHKnrHAndaaeOXOyatessioptcCrt3rTsnaaeeNiHOiIxtv,IOiMmp«pcrMoafMyiaHdtlpHaoaYHHAuTHBsoRuaHmzTmOaCn,aIOCcyltAOMBtKuoGoPoAMixXAayBSc>TsoYAeaa.yAsMTypsKNHTsi(XHtiipNtecoKtXHCeroUsBATmBtSTyyHo1HiAO,Bca7pEHNn,o,bMCTeTe-iB1KeKuc.OkA8etUtKtyT8boSaKnH0'UeCpxYaMOoBperrAmrOOrs.oH)epNpMserMcNGaHeuk\"Tn.npeaoHiuopLpsitIisTOaoeOaHmAxHncTcoBriaHHOnnennMiaHysxHTNGOp»KOaNyBeT.aKuusk3eIaKnaCposXabTeomnICYxpBuKoNeaAnnMHnseatrXTTBa:aThnyeKKrHuHpraeOano:--a-- utAOBOTBCTEOAKaOT>kmH.uBemcHTBRoIMe6NpHaBXsIoOXmJO,MTMpe6pcpadsaBpitHasTAoHBns tai-nmRiatc,saaxpHcuektOMroOMc:eyIaOOmIOLaHueteercTHBHAAaNl.yEMrOO:annnoyit6kemasmesripopoaeekt¢- 8h
‘Ha HenpaBtabHocTs HocToponHero BMellaTeAbCT3a B KUSH Apyroro Ha- pola H CHHTaeT PasyMHBIM HanpaBuTD Haposb MO UX ecTecTBeEHYOMy XO- Ay passutasa. Buemwnee BMelatenbcTBo, Hapyiiaiomlee ator npuAunn, He TOJbKO He MPHHOCHT NOAb3bI, a, HAOGOPOT, HaHOCHT OrpOMHBIii BPEL HOpMasIBHOMy pasBuTMIO HaposoB. AatblHcapun mperocreperaet B BEIIIeyKa3aHHol CTatbe oT onacHolt OWHOKH, <TaK Kak MPHHyAHTeAbHAaA CIOMKa ObITa WesOi Haman cioco6- Ha Obipaer NpespatuTy Halmo, HHOrAa CaMyw cHocobnyio, B anaTi- 0HYIO... H TAK KaK B 3aKOHAX MPUpoAB! HET NPUMepa, YTOGHI BOSMOXHO ObI- _ BBpaasuxmpyesrnpeapmaantetsnuMaxastoMaeotpHaenroApnerGeeinncKaapnBnOa BspoccIioro Mya»! 06 o6mectsenutix #B- TeHHAX 3a102%KeHb TAYOOKHe MBICAM, XApakTepHusyIoMLe ero Kak MbICAM- Tes, BOCPHHABUIETO MPOrpeccHBHBIe HEH BeEAHKHX PYCCKHX PeBozt0- MHOHHBIX eEMOKPaTOB B COlMOOrHYecKHX BONpocax. Kasaxckuit npo- CBETHTeNb 3AeCb NOAYEPKHBAeT, ITO XO PasBHTHA OOULecTRA HeAL3A Ha- “TiPaBAATH NO BOE H Ke1AHHIO OTACADHBIX /HOAeM, YTO OOULECTBO HE pa3- BuUBaeTCH NO Sapanee BEIPAGOTAHHBIM NPOeKTAaM; NOLYMNAACH CBOHM OHO OMKHO NPOXOAUTh oMpemertenHle €CTECTBEHHBIM 3AKOHAM, Cryne- uckyccrsenntim o6pasnm oprausoBatb nepe- ‘in paspurus. Tonbirka _ cKakuBatve Yepes 9TH CTYNeHH HeH3GexKHO NoTepnuT HeyAaty. fa Tosops 0 Tom, YTo HacHALCTREHHOE BMelIaTeILCTBO B KHNB Hapd- | nary6no orpaxkaeren na nem, Anteincapnn no cynlectay “noxaapi- ‘pacer Gespaccyactno, BPeAMOCTh KOAONUZATOPCKOM NOARTHKH WapiiaMa, Hanpassenioli na -vacnrycrsentoe OTGopMyOcemnUneTeTNoHapboIesioPs eaHyaamsTroanraectbjuaEeIxt oxpamm, Asrsmcapnn moxasaa, 410 “AiYe ,H1acciHmanye,OGa vceoKntHeBliHetDa:nxeyeectotencittniie,nHGyozMYTy XonY Reltteli, B KoTOpoM Hapo- samittepeconatitt Ho BsaHMiON “cOsMKeHNN, B NpHOGMeHIN K PyccKOl KYabTYpe, B 3ANMCTBOBANHH NO- “Mesiioro ontita B 9KOHOMHKe. Tosopa o ectectnenilom xone pasbutua Haponos, H. Aatoncapin, *KOHeYHO, He Mor OODACHHITL ero Hay4HO, SKOHOMMNeCKUMM cbaKTOpaMH, eM He Metiee, PAccMOTpertiie OGuLecTBEHHOrO paanittHs KAK ecTectDer CBIAeTeABCTBOBATO O RAUALH NepeXoBLIX’ OOULecTHeEH- aOTO Mpollecca cbopmuponauwte Baratos Hopas- Aarbincaprina. IX TeopHii Aateticapun yKasbipaer, uTo Ka3axCKuit Hapo;, MOGpOROABIIO NpH- _ K Pocenit, He HysKNaete B TO/14- youmiien KAKOM-a1NGO BHelllHeM AAA TOO, YTOOR! HTTH No NpaBHALnomy nytH. Beara cosmeéetiywo NHont o¢KePYnCuCsKUBMeuHtealp, oBrOceMG, KoasAbxiAexcMKneiipeHnuaMpoarer cam, B CHLIY OGneKTINHO- To W'kYistypy pyecKo~ Get aus.FO Hapora H MocTenentio riepexoAuT K ocerTOMY OGpasy «... Kup- OBKi,O—ercorencoTpBueHt HAOMaTybicjaasp’HHBC, ex— it Ges BHeLINHX TO.TKOB, To ORHOMY “MOReit noGy2ueHHIO UckaTb Ce6e 6O- ayumero u yno6uoro tonoaxKeHnus, Haxosster yKe Ha nyTH K oce;t- >. passinTlanee'on npunozut daxter nporpéccuBHoro SKOHOMHKA detKas“atxocctaana nox BJNsiivem SkOHOMHKI Potenu, usMénenia Opita Kasa- ux Mlepexona B Nowtaricrso, AJtsicapmH coo6- poccniickoe 0 TOM, UTO Kagaxw CTasmt CTpoHTS TemILIe KHOHTKH, 3eMaANHKN It
axe «nopalovibie AOMa», Yero y HHX He ObI0 20 NpaHATHA NoAMaHcT- Ba Poccun. Tenepp yxke MecTaMH BCTpeyaioTcA HeGoubUIHe JepeBHu, B Hava 3aHHMATbCA 3aroTOB- KOTOPBIX WKUTEAM-Ka3AXH CeHOKOWIeHHEM, : Koil KOpMos. Aatuiicapin rowoput, To Tenepp H3BECTHAA HaCTe KagaxoB He KO- uyeT MOCTOAHHO, Kak Palbule, a KOYYeT TOdbKO To HeoGxoAMMocTH, TOAbKO B Tex Cy4aAX, Kora KOPMA ALIA CKO- Coupe HET NOAHOARHOTO ta, «¥kpemisisich TAKUM O6pa30M Ha OfHOM Mecte, —nucaa HW. Aartoiu- capuH, — KHPrH3bl — 9TH AHKHe JBYHOTHe KO3bI, ABa-TPH AecATKA JeT TOMY Ha3af, CTAJIM Y2KE LOPOXUTh KaxKABIM KOYKOM 3eMJH TaXOTHOII TeOeHesounoil nH -lyroBoii. H3-3a storo %e NpehMyulecTBesHO MIpouc- XOJAT Tellepb H Me*KLOYCOGHBIe y HX CCOPbI, AOXOMsUMe AO KPOBABbIX Apak W Aaxke yOuiicrB>. x oceasoctu, rosopua Aarsicapnu, Kazaxi Baarozaps nepexony He TObKO CTatH Goulee Pa3yMHO BECTH CKOTOBOACTBO, HO CTaJM 3aHH- MaTbea H 3eMenenHeM, O_HaKO B SeMJeqeIMH KasaXH cpasy MO.1- HOCTbIO He YclelH Nepensth Gosee copepuleHHbie OPyAUA 3eMseeMDYe- cKOFO Hpou3BosctBa Poccun, Oxo Besoch Ka3aXCKHMH KpeCTbsHaMH- 3eMJefeAbUaMH NPUMUTHBHLIMH Opy/MAMH Tpysa, AjTbIHCapHH ¢ COr%Ka- sleHMeM TOBOPHT 0 TOM, YTO Ka3aXH JWIA HCKYCCTBEHHOTO opomienns HcnlosB3ylor TakHe Mpocteiimme ycTaHoBKH, Kak YHTHpH. Tak xe, Kak YU, Basnxauon, on onvchipan upesBbiuaiino TaKeTOe MOLOKeHHe Kasax- 0CKHX 3eMJefembues: «... KHpru3bl-erHH4n Kaxkablii WeHb, C yTpa Bevepa, HeIbIMH CeMe/icTBaMH TpyAsTcA Ha TaMHe>. [6pait Antbincapun cyHTan, UTO Nepexox OT NPHMHTHBHOTO seMule- Zeaua K Gosee copepileHHbiM (opMaM 3eMJesebYecKOrO NPOUsBOsCT- Ba MO2KeT NPOH3OMITH TOMDKO B TOM CélyYae, ECM KasaxH OyyT YUHTDCA nepenumatb y HX Goree apexruBHEte cro ema.ycoopynccOk6upxaGnolreKpnecesenuen, «Bens Ha PYCCKHX MOCeAAH MbI TOMaraem BCI Halexay, Kak Ha YUHTeselt No YacTH KYAbTypst HM MpeoGpasoparesteli KuprHackoit creny»,—rosopuat M6paii Aatbiicapuu. O,sonpemenno oH yka3bipaa Ha TO, ¥TO B KasaxcraHe He BO BCeX ye3qax HMeIOTCH IiAoctatouno GAaronpusTHble KAMMAaTHYeCKHe H MOYBeHHbIe YCOBHA pasBHTHA 3eMseqenHs. On NOHHMAd, YTO B YCOBHAX NaTpHapxasDHO- qbeonaapuoro Kazaxctana wet HHKaKO/i MepcneKtHBpl OcBOeHHA Ge310)1- HMooictHNYoCTTLIKHHan, pHH3OoTnMneYoraos,geYt,TOor3eMcTJueLxmemiiMnbeixHAcXiOt.ANHTCeA B NOAHOM saBHCH- cayyaiino noaTomy Aateincapsn micas: <K npucKop6uIo, B HeKOTOPEIX cTeMHBX yeanax 10° AOXKUTeIDHO He MPeABHAUTCA HHKAKOl 3emsezenbYecKoll GynyuLHOCTH, pactTloupa 3fecb rAMHHCTO-COAOHUeBAaTAA, HIM YHCTO NecYaHas, BCA 1TeADHOCT3aKMOVAeTCH B FOPbKOii NOABIHH; KAMMAT CyXOll HeBeposT. OT FoyHOCTH; PeKH FO MeJeIOT, TAK YTO B MOCHeAAHE TOABL MHOrIe onacaJHcb, Kak Obl He3HaYHTebHBIe CaMH NO CeGe PedKH H BOBCe He ucnapHance>. Yaursipas o6uupuocTh TeppuropHu Kasaxctata H HeMpHrOsAHOCTs eé 3HauuTenbHOM MacTH AIA 3eMJeqenua, AnTbIHCapHH yKa3biBaeT HA ireiHnoalsHougHcetsaG. AMaroenspus3THBEuIsXy yeroBuii B KasaxcTane PasBATHA 2KHBOT: Te paiioust Kagaxctaua, ycaoaya HeOaror
MpHATHEI AIA 3eMJefeNHA, HO O1arONpHATHRI AAA %KABOTHOBOACTBa, elAarpincapun nucas: <EquHcTBeHHO BOSMOKHBIT B TAKUX ye3@ax NPOMbI- — 9TO CKOTOBOACTBO, KOTOPOe Mp HeKOTOpoM Oyaroyerpoiicrne 4 GaarOnpUATHEIX YCIOBHAX, MOXKET OCTHTHYTb, Kak OKaSbIBaeTCA Ha j1e- Ae, GoraTbix pasMepos, a MPH YBeHYeHHH 3anacoB ceHa B ypoxaiinpie TOAbI HW GepexKHBOM OTHOUIEHHH ¢ CeHOM, CKOTOBOACTBO MOXKeT ObITE oGecneyeHo B 3HAYHTeAbHOM CTeMeHH OT BCAKOrO NorpoMa, Kakoii, Ha- TipuMep, HenbITEIBaeTes HBIHE>. Paccmatpupan Kasaxctan Kak cocrasuyw 4Yacth Poccnn, Aatniuca- PHH K pasBHTHIO AKHBOTHOBOACTBAa NOAXOAHT C TOYKH 3peHHA OOiLerocy- OH BLICKASbIBACT 3AMe4ATEbHYIO HACIO 0 TOM, uAtAoaPCKTBaeH3HaBxIXctaHHJTOe0p/2eKcoeHB. He yeTynaw- meii CTaTh *KHBOTHOBOAYECKO! Gasol, 3Ha¥eHHIO AA pyccKoro rocyAapeTBa ero Joro-BocTO4- HBIM No cBoeMy paiionam, AaTpicapay nucaa: «Eca# 3epHoBEIM Pocca cnparea- <uBo TOpAUTCA TeM, NTO sOro-BOCTOUHBIe TyGepHHM e& caAYAKAT Marke WKUT- cHnnueli 8 Espone, 10 KuprH3cKas cTenb He MeHbUIYIO CY2KOY COCAYKHT, GyeT CKOTHBIM ABOPOM XOTH Obi JuIst OHO! Poccuu. HuKaKue npe- MHH, HHKaKHe CebCKOXC3AiCTBeHHbIe aKaeMHH lie CAenaioT TakOrO NactyXxa, KakoB ecTh KMpru3. ItoT nactyx coctTaBaser npeamer TafiHol gapuicTH aim esponeiicKoii aunaomatun, cosHatomeli cay PoccHu HMeH- HO B TOM, TO B Heli eCTh H BOHH XOpOUHil, H 3eMueAeTeL UCKYCHBI Nactyx npHposupiii». Cuntas, YO NPHHYANTeAbHbIe MepONPHATHA MO NepeBoxy KOUyIOULAX KasaXxcKHx aysloB Ha OcemIbI OGpa3s x*KH3HH HeNpHeMempl, Anrainca- PHH BOBCe He AYMa1, YTO Ka3axXH BeYHO AOKHBI GyAyT BecTH KOYeBYIO 2Ku3Hb. ON YTBEP*AAA, YTO KaZAxH HeNpeMeHHo AOMKHBI NepeliTH Oces.I0CTH, HocKOAKY Mepexon K ocenocTH, No AJTBIHcapHay, sBameT- CH HeH3GeKHbIM CeACTBHeM NMporpeccuBHOrO passuTHA J060rO Hapo- Aa. «Bcem H3/10X%KeHHbIM MbI BOBCe He HaMepeHb! GbIIM HaMexaTb Ha MpeANOYTHTeLHOCTH JIA KHPrH30B Toro HAM Apyroro O6pasa *HSHU,- mucan AntuincapuH, — ellie Meee 2Keraiu Obl MbI OOpedb KUPrH3OB Ha BeYHYIO KOUeBYIO KUSH, TAK KaK KAKA HApOA, pasBuBasch Mporpec- ‘CHBHO, HeNpeMeHHO O/>KeH B KOHLe KOHUOB NepeiitH OT KOYesOro GbiTa K OCeMTOCTH, € KOTOPOIW TeCHO CBAZAHO NpocBeutenHe>. Ormevan Kpynneiuime NepeMenbl B AKUSHH Ka3aXOB, AKUBYMIMX B He- NocpercTBenHoi CBASH C PYCCKHMH, OH YTBepAa/l, ITO Ka3axH, Nepe- | -HHMAS AOCTIKeEHHA 3eMAefenNA y PyCCKHX, AOObIOTCA B HeM TaKNX Ke yenexos, Kakux focturan pyccKue. IIpoiiqer eile HecKoAbKO AecaTHAe- War“THii MW Ka3axckHil Hapo CAeaeT 3HAYHTeAbHBI BHepex B IKOHOMH- “MeCKOM H KYJIbTYpHOM pasBuTHH. PayGoKO Beps B CHJIbl H BOSMO2KHOCTH epoero Hapoga, Antpincapnn nucan: «YxKe H Tenepb MHOrHe NpHaH- Heiiwble KUprusbl 3HAIOT 3eMAeAeMbYECKOe HCKyecTBO He Xy2Ke PyccKoro ‘MYXKHKa, a c TeveHHeM BpeMeHH, To cBOlicTBeHHO: MOTOAOMy Haposy BOCNPHHMYHBOCTH H CMBIINIeEHHOCTH, KHPrH3bi HaBepHoe M BOOOIe He orcranyt oT KopeHHBIX seMsleqembueB>, } YenemHoe 9KOHOMHYECKoe HM KYsbTypHoe pasBHTHe Kasaxcrana AateincapHi paccMaTpHBaa B HepaspbIBHOf CBAIH C PasBHTHeEM jLpy- KeCTBEHHEIX OTHOMIEHHI MEKLY KasaXCKHM H pycckuM Hapodamu. YKa- 187
pycckoro Hapoja BbiTeKaloT 13 GAaropoAHOro CTpeMseHHsa BEILaIOULero~sblbas Ha baKTHl ApyKObI KasaXoB € PYCCKUMH, OH TOBOPH. O'TOM, UTO Ka3axckHit Hapox NuTaet riyOoKyio cumnaTHio K PoccuH, K pyccKHM —©cH MpocBeTHTera eule Gosiee apryMeHTHPOBAnHBIMH Cie1aTb CBOH WOBO-mogsm: <Benkuit pyccKuii, 61n3KO UMeBIIHit es10 C KUPrH3AaMH, BepOoHT- HO, 3aCBUAeTeALCTBYeT, — NHcasl OH, —4TO KUPrHsckHil HApoA OXOTHO CXO{HTCR € PYCCKHM H NTO HeMaJio CyULecTBYeT y2Ke HeKPeHHO ApyrKec- KHX OTHOIMCHHH M@KLY NPHANHeMHbIMH KMprH3aMH H TAaMOLWIHHMH pyc- CKUMH JKHTEISIMH>. AatbicapHu 3anBaset, YTO MexKy Ka3aXCKHM H PyCCKMM HaposOM HMCETCH jLYXOBHOE POCTBO, KOTOPOe MOXKET CAY:KHTS OCHOBOII COM*Ke- Hus OGOHX Hapogos. To oGuIee, YTO HMeeTCH B XApakTepe STHX ABYX Ha- porn, no muenmo Asmincapiua, saxmouaeten B GeabieKyécrpetttocTi B KuTelicKOM GBITy, B 3ApanoM MpakTHuecKOM yMe. Ou yrepaciaer, YT0 Kak pycckuii, TAK H KaBaXcKHit Hapostt He pas- Bpallletibt PeAUTHOSHLIM (aHaTHSMOM, HaIMOHAHCTHMeCKHMH Mpempac- cyakamu. Y Hx HeT HeNpAASHH K APyrHM HapoAaM, OHH He NposBAsIOT HeTeprimoct K UYKUM PeAUHOSHLIM BepoBannsM, Takoe cXoncTBO 6 XapakTepe 9THX HapoOB, NO MHeHMIO Ka3aXCKOrO NpocBeTHters, ABUT- ca BaxubIM cpakTopoM B Oysyulem ente Gorbmem cOaMxKeHUM Ka3zaxcta- na c Poccueit. ‘ Specs sacnyxkunaer BUHMaHuA Tor akT, TO AaTuNcapmt npa- ‘BHADHO MloAMeTHA TICHXHMECKHe OCOGeHHOCTH pyccKoro HM KasaxcKoro Hapoglos, Sxpasbifi ys, TepHUMOCTb B OTHOMIEHAM 4yKUX PesMTHoaHELx Bepobanuii cBojicraenubt 9tHM Haponam. Mayyenue uctopit pyccKoii (uaccodcKoit MbicM MOKasbIBaeT, YTO OHA HMeA COsMAHYIO MaTepHa- GMCTHMECKYIO TPANMUNO, YO HAeaIIM B Hell He Hrpan NpeobsaLaw- liel-poau, Buecte ¢ TOHMaHe eicTBHTeTHOCTH, Tem MHCTHYECKOe Hapory. H PeAHrMOsHOCTS GLAM UyxAB pyccKomy Kasaxcknii napox 8 Choeit OCHOBHOM Macce He Obst OXBAYEH PecrHOsHLIM (anaTH3MoM,. Ko- topbiii BCAYeCKH CTapaloch HacaKLAaTb PeakiMOHHOe MYCy/IbMaHCKOe ayxopenctso, Cruxniino-matTepnasuctieckoe nonuManue jelicrBuTerL- HOCTH, TaK HasbipaeMiil 3ipansiil Berang Ha BeuH,, Obi cBOlcTBEHeN 1 Gonpuielt 4acTH KasaxoB. Stu nonckn H, Aarincapnusim xyxonnoit oOuMocTH KazaXxcKoro 4 bl OTHOCHTEABHO HEOGXOUMOCTH IpHOOULeHHA KasaXcKOrO Hapona K KYIbTYpe H 9KOHOMUKe pyccKoro Hapoza. Opnako HEeOGXOAMO OTMe- tutb, uto W. Aatbiucapun B CHyy OrpanMeroctu cBoero MNpoBOs3spe- HHS H2 CyMed Hay4Ho NogoiitH K 3TOMy BONpocy HM NoTOMy He yKasa.t #1 He Mor YkasaTb Ha TO, 4TO OcHOBa cOmMKeHHA Kasaxctara c Poccueit HaXOMWACh MPOKAe Bcero ‘He B HLeMHBIX (pakTOpax, We B CXOseTBe TICH* XHYCCKHX ‘CBOICTB HX HapoOROB, a B MaTepHaIBUBIX (pakTOpPaX, Be TeppH- ‘TopHarDHon Oanszocru Kasaxcrana K Pocewu- 4 ucTopHuecka ycTaHoBHB- iuelics Mex HUMW Oularo_apa sTOMY TecHOM SKOHOMHUECKOTT CBASH. Benny cpoeit reorpaduyeckoiis6anadeTA’R: Poech H HeoOxomUMocTH SKONOMHYECKOrO OOuLeHT ¢ PYCCKAM HapoNOM Kasaxckuil Mapen, Kora ‘HOMaGOerKaMa3b.ciOboaCrTcOaPOBNbG! eHeH, OSOEcMOHGBeIHXHOsaxKBAoTraaNKNOoDA, sOepGrapaacma’lastcpaasoKpHPToecnewnHibeiaMa
1BHHUPPnUoCuoimMceKsmpabKEeHoTKCnabuKatBakctH3bTKBa0BNnYex.aOCppAcxIGHkoBHOpocoTXomHrsrYBKooeeppoUrHnmauBHcsnBbtUcnoHIaereoIpBaOe,cseonMeoctAgH,HHbYaHaXMMx¢oOSuKr6BpKo3pHpuOHyCBacHceiIo6BceOiHsekAMMgHHNACHuAMKBBHYaHAe.IEteHHSepCnHAOHKiuH,iOIuncKOHeaaATpnKeKKuuHpOUaeuieHOCu3paEUezrBHIroae:HxH3B6KscaepH«cXtUAKaHaeKZImnoHeeaarTOcXaoOhEcceKKI?arHrOCepanrGpPaTpOeyotooAHocemaHmccrpaTnmayysPpOicpooenTempnalcOy,OloBaMfcsmrHITcoOCMUkuXoTutMKMKyMOe1eayT-o-- ‘Mexkily MpoiM pachpoctpanenve cpean KUprH30B pyccKoro O6pa3s0Ba- NUS, yka3bIBalolllero HaPOAY BUANMbIe BEITOABI OT COsMKeHUAT, Bee npo- wee ykaxkeT cama 2%U3Hb. B HacTosiitee BpeMa Ge3 BEAKUX MeponpusTHit HawHy Npwannelinbie KUpru3sbl Ha XeGOpOAHbIX yeG0K 0 GoK, LOM ¢ JOMOM C Ka3aXAMM, a MECTAMM pon pycckumn ceseHusimuD>, MecTHOCTAX KUBYT CTO- CO BCeX OKPY2eHBI Hssectio, u10 noce npucoexnnenin Kagaxcrana x Pocenm napeKoe MpapirTemcrBo B NeAAX KOONNZaLNM OGUIMPHOrO H GoraToro Kpast Te- pece-t10 13 Poccun 8 Kasaxctan OHbeixtoroppasoMe eKutoeHzrsai,ecrtasBoHcbeimMell Kpectbs, pyccKHX Pyccke nepecestenubt OGpagoM, ‘B MECTHOCTAX, Fle HMENACb BOA H Me, CEOBATEIbHO, ObVIa BO3MOXK- HOCTb 3aHHMaTbCA seMseseHeM, Tloxxoaa K Bonpocy c TOUKH speHua HHTepecos Nepexofa KasaxcKo- Hapona K ocegutoctu, AaTbiKcapHH 3aGoTHIca 0 TOM, YTOSBI semeqenMO, ObiM COXpaneHbl. OH yKasbipan Ha Mecra, PHTOAHbIe K peaK- MOHHYIO CyMLHOCTL MepeceeHYecKOit MOAUTHKH, B Pesy:tbTaTe KOTOpOI MecTHoro HaceseHHA OTOHNPactich Cable AYULIME 3eMesbHLIe Pasnanaauce nepecetentam. AJTHICapHH BEICTYNHA NpoTHB yuacTKH sTOH no- THKH, NPOBEAEHHe KOTOPOIL padorKn, On nuicat B cBasH 18eit KupruscKoit oceatocTH JIHIIATO KaZAXOB 3eMexTb, NPHFOAHBIX UIs Geperb Gy- c STHM: <IIpunagtexuT Mecra; MexKIy yAOOHbIe K 3eMJIeeTHIO M STHX TO HMeHHO MecT OCTaIOch HeMHOrO, a ECM AONYCTHTH BOABO- me PYCCKUX NOCeeHteR, TAKHX MecT GyzeT eMlle Menbine, HapectHo M, YTO KHPFHSbI-SeMTeReMbUBL HAYHHAIOT LOPOXKHTL KAKALIM KMOU- M YLOOHOI K TOMY 3eMAIM H TOTOBEI OTCTAHBaTb ero BO UTO GH TO HH Be0, COSHABAR, YTO B HEM 3aksONAeTcA GysyULHOCTS MOTOMCTRAD. Ocyaknat peakunonnme meponpustua mpasitemscrea, meuiaioune BMUTaHtpIOuaSpExMaAsEpMnEoIN-eAorBarKbAuSsAtXiCi KHGXit,ayAsaaxt,bucocxappaitutstoOuRmMOeBpBeMKeHaHsaOxcBrabI-- Iynast 3a COTPyAHYYECTBO %KH3HH KasaxcKoro H pyécKo- Hapozon. HM COBMECTHYIO KKaaPssaaacxxcccmrkaoaniteip, ucrs<eanCsmo,ppcyeAcmncTkHnuneHocerapoHgpHuoaavYenKKnaaeskbiGBo¥yavanayrmtHaupMHaeXcTnbpKoBycsbtKpTHaYpnpreHHnyaucioKaoiMlsuIc2acunHn3IiO-t pycckwe ropoga...—rosopua Aatsincaput.—B witesaurentiom, POLOM H PeMEcaIeHHOM HaceseHHH ropoxoOB KAPrH3 yBUAKT NorpeGn- if, CHaGAaloulero CTeMHAKAa BCeMH YyC/lyraMM CoBpeMeHHO! NHBHAN- iH, HcKyCCTBa M HayanLIX sanMit, BansHue ropozos u yoGurIx ny- coofinenust OyqeT 1A 2KH3HH KUprH3cKoro Hapoa B BbICHIel cTe- iM OslaroneresbHbIM>. 189
§Homuueckoro paseutua Kagaxcraia noKasbipaer, 470 oH, HaGmozast 1Takum o6pa3om, H6paii Anttincapun Bbrctynaa npotHs npHMereHia OCYILECTBTEHHH Mepexona OT KoUeHOH >KHSHM K HACHABCTBEHHLIX Mep B MporpeccHBHoe pasBHTHe Kasaxcrana Npupeser ocesOCTH, CHHTAd, UTO 3aa4aHeH3G@KHO K OCe/IOCTH, K 3emueeNMIO. COCTOHT B TOM, YTOGLI ¢ NOMOULbIO NpocBellleHHs, BOCHUTaHHA, pacnpocTpaHeHusA KyAbTypbI Ht 3HanHit copeficrBoBaTb pasBHTHIO Ka3axcKoro Hapofa. «Tlogjepxute xe KUprusa Ha NyTH ero ecrecTBeHHoro eTpeMic- Hust, —ucan AntbincapH, — oGeperaiite ero GnaroppeMcHHbIMH 3a- Goramu oT cayuaiinbix xossiicTBeHHbIX NoTpaceHHii, KaKHe HcrIEITbIBaeT pasBuBaiire cpeaH KUprus BAMAHHe pyccKoro OGpasoBaHHs, OH Tenepb; Ha louBiii, AapoBuTbiit H NosTHYeCKH BHeyaTANTeAbHBLL Ha- neiicTayiire Poa MepaMM HPaBcTBeHHOrO COMMKeHUs, HU KUPrHScKHit HaDOA CKOPO Coubetca ¢ TOCYsapCTBOM PYCCKHM, CaM BHAT CHacTbe cBOe B STON COMKEHHH HU GYAeT HE TObKO CKOTOBOAOM, HO if SeMAENETbUEM M AarKe ja‘venlSeptbn rcoapoapuareAs»a.tuucapnua, ckasannule uM nowTH 3a 40 aeT 20 noGe- BOHHOM Nox AOporuM Hero 3HaMeHem PoccHH, KOTOpbIM OH y2Ke It Jib COBETCKOFO CTPos, OcoGeHHO GAN3KU H NOporit HaM ceiivac, TAK Kak O TOM, UTO AnTEIHcapHH Gbit NacTOmLMM NaTpHo- OHH CBH/eTeLCTBYIOT CTpactHo H TopAyO *elasuiM emy Npouweranns TOM CBOero Hapoga, yGexeHuI0 Poccun. 4 cHactbs, KoTOpble Ka3axckuil Npo- Nox TpcBeTHTeAA, Mor OOpecTH AMM Hapos, No TayGoKomy NoKpoBuTenecTBoM 9TOM OH OLLI NaTpHOTOM B WIHPOKOM CMbiCsIe 9TOTO C1OBa, NOAHABILMM- NOHMMAHHA OOULHOCTH MHTepecos HapoxoB Hatuell cTpa cA AO YpOBHA Hbt BO PYCCKHM Hapogom. Bot nouemy sHamsa Poccuu, sHams Tape c Cutan AOporHM H JWI CBOero pyeckoro Hapowa AuTbIHcapHH i 3HaMeHEM Hapoma. W6paii Aatumcapnu ne Mor, KoHewHo, sHaTb, YTO MeHee, Heat Hepes TosycrosteTHe ero <BIYeUsIIiHxeoiMt eO4TxEtIaSBpOeNcOKToAiTCHcouB mKaUsSuHcDti.ecKoit Tlocae no6ensi peso.0- MMM, B YeloBHAX coBeTcKOrO OGiecTBeHHOTO ctpos, Kasaxctan craa ro- bCoYmAaPHCTKBOyMaty€poBibtI.COBKeOaPuaSxBaHaTOO! reMvPeOcMrsBeILnLuIeaEHsHOpCoTfbiItOa, CeIbCKHM xosaiict- Conercxoro Co1sa HauleitTpOTHD HeMeitKo-(ballucTCKHX 3axBaTHKOB MlOKa3aa, ITO KagaxH BMeC- Te ¢ CbIHOBLAMM APyrHX Hapofo CTpanbl cpaxKasucb MWw1ewom K Mey, MYDKeCTBEHHO SaLILMULAN CBOIO BeAUKYI POAMHY OT HHOZeMHBIX nopaGotiteseli. Virax, anaans paccyxaenuii MW. Aatsmcaputa a. nepcnextupax 9ko- wWay4an OOULeCTBeHHBIe ABNEHHA, YCMATPHBAT B PASBHTHH YeMOBELeCK- Ioro o6tilectBa HekoTOpyl0 3akonomepHocTs. snauit, wro A.rbtHcapiit Hei TornHHoOog-ltNOGKJrHHaTSroHHTMYsEoCpKHMOLpHIHMGMABMBICKAAAMMASHCBHAEHMKOHMMNMpeoApreHplUoeBcMcBuIBMHHEBKOIXTMObPIEcIAXNTBeApoymTcMpcoKcooBiPt oOOccGGuuuHLLeeccTTBBeeNH Bpemenu.
TAABA VII MATEPHAJIMCTHYECKHA XAPAKTEP MMPOBO33PEHUS AJITBIHCAPHHA H EFO BOPbBA MPOTHB PEJIUTHO3HOM CXOJIACTHKK ObiY Hopaa Aarsincapnua ner cnennaabusix Kune Han crateii, B KoTo- PUI On uIMarAT CHO huAOCOpcKHE Ho Hs sTOFO He eHesty- BoNpocaMM. Bars.€T, WTO OH He HHTepecoBases dbHaOcodcKUMH OTyeMbIIBIE ero FHOBONBuCHsICMOhKMHASHH(H1UI3CBTHAOeHnKUCuTAcOHeGPmOBOBRAKNTeHKyp,aueKnHHMTCcOeKOmKeBAopSCebMIMBYAeUaHIOgHHToTO,ExA!uYAaeTMyMOHyoOnHWsNKOnOOuX-bc1H,ais, :K3TOHaTAKO<KPOIHHpMIue iCeNEpMpaYoxMuuNlpIpoPoHaHriaoXiRr,OeemAcHenB-- “aqcYTCpuOuKMaaNrA6ecoL3lrcKocabxOTroeobpO:rCHaobOI-MTGBnbb«eeloTbxrAuaKaazOHotrBHccBoOaroErsAwMaoRBp,HaaB,sCKoIIBMbToKOHHBmHoeeMTelyTinotaetcpaMIJkIoe:H,eorYor<YH,oBnTb!OPI:KMeyMoYm«rsgYHIeH,aEpHcCeXHrTneuHtceoBmCnMcITMpToboai,e>uTrHo?pcir,yuTpZCaeaO,cOiMtBnkae»,uoT,pTa,sMoBlpaa lyetee3eumHM,reamoKeArcHyooprHcryTTocrOoepour6rsOToee eCCeOKcBaapkcOuulcbeaoinoyG6lUompxueikatseaBieoEcrIBMYcoaeofcniTsHpOAoeOmHwM3eWnaIut3UmpaoAnKxuA.ncoBKHGus6OTypOauaMMsnOteTAoaeTKaaHarO.uAWtB.iecHoBaHupaHairiuaNm,pHeGKmearpcoeyTpraacs:oAeurAo«neYHTneuAnurnNnea-- yuna, y, , KKApJFeaoAxate6Hnr®rXppie<t,ouaaHNns>ce.iau’rocMopn6mapuTouunaeBsopaaaraeyo,lriKu,nBn6euust)er1n,aa1naua0pnuTuscoBanmKrne3ooeuga1prsaao,,r,’coAeerK6.nAeupHens.icHrtakeoTCnnzoKuxaOa>;cA,ttDpuoJK[3yerOeop2xmomKen(HHo«n.UoBuuTcUtopro3ipaisauM,auaoO,tcBburiNUaaxiesemidpupauauomBprtnou>Txarm,oeH, pes«KnoAcesPnKnyo—nocc-ia--t Xora y Anrsimcapuna ter npouanegennii, nanncannex na dnaocop- ip2fAfogilg‘fpCgolomTu:sAiBaniOpAHoAec, nmTauBibBoveLoKcIxMeCKHoTKnIYuoaoNmnc.maoeeaBenxRncpcunekexpmomuoariTe.oiunirtHseGsBaOuiiosOi2Rtoc0GaoiyoouenommempHcumoyyutTsiaxiuncaHnnszaoaseypaKTevHexe0lHAtm6BeucHtpoaxe,tOmu.eialnoIibTAnlHitM.pinOoaaeScKAaHaTcOaaOnsrrRouBHrnK,accCaxHatoOpronMHyimamXmacuTTeaTeeé,spcpKiYkNeeKroA,a,aalasnxaxeiuTeeoMsipmt,iKoecxBC1kp8lyax9iroO5. 1, an2Lirrupyeten mo xunre A.C. Curauxova <Iegarormueckne june m npocserit- AeaTembuoct H, Aatunicapuuar, Aama-Ata, 1949, erp. 142. 191
CKHe TeMEI, H3yYeHHe COLepAKAHHA ero saNHCOK W MOKTAMHEIX, cBAsalt- HBIX CO IKOJDHLIMH Je1aMH, NOSBOAAeT HaM ONpeseAHTh Xapaktep ero meqarormueckHXx Bos3peHuii H yOeqHTbCA B TOM, ¥TO ykasaHuA AsrTbiica- pHHa © WeNAX HM 3aqayax O6yyeHHA JAeTel KUPTHSCKHX IKO1aX, NPOHUZAHbl WAeAMH B OpraHH3yeMbIxX HM PyCCKO- MaTepHasHCTHYecKOrO Nout Manus nelicrsHTerbHOCTH. Aariincaput BbicTynaa npotus o6yyenna gerei B Meapece peauri- o3Hoit cxonacTHke, He HMelollell HHYerO OGuero C NpakTHYeCKO! AU3HbIO napoga. Ukoabl 20KHBI, 10 efo MHCHHIO, BbIPaGaTbIBaTh y yuaLLNxcA ..cassSMOPOBLIe, IpakTHYeCKHe B3rAAAL Ha MUP. : B c stam Anrsincapui numer: «. B o6umux nutepecax. [pa- BHTeALCTBA HPABCTBEHHO M SKOHOMMUCCKH PAasBHBATh MOABAACTHBIX MY HapogoR, Ht GbiT0 Opt %KeaTeMbHO Ges0TAaraTeAbHOe pactpocrpanenine B KHprusckoit CrenH pycCKO-KHprH3cKHX IKOM, KOTOpble CCH H He BbI- TecHAT BHOTHe TaTApcKoe YueHHe, HO BCe %*Ke GYAYT CAYKNTS NPoTHBO- BecoM MY, PACCAAHHKOM, TAK CKa3aTb, MPAKTHYECKHX B3TVISLOB Ha BELL, OTPaxKaloulNx MpeMpaccyAKM, BPeAAMULME HAPOANOMY Pa3sBHTHIO; a 3TO B CBASH C HeYMepIIHM elle H BONE GoApeCTBYIONLHM KHPrH3CKHM Hapo- AULIM OG6bM4aeM, OCHOBAHHBIM Ha MpakTHyecKHX HayalaX, IPH TOM BHe BCAKHX PeMPHOSHLIX BAKSHI, He NONycTHT Hapog K HpaBcTBeHHOMy PasxoxKenmio; »esaTeNbO 2%e GesoTaaratedbHoe yeTpoiicTBO pyccKo- KMPPH3CKHX IKOM B cpeme KUPrH3>’. Suecb caenyer nogyepKuyT> TO, ¥To AaTbiHcapHHt mpesnaraet, ¥TO- Obl B WIKOAAX 3ANATHA NPOBOAHANC. B COOTBETCTBHH C HaposHbIM OObI- WdaeM, HAXO/SMUMCH BHE PEIUTHOSHEIX BUMANH, T. e. OH, MO cyuecTBY, BBICTYNaeT 3a OGyueHHe H BOCTINTAHHe YuaULIXcA B MaTepHasHCTHYeCKOM ‘ayxe. Tonops 0 «npakrecknx parantax Ha peuut», AaTbilicapni Meet B BHY, KOHeuHO, He HeasHcTHYecKHe, He MHCTHYeCKHe, a MaTepHa- HaAMCTHYECKHE BSAA BeULT. H6pan Anrpuica- O marepnaanctiyeckom xapaxrepe Muponosspenua eropiliia TaK2Ke CBHAeTeALCTBYeT BbICTYTeHHe pH OTKPBITHH PeMecseH- Hof mkoatt B Typrae 15 vos6pa 1883 r. M3 pean HM. Aarpincapnna Bis HO, 4TO JIA Hero 3HAHHe eCTb He YTO HHOe, Kak MO3HaHHe OKPy2KatouLelt aelicreutempuocr. <[oaaraior, wo Mbt OT Hpupoas Hapoa yMHBIi, NpaK- THYECKH H BEPHOCTS TAKOTO MHCHHA MbI AOIKHbI CTapaTbCA AOKAsATb Ha eae. ambYa npuposustit cnocoGex OGHUMAaTh TO, YTO ero OKpy2KaeT, a PaSBUTH ero U cAeAATS CHOCOOHEIM Y3itaBATb 1 TO, Hero OH He BIEL, MO- 2KeT TOAbKO CBeTCKOe O6pas0BaHne>?. Hpu3uasaa ncKmounTetbHO BaxKHOe 3HayeHHe yyeOHEIX nocobuit B oprannsauun yueGHo-nponspogcrsentioro mpouecca, M6paii Aarstucapuit CUHTAaA HEOGXOAMMBIM He AOMYCKaTh HCNHOALIOBAHHA B WKONAX PeAHrH- OSHEIX KHHT, KOTOPLIe MpMtocaT orpomnbili Bper AeTY HByeHAA NOTOAH- TeMbHBIX HayK. OH cam pemtia nanucath «Kuprnsckyio XxpecTOMaTHio», B KOTOPO!! He ObLIO HUKAKHX PeANTHOSHBIX MH MUCTHYECKHX Mpononereil. 1H. Habsunck nit, Bocnommmania 06 H. A. Aaruncapune. Kasans, 1895, erp. 271—272. yunaume wr, Typrae. <Open6yprenuii auctox», 1884, Ne 5, 29 ® Slxoaencxoe aupaps, 192
eayr JoelTMM«OOaBHcKHToubuOaIe.oeCierQ.,CaprpoR.TopOTOUae,—UHHskOBMnArSeYTneUgeeOnH4EecrHboeenTpOoCutlaHueaKup,pOOorBTsoHauCnAK©opXKTtHKrrpiuBbaeaHaoeNyaukpoxE2pyMnycpyKppeMAulkmeaqKiopaotcorMaHl-ec,4cuo-urUskyNelapsulTluAaTiMcpeoH6OisTiaKaocBB,yibxA6aaIaacBaCepKcA,bpnHHHpkMamOMaieanosuTe.AAcuyuO-ipAbBtr,nMaXPAUIHaEeb,—IeaatIHpSHoBeiBprMeUToTsK.aanHiA3ektUuaAAHaX<rccuBPensUkaHrscMqpHtpCNOnrapaOu3Hue<au.KHX,yMBniJAPCecuKOloKTnyeaiCroHHao2oHrOpTk6OBeKOuuHcpMxeraMn-yHaoKMlapoOab,rJWapuaTaomItaceTcIamNTArccKuaeeoeympcpcyXtsOemBHHsuxKMneUTeapOaAoa©CXaaCuatTqKt»uTpp>XTxaOc,euAaOy'cpYCT..rXB3aOaTNpHNbnoeBaHOIeeMeKmgpeEXacHseerHo,KbnIrHgiOorBe#geHK1aBHertaOIbo3pBXOoMTscarOOFOosoBrMHAPGisysilBBopHcedoyOyIeeHMJMlaiOA~lNrl.0-,-,--- ilecTBeHHLIX YCAOBHH, B KOTOpBIX JOA am ETE,alaraer choM COOGparkeHiA O TOM, KaK axuBYT. Hcxoga u3 9TOFO, OH H3- CocTaBHITS OOY- yueOuINK aA ostomsyogei,BBKMJKae@UTylSwbOHHeUYEOIH2LNuXHHNCCBHKOAIXaXXHNBxYOyePCcMYKoCOeBCMllnKaYPTaOYxb-CKC.CUTKKPaHlPkaXHoqSlyiCWKKMUOXaAT,pemap1cHHKceOkaNaAaBO,sabX3AIpb.KXPiOO,AOTAaHcO6MKopTMaL3ayIKHikiHiaiosZJMbOIHIAy%BxGaKeaKeTcBHau,3HaoUX, nTcCOpoHKoeMHTBeeXBeIOyHeUyTnHLeeeMOTBtBeeuICHXOiHi,-- ARJHTKAlOeUeIKXBHOEMYCLTaUpOpHNeIHEOXML, OeUBB—rOHoATMsADpHIUaBOnsBITXoBI cHeRYTBpUEcpPanMPOleo,HsBUUtH4iSleTAaCeOnKX.cH.aAe{1«e.TMN1ea.o0iJtcI.bpOHYeKMXHaHbuKIyTpHYurcauOyTsBpa,cHockHBHAaHoIaa,iN,t p¢nauaxMTHKpay3oeKHsppOU,aHI,TO,Te—AITKHHUpraoMecUMbsXyoeHeMprGeuEKLrtoiBeBINOoAaoTOCnH6M--- 4TAM, 4TO GyATO CopoKa roBOpHT ¢ BOpoHOIO HT. 1.>2. _ S‘CMuKupIpAaYoMrBkkabaaHIsBeHbATiHpINaACsXiohraaHpnNaakOkMyTteo0p,B6aANomAnHpoHeMgExecMelHla.XnyHieoYnmeoCBtKeHlHtietpOeocrmooGexHOUHOsOMHCeHcTTH,RMEHKOHapgOaa!ixitcKcpAOeramOrtptiHiBcaa(phpoongpna- dZSXMlHhopeoTneuxCeBctelkrLoloatHcp,mrOabTac,CCyrcMTuokoISmbpaT,IM»ssc3e,yG,HreaeA«HHrCNBeMTBhH3ABieanexIHeNyGcC3PTaaaaHBpoGnHeOsoHHurGreH,pcrBBhesBINTioMnIaaCp,plKeoGaArxHseeuSHnsnbTetIHKiBBaAxukXYueeaoTces»LMHk,euMyeinHBtNoIHHCmPOeAEacbGekInxTlOp0eHacnnos4TtboeOiHcoT2MKm'BpB,oeIiHMGItTBHu.OAo«ceYjAKTeMTenuel,Ealp,AIcroBouaHTosO6cGCpHoeTacHie--i yelpe 1MuoAOeTcmlHBtiibyoeKInanEOBicluaieeAoBceHT,xrYeaxAInAHeKHpMrcyy,OheNrcHyoOpATreUaeaaNC,cldeOKMccKOAaksMHeOGacMsUHtoaPyP.YAMoucBegKaupTHHunioAtHoHrersg6oOIoaHTaacAHsaKaATyYAynOac,acaaaKaaan.O.nKOGOuaTTnTOeGcYMmscaH.ehOcAiaeKYBnbpnpEeyGeHexMBOnesuXoeonsKxHpsiAastee,.cMkpBaaKHAetxOeaucYKHyaapHCcnusKaee,cHuceCcyE,t,HeAsyApBueapAsOnayaCaObeeaAcKCsaaHnuM,mLmepHOpiecoTaHe--- ‘o1f5f. HabMunekui. Bocnommmaunx 06 HW. A. Aaruucapuue. Kasauy, 1895, *Tam me, crp. 237-238, 8 193
ioulem Mupe.xouesku, Yee Geper 3a pyky Acatia, m OHH BMecTe OTHPaBAAOTCH NO orTnuxsyaTk*tbHoaanryKek,i.umnMacy3YUNpakYYu.eoeuxwTecccrpOpabOeeyplelleuuasOennsMyeonaJBrOrama3rypkKoHMeMaeoaenynktecKrr.eeea,KYocammnTYT.gaHobfaprly.HHBoaoB2pinXOnppKeHBaxXoaerka(eeKHaetKnMTaeor,eycaOsBroycCgsspbrt,yebeHHiiHBtmtaTekYOpeOsoeTyMe3toTbrOmrjoOP)iaAHtaupM0HAobcCb3BraY.ecIaHHatOBsTalHe6aeyKiuMbctBeuNeKaHKpaHMos,TmaaOscabexCCDaoeIro,TKOmKYrMrOYeuypcaeOHdeaaee3rM-etarenTiaoHbMOaMrO,cHLG,HhLex.H\"esobYTBHgpIarKAOTOouqeaoOMaXycrpauBOHHKoHunlBO_Aaaca3ouesTTterGlTe,OTbxobK1CP.oHesALaJHiNrTOI3pYtXe0uGoMHtaOCTlaHiaHmnaTH.IBpBtHoeaapa3UA3Tciamam4HTSTsrCK0Souoxba,epB6kcnneOpauaHMsKaMtTripieaOHpneyHuyyimoTaHaTa3lbo-r--,---., =B strom paccxase H. AnrsincapHi crpeMHTcH MpHBHTb ACTAM-yua~eH ori.Mora,B[BMpfKB6CaHCoo1McCcHHn0rOTHBHOMyeMeMMapn,SAHlo,eTMaMrTrOHcenHHeBaFoMrAeeOaaOeaHOpTyKYpaOKiYOoaecPcHmvTcCIeOaKOetpTmBiUcpaFpaCTK,Ieu.AswKAalbA3tB%OaAlHbJpkOIaBeaeOHacpHAxnaTa,cCHCuBT,ATYTepBaCTaYLsMHAOOlOeTIaOaKaTrBenUYBXBTBObAHHHeOAui:HprIunKKMoAnksTHHMpHTciuAKEyHHhOCrMMyKCcKAnbH,HxOWiHXp,TTAa,oaLHapaaAsKekHeeoeHOaBMneamaAaOoabPccTxeaitqOTTTiIaMaOeaaGlKnptoHoeHrr31sicc3cidatnBcH3ee.AaoaaPloeTB,MOeelibKcKee,yHKyMmU.aaapyAeryTtopT1h¥aeaiomsc.xKHMOKn.OeYbposeTIpCT.erHtebaecAmK.uBnYBooe.eYcnMOxKTeOeeeeAoewlptu-t,t; epTdBBAuUeCMcTTbYe,HM,cTTeTbDTHnaeafO0GlapB6yYmOHBoSLeUuTApcuOI,LreiMekAlHH,McHOXTGA3aKaoOpcMwoayEbmeHHITNobuHlImOTAObeHeIArTtne0Obod3HWq.¢-uouPTaOTu0saMee,mpklHaiBa,B.OGtIoKIrBNraPeeYrXposTOcmHMHoKOaAOAMyTxOsOaoHBJprI,OOMburoHO3HmKaNMKoaoBOcTONaTHuuMYyecAHHbNaObOcC6oTboeuxa6nKg9paTaasOg.MneYolMincB1PTaH3I----- 40SKTHHHmeaTxIoEOBHuCUOeAIpHlMaOnMCcec.oKkpYMbacOOsKxeseXteHTxYm6eOpeTL6aOIaiTB,iheKOATaONBrOAcuOeKtLiOcIGBaAopTHmOuUTiMbt, eKncTpoOeHKMaTcaGPTsYoEiaAiabUKUeTrICx,eHus,THOKHATO.ycYoBBaoeb6TImypaapcAsoBKuueAteneceeaHcHbeiMt3b2aiIH6M03,o--O SAKOHOMEPHOCTAX. Tlpaxruueckast Ac- BHeMIHeM MHpe, O eTO ABCHHAX H HICTOUHMKOM ero SHaHUi 06 OKpy%Ka- HTeMbHOCT YeNOBeKA CTAHOBHTCH ulumcs 11060Bb K TpyAy, HOO TOABKO B TpyAe Yes1OBeK MpHYMHO*KAeT CHOI 3HaHHA O BHEIIHeEM MHpe, TOMbKO TpyA AeMaer ero YMHbIM, coo6pasu~ TeIbHEIM, HaxonunBBiM. A mom GecneyHble, *KUBYIMe 3a CYeT HyKOTO Tpyla, CTAHOBATCA HH K YeMy HECHOCOOHBIMH, TYNBIMH, HeBC2KeCTBEHHDI- MH, Oe3BO/bHBIMH. Anrsincapuntim 3HpaoymeHHet.pyStiaecb8 pasBHTHH yM~ Tloquepxusanne HW. ¥TO uMeeT BaxKHOe MbI BILLMM, cTBeHHBIxX crlocoGHocTelt Kagaxckult NpocweTHTeMb BHAeA OMTpereTMOULYIO Po-tsbHanNMpAita,kTDHYrEoCKGoeile ero‘TpyaOBO!t AeNTeNbHOCTH B PasBHTHH YMa YerOBeKa, cHopHo Obiia MaTepHasucTHYecKad Hes. 194
ao ® Marepuasucriueckue npegctaszenna y HW, Aarscapuna ne Opn U yo«NMHoacTeHB6H0eHLp>HoaBc3NacTeOkeMKaAAsJb3e0UbI,LB<AICYMIOuOHTe,,AnuOYiTTtOAveOeAuaHIYboHHBsYebe,Ixpe»HHeaIHrWoHB. eAGGpaeoncrtcas3KiBnKaeics3aba/kbipIuB,1n3NBHen«ApiKmMBumMopnerrpuF,H3ospycbnKiHoHyMitbMtxKBpuapeIMLacHA.toHN-, ale.BeTep H LO2Mb; KAK NOAYMAelllb O HHX, BCe 9TO TBOPHTh YesOBeK GeccH- HeBHAUMAR S70 sHayHT, YTO TROPLOM BCero STOTO AOAWKHA ObIT IAHac cBepxpectectBeHHan cista>', pea,Tarpuapxanpno-peoraapiiaa o6ulectBennat 8 KoTopoit roc Anticapiia.NOACTBOBATO PeTHTHOSHOe MUPOBOSspeHHe, He Mora He OKAsATb cBOerO Bansnua Ha B cuay 9Toro on He cMor ocBoGoq_HTBCA OT OG «apantaneIMTHOSHEIX MpempaccysKos. sToM cBHJeTeTbCTBYeT H yrBepaeHNe |. Anriiicapuna B Kure uciaM»> 0 Tom, uTo Mup coTBOpeHt Gorom, 2a u cam tbakT HanHcanua MM KHMrH, NOCBAMLeHHOM H310%KeHHIO OcHOBHEIX noOxKcHHi HeaaMa. OnuciBan B ueii* Kpacory npupomss, ec Gecuncnentbie GoratcTBa, ee pasHooOpasHBIX XHBOTHBIX, ee MHOrOOGpas- ublit pacrHTeabnbiit MUp, €@ PeKH H OSepa, HONHHLE H TOpbI, O;HHM CiIO- JUBOM, ONMcHIBas BCe TO, ITO UMeeTCH B IIPUPONe HM anopasutixGonreone, ii,OGUHa. aAainoursuiiuMcapHueausrMoseoppuuMrto,lt ur0 Bce CAYIUT NeOBeKY co3- cusoi 9TO AONKHO OBITS TpH mu croco6uocrsI, 9TOM HeOGXOAUMO OTMeTHTS, uTO y AaTuIcapuia Her KaTeropuuecKoro YrBep2xAeHHs O cyulecTBOBANHH cBepxbectecrBeHHoro syxa. On cunTaer, 470 HaaMuHe 8 NPHpoRe TAKHX GraronpusTHEIX yenoBNii 114 cyulecTBO- He LOMKHO ObITh cayyailNBIM H MoxKeT cayKUTR NOKAasa- BaHMA mogei TEMbCTBOM CylleCTBOBaHHA 6ora, MyApOCTbIO KOTOPOrO H Mora 6bITb CO- TeopeHa sta TapMonus Mupa. B pacckase «JIyxnau-Akum> U. Aarstucapnn yreepaxaaer, sto Gor Mar veslowexy pasiHUHBle oprael H uTO KaxKyLit Opal HMeeT cBoe on- ant“peyesteioe HasHayenue. TCH, 113A —YTOGH UenoweKy pyKU JIM TOTO, HTOOM Tpy- XOAUT, YUM — 4TOGB BHZeTb, HOrH — YTOLI aT. JOAOW yKasbiBaer, 4TO AOMKHEI HCIONb3OBATh NO CBOeMY. aveHMiO OPraHbl YYBCTB WIA NOsHaHHA OKPyxalomlero Mupa. Kak suauo us 9toro, Anreiicapun He sOtTopiHilPaednt upreHAHM,rHMH, yH..O. 9TO He Me~ iiaio emMy HeHaBHAeTS NponoBeALHKOB Tipusuasas cymecrsovaune Teopua Muposanus, Anritncapun, mo- 6HO AEHCTaM, PeLIMTeAbHO BHICTYNat NpoTHB MpakoGecna H HeBexKecT- , KPHTHKOBAN HemenOCTH pesHTHOsHBIX NpexpaccyaKos. Ow copeToBart aM,BOACTBROBATHCA B CBOHX MpakTHYecKHX AelicTBHAX He CyeBepHbIMA mM. He NpeAnHcaHHAMH pesHrHH, a 3qpaBbIM paccysKoM, pasy- B arom orvomenna sacayxupaer sunmanus cept pacckason H, Aa- Aattuunnccaappmuyn., Kuprusckan nxepnecat,omKaarsuasn.n,Ka1s8a8n4b, , er1p8.792, —erp3.. 31. Wapawran 195
‘¢THeelcnaepxneucats, o»T!o.mBemaenranxbixpa8cck«aK3uapxrusAckarobitiucxappeHcirtomB aTcauTnu»pHnoecxK3oairtmpapoHpmeme BEICMeHBaeT TMoBeeHHe JNoReH, HAXOLAMLNXcA B NeHy cyeBepuii, H pa- 306aa4aer MyLI, KOTOPHIe HAKHBAIOTCA, NOTL3YsICb HX HeBexKecTBOM. Olt IepaccekFOa33beiMpaAcATHKOHTOexMK,EAKHaEKBHOOAHHOYHb3IOBeHpyIpIOaUloITHX4,epMTHp,eANTpOHnTaVraasW, aYaTOHaHyaTeKHPHbIE- MOJNTBL Myst, WTO OTOFHATS OT AOMA HeMMCTHIX LYXOB H HCTpaTH.t Ha 9TO HeMaao gener. Kak BEIACHHAOCh BHOCAeACTBHM, YepTH 9TH CyukecTBO- BaJH.JIL B BOOOPAKeHHH XOSANHA, KOTOpEI NpHAsT ga YepTei MpbI- TaBIIHX Ha KpbIllle 3eEMJAHKH KO3AAT. TioKaabiBaer, x Ka- B oanom 13 pacckasop sToi cepmu AaTsiHcapmi ayaKncByHynMiM0KOuT%r.pHKaeOarMeHu,IMyMeNccHPokYHoH,G3MbCuIluBaHeaTTTdoAcAsJ0Ne6eLOeCAToefBMlHtHeOpAHTMMaBOcNiMia,oyOmKT4MYaaToeku,sH.MKpOHHToBOuMreCaTOoHA%faMKp,HeBmOYbHeWeMTTHOHYSBBoeaUsKHkIHobCInHeba,3aNHKppeHGaypoavadtHcbta--e OcMedmca TOfOlTH K Moriuie, Nosaras, YTO 2%KeHMMMHA KpHUNT TOoTOMY, OTBET Mepe cyZoM 3a coBepileHtbie rpexH. AarbincapHi uTo JepxKHT sogel,rHeBHO OGsMUAeT HeBeXKECTBREHHLIe MOCTYTIKM XopoHSULUX yMep- WINXBCppaacsyckMasoecsle«<CJMlyexpnTaHn,-AKkaukm3»TOANxrppesiMticMaCphHIBiAepTeuHmCtaeMrb. io ocyxKqaeT n0- BeseHHe MYCY/bMAHCKOFO JYXOBeHCTBA, KOTOPOe CHHTATO BPeANDIM J1e- unt siogelt of Goresueli, Tak KaK JeualIINe GOabHBIX BEICTYTAIOT NpOTHB Born. Mysibt noyyasH BepyIOMHX, 4TO GObHBIX He cuIe- 6oxecrBenHolt Ayer Aeunt, uTO ¥TO GecHonesHO, 4TO CKOJKO Obl HH JeHHH YenOBeKA, Gorom. Ol BCe paBHO YMper, ecu eMy CMepTb NpeanHcana yaaOcyxknad Hesenocrs NOAOGHBIX yrBepxAeHHit, BCKPEIBAR BPE, KOTO- put om upnnocnat, Antuicapai mozelt He BepuTb HeBexKecTBeH- a1fbIM MpenpaccyKaM. Toro, ToObt cantare NpaBiaab- Tlo muenmo Hopas Anrumcapnia, HBIM TOUsTHE O TOM HIM HHOM TIpeAMeTe, CHAa4asTa HY2KHO YMOM OXBATHTS 9TOT MpeAMeT, OCMOTPeTd T1a3aMH, a 3aTeM Hayo YOeqUTbCA B NpaBHtb- HOCTH MpeACTaBseHHA O NpeAMeTe, CHOBa MpOBepHB 9TO NpeAcTaBseHHe MoM H 3peHHeM. ToabkKo Nocse 9TOrO efO MOXKHO B3ATb pykoii, nonpo- GoBaTb ero ASbIKOM. Takum oO6pa30M, 3fecb B ONpexeTeHHH HCTHHHOCTH MpescTaBseHHA TOM IIH HHOM MpeaMere MapaienbHO MpHHHMaioT yuacTHe HM pasyM, © HIGB BHULY oMLyulenne, npuyem AsTLincapuH uMcer spHTe-tbHOe OLLy- 1 menne. Y vero HCKMIOYAeTCA U3 NPOBePKH MpeAMeTOB PO.Th APyTHX OLlLy- uleHHii: CTyXOBBIX, OGOHATEABHBIX, OCAZATeMbHBIX. OnHAKO He cuesayeT MomaraTp, YTO STO AaeT HAM NPaBHJIbHOe NpecTaBreHMe Oo NOHMMAHHN qauxoro Bonpoca VM, AariiicapHubim. B neGoubinnx pacckasax, noMemennbix B yueOHHKe 21% HavaJIbHBIX Kaaccos, AnTsIicapHit He Mor cTaBHTb 3aqauy OObACHeHMA OGMINX MAN ‘paHxteVecKisGorloot.xleeoenrvpWoaAneCuTyHBebbInXiltlieoMcaHreaPOTmBOHuSapM3oPseoHHs3esBcpKeeCUnTXHuOsBeOHTO6PCOpHCaOOsBBa.HAHaersCiyicAaHpTub ia0,6 + HCTO- KoTO- 1H, Aatwucapun. Kuprisckan xpectomatis, Kasaup, 1879, erp. 52. 196
pad Npexkze Bcero BHAHA B NpH3sHaHHM HM CymecTBOBaHHA Gora, Kak TepHgoonpHuoa6npaieitt Bcero cymlero, B ero Bepe B GoxecTBeHHyI0 rapmoniio. npoceetureaem, BsictynapimM 3a pac- Aaruticapun 6x11 Tipoctpakenne O6pasopanna HM 3HaHHit B Hapoge, 3a Mporpece HayKH MH exuukn, Fostomy, nogo6uo AGaio KyHanGaesy, on 1 B cBoHX paccyx- AeHuAX NO BONPOCaM peAHTHH NbITAeTCA Cc NOMOMbIO peaurun yGeqUTS Bepyloulnx B UpesBEtuaiinoll MOAesHOCTH HayKu mM NOGYAUTb HX K ee H3y- yeumio. J[18 9TOrO OH XOYeT NPHMHPUTS Awe NPOTHBONOAOAKHOCTH — Hay-_ Ky HM PesHrHi0, NOKa3aTb NoctesHIOW, Kak COBOKYNHOCTS HpaBoyyenHit, MPeANHCLIBAIONMX MOLAM OOAZaTeABHOCTD N3yYeHUA HayKn'. ay.Tlo muenmo Antbidcapuna, TBopel B Hayate Npexonpexesma MyTe K paio mk Ho kro u3 ziogedi JnOongaezlelr, B pai man ax, 9TO He npeayemor- Peo Gorom, a 3aBHcHT OT CaMHX OT Toro, KakHe NocTyNKH Onn 6y- AYT copepuiat. Aatbicapui Baer MOHATS, ¥TO H3yueHe HayKH 103B0- THT sagsiM pasoGparecs, Me LO6Po U 3.10, Ht TeM CaMBIM yKaxKeT MYTb K pato. Ou NpusbiBaer H3y4aTb HM 3HATb NOAOAKMTeADHbIC HAYKH. Aareiticapui NpusbiBat MONOAexKb HByYaTb eCTeCTBeHHble HAYKH: Ma- TeMATHKY, MCAHUMHY, aCTpOHOMMIO HM ApyrHe. On yKa3piBaeT, YTO cama Tak‘pHee anuorunapo6cuyuerraBerogHy auy3kystooript opmeHxoni,i pexoil. 11 te, KTo nonpobyer mt Te, KTO Bce panio GyayT HeqOBombULT (apman- aa). Tleppbie 6GyayT HeqOBOADHBI NOTOMY, 4TO OHM NOsHaloT Wey HayKH, a Hayka GesrpanHuna H rayOoka, 4TO He1b3A NO3HATb BCero TOrO, YTO BaxoTenoch 6bi NOsHaTb. Bropple xe, He 3HaloNMe HayKH, OLIBaloT HeRO- BOJbHLI TOTOMY, ¥TO OHH, GyAyun GesrpaMOTHBIMH H HeBexKecTBCHHBIMH, He 3HaioT uygec HayKU M ee NOAesHOCTH. Taxum o6pasom, H6paii Aartincapnn qaxe B CcBOeM peTHTHosHOM tpaxrape «[Hapautan ncram> crpemuica nponaranauposaTs npocrern- TelbckHe Welt. Baecre c Tum AntbiicapHi yKa3bipaeT Ha Gesrpanmunocth 4 pasBiTHa ItaHayku, Ha GecKOHeIHOcTb YeAOReuecKOrO Mo3HanHa Mupa. Wes, BbI- Paxkenas KasaxckHM NpocsetuTerem B (hopMe nonyaspHoro pacckasa, sacayKuBaeT CepbesHoro BHHManHA. Ona noKasbisaer, uTo AntineapHn MibITaich paccMaTpuBaTh NOsHaline, Kak NpoTHBOpeynBHI npouecc. * Vurepecst npocsemenus, HeoOxoqumocTh H3yYeHHA NOOAKHTeETbUBIX HayK GbLIN COBepUIeHHO HeCoOBMecTUMB! ¢ PeMTHOsHO! cxoacTHKoli, Tiponopesyemolt Myvi1aMM B MYCYJIbMaHCKHX AYXOBHBIX UIKOsIaxX — Meq~ pece. Tostomy p amue npencrasnteseli mycyabmatcKoro jyxoBencrsa Axruticapun Bujer Monel, HpascTaeHHo pasBpauiaouwx Hapos, nop- Hoy yo‘TAULUX ero BL0POBDIi OpraHuaM, je-TAIOULX ero HecHOCOGHLIM K KystbTyp- mporpeccy. Ox rosopu, Kasaxckuii Hapoy, HaxoAUTeA «B Mepe- XOMHOM cocTOAHUN» OT GeckYBTYPbA H HeBexecTBa K UMBHANZANUM H ‘Kyabtype. Umenno B Takoit nepos, ykasbiBad OH, Hapoy OcoGeHHO Hy2K- 1H, Aatuncapun. Wapantan ncaam. Kasamn, 1884, erp. 6. 17
qaetcs B AyXoBHOl nume. Mexay Tem, nucan AnrbincapuH, «Hapon .. - 0-STY MMULy, NO HeOOXOAMMOCTH, NOAyYaeT M3 HeBEXKECTBEHHEIX PYK, BOMHO 2KALKO HaNUTLIBaeTeH C10 H MOpTUT cBOi 3n0poBEIlt opraHiam>'. Becru Gopp6y c MYcysIbMarcKHM apxambHo-deosatbuoro Kasaxcrana AyXOBeHCTBOM B YeaoBuAX naTpH- K. Ka- 6pi0 Henerkoit sanayell, T. :eoMabHad MY,3HaTb BbICTYMala B 3alLTY SaXxcKaa BCAYeCKH CTpe- MHIach NOULeprKaTb HX aBTOpHTeT. AeAyOtmMeuas, Kako Bpex NPHHOCHT AeATeMbHOCTh My. HaposHo- . TO OGpaz0Ball4st, H MOKPOBHTEALCTBO. HM CO CTOPOHEI npenctasuTentel saactu, H. Anrsiucapni rosopua: «Myatt, KpoMe ocoGeHxoro caoiicraa Ha6uBaTD YeTOBeNeCKHe romOBI HecKAMH, HOPTAT H A'3BIK MpHpoguEtit. B OpsHaniel crpaue MysuncKas Tlopoma pacnpoctpausetca B GombUINX pas- Mepax, H HX BbDKHBATS H3 HeT HHKAKOM BOSMOXKHOCTH, HOTOMY ¥TO xeBCAKOe MPHKOCHOBeHHe MYJIMHCKOM YeCTH TOTYaC OpabIcKoro HayasbeTBa>*. CAeMaeT KadppoM 3aGLH NponoBeANNKAMMH HeBexecTBa H MpakoGecus, TO Mocaentine HeHa-\" Ecau HV. Aarpiicapan ocyxqaa esteAbHocTh My TO, YTO OHH suqeadt Anrsicapitia 3a ero mpocserHteabcKyio sleaTebHOcT». Oprattn- Hesauna AnTbItcapHHbiM pyCCKO-KUpru3scKHX MIKO, O6yyalomlMx geTe PeAMrHOSHOM CxXONACTHKe, a NOAOXKHTCADHBIM 3HAHHAM, HaHocHaa yAap TO MmpecrwKy Meapece, PYKOBOAHMBIX TaTaPCKUMH H CpeqHeasHaTCKHMH Mys1aMH, MOAPLIBAMa HX aBTOpHTeT, a caMoe MlaBHoe, pacnpoctpanana B Ka3AXCKOM Hapoze PYCCKYIO KYJIbTYPY, YTO MPOTHBOPeYHsIO KACCOBBIM wuTepecam peaKiMonHol KasaxcKoit (eonatbHOf BepxyMIKH m peakuHOH- Horo MycystbMaxicKoro syxosencrBa. Mmentio ostomy mysist 1 peakun- OHHad KasaxcKad (beolaJbHad 3HaTb BparxKLeOHO OTHOCHAMCh K MpocBe- TTHuprOeBtbAcaTKboietroxeBwrr1eaa3banxocTrPYHAA6LpLaHaXCAA,srBbeiAnYceaCpKuHiaO, NcOrpaopunaTsDicseroc.KoHmempocmaye-- uaiitto AsiTbicapuH roBopHt, YTO <npHOGpesr yaKe Hemasto TaflHBIx Bpa- H3 TaTap H TaTapo*HsOB — BCe 9TO BMeCTe B3ATOe, H Kak HCO_BBepSITeOHM- TOB Hesacay2xennioe, Kpaiive zypuo BauseT Ha Moi OTSHIBUNBBI Ho ornemennn caa6ntit xyx»’. Syecb HeEOOXOAMMO CieIaTb BOOOTObBuOIep.KYK, o4r7a0a Aarbincapuu, ropops 0 Ta- TaTapax, Tapax, He MMe B BUY TaTap OH TOBOPHA O OH MMe B BAY TATAPCKHX MysWI, MpoMloBeAOBABIINX UCMaM cpeaH Ka3zax- ckoro HaceeHHsa, a TaTapodusaMH Ha3bIBad Ka3axoB, BCAYeCKH MO/- AepKUBABIINX PAHTHOSHYIO NPOMOBeAL ITUX TATAPCKHX My MH MOApa- *KaBWNX TaTapeKoi 3HaTH B GpITy. Tlocrosuno 4yscrays Bpaxkze6Hoe OTHOMeHHe K ce6e cpesbI, B KOTO- oPporiaHOuHsye2KMHLbAI,MMHpomcB0eTeHroTeNabgpHece yOTsCtToYiNHcApeNsoeipie. s KeBeTOi Tlonumaa M HUTPHrAMu, Heu36exHocTD TaKOFO OTHOUeHUA AK nHteuMiiYcaCpOunCTOGPuOiHIBeppeHaLKIIMHO2H0HbKIXoHKIapyrcoBBouMKa3ya6xCexKsOIero o6mectsa, M6pait HHAM H TutyGoKO CosHaBad Npasoty cBoero Aeta. On AcHO BHACM cBASb 1H. Masauncxmi, Bocnomuanus 06 H. A, Aaruncapune, Kasane, 1895, erp. 289. xxee,, ep. 215, ' # Tam 258, 2 Tam ctp. 198
Bpaxse6u0ro oTHoMeHHs HeKOTOpEIX ero HeApyros K mpocseTuTerLcKoii xeAeATeABHOCTH C.cOBpeMeHHOM emy HcTOpHyecKOii OGcTaHoBKOH. <Uto reMope.1actilb..., BPeMA TaKoe, —ToBOpHA OH, —4TO HafO KaK-HHOyAb H NpeACTOHT BOSMOXKHOCTS NpoTHBoLelicrBoBaTb sly, pasbenaioulemy oOulecTBeHHOe GularococTosHMe KUprHs HM HOpTAMemy HX GOyAymHOcTD, TeBeb He AabaTb PYKH BIAMIIb, YTO soAH yToNaloT, Oui0 Gbt GecuecTHO, a He GesonacHo»!, MOMOMIH TaM, 9TOM CMBICAe TOXKe, OKasbIBaeTCA, AeiicTBOBATb B M6paii Anteincapmtt Bbicrynaat He TOADKO NpoTHB AeATeABHOCTH MYL, ‘BpeAHO OTpaxaiomlelica Ha NpocsemeHHH Hapofa, HO H OcyxKAaN HX ‘HH3KHe MOpasbuBle KayectBa. Ilo yreepxKAeHMIo Mpocseratens, Mysabt BUATOBROPAT J1O2Kb, OHH TOTOBEL ObITH CBUAETeAAMH TOTO, Nero He H He sHaior. Ho Hy2kHo oTMeTi#TS, YTO B LeTOM KpuTuKa M6paem AatsticapHnyim MYCY.IDMAHCKOTO AYXORCHCTBA, B CHuY TOMO, ¥TO OH CaM GbIM He cBoGo- OT PeHTHOSHBIX MpepaccyAKOB, HOCHT Henocse_OBaTeAbUBI Xapak- Ocy2kas TO, 4TO MYJWIbI CBOeH ‘ACH Macc MelllaioT Cpe;‘ep. MeEATEMHOCTHIO Pacnpocrpanenmo B Ka3axcKoii crenu nonoxNTeRbELIX sHanHit, a B cBO- ‘MX Mempece BOCIMTHIBAaIOT HeBexK, H chanaTHKoB, H. AntincapHH, Kak axeYkasaHo BBIIc, He MOpBad c HcnaMOM M Mpenogapanne pesurnn B INKOaX. MbITasIcA <NOANpABATb> Ou ykasbiBaa, ¥TO MyJWIbI ABAAIOTCA HeBexKAAMH B OOMAaCTH TOI PerH- cama.THH, KOTOPYIO OHM MpOnOBeAYIOT, YTO OHM He MPUSHAIOT HUKAKHX APyrHX upapoyyennii, KpoMe orMaTos «.. .Yaenuxn TatapeKmx Meapece, — rosopur Aarucapmi, — yunn- ser,IIHCb NO CYLLeCTBYIOULUM PYKOBOACTBAM B TeYeHHe HECKOABKHX BCe- TaKH OCTalOTCA HoAHefLINMH HeBexAaMH NO OTHOMIeHMIO K CBOE peaH- THH, HO TOJbKO C FpOMaAHBIM 3amacoM AYXa HeTepmHMOCTH KO BCeMy He- ,..BEHHEIM HCTOUNHKOM BCAKOM MYApOCTH TOKO MaroMeralicKoe Bepoyye- Tarapckile m OyxapcKHe crasar emimicr- yaabtMycyzbMancKomy ue, H BCe, TO He OTHOCHTCA K STOMY, CUNTaeTCA HeTOCTOMHEIM O6yyeHnA P M3MBIIICHHAMM HeBepHBIX>®. Mopah Aarsitcapun mbractea pocctanosnrs «zelictsuternyio> cy- MHocTh AormMaTos Hctama. Ilo ero MHeHIIO, OHM TaKOBBI, YTO BOBCe He AWKTYIOT HETepHUMOCTH B OTHOUICHHH BCero HeMycy.tbMaHIcKOrO, He OT- PMuaior 1 HeOGXOAHMOCTH OGy4eHHA moeH «CBETCKUM HayKaM H HeKyCcT- Bam>. _ Byayan nog eanaunes peaurnosnoro mitpososspenns, M6pait Aarut- ‘CapHH Hanucaa Ha Ka3aXCKOM A3bIKe PeHPHOSHBI TpakTaT 06 HCAaMe, B 3aa4yKOTOPOM OH CTAaBH. LaTb B MOXOLYMBOM opMe TOAKOBAaHHe pezn- THOSHBIX OOpAOB HCIaMa. » «K sTomy no6yx1an0 Mena H To ene O6cToOATerBcTBO, — nucan An- HTHM.a. mAWxaaetsi,waenurpcn.ac2xp5u8m—iin,. 259. Kasans, 1873, erp. 98. 1895, eTp. 248—250. Aarsincapnne, Kasaws, BKoucnpormusmcxmaaanunxpeoc6roMma.Aru.s. 199 ‘
‘HHCApHH, — ¥To caMH KupruscKne myaabt nfusnavann uecoorserersen> HOCTb HMCIOWXCA Y HHX PYKOBOACTB, a GOAbUINHCTBO HerpaMOTHBIX KHp- TH3 3AABAAO, WTO TaTapCKHe HayasbUbe KHHTH Ws MBI, YTO He CyllecTBYeT HH OAHOM TaKoil H TaTapcKOi AeTel ux HenoHAT- cOOpaHbl Bce usaGxtObi HEOOXOAUMLIe, OGa3aTeTDUBIE K KHHTH, B KOTOpO! Bepbi>?. HCHOMHeHHIO mpa- MoKpATuHCHMmHaCToaMTKcBapoUkaaecX.uGtrmHaHcsoUamec0TGsA6aBKeApapMa3yOaa3ulTXoleYeCMm6eHKTup,OAumoMiccK,BrBpeuennsTm3l3oOeBHnsMIipKaHc,bereaaaY,, ntTnOrOOiuHep,CmruBoHcOOnOG3uoHO1DccaAaaoeKrHa6aTmKTusSHTaaBbsAeaHr<xOOMocc[keaaOoTcrpTmeonoamTcHnaoese6ktriNsaacpOTnHniBcHkaKeO3Au,bTRociHBeaMaAEaa.eIBmeMeA>BpA.noIOXyrtOMiytMnAeicTnyHaHnaT-ee- Nepes-3rTu0ACaXT,ObxHMHHK6aMpaKHasoaiCtxbMmcAkAbotXnr,HroueTinAoHcKTaappHpuuuoBitaa,emH¢naNeTsHPouycrCeoaCcnKHkcHhioMalikcrrHaaHM,pa¥apTKonOgHcOeMKMraeK,ZO0B3KaHMaqe3yKaacaOTycTsabOMAPBYaUHIXeXMOCBbKCIHBOOYOiItHOOX6DGCaaATmCai---yueMyTTHlYueeUCNeaBySbbOOnHHueuoHOomeMecKn,IatOObhHaTOyHeHKPtXroBA.piIKYXtaYAnHAKtaeLorYuLCs,uTUiTnrOM4ePcA7eaNC0Mp«HOmH<,sNcInteRKyOagO»xAToaMONmrcPopTBmrrHemIaMoOHpGyxOaeuXycUeEOktIATncTBheaenAetKruniNoixpieepcepAHynaeceLocpAKagmTiMTnOueMheaitNcBNprHAnKoOO.cyCOpaTCebKHHrTUHre.YtTTapAEKeeiBTn.xaTbbkoUuOnabopnITEBMpiin3bmBIHeTasBaa---- eTed AOKasaTb, 4TO Hanucaine AarbiHcapHHBIM perurHosHoro yueOuuKa Ha POAHOM ASbIKe GLIIO ABACHMEM MONOKUTEABHLIM, ECA HMeTb B STO MYJUIbI 3ACTABAAIH KasaxckHX AeTel saay6puBatD HerlouaTHEe Busy, apad- ckHe TeKCTH Kopata. eranSKAMAOXaBpCrO<usKAHTitOCcyaelTiaknnEposoOXeniuopusJeurI.HcnAeTa—oeOc,MNnKaaknpnT.aaeeHkmnBHoaH.,mx)taOeaogHnxppaeanCneercOeuTcCnsbAmTKMA.BaBaHtHCe.p,Apuu—ostTHyaaMaspaneiounKksmnaKoto3asamaeXkrycC, ArK(ca<HoO.spLMauepCarpaupbsua3TatybeauI<LnKcrt[iaeiKlconaooHpscA,aHrHnae—ocgstrcaoaanrnoeMyynnc>niTe)ou*imteM>a.mKpoy€ea-, a omty qocky ¢ «Kuprusckoi pallinpanna caa6ix Momentos i-vero He BbIurpaer. xpecromarueii». AOxrTbTiatixcoarpoyiapozHaayKmapuyk- B yeatesbuocTn Ty OH,HUTb 3AKOHOMEPHOCTb TecHOro COAWKeHHA AoB. YACTHOCTH, CTPeMHICA MpOBOANTH HB CCTCCTBCHHOCTh, B THX Hapo- MEIC «lllapanr- JIM HeaaM>, @KeTAK OKAsaTb, YTO 9TUKA MIM YueHHe oO HpaBcTBeHHOCTIT KHPPH30B H Wake MOTMATHKA UX O.WKe K yYeHMIO XPHCTHAHCKOMy, ¥eM K MHPOBOsspeHHiO Ka3aHCKHX MycyabMan>’. OTH peaurHosHble MOMeHTHI, HMeBUINe’ MecToO B NpocBeTHTerBCKo! Aesteabuoctn H6paa Aarsiicapnia, He yMaamor ero 3nayenna B HCTO* PHH Ka3aXcKOro Hapona Kak BBILAIOMerocA NpocBeTHTers, NOCBATHBUIeTO eryBCIO CBOIO COSHATEIbHYIO AUSHb OlaropoxHOMy HaposHoro O6pas0- 1 Tam xCeu, rearup.x2o5n1., Mexarormeckne naen 1 npoceeritreabwag eateaboct 2 A.C. H. Aaruincapiua. Aawa-Ara, 1949, crp. 67. ¥ <OpenGyprexuit anctoxs, 1889, 31. 200
Bana, Soph6e 3a NpHoOueHHe Ka3aXxcKOrO Hapona K SKOHOMUKE Ht KYAb- Type pycckoro Hapona. Tiporpeccusime nzen Aarscapuna, noayanemme caoe Bmparkerme B ETO AeATEABHOCTH, NPosBIAHCS B NpoTHBOpeunBolt bapme. C omNOli CTO esas¢HPnOpAaUopLcyIOs,reobMiiUjtBeIIncnrBHoeHpaAonHHupMasa,pls,oYazOeTaOnH,ttB3eaHAapearGcoonYpCpMTso6YpcayNKrKpTMnaHpnYoEepTCneHKruUBAeNrHcMHpjpee,HaqKxTuBeoAJGMIDMeacHOcucOMs,CHeTlaHi,cyAeKeBHreBoxHpeCacrSTToHBpmeAaM,HHt3Neaa--; YkKH H OOulecTBeHHOrO Mporpecca. Sra nporuopewmBocrs B Muponoaspenun H6pas Aaruucapuia o6b- HTfacBAikYnovIvcPl,KeiHlHecOABbpkeTIyuTMoOTcezloHpcieOmKBniUoplyIMalHpAnGPAacaOsHKoxrBTHryTeHeeaebBMIpbiHOHTocPyay6lePppaYpByMuMacIpi.BcitytaKOkCCooABTBrhHoOnooIe!OrpTHeMBijaceuOTpsapTBoopoeAglBuMaIanC.bcc.HOmHAGOiFmctCLhpTeeuConSATOnreBNpoABeMeHCcnUeHcoSOuKsK-ntOHsAoeiHosmsuAAOTeyUMXeNTCH1HKYBeYHEHCcEenKsCpoHKnMoeMpOcipoilsorepcIntrBecueceKpsrcTeeaHyHrarcDEToIsb-et---, Oxuaxo Aarsmeapun PuapxatbHO-eoranbuot Bsipoc 1 cBo1 xesrebHocTs pasnepHya B naT- cpexe, BANAHHe KOTOpOl! nocTO- OOulecTBeHHOM AHHO MCHBITEIBAT BO BPeMs YaeGEI HB MepuOg NPeOLUBAHUA Ha PasIHMHEX ANMHHHCTPATHBHBIX JOmKHOCTAX. H. A. Aarsmcapun, p otanune or YU. Baauxariosa, cbopmuposaaca Kak MBIcHTeAb U MpocBeruTeAb rlocae pedopMur 1861 Fr. , Koza npouier _ _ HlepHioy OcTporo KpHsHca KapH3Ma, HCKMOUNTeAbHOTO HanpswKeHHA Kaac- Copoii GoppGut H peBosONHOHHOTO BooAYUIeSAeHMA pyccKoro Haposa, BLISBAHHbIX TpeSoBaruem oTMeNBI KpenocTuoro MpaBa. B 97o Bpema BMecTe C HavaBlMMcs GypHbIM pasBHTHeM KanuTasH3- GotH‘wMuaeiiHHcarcBeTnOyeHHKnUiuNX e6pM1uaHOrCooCnyHpOpAHOETTpHcCOTKCBHHXOTeBTaODTHpOraAneMuAsHTaEpnHAuODiTHiO,OCTpBHaesTBpHPeveTAaHBULAPU,HNOKXSOHTLBOIXpLLIITyliBUIBKpHexMsea~- TepHanucTHyeckHe H aTeHCTHHNeCKHe BO33peHHA. Dro He MOrO He BAHATH “OTPHUATeAbHO Ha (POpMHpoBaHHe MupoBos3penua H. Aarpicapnia, 4TO H BEIPA3SHAOCb B MPOTHBOPeMHBOCTH eTO B3TAALOB, B TOM, HTO OHH He OKA- pearHosHBxX sa6ryxKneHHi u NpeAMectBeHHHKa Baauxanosa. Ecan atxSaanich cBoOomNbIMHOT npexpaccyaKos, Mero MbI He BHANM Yero Hi. Aatpicapnt 8 yenonnax cram psiaioutmmes mpocse- (eM cBoeit CTpalibl, 3aHMMAIONLIM BHAHOe MecTO B HCTOPUM ce KyAb- LI, TO B STOM HallJIN BLIParxKeHHe HaspeBmile NoTpeOuOCTH SKOHOMH- BausKOuHBHHMOMKYyJbTypHoiPoxuc3cHuHmKHaasaxKcraasnaax,craBuO,sHBHKpUeIMseyaGstraatreoqaypcuasennpnost- HOMHYECKO! MH KYJbTYPHOM CBASH Ka3axXCKOrO Hapofa c PyCCKHM Ha- mM.
SAKJIOYEHHE Buimaiomumes Ka3zaxckum npocserutenam Yoxauy Baauxanosy WOpaio Antsincapuuy Opin cBoficrBeHHbl HeKOTOpbIe H3 Tex YepT MpocBe- TuTembcTBa, Ha KoTopple yKasbipan B, U. Jlenun B pa6ore «Or Kaxkoro Hacneqctsa MBI OTKa3bIBaeMca?». OTMeyan TpH XapaKTepHBle YepTst 32- fagHoesponelicknx mpocneriteael m pyccKux ro: mpocseruteneit 60-x nop, JleHuH TOBOPH., YTO OHH OfyuleBeHE «ropayei BpaxzOl K Kpe- nocTHOMY npaBy 4 6cem e2o NOPOXACHHAM B 9KOHOMMMECKO!, CoMMadth- Hoit 1 1opuaueckolt oGa1acrH. Dro neppas XapaktepHas vepra <mpocneri- ct—eKaus-xr»o.oppaBtmraodp2aHgsUa3txiHuaMtpraaHkrBmeOpOpHOoMcasLseemwBeeCnpeTiaca,T, oopcOoaHmilHMaaeolyBneCpseaMppozrpeeyrunccssK,aUncaMpnoGMPopoaocbcctB,HeueT.sHpTHoearAxeMoli:-, Hell, TpeTbsA XapakTepHas YepTa <npocBeTHTeIA> 9TO — OTCTAHBaHHe HH eleTepecon HapOAMEIX Macc, TaBHEIM O6pasom Kpectbstt (KoTOPHIe He ObLAH BOMHE OCBOGOAKACHEI HH TOKO OCROGOAKMAAUCh B SMOXy MpocBe vurestelt) ...>*. Ova TeHHHCKasd XapakTepuCTHKa MpocBeTHTeABCTBa B H3BeECTHOH Mepe OTHOCHTCA K Ka3aXCKHM MpocBetutesaim. Ho copMbI HX JesTeMbHOCTH CO- OTBETCTBOBATH TEM OOLEKTHBHBIM YCAOBHAM, IPH KOTOPBIX OHM BbIPOCIt M TpyaHaHch. Baranget Uoxana Baauxanosa nponnsantt Counaspuo-noautuyeckue HAeiMH AeMOKPATHSMA, 3alITH! GecnpaBHBIX TpyAAMAXcA Macc OT TIpHt~ TecHeHHii, HecnpaBesAHBOCTell H IPOH3BOa CO CTOPOHEI FOCcnOACTBYIOULNX KslaccoB M MeCTHBIX Balacteil. B anaause oOmectsenntix oTHOWeHHi Mozei ON Moule Ao NOHUMA- HHS MPOTHBONOAOAKHOCTH HHTepecos TPYAAMUXCA H SKCTAyaTaTOpoR M Tes CaMBIM MOKa3a.1, TO PYCCKHe MOMeIMKH H KanHTaJHCTBI, KasaX~ cxule heonaaut u Gan HUKOra He YMAIOT H He MOTyT AYMaTb 06 MiTepe ¢ax TpynoBoro Hapowa, a, HaOGopoT, 3aGoTATCA O CBOHX BbITOMax, Of yBemnyenuu cBoero GoratcTBa 3a CYeT SKCIyaTalMn TpyAAMLAXCA MACC, 1B. H..Jlewuu, Cou., r. 2, erp. 472. 202
Smt unzen YU. Baauxanopa cogeitctsosaan Pocty KsaccoBoro caMocosHa- HS KA3AXCKHX TPyAMULUXCH, B commonoraueckax Bonpocax Y, Baauxanos puictynaer Kak ray6o- xuil U OpHTHHadbHBIit HccHeAOBaTeNb, KOTOpEI MPH u3y4eHHH H OObAC- HeHHH OOUecTBeHHBIX ABeHHIt MpHsHaBan HeOOxo_UMOCTS Hay4HorO, MoAXoRa K HUM, HayYHOrO aHasu3a. Pewaioutum tbaktopom, o6ycsoBausaioulum MOTpeOHOcTH H3MeHeHHs Ta 6stYPYKBMOyeOuIOeiXbaSluAoYOHotBCMOBH.aMHHUuuapHHonBsiTeoxATlcOaeTScaApByu23HAeeXwaMxHOKaouaO,HllpO3ebuUOHeHcuoLH-sHOtNEbsCosCBlOXmoeTOOHsBoGAaTEOuHAnHHunOYluYHeoKWaBceHnAnCTIe3enbceKBEMTopOAaBrAsoMHo,eOiBgHiaOmJeOHTCiKUOLHlHy.eTicaH3BCtOrasaXATpraoBooxmiHarPci,aOaUcte3TcCaBMOOUKBnHTOGmMa.HeTAeOHHO0XBC-tHAHOUpoHaA,ONayrnNCTpcouTceToHSIKxkeOfbluoaBHt BnKOpeoHe,UromonUpOOMeCepHlnoMNlalicOetwzT.pHoMNpOeHsibAoaIaIOTHTnrgeKUpup3oaAbeHTcuiOocameMJlHcuIrabMauyHs4CsmaBKH4itfHIeeOaaoE----. SAXCKHM YYCHBIM, CBOOOAHBIM OT BCAKHX CYeBepHBIX MH PeAHTHOSHLIX NpexpaccyaKon. cd‘4yie.eitsBBepoMauaicyinscrx,yyaInbnHaMoaesavHeHxcmexkreoopckruroaMssoau.sApt,uyTMxlKoobBsaIteMkonomclTyMBBpaoop,mTeHxBBopHcnaoHprGoKuBeOnnMoHcoMaPtaeynkaeKuwTHrHpayBoAHusAHaMeonOruoMOmuclA«pepceTannBca=etTMHaabHa3cnOmctareaMO-, ‘miporpecca. Baauxanon ykasbipaa, 4to Haw NepciieKtuBa>, ecm OH B Ka3aXCKOMy Hapofy «npesctouT ruGerb- ‘HeTCa pelurHosHbIMu HAeamu. PesysbTATe AeATeAbHOCTH Mya MIpOHHK- IlosyToMy on TpeGoBaa oT NpaBHTerDCTBA MPUHATHA PeuIHTeADHEIX Mep AA OrPAHHYeHHA AeATeTbHOCTH ‘H‘cXUyKaeJOsIeBbpHuOiMi-.pyecBoyxc.laebnMb9Ha7n0ocrkouomiloebipotleetcButBEruaIna.l,olpleaescoaOnsaH4aayaennHe eBneyneoscloTpuHax NpoTOBes- BpeHOCTE MaTpuap- Nica‘_‘HM_eMpBBBauuiiMNicAtyBMnbIeaCcnTcvYeMB eHYRH.opeMeBBaoamPuaosxuyNaMnoHoasHaHOMHnapyoKKrHuapsaMxPpcoerTsauunrBHe.Hpe[wpMHa0rsHacOzysaiHl,eOcYTrUOB. yBOxaya6pu1Mx1aa0-- “HHOaBBporoiankfneteehlea, .KyOHseaTHamsxaoMyM.xcOcoBpSGOknTooooOcHuropMcosGouTyBrenpboHHyeteaaAHraaoncBoKeccasMBHBseHapeonxMEouucuMHcsoKsMa,cBHtpeeJaOPxxmBoYesHHReT.dLMHHOeIBOAeHMoMaBnFnOcaHruAKoCtexgoyTasKasbsNaIiUOOxoCHTcAgBKEyHOMNoEHmOKsGIIaTMae3XO3suaK3IMx3uaNCYbpKiSIKalOHKacOHHOennM,MH,pAoyABMcHEGtHHApIaAsexaaBcHopAnBmoPpeNYsanaKyCBcuKC,ahAH3KnabcOoxeiMxBB--- Pats HaHeHaBHCTb CO CTOpOHDI yrHeTaTetei Hapoxa, KoTOpble OObABARAN Hero NOHOCKI, He AonycTHaM ero XaHOBa 6e360%HHKOM, HCA xasejoaHBcAtuCTHpbaeKsBeaAsOHaTWxaPpKcyotAHasOOneBCaOTCSrBOBOCHTHTeaavMppemPxoOlnrearerpoeOcccnncuoyBeGaHlbiTbLalIeKiaXo.HKpoUAXrBeKHLoIoMriaHt aB2BOHPraOL3aHAIOuHHUxOLaMeHvHeoUAseM3MLoBIKrBecp,euaeHarcyoO- FO NepexoBoro H NporpeccHBHOTO, 4TO HMeOCb colt crenH. B TO BpeMA B KagaXx- 203
oJHlGeMnMY,oleoBNpxpeeaHnHnosEBuIssBBieAaPBsoIumUcxUpcaMeunsnoc,ctsaBBMOOueintueiHnTnaaHxpnoepAMBpbypKiHcMcoAKOPMoKyrOUaoxgTKaLxeHcKacKHpapoMsyjaaexcckKyTuYuomiertHobHHIMBaAppaoepHmMomoeMHMKHp.o,OOPcYb2#eCK,TCeHKK1TOaae7k!- eAKmpyyaebxJTlOpeybapt5tee0nN-HxbeaupuoesMcot6hBp0ob-rxipxBecarnocsuwpuBxeauaxsoncloitM,anpsaAoueutMlsespsiooeKsrioepatKTccTuasoNsaaeexsTcickpUkokAoiutrmooscaHHkmOspaaHpBLmoeMb.yIaeBpoAMC TmCTihpoorroOp,eCcHcHOKBBaH-k Hoi, AeMoKpatH4eckoit Poccueii. Baanxanopa©AMacOHpyOOppePolCymtYlcClTreenbCbuceartCITrxOmoTKBHBHoMetMKCbHTieoenaHNpAs3oHYaeeAaslxlaIxoiB0pocucoBTGalkjuBeXblooxI%niorxOMcKonBUsetSaMHIHHbHpbBNeaeIKcppsaATyeoaNaob3rHfupcsaTaTbotxx,aaKeroasapTOHBeueoOiOTc.lp,cMOeCuaHsTBKotKeBHoMKlGPTtMoBajOolMLkaMepBIrcEayootITMHearBAiMapaeOuscapeutBspspeeBoHocM*runeKOoeTyiUriYKOH3ToKHBiGuoKbbaBaBYasayAaBnKrKMxoHaAaJcpAHassKoA1HYamAXHoxTCAHrcbKoTaoOAaiPTtHyyHOouuaSAceu.cHeHeurAoo‘auCrpTBooeOonHbeyan-Ia-t é en* e ¢TNbHpeYOoeUgTCNaKipZaHapoeHuc, HnbBeixrIeuOroeOTAaIHLesMEOcCKOUTKaeBHsPEAHHHTniIOHe-YNaHeOOtCeMCKnHMUpATMMuHHoYTEcCatHsKKeHKAeHeM6HrpHyMa,GsBoCKAOyOMcaarMouOBMuOHpcroaaHrXpp4eeuCcMncKHaHaB,TePHeHbrIa‘L0pBXmaxr‘esaamJApIbasaHbrkOol-,-- BTeKOGHraeG3aso,pBXisBa.EOaOuMAexMOaCbcUoCHklMlTHuugaOHAieeiCAXHsHTKtHHeeaHOOlnaHHpppYaAHaoYuuBsHso,CsBkTecTOuLHAtMC.sBAaBpHHCHAMEHoyOMX6aOBpWPO3aTYaaGOTACq,JheCaasKATc¥uOTTeeyaMrOArOtopObXYHibnOIKOHAceCaMMaeTPpnpMHypToucoTescncnaKBKab,OeH,KaTxiOaNlKHK3CajeTaOTXKpbkHreoyOBn,soubutT1meBY3HtyaapoxtMaHebKb-OHalWMXineBieeraSloUMH8McOBeeCKTHIoaTOOyuvHATSxuCPBxaHTHP{aYmpnaePXHpMouYoae-ia-,- Ppaktepupie OcoGenHocTH. M6paa AUn, tpBinaacuapxuasiaoaaO.THUOC. HBTCaHanK: Tlpocserurennckas AeaTenpuocTh paGoroil, crapalleli CBoeil nepioay Gostee nosaneMy, sem jenTeAbHOcTh XaHOB 3aHHMa@QICH HAYYHO-HCcAeLOBaTeAbCKO! sHWKHBUOoeMilWplicAnEaTaeUsiBITiHCOeHOBAs!AaOTNNrTbueeKnMnPTScbbKeIaIOTtOpeHHMuECOnMOM,MMHU8pMPSaYHeokcCTTrKChsHOKmYOMKie-ynKacsKUeaPoxTKorcOHrKYSCHaYKHbiHioTaXxnyHappnaHaaIpBKoomxeBOnyaCuasuH.mPxYpTaOCouecxmrKopHseGaMc,occy-anbMHiAplbKlPieeMOarAsBtOaeeMxecrc,eBOt1Caanes—draCio4O.,- Jt OaJPMEeApaTotcEbsNeumUuCeiHCTwusHa,rKTKOa3TaOOxHMckYo3, AroYHTUOMHGaaHLpIICoHCfloa,3CL10aUTtHNoOCOTGOKbMEaBKcKaTeYHt,BcaHMBOIeCeKrOMoApBEAKaMYyOtrSebpIAaKtyHOPHAbOIiHt! HEOOXOAUMA Y/YUeHHA paOoTbl OTKPbIBAeMBIX HM HIKOJT. Toapaenne HW. Aatsimcapuua Kak npocperitesis sipadeTct CAMUM We 204
SAPKUX MIPHMepoB NporpeccuBHbIx NocaercTBHit AOGpoBorBHoro Mepexo- Aa Kasaxckoro Haposa B NosAancTBo Poccun. PasBuTHe SKOHOMM4eCKHX H KyJIbTYPHBIX cBs3eit MeKAY Ka3axaMu H PYCCKUMH H 3aMeTHOe PaSBUTHE MPOUSBOAMTEABHIX CHA Kpasi, BbISBaH- Hble pasBiTHem KanuTadu3sma B PoccuH B NopeopMennelii nepHos, no- B Ka3ax- Pork aH NoTpe6HoctTh B pacnpoctpavHenuH HayKU HM SHaHHii _CKoil cremu. M6paii Antsmcapuu Kak nepeqonoii Aenter cpoero Bpemenu Gomb- ide BCex Olllylad H COsHaBaI 9Ty NoTpe6HocTb. HMenHo nostomy on Topsa¥o B3xJICH 3a MpocBellleHHe KasaxcKOrO Hapofla NyTeM OTKpbITHA PYCCKO-KUPrHscKHX MKO.T. OrpomHoe sHayenHe npocpetutenbcKoit neatempHoctu WM. Astetica- ‘pila cocToHT B TOM, uTO OH, OTKpEIBaa B Kagaxcrane pyccKo-KUprHscKHe MIKONbI, BlepBble NPeANpHHsA NpakTHYecKHe Ward JVI NpPHOOULeHHT Ka3axckoro Hapoma K PyCcKOit KYsIbTYpe, MeyTaT O <cKOPOM CAHAHHH> Kasaxcrana c Poccueii. Ero 6aaropoxnaa AeaTenbHOCTb sBiace Ha4a- jinKAJoaamnsSubtOoXictypGleuleMcactaTorBMBowpae1otH8uz7Hsn8»Ao, er.SMcTntpepOepelpmvesarissloeinnauByvueeeeNHOKAnuObmniMKtiteiiMnBcaea4upKKTHaBavI3.ieaacTxcRRKeHoAmH-KOHMs3THHn3KTeOTO<, KUUuTTOperHuHHs3A-+ ais KasaxcKkux jeteli, OGysaBLINXCA B PYCcKO-KUPrUSCKHX IKOTAX, OBIT asasut1aa.BHuaannuoc,anuoMpHo. cpAentuttseisnecmapnmi,occpoexscqtaBpoama V3 storo pycckoro nepsbiit yseOunk KagaxcKHX WKOM, CTPeMHICH TAKKE LaTb HOBYIO OCHOBY MHCbMeHHOCTH Ka3aXcKOTO Hapoaa. Hanucap cpoii yseGuuk pycckum aatpaButoM, OH elle TpH Yer: JI‘‘KBae.PTSHtoBeKGabiTiaOMNYepHBaa3saaq OKAIAI ero NPUMCHHMOCTS KA3AXCKOTO SI3bI- nonbirKa Takoro poga. Ona noKasbiBaer, uTo Aa- HHHTHHCAPHH MpeABOCXHTHA Takoe KpynHoe cOObITHe B KyAbTypHOM ‘Kasaxckoro Hapoa, Kak MpHHsaTHe 3a OcHOBY cBoeii NHcbMeHHOCTH pyc- ‘ckoro aabasnta. sbavi Conerckoli Baacrn, crycta Goree vem 60 ster Mocste BLIXOMa B cBeT ra» naogorsopHaa uzea Anteincapuna ocymlectBHAach B ro- ro KHUTH, HallucanHoit pycckoi rpaduKoii. 6pMopaii Antpicapun mponarauznctom apy6xb MexkAy Ka3zax- ‘KUM H PyCCKHM Hapofamu, Ou H CBOHM JIHYHBIM TIpHMepoM, H cBoeil MpocsetHTexscKolt jlenTeTBHOCTHIO, CBOMMH BBICTYTeHHAMH wa crpant- Wax MevaTH CTpemHJca K TOMY, ¥TOGbI BOCHHTbIBAT CBO! Hapom B Ayxe Eo[PH3HATebHOCTH K PyCCKOMy Hapogy, ApyxGnic HUM. On cuntan Poc- OGUIHM OTeYeCTBOM BCeX HaposOB, HaceaMOMLMX rocyAapeTBO poc- Mmenno nostomy, ickoe, a KasaxcraH — cocrasioii yacrbio Poccuw. pallasich K OpHUHaAbHbIM MpeacTaBHTeraM pyccKHx Buactel, MH. An- iicapHu, Kak Hw YU. Baauxanos, npH3pieaa ux MposBuTb 3aGoTy 0 Ka- XCKOM Hapoje, OKASHIBATb EMY BCAYECKYIO MOMOUb B KYJIbTyPHOM Ht KOHOMHYECKOM PasBuTHH. Tax xe Kak u YU. Basuxanos, MW. Antsicapun peumterpio pbicty- ‘axlacJPIKTNnAPihOeTrHHoB,apKNoaxeKstrAeTTJOHOBHMOOPCHpT.eHIstOHPHreH,aKoIsOUHHHoObfIHi,HMOApTPoOnOoBMBHYeaTCNHY.sII,bOMCraOKHCp3bK4iOptHaFBOeLIyMBXOKyBaMesaHOXMCcTKBKHAaX,- 205
=are+IKOacypaeaaxctsoPYCCGKoOp-bKOHbPTi HcSCKBHPXeAHBIMHOH paccMaTpHBaa Kak BaxkHeiimee HAeouOrHYeCKuMH if pedMrHosHBIMIt BAMAHHAMH, H/LYUUMMH CO CTOPOHLI peaKkIHOHMBIX cpemHeasHaTCKHX .XxpoPTaToeEaHHmNnneBbooaoTHmpuoBO,oeii.CHctrTBtHHybpIiKnOtIypayccaalcaOxckHpKc3oyoaaCipiCCoTKKmrKPoUOeypMMapoybMecrTHsHHseIyiecabtpATiplEeeeontH,wocHMoMWeAfHe,lOTiHcHep3TpaaaeBGipctOboeptBrcAaaAncK,nnTpatphass3osamacxnTccHaKap,pSapaOGsoulaBriTnOeBuH,eTGHuHHkHeeecaaIkpOkByosnnbAKKaTp.aaYyyssrpaKoabCXexxsxcCaacTontkBeaHoieniHrBtoeHHaADaenHnBIeXe-sae---- axe22AXKoKnpnUeeyct3cOBbTHT3BHiHOnaaKMHc. BOaAubpMBTIuHaPaniHAsHc>shBH,cIBsXtBorYeaBAaBpCOCiTTTMbHHHieBXOmdAIaWXXTeHH.HOHMe6OHPpCgaaKbCsuMoCaMAPkKXaoas,3aKnamxuA,iePbqYiaMSrMBoOrAYMMMcHTEuT,LeoALcpBHeKoHHOoH9lTBaTiAMIHXEMADBAOoHeGKBA«IYuKTXMreeuICc_pHTCHrTBTuOEAseIC,cnTTHkHIMoSOoXibi,tiI, HapotacBBMrHapoXAaeCUBscMKctoHTHsiBBtpoaerH,oaMuupNyooeacu6pBp1aeAMgaTHnHsuTnsHTHeeeTMl3eCMIbAAaNapTBHBeICCnIrHBoTaHCyANampTCAHTOapHETupALtALIeMHCtceTaurBuoTYtcIepTOssyOaTtle/plaiAol,OH,TeHKTyPOUArHMHKTa,HaepKUtoAaTTntOpeayH,sAeMBOOibiIB.MGbOiareIOO3UeBMrbbMIspi,cansHHTKapea-~- Hes, HIJPTogoBpeOcpmamakHyy,aABapoT3GkIRVoeMaj.UocrlARaoptpMANnsTeeatI,MyApoXnc,sYHynctTBAHMucHruCBaHNTeiHAnnxOeTHCAMyKTucHTTOaayO2aYHpeTcpHuaACaeMc.uuTTs,1aMtHeOieHpa0pPeBBHn6nOeGHipH»xitHAGa.Br,irBIyanHGXCAApMrOycooyGHpOpesuuaeHoroMOlwo,pepeMecuuTKcoOsHHBymtaH3OeOasacBbGaePHTiOpHUsBypCo6aHBnaaarppnbAnLyaa,aeIIIr,MxcANBitnAeecBupOsTBHyAaIHTpOpHBpaTreOaBOaormOtpeHHOCoMmxnHTaoCe,ccBHscMTaHT.YTopDaTCaBHmnO,kTNOeanTepGsOBO,,MaHebHuIIpNspCO3bAauBToCHlBa.iOyOpKpANMaAO[abaM,IHAtpxpaHeAHHaKuMTAnBoHGjHerCememTsCTrnc.aaOepual«Tlannl2TDHCnueeaTHeTTHrcOyssyOty>------ ay Ha TO, ¥TO G1N3KO yxKe BpeMs, KorAa CHpaBeAAHBOCTh BOCTOP2KeCT~ Byer. AHcCtuOansaMHtMsMauneAcuMMGarMpsepCetcTiTrnHBKpaYoaaeppCsH0KanJxOsHmc,!ckpD0uoP6xceBBseSOKnKuMOplUeOHonSNOcuHHMsueHMrYOaHEtHaMeCaaspKreYoOolCzMgiTaaA,paHYa0H6OoKnBxYToaueJGn3HIbOaHeTasIYOBePBsHeBCaHOseHoMuasHxueaktMcuoekopriiooonriapOi eOxcBTtcaeau6apcyKTpHrHcau6K.separoaxls-t rHoOMrKnOUeatsMaa,xcBNkenoHgiiKOpHTyOkapoosPosy,xCcCtOBKCOoBTmOOOOKHKoLamepHomAxaBy,IxTuMcOtOaTCuTePKcOAkHoCTlCtOBncOoamTpONtuaumH,uCMHTApHMitIHEOcGHKpAoaAetTcHKH0oO0i-t KanHTaMHCTHYeCKy! cTaqMiO PasBuTus. HamodasbHad.NOaNTHKa Haulell NapTHM, imectBo, MHHYA 9.Jlenunckaa HCXOAPLULAN 206
Search
Read the Text Version
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
- 15
- 16
- 17
- 18
- 19
- 20
- 21
- 22
- 23
- 24
- 25
- 26
- 27
- 28
- 29
- 30
- 31
- 32
- 33
- 34
- 35
- 36
- 37
- 38
- 39
- 40
- 41
- 42
- 43
- 44
- 45
- 46
- 47
- 48
- 49
- 50
- 51
- 52
- 53
- 54
- 55
- 56
- 57
- 58
- 59
- 60
- 61
- 62
- 63
- 64
- 65
- 66
- 67
- 68
- 69
- 70
- 71
- 72
- 73
- 74
- 75
- 76
- 77
- 78
- 79
- 80
- 81
- 82
- 83
- 84
- 85
- 86
- 87
- 88
- 89
- 90
- 91
- 92
- 93
- 94
- 95
- 96
- 97
- 98
- 99
- 100
- 101
- 102
- 103
- 104
- 105
- 106
- 107
- 108
- 109
- 110
- 111
- 112
- 113
- 114
- 115
- 116
- 117
- 118
- 119
- 120
- 121
- 122
- 123
- 124
- 125
- 126
- 127
- 128
- 129
- 130
- 131
- 132
- 133
- 134
- 135
- 136
- 137
- 138
- 139
- 140
- 141
- 142
- 143
- 144
- 145
- 146
- 147
- 148
- 149
- 150
- 151
- 152
- 153
- 154
- 155
- 156
- 157
- 158
- 159
- 160
- 161
- 162
- 163
- 164
- 165
- 166
- 167
- 168
- 169
- 170
- 171
- 172
- 173
- 174
- 175
- 176
- 177
- 178
- 179
- 180
- 181
- 182
- 183
- 184
- 185
- 186
- 187
- 188
- 189
- 190
- 191
- 192
- 193
- 194
- 195
- 196
- 197
- 198
- 199
- 200
- 201
- 202
- 203
- 204
- 205
