RA XIX Full Catalog

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 78 LOT 79 5C 1919-S PCGS MS64 5C 1920 PCGS MS66 CAC A major condition rarity, the 1919-S becomes rare in MS65, and Bold and beautiful. While not the most important coin in the set,prohibitively so higher. This puts a lot of demand on the MS64 coins this is clearly a special coin for the date/grade, with lovely soft when they are offered. This coin offers a brilliant, glossy mint lusterthat provides a backlight to the pearly gold that dusts the surfaces. gold and hints of pastel greens and pinks. The surfaces are Accents of rose can be seen on the reverse. Both sides are fully free of any post mintage damage, the only flaws are mint made struck, a trait that is not often seen on this date. planchet voids.PCGS 198, NGC 119. About 40 coins are graded higher by PCGS, PCGS 146, NGC 35, CAC 32. The last PCGS/CAC coin to sellthe finest being a trio at MS66. The last PCGS MS64 to sell realized was in a March 2016 sale, realizing $1,058 and the current PCGS$2,174, a very weak price, in September 2016. Before that one sold Price Guide value is $1,500. Keep in mind that half a step up in in ANA 2016 for $3,290 and an NGC coin sold in another session 66+ will cost about 3x and a 67 will cost about $6,500 if you can of the ANA sale for $3,995. The current PCGS Price Guide lists a find one. For the collector looking to own a very pretty Buffalo, value of $3,400 and considering that a MS65 coin will cost double here is a great coin for you to consider.(and if you could find a PCGS MS66, it would cost high five figures),MS64 seems to be a good grade price wise for most collectors. This PCGS # 3944 | EST: $1,000+ example is above average for the grade and has a nice look that most collectors would enjoy. PCGS # 3943 | EST: $2,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 49

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 80 LOT 81 5C 1920-D PCGS MS65 5C 1920-S PCGS MS65 Rose and gold are seen in areas but the dominant color is a Beautiful iridescent rainbow hues grace both sides of this tough deep, rich blue. A satin mint frost catches the light and brings early Buffalo. The shades of teal, pink, gold, and pale orange are depth to the blue tones. The strike is sharp and all the details really picked up by the light when rotated. Both sides are well matched, which according to our consignor’s notes “is tough for boldly defined. this date, finding an example with an even look on both sides.” The luxuriant luster shines under the lovely colors. The strike is PCGS 69, NGC 30. There are 10 coins graded finer, split evenly even and the devices boldly defined. Only under close inspection between MS65+ and MS66. The last MS65 sold for $3,525 in can we find a few tiny flecks. Not only does this GEM have a nice October 2016, but the patina was a dull nickel gray. This grade eye appeal, it is certainly among the finest graded at PCGS. has routinely sold in the $3,500 to $4,000 range, with CAC PCGS 22, NGC 15. Only TWO are graded numerically finer at approved coins bringing substantial premiums. With 65+s selling PCGS, a single 65+ and a 66. The last PCGS MS65 to sell in for at least $7,000 (and as high as $20,500) and MS66s selling auction was back in a December 2014 auction, a gray toned, for $45,000-$98,000, the presently offered MS65 with the current PCGS Price Guide Value of $5,500 is a great option for anyone spotty coin, sold for $12,338. This coin is much more eye working on a GEM calibre set. We think there will be strong appealing, with nicer color and better overall look. The PCGS Price bidding competition from collectors when this coin comes to the Guide value is $17,000. Going through the photos of prior MS65s auction block. Bid liberally. this coin has the look of many coins in NGC “STAR” holders, with PCGS # 3945 | EST: $3,000+ the added cache of being certified by PCGS. It will take a very long time to find another with such great color! PCGS # 3946 | EST: $10,000+50

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 82 LOT 83 5C 1921 PCGS MS67 5C 1921-S PCGS MS65 Tied for the FINEST certified by PCGS. Exceptionally well struck A rare date in GEM that has not sold in auction since 2014. Thisfrom boldly clashed dies, this coin is cool to look at under a glass, rainbow toned example was struck from a late die state, with both the details from the reverse showing in the fields in front of and sides displaying heavy metal flow which makes for a very satinybehind the Indian’s head. An arc of pastel patina in shades of gold luster. Effulgent pastel pink, teal, blue, gold, and pearly silverand pink accents the right obverse, while the reverse has an even grace both sides. The reverse shows a few minor marks, noted fordusting of similar shades. Every detail is crisp and sharply defined accuracy. For the issue, the strike is bold and pleasing, with just a little weakness on the highest points of the buffalo’s shoulder. giving this superb gem a great look. PCGS 29, NGC 19. The most recent PCGS MS67 sold for $3,525, PCGS 72, NGC 31. Don’t let the pops fool you, it has been over in a June 2016 auction That one was untoned, showed some two years since a PCGS MS65 sold in auction, the last being a CAC-stickered coin that realized $8,813. Non-CAC coins have prominent spots and was not nearly as attractive as the presently sold on the order of $5,500+. The presently offered GEM was soldoffered Angel Dees coin. Before that, the previous four examples to in January 2013 for $8,813 and before that it was in the “Harpethsell fell into the $4,000-$5,000 range. The current PCGS Price Guide Valley Collection” sold in May 2008 for $7,475. The current PCGS value is $5,350. This superb GEM would make a great addition to Price Guide value is $7,700. A beautiful GEM, and there are only a dozen enumerated finer. It is hard to imagine a nicer looking ANY Buffalo nickel set, or some pizzazz to a U.S. type set. example. We could see this coin bringing a very strong price when PCGS # 3947 | EST: $3,500+ it crosses the block, good luck! PCGS # 3948 | EST: $6,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 51

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 84 LOT 85 5C 1923 PCGS MS67 5C 1923-S PCGS MS65+ A wonderfully beaming luster shines on both sides, illuminating A glistening mint luster drips from the surfaces on both sides of this lovely gem. Subtle icy-blue and gold blends into the highly the immaculate surface quality. Boldly struck with full, crisp flowlined obverse. Both sides are well struck and very pleasing. definition throughout. A short, narrow band of pastel iridescent The obverse was struck from a very advanced state of the dies, toning creates a crescent of color along the lower obverse with the letters of LIBERTY beginning to run into the rim. periphery. A glowing iridescence, similar to the obverse arc PCGS 4, NGC 0. There are only three coins graded MS66 finer. blankets the reverse and is amplified by the magnificent Our consignor declared, “I love this coin!” He further elaborated swirling luster. that he “thought it was an MS66.” No MS65+ has ever sold in PCGS 17, NGC 9. NONE are graded finer at either service. auction and there is a very substantial spread in value between The last PCGS MS67 to sell in auction, a frosty, untoned coin MS65 and MS66; the last MS65 brought $3,995 (August 2016) and realized $9,400 in the 2015 ANA auction. The current PCGS the last MS66 brought $32,200 (September 2013). The current PCGS Price Guide value is $18,500 in MS65+. For the advanced Price Guide lists a value of $9,500 in MS67. This beauty collector, this poses a very important opportunity that should not should find serious bidding competition among, not just color collectors, but also those competing for Registry Set be missed. Good luck. domination. PCGS # 3950 | EST: $10,000+ PCGS # 3949 | EST: $7,000+52

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 86 LOT 87 5C 1924 PCGS MS65 CAC 5C 1924-D PCGS MS65+ Charming and warm golden toning adheres to the obverse. As On this Angel Dees gem, the toning is subtle, yet pleasing. you tilt the coin in the light, varying shades come to life: amber, Pastel icy blue, soft rose, and clear gold tones offer someapricot, burnt orange, and champagne dominate, but as your eye contrast to the well struck devices. The strike is bold for thefocuses, hints of olive and and Norway Spruce can be found. The date, and the devices are bold. The fields are silky smooth and same shades are seen on the pristine reverse, but the pattern the luster satiny throughout. Despite a high mintage, these were of patination is not as dramatic. The surfaces are free from any not saved in GEM quality, and this date is notorious for a weak, distracting marks and is very pretty. mushy strike.PCGS 231, NGC 108, CAC 29. While not a rare coin even in GEM PCGS 22, NGC 1. There are 8 coins graded as MS66 finer atgrade, this is a tough date to find so dramatically toned! The last PCGS. The most recent MS65+ to sell was in the 2016 ANA PCGS/CAC coin to sell in auction realized $764 and the current auction for $3,995, and most of the examples have sold for PCGS Price Guide value is $875. If you are on a limited budget, between $4,000 and $5,000. The current PCGS Price Guidebut want to bring home a prize from this important collection, this value is $5,750. Keep in mind the last MS66 to sell realized $16,450 in a September 2015 auction. This is clearly a coin that is your coin! the specialist should look at and seriously consider for their set. PCGS # 3951 | EST: $700+ PCGS # 3952 | EST: $4,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 53

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 88 LOT 89 5C 1924-S PCGS MS65 5C 1925 PCGS MS67+ CAC Crisply defined devices are brought to vivid life by a satinlike The SOLE FINEST 1925 nickel graded at PCGS. Of all the coins in mint frost that shines from below a light dusting of rose, gold, the Angel Dee’s Collection, our consignor made it a point to tell us and icy-blue/green patina. The surface quality is wonderful, that “when David Hall looked at the set, this was his favorite coin!” Looking at this coin, it is not hard to understand why. First off, the devoid of any distractions. satin luster booms loud from across the room! Icy blue, and soft gold and powdery lavender toning accent the impeccably smooth PCGS 39, NGC 19. The most recent PCGS MS65 to sell was surfaces. The central reverse shows some salmon-gold that really approved by CAC, realizing $16,450 in April 2016, and that was makes the underside of the buffalo show full 3-D effect. It is hard to imagine a that there can be many SUPERB gem Buffalos that the first to sell since a pair sold in 2014 for $8,255 each. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $11,500. There are have such a stunning look, all dates combined! four graded finer, 1 in 65+, 2 in 66, and 1 in 66+. There has not been a PCGS MS66 sold since 1998! In 2014, a 65+, approved PCGS 18, NGC 7, CAC 2. There is only this coin graded MS67+ by CAC realized $18,800. This is a rare date, and this is one and it is the FINEST at both services. This beauty has not sold of the finest that may be available to collectors for quite some at auction in the 67+ holder. The only other CAC coin sold for time, making this a prime candidate for an advanced registry set. $7,343 in August 2015. In the not too distant past, regular MS67s were five-figure coins. In today’s market, this 67+ CAC, it is up Prepare to bid liberally! to the bidders to determine the the actual value of this SUPERB GEM! We feel the current PCGS Price Guide value of $7,950 is too PCGS # 3953 | EST: $10,000+ low. For the advanced Buffalo collector, or someone wanting an amazing coin for a type set, bid on this one! PCGS # 3954 | EST: $10,000+54

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 90 LOT 91 5C 1925-D PCGS MS66 5C 1925-S PCGS MS65A satiny GEM with a great overall look. The toning is rich, what we One of the rarest dates in this series to find in gem mint state. First off, this date is often flatly struck, this is not the case with the would call a “rainbow at sunset.” Burnt orange at the upper left Angel Dee’s coin. The satin mint bloom is brilliant and illuminates obverse rim turns to a lighter gold, and blends to an icy-blue at the centers. The reverse shows the same hues, but the depth of the wonderful color, particularly on the reverse, which our the hues is a bit more dramatic, especially the blue centers and consignor grades a full MS66hints of crimson at the left periphery. Well struck throughout, and PCGS 27, NGC 22. Only TWO are graded finer than the presently offering a bold eye appeal overall. offered GEM at PCGS, a single MS65+ and a single MS66. The most recent PCGS MS 65 to cross the auction block realized PCGS 13, NGC 14. NONE are graded finer at PCGS. Despite $25,850 in March 2016. These have routinely sold between a plethora of carbon spots, the most recently auctioned PCGS $15,000 and $20,000 and that is reflected in the current PCGS MS66 sold for $8,813 in an October 2016 auction. Visually, this Price Guide value of $21,000. Keep in mind that neither the GEM is far superior to that coin. The current PCGS Price Guide MS65+ or MS66 has ever sold in auction, and the NGC MS66s value is listed at $14,500. Since there are none graded higher, that have sold have realized between $33,000 and $40,000, the if you are working on a top ranking PCGS Registry set of Buffalo most recent selling in August 2012. If the two finer PCGS coins nickels, MS66 is the best you can ever hope to own, and the should ever come up for sale, PCGS estimates the values atpresent offering provides an important opportunity to purchase a $41,500 and $100,000 respectively. Clearly this wonderful GEM is as high a grade as any advanced student of Buffalo nickels very pretty one. We anticipate strong bidding on this one! could ever hope to add to their sets. Bid liberally if you want it! PCGS # 3955 | EST: $7,500+ PCGS # 3956 | EST: $18,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 55

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 92 LOT 93 5C 1926 PCGS MS67+ 5C 1926-D PCGS MS65+ There is only one world for this coin, SPECTACULAR! This is the A beautiful GEM that is enhanced by a billowing mint frost. The SOLE FINEST GRADED, and everything about this superb gem brilliance of the luster shines through and enriches the subtle yet is PQ! Bold satin luster shines on both sides. Fiery orange-pink beauteous iridescent rainbow hues. For the date, the strike is dominates the obverse and yields to accents of olive and lime sharp, with only the slightest flatness on the bison’s haunches. The green. The reverse is a little more subdued color-wise, but are coin would have likely graded higher were it not for a small dig on very pretty with accents of magenta. The strike is very sharp, the reverse and a tiny tick on the obverse rim. especially the obverse which looks like it was chiseled rather than struck! As to be expected we do not see any distracting PCGS 98, NGC 31. Only 4 of these are graded 65+, and only two of these have sold in auction, a CAC-approved coin in April 2014 marks, even with a strong glass. The overall eye appeal is superb and a delight to behold! realizing $5,288 and the more recent non-CAC coin (NOT this coin) which realized $3,290 in April 2016. The current PCGS Price PCGS 1, NGC 0. In all grades, the 1926 is a common coin, even in MS67, PCGS has graded 41 pieces. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $5,500, and keep in mind that in MS66 these are Guide value is $6,500. This superb coin will fit into any GEM set bringing between $7,000 and $9,500. This lovely gem will appeal of Buffalo nickels and we think that the competition for it will be to a large number of collectors, whether toned coin collectors or as intense as its eye appeal! Buffalo nickel specialists. PCGS # 3957 | EST: $3,500+ PCGS # 3958 | EST: $3,000+56

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 94 LOT 95 5C 1926-S PCGS MS64 5C 1927 PCGS MS67 The rarest Buffalo nickel in the series to find in high grades, and the WOW! This coin has amazing eye appeal and is at the summitKEY in all grades. This date is notorious for the poor and crude strike. of the PCGS Population.. Highly lustrous with a vivacious satinThere are certainly areas of weakness on both sides of this near-GEM, frost that really glows from below a dusting of sheer icy-blue but it does have a slightly better than average strike. Overall the eye and vivacious honey gold that dominate the obverse. The boldly struck devices on both sides add depth and dimension to the appeal is good, the luster is more vibrant than the dull lackluster eye appeal. The reverse is toned in an even honey gold that is examples that generally appear on the market, and this satin sheenbrings out the subtle gold, rose, and olive-tan tone. If the strike was a accented by hints of olive teal. tad bolder, our consignor believes that this coin would have graded PCGS 16, NGC 10. NONE ARE GRADED FINER AT EITHER MS65. The demand for this date is always strong. SERVICE. The most recent example to sell in auction was a year ago in our December 2015 Regency XV Auction, which realized PCGS 178, NGC 114. Because of the rarity in GEM grades, there islikely much duplication in the population data. That said, over the last $7,050; before that, the last one to sell was in April 2009. Dodozen years, PCGS MS64 examples have mostly sold in the $11,500- not let the Population Report fool you, these DO NOT appear at$15,000 range. The most recent example sold for $11,750 in the 2016 auction with any frequency. The current PCGS Price Guide is listed at $7,500. If you demand the finest for your set, you will be ANA auction, which had a pleasing wood-grain tone in shades ofcoppery-red. This coin has a more multi-hued pastel iridescent patina very hard pressed to find a better looking SUPERB 27 nickel. that will certainly attract strong bidding activity. The current PCGS PCGS # 3960 | EST: $5,500+Price Guide value is $16,000. Aside from the overall lovely look of this coin, there are merely 25 coins graded higher at PCGS, none finerthan MS65, and with MS65s bringing between $75,000 and $105,000in recent auctions, MS64 is the highest grade that the vast majority ofcollectors can ever hope to own. We think that the competition for this coin will be fierce when it crosses the block. Good luck! PCGS # 3959 | EST: $10,000+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 57

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 96 LOT 97 5C 1927-D PCGS MS65 CAC 5C 1927-S PCGS MS65+ A glossy GEM with a delightful lemon-gold tone and brilliant The colors really sing on this GEM! The a strong steely satin frost throughout. The strike is pleasing, and not as weakly chrome-like luster shines in the light. The color, which admittedly is perhaps not entirely natural, is quite pretty. Bold rainbows at struck as sometimes seen on this date. There are hints of the obverse rims blend to an icy-lilac/periwinkle in the center. A frosty aqua-olive and rose iridescence on the reverse. Even similar toning on the reverse, but the central icy-tone is deeper using a strong glass we have a hard time to find any issues of and shows hints of deeper violet hues to the periwinkle/lilac tone. The strike is bold for the date and we see no distracting ticks or significance. Truly of GEM quality. defects, even using a strong glass. PCGS 79, NGC 32, CAC 19. Eight of these are 65+ and there are a mere 7 graded finer at PCGS, all MS66. The most recent PCGS 40, NGC 34. This is one of only four MS65+s, and there is CAC coin was NGC graded and sold in June 2016 and realized only a single coin finer. NO MS65+ has ever sold in auction. The $7,050. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $6,250. This coin last MS65 sold for just shy of $10,000 and have sold for as much is very pretty and should realize premium price. Keep in mind that in 66, this is a $20,000+ coin if you could even find one. as $27,600. The SOLE MS66 sold in our July 2013 auction for $86,250. In MS65+ the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed PCGS # 3961 | EST: $4,000+ at $29,500, and with this immaculate GEM’s great eye appeal, we think this coin will bring a strong price. If you are looking for an ultra high grade coin for a top notch registry set take a look, and bid on, this coin. PCGS # 3962 | EST: $20,000+58

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 98 LOT 99 5C 1928 PCGS MS67 5C 1928-D PCGS MS66 CACGlistening mint luster blazes along both sides and really amplifies The eye appeal of this PQ gem is fabulous! The strike is bold,the the stunning toning. This SUPERB gem has an amazing look, the luster swirls and shines throughout the devices of both sides.with the pastel iridescence of a beautiful Easter egg. The surfaces Light rose, lilac, gold, and powdery blue accents adds to the are icy-smooth gleaming fields are sleek like a freshly cut piece superb eye appeal. of glass. Even with a powerful loupe you cannot find even the slightest imperfection on either side of this well struck beauty. PCGS 53, NGC 5, CAC 15. The most recent PCGS/CAC coin to sell realized $2,820 and the current PCGS Price Guide value isPCGS 20, NGC 6. The most recent PCGS MS67 to sell in auction $2,250. The presently offered GEM has a way better look than realized $5,170 in an October 2015 auction, and the current that lackluster example, and we think this one will sell for a strong PCGS Price Guide value is $6,250. This presently offered coin price. Only a single 66+ is finer, so if you are looking for a great has exceptional eye appeal overall. example of this date for a set, or just want a somewhat different date for a type set, get a good look at this one and bid liberally. PCGS # 3963 | EST: $4,500+ PCGS # 3964 | EST: $2,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 59

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 100 LOT 101 5C 1928-S PCGS MS66 CAC 5C 1929 PCGS MS67 CAC This is a date that almost never comes with full definition, but the Radiant satin luster shines on both sides of this amazing high end presently offered SUPERB gem is about as close to a full strike quality superb gem. A light, subtle silvery-blue, and delicate gold. as could be hoped for. A brilliant satin mint frost shines through The strike is razor sharp and the details have a bold chiseled look. a lively pastel toning. The obverse shows shades of icy/powder The overall look is superb and it is doubtful that a better looking blue and rose that accents a pleasing dove/gold. The lower coin can exist. reverse has hints of sunset patina, while the upper portion is an PCGS 10, NGC 1, CAC 3. NONE ARE GRADED FINER. The last icy-steel blue. A beautiful example. one to sell did not have a CAC sticker, and sold for only $8,225, the last PCGS/CAC coin to sell was nearly three years ago, in the PCGS 11, NGC 10, CAC 5. Only a single MS66 is recorded 2013 FUN Auction, for $23,500. The current PCGS Price Guide at PCGS as the finest The most recent PCGS MS66 CAC sold value is listed at $12,500 and this coin is virtually perfect so we for $11,498 back in September 2013, and one sold for nearly have a suspicion that when this great looking coin crosses the $20,000 in August 2013. The current PCGS Price Guide value is block, there will be many hands in the air and bidders online. If listed at $17,500. This PQ coin has eye appeal for days and we could see serious bidding competition when it crosses the block. you will be one of them we wish you good luck. PCGS # 3965 | EST: $10,000+ PCGS # 3966 | EST: $7,500+60

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 102 LOT 103 5C 1929-D PCGS MS66 CAC 5C 1929-S PCGS MS67 Lustrous and well struck this 29-D is HIGH END for the date Rings of gold and subtle emerald iridescent toning at the rims and grade. The toning is very subtle, with hints of apricot and show hints of rose and olive depending on the angle the light hits the surfaces. The central portions of the coin sport a lovely champagne tone. ice-blue/lilac tone that is light and does not block the bold luster from truly popping. As expected for the assigned grade thePCGS 59, NGC 16, CAC 12. The last PCGS/CAC to sell brought surfaces are extremely smooth, free from distracting marks or$2,174 in October 2014. The most recent CAC was an NGC coin spots of any kind. The dies were heavily worn by the time thisthat sold for $5,405 in June 2016. The current PCGS Price Guide coin was struck, so there is a touch of weakness, but nothing detrimental, most of the details on the bison’s shoulder are visible. value is $1,950. This coin is very pleasing and PQ. PCGS 9, NGC 5. There are NONE graded higher at either PCGS # 3967 | EST: $1,800+ service. There has not been an MS67 sold since a PCGS coin sold in February 2014 for $11,750. This coin has a much more eye arresting look, and should sell for more. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $9,500. Like many of the Angel Dee’s coins, this one is tied for finest graded and good luck finding another with this kind of look! PCGS # 3968 | EST: $8,500+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 61

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 104 LOT 105 5C 1930 PCGS MS67+ 5C 1930-S PCGS MS67+ An amazing SUPERB GEM, a MONSTER! The sole FINEST This tie-dyed beauty is the SOLE finest graded at PCGS! Lucious certified example. As our consignor says, “The obverse just pink, green, gold, and lilac iridescent hues really dance with the reels you in!” Iridescent rings of pastel rainbow hues flaunt pink, olive, orange, and gold. The luster is vibrant and just swirls luster when twirled in a light. The color is spectacular and the undisturbed across sleek, smooth fields and devices. This is the overall quality is great. The devices are boldly struck and the FINEST seen by our consignor who has specialized in Buffalo luster GLOWS in the dark! One of the prettiest nickels in the set nickels for many years. That statement means a lot. The strike is to be sure. Our consignor told us he never thought that this date could ever look like this. Another coin that we are unable to come bold and the quality is quite nice. up with enough superlatives to describe it. PCGS 1, NGC 0. THROW AWAY THE PRICE GUIDES ON THIS PCGS 1, NGC 0. Here is another coin that the price guides can ONE! Our consignor paid a huge premium to purchase this coin be thrown away for; PCGS does not even list a value in 67+! In regular MS67 the current PCGS Price Guide value is $12,000. for the set, and with the beauteous colors, it is not surprising. The most recent one of those to sell in auction brought $8,225 We note that there is not a single record for even a regular MS67 in December 2015 and an NGC MS67 sold for $10,350 back to compare this one to. The current PCGS Price Guide value in January 2009. We know that even in this somewhat softer is $5,250 and we know that our consignor paid about 3X that market, Buffalo nickels are always popular, and when given amount to buy this special coin. If you demand only the BEST for the opportunity to bid on the sole FINEST example, bidding your set, you need this moose of a buffalo! participation will be heated. Good luck. PCGS # 3969 | EST: $8,500+ PCGS # 3970 | EST: $12,000+62

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 106 LOT 107 5C 1931-S PCGS MS67 CAC 5C 1934 PCGS MS67+Tied for finest of the date, and one of only two in this superlative A very pretty example of this date, this coin is tied with one other grade to receive a CAC sticker. The toning on this SUPERB for finest graded honors at PCGS. The rich original satin mintnickel is sublime! Blended shades of pink, rose, gold, lavender, bloom sparkles in the light and around the boldly struck devices. While many of the coins in the Angel Dee’s set are dramatically teal, periwinkle, lilac, orange,and baby blue all combine over toned, this one, is a bit more subtle, but no less impressive. The rich satiny surfaces. The strike is about as sharp as can be color is pearlescent in nature, with lovely gold and rose tones. The hoped for, with the details in full chiseled relief. Certainly high look is graceful, pleasing, and the overall quality will delight evenend, and quite memorable; this is a coin that once viewed, will the fussiest of collectors. not soon be forgotten!PCGS 7, NGC 2, CAC 2. Going back to 2008, PCGS MS67s have PCGS 2, NGC 2. The other PCGS MS67+ to sell in auction was sold for very strong prices, the most recent being for $21,738 in CAC approved and realized a hair shy of $10,000 in January 2015.October 2016. A PCGS/CAC coin, not the presently offered coin, sold for $38,188 in the 2013 Central States auction. In 2008, the Even though the current specimen is not CAC, the one that soldfirst recorded auction sale of a MS67 coin in any holder, realized had some fly specks on the obverse in prime focal points, making $63,250! The current PCGS Price Guide value is $28,500 and this one clearly a more eye appealing example. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $9,500. Because of its relatively high we would not be at all surprised if this AMAZING coin sold in mintage of over 20 million coins, the 1934 is often included in Type excess of that amount. If you appreciate coins with great eyeappeal, along with being among the finest graded, you would do sets; if you need one for your set, this uber-gem will attract your attention for sure. a disservice to your collection by not bidding on this coin! PCGS # 3972 | EST: $7,500+ PCGS # 3971 | EST: $20,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 63

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 108 LOT 109 5C 1934-D PCGS MS66+ 5C 1935 PCGS MS67+ CAC Tied for finest certified. Showy and dramatic pink, gold, and icy Beautifully toned, another coin saved in a contemporary album green iridescent tone dominate both sides sparkle in the light and saved in PRISTINE condition. The satin luster is is dramatic amplified by an underlying glossy mint luster. Clearly this coin and enlivens the pretty gold, pink, and sky blue accents. The was set aside soon after leaving the mint and stored in one of the then popular National or Wayte Raymond albums. Aside from strike is bold, all the details are are razor sharp. a couple of tiny ticks on the buffalo, this coin has zero marks or This gem is superb. other distractions. The devices are rather well struck up and the PCGS 154, NGC 41, CAC 30. Only 14 examples are graded as overall look is nice. MS67+ and only ONE is graded finer. The most recent example PCGS 5, NGC 0. The most recent example to sell in auction to sell brought $4,700 in March 2016 and in December 2015 was a CAC approved coin, which realized $16,450 back in one sold for $8,813. The current PCGS Price Guide value is September 2014. The color on this one makes it more appealing. $4,000 and in April 2009 the sole MS68 appeared, selling for $34,500. This SUPERB coin will certainly fit in the FINEST of The current PCGS Price Guide value is $13,000. Buffalo nickel sets! PCGS # 3973 | EST: $10,000+ PCGS # 3974 | EST: $3,500+64

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 110 LOT 111 5C 1935-D PCGS MS67 5C 1935-S PCGS MS67+WOW! Every detail on on both sides look like they were carved Whoa, the colors! Toned in moderately psychedelic colors. Both obverse and reverse are well struck and awash in bright pink, from a sheet of fresh smooth ice! The luster is amazing and it really makes the stand out dramatically. This is one of the green, blue, orange, violet, and gold. The luster is strong andmore eye-popping nickels in the set. Gold, pink, and sky-blue bold. The surfaces are clean and free of any distracting marks. The collector says this coin is awesome! “I think the obverse is shades can all be seen in varying degrees as the coin is MS68!” You certainly will never find another 35-S nickel that looks rotated in a light. like this anywhere else!PCGS 9, NGC 3. NONE are graded finer, and it has been over 2 years since the last one sold in auction, realizing $8,813 in PCGS 1, NGC 0. This is the FINEST graded at either service. The August 2014. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $8,000 color certainly adds to the allure, and some will certainly find it and we would not be surprised if this one brought near thatlevel when it comes up for sale. As we have cataloged this set, irresistible. The current PCGS Price Guide is $6,000. If you are intothere are certain coins that stand out to the cataloger, and this outrageous colors, you need to look at this one. is one of them. PCGS # 3976 | EST: $5,000+ PCGS # 3975 | EST: $6,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 65

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 112 LOT 113 5C 1936 PCGS MS67+ 5C 1936-D PCGS MS67+ CAC Rich golden toning displays accents of light green, rose, pink, This SUPERB coin is BEAUTIFUL! You will not find a more beautiful example of this date anywhere. Lustrous surfaces gold, orange colors. The satin luster is bold and attractive; highlight the wonderful Easter egg colors; both sides are surfaces are free of any marks or lines. The strike is crisp and the awash in light pink, teal, gold, and a very pleasing tangerine. The reverse has a more subtle steely-ice blue with hints of details are fully rendered. pink. All the devices are fully and crisply struck, all the details PCGS 11, NGC 2. The last one sold in April 2014 for $3,814 and are fully defined. the current PCGS Price Guide is $2,650. This one is definitely the PCGS 71, NGC 14, CAC 16. This is the ONLY MS67+ graded, most colorful! and only two MS68s are finer! While the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $2,650, we think this coin will sell for PCGS # 3977 | EST: $2,500+ substantially more; keep in mind the last MS68 to sell was back in April 2009 and sold for $32,200. This superb coin will definitely be a prize in any type or Buffalo nickel set. PCGS # 3978 | EST: $2,500+66

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 114 LOT 115 5C 1936-S PCGS MS67+ CAC 5C 1937 PCGS MS68TIED FOR FINEST GRADED. A gorgeous toned superb GEM. An amazingly high grade survivor, one of the finest in the entire Icy blue dominates while the rose and gold create a lovely series, certainly for the date, and one of only a couple of 68s in the Angel Dees set. Well preserved, the surfaces are pristine and as arc at the left side of the obverse. Light and subtle color nice today as the day it came off the dies. The color is a bit morethroughout graces the reverse. Both sides are boldly lustrous subdued than on other coins in the set, but that does not make them any less impressive. Lovely pastel patination accents the and sharply struck. boldly struck and expertly executed strike. PCGS 3, NGC 0. None are graded finer. The last one to sellbrought $2,820 in January 2016 and the current PCGS Price PCGS 10, NGC 9. Only one PCGS MS68 has ever sold in auction, Guide value is listed at $2,850. This one looks like the NGC realizing $8,225 in the recent 2016 ANA auction. The currentMS67+* CAC that sold for $4,230. It is beautiful and certainly PCGS Price Guide value is $19,500. This coin is bound for a fine worth a premium bid! type set or a superb set of Buffalo nickels. PCGS # 3979 | EST: $3,000+ PCGS # 3980 | EST: $7,500+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 67

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 116 LOT 117 5C 1937-D PCGS MS67+ 5C 1937-D 3-LEGS. PCGS MS64 CAC A beautiful SUPERB gem with brilliant luster and a soft Lovely gold tone dominates both sides. The typical subdued champagne iridescent tone on the obverse. When the coin is satin luster is noted. The 3-Legged Buffalo nickel is one of the rotated in a light, a pale sky blue and pink. The reverse color is most famous of all U.S. coins. The variety was created when more impressive and eye arresting with a blazing arc of gold at an employee of the mint over zealously filed the die down to remove clash marks. These marks are still visible throughout the lower rim. The eye appeal is great. and add a texture to the surfaces, typical of the variety. PCGS 5, NGC 0. Only three are graded finer at PCGS, all MS68. Everyone, even non-collectors have heard about the “rare The last MS67+ sold nearly three years ago, in January 2014, 3-legged Buffalo nickel.” and realized $3,819.The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $3,250. Keep in mind, if you can find one of the MS68s it will PCGS 191, NGC 232, CAC 41. While the last two PCGS/ CAC examples sold for weak prices, $6,463 and $5,640 certainly cost you about 10x the value of a 67+. We think that this (both in April 2016), a non-CAC sold for $9,400 sold in the coin represents a great value, compared with a 68. same auction. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $8,000. These were selling for $7,500+ over the past few PCGS # 3981 | EST: $3,000+ years. We think that this one is particularly nice and should sell for a strong price. PCGS # 3982 | EST: $7,500+68

THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 118 LOT 119 5C 1937-S PCGS MS67 CAC 5C 1938-D PCGS MS68Very pretty gold tone drapes across boldly struck and lustrous WOW! Its like looking into a kaleidoscope. The vibrant colorssurfaces. Hints of rose, lavender, and pastel green iridescence mystify the eye. Both sides are superb in quality, free of any distractions. Magenta, pink, gold, orange and hints of green frame on the reverse really adds to the appeal. both sides, although a touch more vibrant on the obverse. This is clearly one of the more beautifully and colorfully toned GEMS in PCGS 126, NGC 84, CAC 15. Only 2 PCGS/CAC coins have sold in auction, the most recent was in the 2016 ANA auction, the Angel Dees Collection. realizing $1,294. The current PCGS Price Guide is listed at PCGS 20, NGC 21. Clearly none are graded finer. The current $1,200. Keep in mind there are 2 MS67+s and a single MS68 PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $16,500, and the most recent graded at PCGS; only one 67+ has sold, realizing $8,813 in example brought $11,750 in June 2016. This highly attractive 2013. This beauty should sell for a very strong premium. superb gem should bring a substantial premium when the advanced collectors go after it. PCGS # 3983 | EST: $1,200+ PCGS # 3984 | EST: $10,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 69

THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 120 LOT 121 5C 1938-D/D PCGS MS67+ 5C 1938-D/S PCGS MS67+ CAC Pretty peach, champagne, apricot, and pale tangerine all What a fantastic coin to cap off the Angel Dees Collection! combine on both sides, creating a fantastic look. The D/D is This repunched mint mark has all the stunning eye appeal you evident with magnification and the strike is bold throughout. The should expect at this exemplary grade and accolades from luster is superb and really backlights the fantastic color. A real CAC. Beautifully toned and well struck throughout, this superb delight for the advanced collector. coin should entice even the pickiest of collectors. PCGS 14, NGC 5. Only one of these PCGS MS67+s has ever PCGS 232, NGC 127, CAC 28. Of the PCGS and NGC coins sold in auction, a CAC coin that brought $2,585 in April 2014. there are 18 and 7 in MS67+ included in those numbers, and The color on this one is clearly more attractive. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $1,500 and clearly this one should sell for PCGS has never graded a single example finer. NGC has certified 6 examples as MS68. The current PCGS Price Guide more. There are none graded finer! is listed at $7,000 and the most recent coin to sell in auction realized $5,875 in a June 2014 auction. This GEM will serve PCGS # 3984 | EST: $1,200+ as a wonderful capstone to any great Buffalo nickel set! PCGS # 3985 | EST: $4,000+70

LOT 122 OUR ESTIMATES The estimates you see published in this catalog 5C 1913 TYPE 2. PCGS MS67 are just that: estimates. Keep in mind that a coinGlossy mint bloom accentuates the boldly struck devices on this could be either low or high end for the grade, superb GEM. Pleasing iridescent lemon and powder blue can have stunning color or be dull, all of whichbe seen when rotated in a light. We see only the tiniest of hidden radically affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be huge price differences within a grade, and we ticks under close inspection with a strong glass. offer estimates as a guide so collectors can have PCGS 23, NGC 12. There are only 5 coins graded finer, all a better idea of value. One thing we will neverMS67+. The last MS67 sold over a year ago, realizing $5,875 in do is offer low ball estimates in order to claim a September 2015 auction and the current CU price is listed at stronger sales. $5,950. A lovely example of this first year of issue. These published estimates represent what Legend Rare Coin Auctions determines to be an PCGS # 3921 | EST: $5,000+ approximate high wholesale value for the coin. The numbers are based upon current market values, similar trades, auction prices, published prices, and a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is no guarantee that the estimated prices are minimums or are exactly what you can expect to get if you attempt to resell them wholesale. We always advise you to view the coins you are interested in and calculate what you’ll pay using as much information as possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask us. We are here to help you!LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 71

LOT 123 5C 1914/3 PCGS MS65 CAC One of the more controversial issues of the 20th century, there has been much debate and research that has been done on this “overdate” issue. Since its discovery it has been collected as part of the Buffalo nickel series as an overdate similar to the 18/7-D, the current thought is that a 1913 master die was repunched by a 1914 dated hub, which then went on to create several working dies, each with vestiges of the 3 visible to some degree under the 4. PCGS now encapsulates these as 4/(3), and will only do so with certain dies. With a glass you can see parts of the top of a three under the 4, however the doubling of the date that PCGS CoinFacts uses to show the traits of one of the dies is absent. The current GEM is FS-101, one of the dies that PCGS recognizes. The coin itself is a lustrous gem, possessing great eye appeal partially imparted by the soft pink-gold and periwinkle iridescent hues. Well struck and free of any distracting marks, this buffalo will certainly be welcome in any herd. PCGS 2, NGC 3, CAC 2. The last one to sell realized $32,200 in a February 2013 auction. This coin is ex Joseph C. Thomas and realized $18,400 back in April 2009 and at the time was not CAC. PCGS CoinFacts still lists a $27,000 value. We are not going to weigh in on the ongoing debate as to whether this variety should be included in advanced Buffalo nickel sets, other than say that it has traditionally been collected as part of the series. If you would like to own a GEM example, here is your chance. PCGS # 93924 | EST: $20,000+72

LOT 124 5C 1915 PCGS MS67 What a beautifully toned Buffalo nickel! The periwinkle and apricottoning is brought to life when the vibrant mint frost is picked up by a light. The strike is bold and both sides are crisply defined. PCGS 48, NGC 10. Only 5 are graded finer, all MS67+. The lastMS67 to sell realized $2,585 in March 2016, and have generally sold in the $2,500-$3,000 range. The current CU value is $3,250. If you missed out on the SUPERB MS67+ in the Angel Dee’s Collection,here is a very rare opportunity to bid on another superb toned GEM. PCGS # 3927 | EST: $2,000+ BOB SIMPSON DAVID HALL GERALD FORSYTHE PHIL FLANNIGAN HAVE ALL CONSIGNED TO LRCA, WHY HAVEN’T YOU? CONTACT JULIE ABRAMS OR GREG COHEN TO DISCUSS YOUR COINS!LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 73

LOT 125 5C 1916 DOUBLED DIE OBVERSE. PCGS MS64 CAC74

LOT 125 5C 1916 DOUBLED DIE OBVERSE. PCGS MS64 CAC In an auction full of memorable Buffalo Nickels, this coin is certainly one of the most memorable and a highlight of the entire sale. We are pleased to present this EXCEPTIONALLY RARE coin. This is one of the major rarities in the series, in consistent demand from collectors in all grades, from low-grade damagedexamples to the AMAZING near-GEM we are proud to offer here. Legend Auctions has had the distinct privilege to sell the Forsythe Collection duplicate in our July 2013 Regency Auction IV for a strong $253,000. There are perhaps around 200 examples known in all grades, most in the VF range; very few are in mint state.The presently offered coin is one of only 3 graded MS64 at PCGS, tied for FINESTgraded. The clean, smooth surfaces have a moderate satin frost that really showsoff the delicate lavender, olive, tan, gold, and powder blue patina. The details are boldly struck and the doubling is exceptionally bold; you do not need a glass to see the doubled features. Overall, this example displays fantastic eye appeal. Even using a strong glass there are no flaws worthy of mention, and in the old days, this coin would have likely been cataloged as a GEM. PCGS 3, NGC 6, CAC 2. NONE are finer! The most recent MS64 sold is theabove mentioned Forsythe coin that sold for $253,000 in July 2013; that was the first example to sell since April 2009. The record price for this date is $276,000 for an NGC coin in April 2008. PCGS lists a value of $250,000 and this coin willcertainly sell for a strong price, perhaps even breaking a record in the process. This sale, has attracted the attention of all the Buffalo nickel specialists with the consignment of the Angel Dee’s set, and we think they will stay to bid on this delicacy. The addition of this near-Gem to any set will automatically catapultyou to near-Legendary status. Good luck and congratulations in advance to the winning bidder! PCGS #3931 | EST: $230,000+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 75

LOT 126 5C 1917-S PCGS MS65 CAC Beautiful rose, lilac, and champagne toning cloaks both sides this this satiny and well struck GEM. This coin has a great look and will please any Buffalo nickel specialist. PCGS 85, NGC 64, CAC 9. The last PCGS/CAC MS65 to sell did not LOT 127 have anywhere close to the eye appeal of the presently offered GEM; it realized $3,400 in April 2016. Before that, the last PCGS/CAC coin 5C 1918 PCGS MS67 CAC to sell was back in August 2013, which realized $5,434. The current A masterpiece! This is what all other 1918 Buffaloes should PCGS Price Guide value is $4,500 and this lovely toned coin should look like. We believe this coin easily ranks as one of the FINEST realize a premium bid from the discerning collector. KNOWN. We actually did resubmit it for a 67+. PCGS can be so tough! PCGS # 3936 | EST: $3,000+ Highly impressive surfaces are absolutely FLAWLESS. Use a microscope-you will find NO problems of ANY size, ANY where. A strong unbroken luster shows off gorgeous totally ORIGINAL colors of rose/gold that frame the peripheries and open into lilac/pale blue like centers. Every detail is sharply struck and stands out. The eye appeal is totally spectacular! PCGS 9, NGC 3, CAC 1. The last auction record for a 5C 1918 PCGS MS67 (NO CAC) was for $23,000 back in February 2010. That’s a very powerful statement as to how infrequently these appear! Does not matter whether you are a Type or High END Buffalo collection, this coin will be a super star in your collection. We do expect strong bidding here-so good luck! PCGS # 3937 | EST: $18,000+76

LOT 128 5C 1918-D PCGS MS66 LOT 129 In such high grade this date is certainly a condition rarity. Billowy nickel-silver satin-like luster brings depth and life to the 5C 1918-S PCGS MS64+ well struck devices. Both obverse and reverse show chiseled, Another beautiful key date Buffalo nickel. Pleasing pastel razor sharp details and a dusting of clear, icy-blue pastel iridescent toning dusts both sides of this nearly GEM caliber iridescent tone. Scrutinizing the surfaces with a strong loupe, we coin. Pale lavender blends with gold, rose, and peach huesfind only some tiny marks from bag storage and we see no carbon over satiny surfaces. The strike is about as bold as can be flecks anywhere. hoped for on an 18-S. PCGS 24, NGC 5. This is a date/grade combo that in PCGS PCGS 8, NGC 8 (for 64+). There are 39 listed as finer. The last holders has appeared in auction since 2008 only 11 times. The MS64+ to sell in auction was in the 2016 ANA auction with sold most recent one to sell realized $5,640 in the 2016 ANA auction. for $5,875. The current CU price is $6,750. Keep in mind that the last PCGS MS65 sold for over $20,000. If you are looking to The current PCGS value is $8,250, which may be a little high add a great looking, nearly GEM example of this date to your in light of the more recent APRs and the current market. It is a set, but do not want to spend 5-figures, this coin may well bewonderful looking GEM destined for a fine collection, and keep in for you. mind there are only 3 coins finer, 2 in 66+ and one in 67. PCGS # 3938 | EST: $4,500+ PCGS # 3940 | EST: $4,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 77

LOT 130 LOT 131 5C 1918-S PCGS MS65 5C 1919-S PCGS MS65 A splendid GEM 18-S nickel. Struck from clashed dies, the A beautiful GEM example housed in an OGH. Brilliant luster Indian appears to have whiskers coming off his chin. A pretty shows hints of reflectivity in the fields. A boldly struck GEM with autumnal gold show hints of rosey-pink. The devices are well beautifully original golden-rose-pale green tone. All the details defined and overall very attractive. This is one of the classic in the Indian’s hair and buffalo are accented by the color and condition rarities of the Buffalo nickel series. While scarce in all semi-reflective luster. Despite not being CAC, this coin is all MS grades, above MS64, this is a very RARE date and always in there and then some! A rarely seen date in this high grade. demand from serious collectors. PCGS 32, NGC 17. There are only 5 graded higher at PCGS. The most recent PCGS MS65 sold for $6,463 in June 2016, and PCGS 35, NGC 17. Only five coins are graded numerically finer keep in mind that a 65+ sold for $28,200 and the most recent at PCGS, 4 in 65+ and one in 66. The most recent PCGS graded MS66 sold for $89,300. The current PCGS value is $9,750. This lovely coin will certainly sell for a strong price when it crosses coin was CAC-approved and realized $21,150. Without CAC approval, generally PCGS graded examples sell in the $10,000- the block. $12,000 range. We think that this coin, with its wonderful, PCGS # 3943 | EST: $5,500+ original toning and bold visual allure should sell closer to the PCGS Price Guide value of $16,000. This sale will long be remembered for the amazing selection of Buffalo nickels, each an important opportunity for the specialist; but this GEM creates a very important opportunity for anyone building a gem set. The sole MS66 has not appeared at auction and PCGS estimates a value of $100,000 should one come to market. PCGS # 3940 | EST: $13,000+78

LOT 132 LOT 133 5C 1920-D PCGS MS65 CAC 5C 1920-S PCGS MS65 CACLustrous and well struck. The surfaces show only the lightest A major condition rarity, where the few gems do not appear at minute ticks, essentially looking the way the coin did shortly auction with any frequency. Wonderfully satin luster on PQ gemafter leaving the mint. Hints of gold here and there add to the quality surfaces show a hint of rose-gold iridescent hues. We note the typical softness in strike on the highest points of the stunning allure. design, but most details are visible. PCGS 69, NGC 30, CAC 13. There has not been a CAC-approved MS65 of this date since July 2014, when a PCGS 22, NGC 15, CAC 3. There are exactly TWO examples PCGS coin sold for $5,288. The current CU price is $5,500. graded finer, a 65+ and a 66. The most recent PCGS coinSince there are only a handful of coins graded finer, including sold two years ago, a non-CAC coin that sold for $12,338 5 65+ and 5 66s This GEM is at a perfect grade for most in December 2014. The last PCGS/CAC coin to sell was incollectors who do not want to spend mid-five figures for a 66. September 2013 which sold for nearly $26,000. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $17,000 and we think this gem You will NOT be disappointed with this coin’s quality. should sell for more. This is another MAJOR opportunity for PCGS # 3945 | EST: $3,500+ the advanced Buffalo nickel collector that should not be taken lightly. Good luck! PCGS # 3946 | EST: $15,000+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 79

LOT 134 LOT 135 5C 1923-S PCGS MS65+ CAC 5C 1926-D PCGS MS66 CAC OGH Tied for SECOND finest certified by PCGS. This coin will Legend Numismatics is the proud owner of this superb Buffalo certainly be a highlight in any advanced set of Buffalo nickels. A smooth satin glow on both sides is just the beginning of how nickel and is pleased to offer this great GEM. When we saw to describe this GEM. The strike which is often soft, is bold, with this coin, we feel head over heels in love! We grade the coin a nearly all details fully rendered. The surface quality truly stands up to close inspection with a strong glass, revealing no marks MS66+ easily (that does not mean PCGS ever will). or flecks of any consequence. Outstanding surfaces are not just clean, they are perfect. We used a strong glass and covered every inch of the surfaces and PCGS 57, NGC 37, CAC 10. There are only FOUR MS65+s and found ZERO imperfections. A full booming luster enlivens the fiery three MS66. No MS65+ has ever sold in auction. There were original gold/nickel colors. There are NO spots or discolorations. three coins in PCGS MS65 (2 CAC) that sold in 2013 in the $16,500-$26,500 range (these may be +s today), and the last Every detail is sharply struck. The eye appeal is stunning! PCGS MS66 sold for $32,200 in September 2013. In 65+ the PCGS Price Guide lists a value of $18,500, and we think this PCGS 25, NGC 9, CAC 12. The last one to sell in auction brought $7,638 in a July 2016. The coin we are offering has GEM should sell for that or more. If you are putting together a top more luster and spark. It is important to note; this coin has been notch set of Buffalos and do not want to wait for one of the 66s to off the market in a major collection for many years. This coin appear, you should really consider this beauty. Good luck, as this belongs in a top Buffalo set! opportunity will not repeat itself again anytime soon! PCGS # 3958 | EST: $7,000+ PCGS # 3950 | EST: $19,000+80

LOT 136 OUR ESTIMATES The estimates you see published in this catalog 5C 1926-S NGC AU58 are just that: estimates. Keep in mind that a coin One of the KEY dates to the Buffalo series and ALWAYS in could be either low or high end for the grade, demand from collectors. Scarce in all grades, especially in VF or higher, in Mint State, the 26-S is one of the rarest of dates. have stunning color or be dull, all of which The 26-S is often weakly struck with even high grade pieces radically affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be exhibiting mushy details. For the date this coin has a good huge price differences within a grade, and westrike. Hints of semi-satin luster peer from below a layer of gold- offer estimates as a guide so collectors can havetan-steely nickel toning. Although under close magnification we a better idea of value. One thing we will never see some minor lines, overall this is a very pretty AU58. do is offer low ball estimates in order to claim PCGS 53, NGC 47. Nearly 2 years have passed since the last stronger sales. NGC AU58 sold in auction, a CAC-beaned coin that realized These published estimates represent what $3,290 in the 2015 FUN auction. The most recent 26-S in 58 to Legend Rare Coin Auctions determines to be an sell was a PCGS/CAC coin that realized $4,230 in the recent approximate high wholesale value for the coin.2016 ANA auction. The 26-S for many is a stopper; if you are on The numbers are based upon current market values, similar trades, auction prices, published a budget, this coin may finally fill that hole in your set! prices, and a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is no guarantee that the estimated prices PCGS # 3559 | EST: $3,000+ are minimums or are exactly what you can expect to get if you attempt to resell them wholesale. We always advise you to view the coins you are interested in and calculate what you’ll pay using as much information as possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask us. We are here to help you!LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 81

LOT 137 5C 1926-S PCGS MS65 In an auction that will long be referred to for the extensive offering of Buffalo nickels, this is arguably the most important one in the sale! The 1926-S is the undoubted rarity in the series in GEM, bested only by the 18/7-D. The presently offered coin is tied with as many as 14 examples for finest known honors at PCGS. The luster is better than usually encountered for the date, a rich satin frost accentuates a much better than average strike. We would certainly rate this coin high end for the assigned grade, even without endorsement from CAC. The luster glows under a light dusting of gold accents a rich dove/nickel surfaces. Using a strong glass we can see a tiny speck in the right obverse field but nothing else that could possibly distract the eye. This is a very impressive example one that even the pickiest of Buffalo nickel specialists could find attractive. PCGS 15, NGC 11. There are NONE graded finer at PCGS, and it is possible that there is duplication in the data looking for a higher grade. The most recent example sold in August 2014 for $84,500. That coin was CAC-approved. Before that, one sold for $94,000 and another for $105,750. While not CAC approved like the others, cited, this GEM is very pleasing and certainly worthy of strong bidding activity. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $94,000. It may be a while before another example comes up for sale, so if you need one for a GEM set, be sure to bid liberally for this one! PCGS # 3959 | EST: $75,000+82

LOT 138 LOT 139 5C 1927 PCGS MS67 CAC 5C 1927-D PCGS MS65 CACTIED for FINEST GRADED! Clearly this coin has been kept safe Magnificent eye appeal. A rich lustrous surface shows a pleasing salmon-orange-rose-gold patination across both from any possible damage since the moment it came off the sides. For the date, this GEM is well struck and among the mostdies and boasts a wonderful eye appeal. The luster booms from eye appealing examples to cross this cataloger’s desk. The all over accentuating the well struck devices. Except for some surfaces are smooth and free of any distractions. minor flatness on the Indian’s hair, every detail is bold and chiseled! A clear, icy-powder blue and soft lilac and gold tone PCGS 79, NGC 32, CAC 19. Of those graded at PCGS, 8 of them are 65+, and there are only 7 coins at the pinnacle of the adds to this coin’s SUPERB eye appeal. population report, all MS66. The current CU value is $6,250. PCGS 16, NGC 10, CAC 4. The most recent PCGS coin to sell This colorful GEM, housed in an OGH, is of exceptional quality,was NOT CAC-approved and sold for $7,050 and the Collectors and more vibrant than the other PCGS/CAC MS65s that have Universe Price is $7,500. No CAC coin has EVER sold in sold, the most recent for $5,288 in December 2015. In June auction, so we think that the APR in December 2015 will be 2016, an NGC MS65 CAC sold for $7,050. Keep in mind thatexceeded when this one crosses the block. If you are building a the last MS66 sold in 2014 and realized $23,500. Throughout top set of Buffalo nickels bid liberally for this moose! this sale, Buffalo nickel collectors have many awesome opportunities to add great coins to their sets, and this is an PCGS # 3960 | EST: $6,500+ underrated date in the series in GEM. We think this one will make people take note. PCGS # 3961 | EST: $4,500+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 83

LOT 140 5C 1928-D PCGS MS66 CAC Satiny mint bloom provides a bold backdrop for some delicate light gold color that adds to the superb eye appeal. The strike is bold throughout with only the lightest of weakness on some highpoints on the reverse. PCGS 53, NGC 5, CAC 15. The PCGS Pop includes the sole LOT 142 finest MS66+. The most recent PCGS MS66 CAC sold for $2,820 in a June 2016 auction and the CU price is $2,200. A real prize for the dedicated collector of Buffalo nickels, and an important opportunity. PCGS # 3964 | EST: $2,000+ 5C 1936 PCGS MS67+ CAC A moose of a Buffalo! Ultra lustrous steely surfaces boast a dusting of subtle icy-blue and clear gold toning, which is particularly vibrant on the reverse. Both sides are expertly struck and this coin has clearly been carefully preserved since the time it left the mint and stand up to close inspection. Among the ABSOLUTE finest graded at PCGS. LOT 141 PCGS 127, NGC 111, CAC 23. Only 11 PCGS coins are graded MS67+ and NONE are graded finer. The last PCGS example 5C 1934-D PCGS MS66 CAC in 67+ sold for $3,819 in April 2014, and it was not CAC. The Lovely, original album toning graces both sides of this satiny GEM. Well struck devices are highlighted by the beautiful luster current PCGS value is $2,650 and we think this coin will exceed that level. Be prepared if you are building the finest Buffalo and tones of peach and pale, powder blue. nickel set to bid aggressively on this uber-GEM. PCGS # 3977 | EST: $2,200+ PCGS 86, NGC 28, CAC 23. The pop includes 5 PCGS 66+ coins which are the finest graded by that service for the date. While the current CU price is $3,750, the last one to sell realized $2,585 in September 2016, and the presently offered GEM has a better overall look. We love the look of this coin, it should sell for a premium. PCGS # 3973 | EST: $2,100+84

LOT 143 5C 1938-D BUFFALO. PCGS MS68 Exceptional everything. The luster is bold, with an attractive satin-like gloss. The surfaces are glassysmooth which display a beautiful icy-blue and gold colorthroughout. The devices are boldly struck up and overallthis lustrous GEM is a delight to behold. The final issue ofthe ever popular Buffalo nickel, these were saved in huge quantities and are common even in MS67, but in the ultimate grade of MS68, these are very rare. PCGS 20, NGC 21. There are NONE finer at either service. The most recent coin to sell in auction realized$11,750 in a June 2016 auction and in that same month, an NGC 68 sold for $13,513. The current PCGS value is$16,500. If you are building a top notch set of Buffalos, orjust need an example for type, this is an exceptional coin. PCGS # 3984 | EST: $11,000+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 85

LOT 144 5C 1913 TYPE 2 PCGS PR68 CAC Monumental quality for this early Proof Buffalo and toned with a perfect combination of nickel blue to the centers and framed in varying shades of gold, yellow and crimson on both sides! A more appealing example could not possibly exist, and this splendid coin was chosen to represent this date on the CoinFacts website. The strike is bold throughout, as expected for a Proof, and this is the second style issued in 1913, with the straight and level ground. Only 1,514 pieces were struck and this stellar example is tied with the absolute finest known today. The original design was altered slightly after Mint officials realized the Type 1 with raised ground allowed the letters FIVE CENTS to wear down quickly, and vending machine owners believed the original design may be deemed a counterfeit by their machines. Thus as has been the case of several newly designed coins, changes quickly came about to appease various groups. The Buffalo Nickel design was created by James Earle Fraser, an artist from outside the Philadelphia Mint. Fraser took images of three aging chiefs and developed a composite portrait. The chiefs used were Iron Tail (Custer’s opponent at Little Bighorn), Two Moons, and John Big Tree. The desired result was a Native American that could not be attributed to any one tribe. For the reverse Fraser used an American bison named Black Diamond, then living at the Central Park Zoo in New York City. PCGS 7, NGC 6, CAC 7. A non-CAC PCGS piece sold for $46,000.00 04/2009. The CoinFacts price guide is $55,000. This majestic coin has few peers and should bring that or more! It truly deserves a place in the finest Type or Proof Buffalo collection! PCGS # 3990 | EST: $40,000+86

LOT 146 5C 1915 PCGS PR67 CAC Superb in every way! A soft pastel patina accents superb matte surfaces. The strike is bold and the eye appeal is great! PCGS 72, NGC 36, CAC 30. The last one to sell realized $4,818 in a June 2015 auction. The current PCGS value is $4,950 and keep in mind that one of the 67+s would cost nearly $10,000. PCGS # 3992 | EST: $4,500+LOT 145 5C 1914 PCGS PR67+ CAC LOT 147 WOW, what a spectacular SUPERIOR quality gem this Matte PR 1914 is! Exceptionally clean surfaces show a light gold 5C 1916 PCGS PR66 CAC and iridescent olive-rose tone that accentuates the sandblast Lovely and original. A rich orange-olive-apricot toning covers surface and crisply and deeply struck devices. This is clearly ranked among the finest graded gems in existence and only a the delicate matte surfaces of this final matte proof Buffalo nickel. Both sides are well struck and nicely preserved. few are graded finer. Only 600 proofs were struck. PCGS 95, NGC 53, CAC 23. These PCGS 91, NGC 70, CAC 44. Keep in mind only 7 PCGS coins have routinely sold in the $3,500-$4,000 range at auction, and it and 1 NGC coin are graded PR67+; and at PCGS only 11 are would not surprise us if this lovely gem sold at the higher end of graded finer (all PR68). The only PR67+ to ever sell in auction that range. The current PCGS value is $5,250. Keep in mind you realized $9,400 in July 2014. A PCGS PR68 sold for $12,925 will pay double for a 67, making PR66 a great grade for anyone in the recent ANA auction, the first example sold in more than five years! In PR67+ the current CU price is $9,400. If you are on a more limited budget.building a set of PR Buffalos (a very cool collection of only eightcoins that with effort can be found with AMAZING eye appeal), PCGS # 3993 | EST: $3,000+ make this your 1914. PCGS # 3991 | EST: $7,500+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 87

LOT 148 5C 1939 DOUBLED MONTICELLO. PCGS MS66 FS CAC A rarity in the Jefferson nickel series, especially so well preserved. The Doubled Monticello is a misnomer, it is a true DDR, with FIVE CENTS also boldly doubled. THe surfaces are fresh and lustrous nickel-silver-gray with absolutely no toning. All the devices are fully struck and exceptionally bold. PCGS 8, NGC 1, CAC 1. This is the ONLY CAC-approved Doubled Monticello with Full Steps. That speaks VOLUMES about how hard this coin is to find with the full strike. The most recent one sold in auction in February 2010, selling for $5,175. The CU value is $6,650. There is a pair of MS66+ FS and a single MS67 FS (which sold in February 2016 for $20,563). There are a number of people putting together major sets, this Doubled Monticello will elevate any FS set it gets added to! PCGS # 84004 | EST: $4,500+ LOT 150 LOT 149 5C 1939 REV. OF 1938. PCGS PR68 CAC Virtual perfection! This early Jefferson nickel proof displays BOLD and deep mirrors and a halo of golden-rainbow iridescence on the lower obverse rim. The rest of the surfaces show a steely-icy blue. This coin is beautiful, fully struck and lovingly preserved. 5C 1946-D PCGS MS67+ FS PCGS 11, NGC 10, CAC 5. This coin is likely duplicated in Beautiful with rich golden and rainbow iridescence that grace the pops as we recently crossed it from NGC/CAC to PCGS/ both sides of this exceptionally well struck and vibrantly lustrous CAC, It is currently the PCGS CoinFacts plate coin. There is a SUPERB GEM. Only on close inspection with a strong glass can very wide range of prices realized for PR68, the most recent CAC-approved example realized $4,320 in July 2016. An NGC/ a few light ticks be detected. CAC coin realized $5875 in December 2013, and it had a PCGS 4, NGC 1 (in 67+). Three examples have sold this year, similar look, except it had some noticeable spots, This coin is ranging in price from $2,115 to $5,875. This coin has a great fresh to the market and should realize a strong price because of look, and should bring an exceptional price when the advanced collector of FS Jefferson nickels sees it. It will certainly be a its stunning eye appeal. Bid liberally! welcome addition to a top ranking registry set. PCGS # 4176 | EST: $4,000+ PCGS # 84029 | EST: $2,000+88

LOT 151 89 H10C 1838-O NO STARS NGC MS64 A sultry New Orleans half dime. A very scarce coin in Mint State, the 1838-O half dime is the first of its kind struck at the southernmost branch mint. Interestingly the half dimes struck in Philadelphiawere of the With Stars type, not the more open design as here. This example shows rich pastel iridescent toning and boldly struck for the date. As the New Orleans mint was just getting its coining operations going, the first coins coming from that facility for circulation weresomewhat crude, which certainly adds to the charm and appeal of the near gem being offered here. PCGS 4, NGC 4. Only 1 coin graded MS65 at NGC is considered finer at that service, while the finest gradedfor the date is a PCGS MS66+. This coin sold for just shyof $10,000 in our May 2016 Regency Auction, and before this near-gem sold, it had been over two years since the last NGC-certified example sold (February 2014, realizing $11,750). More recently the superbly toned PCGS/CAC Reed Hawn/Gene Gardner coin sold for$17,625. Given this coin’s lovely eye appeal it should see spirited bidding. PCGS # 4314 | EST: $9,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM

LOT 152 H10C 1853 NO ARROWS. PCGS MS68 Exceptionally sharp and satiny. An AMAZING superb grade GEM. The highest graded example at either service, and the surfaces are satiny and smooth. The fields are free from all but the most nominal and trivial clash marks which are mint made. The satiny luster swirls along both sides, showing off a radiant pearlescent hue. This coin is exceptional in every way. The low mintage of 160,000 saw many melted as the composition changed later in the year. PCGS 1, NGC 0. This coin last sold over two years ago, selling for $12,925 in October 2014. The only other SUPERB gem quality coin to sell was an NGC MS67 that sold way back in September 1998! The Collector’s Universe value is $14,500. If you are building a great type set you really need to see this UBER-superb gem! PCGS # 4351 | EST: $13,500+90

LOT 153 BOB SIMPSON DAVID HALL H10C 1870 PCGS PR66 Superior everything! Deeply reflective mirrored fields are GERALD FORSYTHE attractive and watery. When the light hits the mirrors, the PHIL FLANNIGAN amazing toning, displaying shades of teal, cobalt, rose, goldand autumnal orange-red on both sides. The strike is bold and HAVE ALL CONSIGNED TO LRCA, sharp throughout. There may be a tiny line or two but that is it. WHY HAVEN’T YOU?We are surprised that this coin did not CAC, as there is nothing CONTACT JULIE ABRAMS OR GREG we can find that would prevent it from getting a bean. COHEN TO DISCUSS YOUR COINS!Only 1,000 were struck. PCGS 15, NGC 23. The last one sold atthe lowest point in the current market cycle, realizing a very soft$1,058, the CU value is $1,600 and we think this one, because of its eye appeal should bring a price more inline with the nextgrade up, the last PR67 sold for $2,350 in July 2015. If you are building a set of PR Seated half dimes, or just need a lovely GEM for a type set, step up and take a look at this one. PCGS # 4453 | EST: $2,000+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 91

LOT 154 10C 1797 JR-1. 16 STARS. PCGS AU58 CAC One of the coolest die breaks in early numismatics, this is about the middle die state where the multiple die cracks merge around the date, but have not yet become a cud. There are some minor friction lines in the fields which account for the assigned grade, there is barely any wear on the highpoints. Subtle toning, particularly an orange-gold frame on the reverse rim. The strike is better than usually seen with only slight weakness seen is on the eagle’s breast. Even using a glass we can’t find anything except for the slightest little mark on the reverse. PCGS 3, NGC 0, CAC 1. No PCGS AU58s have ever sold in auction. The only AU58 to sell was an NGC coin that sold nearly a decade ago for $16,100. The two closest graded PCGS coins to sell were an AU55 in June 2005 for $12,650 and a MS61 that sold for $28,200 in the 2016 ANA auction. The MS61 was very similar looking and not CAC. These early type coins, particularly high grade PCGS-graded examples from the 1790s are always in high demand. We anticipate a very fierce bidding war when this choice piece comes up for sale. PCGS # 38748 | EST: $18,000+92

LOT 153 OUR ESTIMATES The estimates you see published in this catalog 10C 1839-O NO DRAPERY. PCGS MS63 are just that: estimates. Keep in mind that a coin Original frost provides a backlight through the golden/dove could be either low or high end for the grade, toning. Hints of richer olive-tan are seen in places. A decent have stunning color or be dull, all of which strike adds to the overall eye appeal. radically affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be huge price differences within a grade, and we PCGS 6, NGC 5. This is a very scarce issue in Mint State, with offer estimates as a guide so collectors can have single digit pops in all MS grades from 61 to 67+. Only threeMS63s have sold in auction going back to 2002; the most recent a better idea of value. One thing we will never for $1,998 in the 2016 FUN sale (held at the low point in the do is offer low ball estimates in order to claim market). The PCGS Price Guide lists a value of $2,500. stronger sales. These published estimates represent what PCGS # 4572 | EST: $1,800+ Legend Rare Coin Auctions determines to be an approximate high wholesale value for the coin. The numbers are based upon current market values, similar trades, auction prices, published prices, and a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is no guarantee that the estimated prices are minimums or are exactly what you can expect to get if you attempt to resell them wholesale. We always advise you to view the coins you are interested in and calculate what you’ll pay using as much information as possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask us. We are here to help you!LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 93

LOT 156 10C 1839-O NO DRAPERY. PCGS MS67 CAC A superlative GEM, among the absolute finest known of this early New Orleans issue. The surfaces are silky smooth, even using a strong glass we cannot locate a single distracting feature. The devices are RAZOR sharp, each fold in Ms. Liberty’s gown, every stripe in the shield, every strand of hair, every finger, etc on the obverse and every leaf on the reverse wreath are fully embossed by a forceful and exacting blow from the dies. A delicate pearlescent lilac tone drapes the peripheral devices, leaving the centers either untoned, or with a subtle dusting of clear gold. The brilliant, satiny, nearly cartwheel textured luster really shines and brings the subtle color to life and adds depth to the chiseled devices. The quality of this coin is unusual for an early New Orleans issue, which often come somewhat crude in nature. PCGS 3, NGC 1, CAC 2. The finest graded at PCGS is a solitary MS67, which has never been sold in auction. Prior to this coin selling in the recent 2016 ANA auction, the only PCGS MS67 was a colorful coin that sold in January 2008 for a whopping $35,650. Since that coin has yet to reappear on the market, this is likely the finest that the advanced collector will be able to add to their cabinet. The current PCGS value is listed at $37,500. While the recent drop in the market for Seated type coins has brought the values of these wonderful coins to more reasonable levels, we feel that coins like this will not be sluggish for long, and NOW is the time to put great coins like this away for the long term. PCGS # 4572 | EST: $21,000+94

LOT 157 LOT 158 10C 1840-O NO DRAPERY. PCGS MS62 CAC 10C 1841-O PCGS MS64+ CAC EX SIMPSON Only two coins are graded finer at PCGS than this MS64+. This lovely coin boasts pearly lustrous silver surfaces are untoned. Lovely peripheral toning frames pleasing light silver centers For an early O-mint dime, the strike is strong and bold and the on both sides of this important early O-Mint dime. Well struck luster pleasing. The details are crisply defined across Liberty’s devices show bold definition from an exacting strike on bothsides. The frosty mint luster has a subtle reflectivity to it, and we drapery and throughout the reverse wreath. Upon closenote a few teenie lines in the fields that limit the grade to MS62. inspection, we can locate, with much effort, a tiny tick or two, PCGS 5, NGC 4, CAC 5. This lovely dime has been off the but nothing is distracting to the eye. market since the Simpson Seated dime collection was sold in September 2010, and it realized $10,925 back then. The PCGS 5, NGC 5, CAC 4. This is the only MS64+ graded by following year, an example that does not possess the bold either service, and there are two coins graded MS65 at each visual appeal of this piece sold for only $8,050. The currentPCGS value is listed at $9,000. Keep in mind that there are only PCGS and NGC finer. This coin has not sold in auction. Insix graded finer, the most recent MS63 selling for $14,375 back October 2014 there was a PCGS/CAC MS64 that realizedin January 2008. Great dates like this do not appear that often, $5,288 and a MS65 that sold for $8,225; this coin should sell and for advanced collectors this is an important opportunity. for somewhere in the middle. If you are building a set of O-mint Seated dimes, or collect early Seated coins in general, be sure to bid on this lovely coin.PCGS # 4574 | EST: $8,500+ PCGS # 4580 | EST: $5,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 95

LOT 159 LOT 160 10C 1842-O PCGS MS63 CAC 10C 1843 PCGS MS65 Bold satiny luster swirls around on both sides of this Among early Seated dimes, the 1843 is EXTREMELY UNDERRATED pearly-silver with pale gold and lilac iridescent hues. The color and luster help define the boldly impressed devices, in MS65. How is this for rare, the last PCGS MS65 sold in 2001 (toexceptionally sharp throughout. Close inspection under a strong put that in perspective, the present cataloger was a senior in high glass reveals the slightest ticks. RARE in mint state, especially school when the last one sold)! Even in NGC, the last coin was back in 2008. This date is NEVER seen! Rich and original silver-olive- so in Choice and Gem grades. russet-rose hues show a dappled texture over remarkably preserved surfaces. The strike is decent, with only a touch of weakness on the PCGS 4, NGC 4, CAC 2. This coin last sold for $4,600 when it sold tips of the top leaves of the wreath. A satin bloom catches the lightas part of the Jones Beach Collection, FUN 2007. Since then, only 1 PCGS graded coin has sold, realizing nearly $4,300 in a July 2014 and brings the details, surface quality, and color to live.auction, that coin was NOT CAC and the current PCGS Price Guidelists a value of $5,450. Early Seated coinage, dimes in particular are PCGS 4, NGC 7. There are three graded finer. By no means is this very underrated in mint state and keep in mind that only five coins a date that was saved in any quantity. As noted above, the last are graded higher. Very rarely do MS graded pieces come up for PCGS-graded coin sold in an October 2001 auction. The last NGC sale, if you are building a set, take a look at this PQ piece. coin was a dipped white coin that sold in July 2008. Our consignor’s PCGS # 4582 | EST: $4,000+ notes state he bought this coin in 2008, privately. Since these never appear at auction, we think the Collector’s Universe value of $4,000 is too low. The Gardner coin, graded PCGS MS66 CAC sold for $8,225 in 2014, and another sold for $6,169 in 2015. While not CAC, this coin is all there and then some, and even if you are not a member of the Seated Liberty Collectors Club, you can understand how important an opportunity like this is. Good luck. PCGS # 4583 | EST: $4,000+ LOT 161 10C 1850-O PCGS AU58 CAC Another very scarce New Orleans dime, and this is not a date/grade combination that is often seen. Pleasing mint frost still lingers in the fields, the coin is the definition of a slider, there is only a touch of minor friction on the highest design elements. We do note a dusting of clear gold and a scattering of minor marks from a very brief stay in circulation. PCGS 5, NGC 2, CAC 2. This date is scarce in all grades AU and finer, and very few were lucky to survive in mint state. The last time an AU58 coin graded by PCGS sold at auction was back in 2010, where it sold for $2,070 (it was not CAC). This is a date that is often difficult for collectors to find, so when they do appear, there is strong competition. PCGS # 84029 | EST: $2,000+96

LOT 162 10C 1852-O NGC MS64 Soft silver luster shines through a lilac-olive-champagne tone. Boldly struck with all of the details in Ms. Liberty’s gown, drapery, face, and hands visible. The reliefs stand out in bold relief against the smooth satin-like fields. PCGS 5, NGC 10. There are none graded higher at PCGS, and there are two finer at NGC, 1 65 and one 66. The last NGC MS64realized $3,525 in August 2013 and it was very clearly dipped and unnatural. Before that, these were selling for $4,000+. This one is quite pleasing and should bring a bid stronger than the one sold in 2013, as it is more visually appealing and original. PCGS # 4598 | EST: $3,000+ LOT 163 10C 1853 NO ARROWS. PCGS MS68 Wow, this SUPERB GEM is incredible. How did a dime, struck during a period of American history that was rife with economic and socio-political ups and downs survive in such an astonishing grade? Whether it was intentional or by pure happenstance, the numismatic community is lucky to be able to enjoy this virtually perfect coin. Essentially as struck, the luster is vibrant and frosty withmuch satin bloom. Save for a touch of golden accents, this coin is as silvery as it was at the second it came off the die. Well struck, all of the details are boldly embossed into the planchet. Using a strong glass, all we see are some planchet lines and die clash marks, which are both products of manufacture and do not affect the grade. Because of the massive amounts of gold pouring out of the California gold fields, the proportion of gold/siver in commerce became unbalanced and the price of silver, relative to gold increased to the point where the content of silver coins was worth more than their stated values. Congress changed the weights of these coins, and the new composition was denoted by arrows placed at the date. Before this change went into effect, only 95,000 dimes were struck using the No Arrows dies. PCGS 4, NGC 5. This is the James Lull Collection coin, which sold in January 2005 for $16,675. Since then, two PCGS-gradedexamples have sold for $18,800. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $26,000. This would make for a great example for a SUPERB type set, and will be a stand out in such a set. PCGS # 4599 | EST: $15,000+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 97

LOT 165 10C 1854-O ARROWS. PCGS MS65 CAC EX ELIASBERG A RARE gem grade example of this popular issue, pedigreed to the arguably the greatest collection of coins ever built, that of Baltimore banker Louis Eliasberg. Frosty mint brilliance shines under a pearly-gold-olive-tan toning. The strike is bold throughout. PCGS 8, NGC 10, CAC 1. There are only two coins graded finer at PCGS, a 66 and a 66+. This is the only MS65 example approved by CAC. This gem sold in an August 2013 auction for $7,637, attesting to the superb quality. Since it may be a long time until the MS66 comes up for sale, this is likely the finest to appear on the market for a while. We think that now is a great time to put great coins like this away in a type set, or if you are feeling ambitious and would like to challenge yourself to building a set of Seated Dimes, this might well be a great example to start off with. PCGS # 4606 | EST: $5,000+ LOT 164 10C 1853-O ARROWS. PCGS MS64 LOT 166 Pleasing pearly surfaces show a pale champagne/apricot tone that dusts both sides and it is amplified by the soft satin luster 10C 1857 PCGS MS66 CAC that catches the eye. Bold definition throughout, there is only An amazing GEM 1857 dime! Satin mint frost catches the light and a touch of weakness on the head and on a few places on the brings life to vibrant blues and golds that dominate both the obverse reverse. Overall though it is easy to see how this coin is one of and reverse. The surfaces are quite impressive. The devices are the finest of the date to survive! well struck and the lovely toning adds dimension to the design. PCGS 3, NGC 1. There is only a single coin graded higher, a PCGS 6, NGC 15, CAC 2. This is the first time a PCGS MS66 PCGS MS66. The last MS64 graded by PCGS to sell was in CAC is being sold in an auction sale. This GEM brought $3,220 November 2008, and it sold for $17,250. A truly rare coin like in May 2012, graded MS65 CAC. The most recent PCGS MS66 this should bring a strong price for the advanced collector. (non-CAC of course) sold for $2,585 in a weak auction (FUN PCGS # 4604 | EST: $12,000+ 2016). The current Collectors Universe Price is $6,000. This coin is more appealing visually, and we think it should bring a strong price when it crosses the block. PCGS # 4614 | EST: $2,800+98