OFFICIAL AUCTIONEER OF THE PCGS MEMBERS ONLY SHOW DECEMBER 15 | LAS VEGAS | THE VENETIAN
PRESENTS DECEMBER 15 | LAS VEGAS | THE VENETIANWelcome friends!This is our 19th Regency Auction, and perhaps offering one of the best selection of coins yet. In the pages that follow you willfind many great coins to add to your collection; from very nice collector coins to major rarities. The stars of the auction havebeen promoted for months now, making their way around the circuit: The Angel Dee’s Buffalo Nickel Set; the Young-DakotaProof Barber Dime Set; duplicates from the Cheyenne Collection of Proof Barber Quarters; the Brand-Knoxville-Morelan 1795Draped Bust Dollar in PCGS MS65 CAC; and the Northern Lights Collection, Part 2.Between these highlights, there are numerous coins from many different consignors. Are you interested in Mint State largecents? We have a gorgeous 1795 and 1798. Do you collect Matte Proof Lincolns? Feast your eyes on the TWO superb 1916s.Seated Dimes strike your fancy? There is a wonderful selection, consigned by one of the foremost collectors of the series. Asusual we have a great group of Bust Half Dollars, always popular among novices and advanced collectors. As in our Regency18 Auction, we have a collection of Carson City Morgan dollars, each GEM hand selected for eye appeal and quality; builtexclusively by our sister firm, Legend Numismatics. Always gold bugs, we are pleased with the diverse offering of gold coins,which features many rare dates and some finest certified examples. We round out the sale with a really fresh group of 1858-59Transitional Indian Cent Patterns and some Standard Silver issues.In all, the 514 lots in the Regency 19 Auction will entice the novice collector and delight and challenge the advanced numismatist.As always it has been a delight to work with our consignors. Each coin was hand selected by our world-class numismatists. Werejected over 100 coins that were consigned to us for this sale. We reject coins that do not meet our quality or value standards.This ensures that you, the bidder, will be able to easily find coins of interest (without having to go through many subpar coins),and will be happy with the coins you purchase. Our motto is“a happy buyer will make a happy seller.”As we look at the end of 2016 and the beginning of 2017, we wish everyone a very happy, healthy, and prosperous new year.We are looking forward to what 2017 has to offer. Remember we are always looking for consignments for our Regency andSessions auctions. If you have coins to consign, be sure to give us a call. We have proven over the course of 19 Regency Sales,that Legend Rare Coin Auctions’ boutique style gets the same, or better, results than the“bigger” companies. We look forwardto working with you!Happy Collecting!Best wishes,Julie Abrams Greg CohenPresident Senior Numismatist
Terms and ConditionsThis is a public auction, conducted in accordance with these Terms and Conditions of Sale, by Legend RareCoin Auctions (hereinafter referred to as “LRCA”). By bidding on any lot offered by LRCA, the bidder indicatesacceptance of the following Terms and Conditions of Sale. Bidders are to comply with the Terms and Conditionsof Sale, posted on LegendAuctions.com, at the time of the auction in which they are participating.Buyer’s PremiumA 17.5% buyer’s premium will be added to all successful bids, and is payable by the winning bidder as part of thetotal purchase cost.Sales TaxAll sales are subject to applicable state and local taxes. Any lots that are picked up and/or delivered in the state ofNevada are subject to applicable state and local taxes.PaymentAll merchandise must be paid for within TEN (10) days of the date of sale. We reserve the right to cancel any unpaidorder after that time and to ban the bidder from future sales. Credit cards (Visa, MasterCard and Discover) areaccepted for auction payments up to $2,500.00 per invoice. Invoices and/or balances over $2,500.00 must be paidvia personal or certified check, money order, or wired funds. Personal checks, money orders and cashier’s checksmay be held for up to 10 business days in order to allow time for them to clear appropriate banking channels.Please email [email protected] for bank-wiring instructions and/or to provide numismatic references.Return PolicyAll lots are sold “as is.” Lots graded by PCGS, NGC or other third-party grading services, or any lot viewed by thebuyer or anyone on buyer’s behalf prior to the auction, may not be returned. This is not an approval sale. All salesof lots to the highest bidder are final. Bidders are strongly advised and encouraged to research any lots upon whichthey plan to bid, and to determine bids, based upon their own evaluation. Bidders assume all risks concerning andrelated to the grade, quality, appearance, condition, history and origin of any lot. Bidders acknowledge that coingrading is not an exact science, that it can be subjective and inconsistent and that it is possible that two partiesmight assess or grade the same coin differently. LRCA makes every effort to accurately describe all items offeredin its sales. All items will be available for preview prior to the auction.ShippingShipping costs will be billed separately and are non-refundable. Items will usually ship within 5-10 business days afterpayment has been received and/or funds have cleared. Coins will be shipped via Fed Ex or USPS or transported viaarmored carrier.The shipping charge includes fees for our third-party insurance coverage, as well as any costs incurred through theUSPS or Federal Express. Any shipments made via armored carrier (Brinks, Dunbar, etc.) will be calculated and assessedat the time of shipment.International ShippingIt is not possible for LRCA to ship to some countries. Please email questions to [email protected]. Paymentfor all international orders is required in US funds. Please contact [email protected] for bank wiringinstructions.Customs requirements for each country are the responsibility of the buyer. All packages shipped outside of theUnited States will include the required customs declaration and full value of the invoice.
Bids Via TelephoneAn absentee bidder may also participate live, during the auction, via telephone. Requests for phone bidding mustbe received at least three days prior to the auction date. Please fill out our phone bidding request form online orcall 732-935-1168 to request a call from one of our representatives during the live auction. LRCA cannot guaranteephone lines, but will make every effort to accommodate those who wish to participate via this method.Rights & ResponsibilitiesThe auctioneer will determine the highest bidder. The auctioneer, alone, has the right to reopen the bidding for anitem, if deemed necessary. LRCA and its representatives reserve the right to remove any attendees who impedethe preview and/or the auction. Title to all merchandise shall pass to the winning bidder after receipt of goodfunds by LRCA. Bidders will be held responsible for their bids, including those bids placed incorrectly. PLEASEVERIFY BIDS BEFORE SUBMITTING THEM. In order to have a bid removed or corrected, bidder must contactLRCA prior to start of the auction. Bidder waives auctioneer’s responsibility and holds LRCA harmless for failureto recognize, accept, receive or execute any lost or missing bids by internet, telephone, email, floor bid, fax, mail orother means. LRCA reserves the right to postpone or cancel an auction without notice. Lots may be withdrawn atLRCA’s discretion, without prior notice. Lots may carry a reserve. A reserve is a price below which the auctioneerwill not sell an item, or will re-purchase the item on behalf of the consignor or for LRCA. LRCA permits bids to beplaced by the auctioneer, or an employee of the auctioneer, up to the pre-determined reserve set by the consignor.Legend Rare Coin Auctions’ partner, Legend Numismatics, reserves the right to bid on items, for its own accountand for the accounts of its clients.Listed Bid IncrementsBid increments are to serve as a general guideline. Actual increments are at the auctioneer’s discretion.$0 - $199 ....................................................................... $10$200 - $999 ................................................................... $25$1000 - $1999 ....... ......................................................... $50$2,000 - $4,999 ......................................................... $100$5,000 - $9,999 ......................................................... $250$10,000 - $19,999 ......................................................... $500$20,000 - $39,999 ......................................................... $1000$40,000 - $99,999 ......................................................... $2500$100,000 - $199,999 ................................................ $5,000$200,000 - $399,999 ................................................ $10,000$400,000 - $999,999 ................................................ $25,000$1,000,000 - $1,999,999 ................................................ $50,000$2,000,000 and up ......................................................... $100,000tThhaet Lthaet the end of the description indicates lot is owned by Legend Numismatics.
Laura Sperber PRINCIPALS Partner Laura was raised in Highland Park, NJ. During high school, the coin bug hit her hard. Her trip to theBruce Morelan 1976 NYC ANA left a lasting mark and huge desire for her to own and handle the greatest rarities. Partner While attending Monmouth University, Laura attended coin shows more than classes. After college, she started LSS RCI, a wholesale coin company. In 1986, she realized the need for a “better” coin retailer and Julie Abrams teamed up in 1986 with George Huang to form Legend Numismatics. President In 1996 Bruce Morelan became a partner and since then Legend has exclusively built or assisted in assembling this generation’s greatest collections. In 2012 Laura saw the need for a smaller, boutique auction firm, and created Legend-Morphy with Dan Morphy, whom she split with in 2014. Today, Laura is also a leading consumer advocate for coins. The passion has never subsided, and she keeps a beautiful Proof Walker on her desk to this day. Bruce started collecting coins when he was only six years old and by the time he was in high school his dream was to be a coin dealer. But life intervened and instead, Bruce went into business. By chance, he became Legend Numismatics’ financial backer in 1996. His great grandmother had given him three coins when he was young, one of which being a Trade Dollar, so he set out to build the finest Trade Dollar set. After a few years with ultra rarities, Bruce returned to his love of dollars and completed both a set of Gobrechts and a set of Seated Dollars. After selling those sets, Bruce recently returned to dollars with a new Gobrecht set and a spectacular early dollar set capped by his dream coin, the Amon Carter 1794 Dollar. Not many collectors can say they have completed not only the finest 1794-1885 Dollar Sets and have over the years owned such coins as two 1913 Liberty Head Nickels, an 1894-S Dime, 1876-CC Twenty Cent piece, 1827 Original and Restrike Quarters, 1838-O Half Dollar, two 1885 Trade Dollars and four 1884 Trade Dollars! Julie Abrams started in numismatics in 1986 when she joined up with Bernard Rome and launched Teletrade, the first computerized auction company. Teletrade developed a unique coin trading method, utilizing state-of-the-art digitized voice board technology to run live auctions before the advent of the internet. As President of Teletrade, Julie helped expand the company, increasing the frequency of auctions and expanding annual sales to $24 million within a few years. In 1999, GMAI, a publicly traded company, purchased Teletrade and Ms. Abrams became Executive Vice President of Sales for the parent company. Her job responsibilities included continuing her role as CEO for Teletrade as well as marketing to buyers and consignors, with the goal of maintaining a balance between inventory and sales while growing the business. In 2004 she joined Stacks-Bowers, an old world traditional auction house where she worked to expand their e-commerce presence, including the development of an online bidding platform for the firm. She also marketed Stacks’ programs to secure consignments from dealers and institutions such as banks, museums and universities. Julie is a member of the American Numismatic Association, the Central States Numismatic Association and Florida United Numismatists. STAFF Auctioneer Bradley Karoleff Photography John EmersonGreg Cohen José Campos Patrick Braswell Ann Marie Van PeltSenior Numismatist Auction Coordinator Art Director Office Manager
Official auctioneer of the PCGS Members Only ShowThursday, December 15, 2016 | 4:30PM PT/ 7:30PM ET Location The Venetian - At the PCGS Members Only Show Auction Room: Lido # 3003 3355 Las Vegas Boulevard South, Las Vegas, NV 89109 Lot Viewing Tuesday, December 13th 3PM-6PM PT | Location: Lido # 3005 - By Appointment Wednesday, December 14th 9AM-11AM PT | Location: Lido # 3005 - By Appointment 11AM-6PM PT | Lido # 3005 Thursday, December 15th 9AM-3:30PM PT | Lido # 3005 Lot Pickup & Settlement Friday, December 16th 9AM-11AM PT | Location: Lido # 3005 Preliminary lot viewing available by appointment. Please call 732-935-1168 to schedule an appointment. ON LOCATION PHONE NUMBER: 732-233-0719 17.5% Buyer’s Premium Legend | Rare Coin Auctions P.O. Box 9, Lincroft NJ 07738 • [email protected] • Tel. 732-935-1168 Fax 732-935-1807 | Hours: Open M-F / 9AM-5PM ET legendauctions.com
LOT 1 1C 1794 HEAD OF 1794 S-59 PCGS MS63 BN CAC EX NAFTZGER-REYNOLDS Just the names Naftzger and Reynolds should be an indication as to the quality of this beautiful early large cent. Steely brown luster shows light tan-gold in the protected areas of the well struck devices. Some light ticks are noted here and there, but blend nicely and are not noticeable without a glass. Middle to late die state for this R-3 variety with a couple of reverse die cracks, most prominent at the lower portion going through the fraction to the A in AMERICA. Depending on the EAC condition census you follow this is either 4th or 5th finest. Not only does this marvelous Choice Brown 1794 offer a great eye appeal, but it also boasts a great provenance going back to the early 1960s: Herbert Dietz Collection, Stack’s April 1962, lot 271; Stack’s October 1966, lot 46; Gilbert Steinberg, Stack’s 1976 ANA Auction, August 1976, lot 232; Del Bland; Herman Halperin Collection, Stack’s March 1988, lot 80, Ted Naftzger, 1990 EAC Auction, lot 27; Tom Reynolds Collection, Goldberg’s January 2016, lot 36. The lot tickets from the 76 ANA auction, the Herman Halperin sale, and Naftzger’s envelope are all included. PCGS 25, NGC 1, CAC 4. This coin sold for $29,375 in the Reynolds Sale, on an estimate of $40,000+; at the time of that sale, the market was very depressed, having succumbed to the triple whammy of plunging gold, oil, and stock prices. Since then, the market overall has firmed up and since there hasn’t been a major collection of Large Cents sold since, we think this coin should bring more today. If you are looking for a 1794 large cent for a type set, or need one for a date set, this exceptional coin will serve either purpose brilliantly! PCGS # 3539 | EST: $29,000+6
LOT 2 71C 1798 S-166. 2ND HAIR STYLE PCGS MS64 BN CAC EX NAFTZGER-REYNOLDSWhat an awesome early large cent! One of the worst kept secrets in all of numismatics is how much the principles at our sister company, Legend Numismatics, loves high end copper, and this coin is one that would appeal to even the pickiest of collectors. First, the luster swirls on satin smooth surfaces. Even medium brown shows hints of a lighter golden tone in areas. The strike is razor sharp throughout. Even with a strong glass, we cannot find a single spot or stain that would distract, but tiny abrasion is noted in front of Liberty’s bust. The obverse die was slightly misalignedshifting the design up towards 1:00. Struck from clashed dies, and the reverse has a heavy die crack that goes from E in UNITED through the wreath and arcs down to about 6:00. The extensive pedigree is as impressive as the physical qualities. Beckwith Collection (Chapman, April 1923, lot 17); Henry Hines; Dr. William Sheldon; Roy “Ted” Naftzger; Eric Streiner; Denis Loring; John MacDonald; Tom Reynolds Collection (Goldberg’s, January 2016, lot 162) at $18,212. This near GEM is ranked among thefinest, and depending on which census you follow, it fallssomewhere between CC#1 and CC#5; it is also plated in several of the major references on early cents.PCGS 7, NGC 1, CAC 5. For the 2nd Hair Style type, only 3 are finer in the BN color designation, none are CACapproved. This well preserved coin will serve wonderfully in an advanced type or date set. The current PCGSPrice Guide value is listed at $50,000. We think whoeverpurchases this near-GEM will have as hard a time putting it down as we have! PCGS # 36068 | EST: $25,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM
LOT 3 1C 1824/2 PCGS MS63 BN CAC EX ELIASBERG Scintillating steel and olive patina over smooth brown. Bold luster throughout both sides of this well struck CHOICE example of the over date. Under close inspection we can see some tiny marks but none that are distracting. This attractive large cent has been a part of three of the great collections of the 20th/early 21st century. Starting with the Louis Eliasberg collection, this coin sold as lot 556 in the B&M/Stack’s May 1996 auction. At the sale, Dr. Juan XII Soros bought this coin from the Eliasberg sale, and it was part of his collection that focused on overdates. The Soros sale was auctioned by Superior in February 1999. Gene Gardner ended up with this coin, where it sold in the sale of his collection, June 2014, where it was NGC MS63 BN without CAC approval. PCGS 5, NGC 3, CAC 2. The last PCGS example to sell was NOT CAC approved and realized $32,900 in the 2013 ANA auction. As mentioned above, this coin last sold in a non-CAC NGC holder, and sold for a decidedly soft $14,100 (it sold for $8,800 uncertified in the original Eliasberg sale). The current PCGS value is $36,500. Now that it has been crossed over to PCGS and is CAC-approved, there will be much more demand from specialized collectors in our sale. There are only 4 coins graded finer, none have sold. If you are interested in condition census, rare date large cents, be sure to bid liberally on this CHOICE coin. PCGS # 1639 | EST: $25,000+8
LOT 4 1C 1844/81 NEWCOMB-2. PCGS MS63 BN CAC EX DAN HOLMES COLLECTION A very choice example of this blundered date. The underdigits can be seen with the naked eye. Lustrous chocolate brownsurfaces show some satiny luster and tinges of subtle mint color can be seen with effort. The reverse has steely-olive overtones and it takes a strong glass to find even the slightest little tick. PCGS 2, NGC 1, CAC 1. Currently listed as # 6 in the Grellman Census, this is the Robinson S. Brown-Dan Holmes coin. It sold in the January 2011 auction of the Dan Holmes Collection for $6,325. All the pedigree info is included with this lot. This coin has graced two of the most famous collections of Large Cents, and it can now be yours! PCGS # 397722 | EST: $4,000+ LOT 5 1C 1857 SMALL DATE. PCGS PR66 BN CAC Wow, this SUPERB PR large cent has bold eye appeal. The devices are razor sharp, every minute detail in Liberty’s hair, isfully defined. The deep chocolate patina and chiseled strike give this GEM the look of a copper-bronzed medal struck at the mint during this era. Accents of azure and olive patina can be seen on the rich mirrors adding to the amazing eye appeal. Only 238 proof 1857 large cents were struck. PCGS 5, NGC 10, CAC 4. The most recent PCGS/CAC example to sell was graded PR65 BN and realized $8,813 in November 2013. No CAC approved PR66 BNs have ever sold in auction. The current PCGS Price Guide for PR66 BN is listed at $17,500. This GEM will surely attract much bidding activity when it crosses the block. PCGS # 2000 | EST: $10,000+ LOT 6 1C 1857 FLYING EAGLE. PCGS MS65A pretty MS65 example of the first year the small cent was struck for general circulation. A glowing tan-gold luster shines on both sidesof this well struck example. Consistent with the grade we note only a couple of insignificant hidden ticks. PCGS 236, NGC 226. The most recent PCGS MS65 to sell was in the 2016 ANA auction, realizing a price of $3,173. The CU value islisted at $4,250, which in the current market seems a tad high. This is a very pleasing coin and should bring around what the last 65 sold for. PCGS # 2016 | EST: $2,750+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 9
LOT 7 1C 1858 SMALL LETTERS. PCGS MS66 For the Small Letters variety, there are only 2 MS66+s that are graded higher at PCGS. This marvelous GEM has a vibrant cartwheel mint luster that rolls along icy-smooth surfaces. The design elements are expertly struck rendering razor sharp definition on both sides. Mostly a light copper-golden-tan, we can observe some deeper coppery hues. There is a single unobtrusive fleck on the obverse, near the eagle’s talon. PCGS 12, NGC 16. In January 2016, a PCGS MS66 sold for $18,800, and before that, in October 2014, one sold for $24,675. There are two MS66+s graded at PCGS, neither have ever sold in auction. The current PCGS Price Guide is listed at $24,500. If you are building a GEM set of Flyers or need one for a GEM type set, this beauty is well worth strong consideration. We think the bidding will really take off when this one opens for bidding. PCGS # 2020 | EST: $15,000+10
LOT 8 1C 1857 FLYING EAGLE. PCGS PR64 CAM CAC LOT 9 A boldly contrasted example of this RARE proof issue. It is a widely accepted fact that the 1857 PR Flying Eagle cent is tied 1C 1858 SMALL LETTERS. PCGS PR63 CAC with the Large Letters 1858 for being the scarcest proof in the A very rare proof Flying Eagle cent. Choice quality surfaces boast short series; much more so than the highly coveted and much bold mirrors that accentuate a rich orange-tan coloration on the obverse and a rosy-pink patina over golden-tan surfaces on the higher priced 1856. reverse. A few light specks on the obverse and a tiny contact The fields are boldly mirrored showing a lovely golden-tan color. mark are all that limit the grade. At first glance, this coin has the The eagle and wreath design elements are nice and frosty, impression of a higher grade. contrasting nicely with the mirrored fields. The cameo contrast isparticularly rare on this issue, most examples are more of a brilliant Despite the small mintage of 200 for the Small Letters variant, and there are 4 die marriages for the Small Date listed by Rick Snow. This proof in nature. Close inspection reveals a few minor flecks, but none are serious. Due to the new planchet composition, many coin is the High Leaves variety, listed as S-PR-1. It is a very scarceproofs do show weakness in strike as is the case here. Some of the variety, as would be imagined given the low mintage in general.highpoint details on the wreath, tip of the eagle’s tail feathers, and PCGS 11, NGC 1, CAC 3. The last example sold in the 2012 ANA some of the obverse lettering are not full. auction, realizing $7,050, the same price a non-CAC PR64 sold for in December 2014. This coin, housed in an OGH and bearingOnly 425 were originally struck. PCGS 9, NGC 0, CAC 3. Not only not just CAC-approval, but the specialized Eagle Eye Photo Seal is this coin CAC, but for specialists in the series, do note that as well, this coin has a lot going for it, in addition to its great eye it is also Eagle Eye Photo Seal approved. This is NOT the coin appeal. The current PCGS Price Guide is $7,650 and that level that sold in February 2016 for $9,888, but rather the example may get challenged when this Flyer sells. that sold in an April 2014 online auction for $15,565. The currentPCGS Price Guide is $14,500. This is a great looking coin and is PCGS # 2043 | EST: $6,500+ destined for a special set of PR small cents. PCGS # 82040 | EST: $10,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 11
LOT 11 1C 1877 PCGS MS63 BN Housed in an old Green Label holder. The KEY to the Indian cent series, and in demand from collectors in all grades, from AG through GEM BU. Pleasing golden brown surfaces show a soft satin luster and a hint of woodgrain. The devices are well struck and there are no carbon spots, flecks, or serious ticks to be found, even with a strong loupe. PCGS 59, NGC 30. The last non-CAC approved 1877 Indian cent sold for $4,112 back in the 2015 CSNS sale and that coin had no where near the eye appeal of this one. It was brown and lifeless with a rather serious carbon spot on the obverse. This coin is clearly finer offering much more eye appeal. The current PCGS Price Guide is $5,500. If you need a Mint State example for your set, this one is certainly worth looking at! PCGS # 2127 | EST: $3,600+ LOT 10 1C 1860 POINTED BUST. PCGS MS66 CAC LOT 12 This SUPERB gem also has the approval of the Eagle Eye Photo Seal. A bold golden-tan luster revolves around silken surfaces, 1C 1909-S INDIAN. PCGS MS65 RB CAC free of all but the most microscopic ticks. Add to the great color Glorious mellowing mint red luster shines on both obverse and and luster a bold strike and you have one PQ copper-nickel cent. reverse of this pretty GEM. The surfaces are a very pleasing PCGS 11, NGC 2, CAC 4. The most recent example to sell in red with a fascinating woodgrain texture and hints of rose and auction realized $7,638 in December 2015, and while the last gold hues throughout. The luster is bold and vibrant, without any seven examples have sold in the $7,000-$8,200 range, PCGS graded examples have APRs into the $12,000-$15,000 range. breaks or marks that would distract the eye. The current PCGS Price Guide lists a value of $10,500 in MS66. There is a single MS67 finer, which sold for $32,900 in February PCGS 160, NGC 107, CAC 48. The last one to sell in auction was not as pretty as the presently offered GEM, realizing $2,115 and 2014. This GEM will certainly bring a premium price to a the current PCGS Price Guide value is $3,250. Keep in mind there specialist who wants the very finest. are only a handful graded higher in the RB category, and in RD, a gem example will cost double. This 65RB offers about 90% full red PCGS # 2056 | EST: $6,000+ and is a great looking coin that should seriously be considered. PCGS # 2239 | EST: $2,000+12
LOT 13 1C 1909-S LINCOLN. PCGS MS66 RD CAC A brilliant golden-RED that is well struck and beautiful. This wonderful GEM is about as vibrant and flashy red as it was theday it came off the press. The luster swirls around both sides of this frosty gem and the bold details are razor sharp. PCGS 187. NGC 69, CAC 35. The PCGS figure includes the15 graded MS66+ RD, and there are 9 graded MS67 RD finer. In September 2016 a non-CAC approved MS66 RD sold for $3,055 and a CAC approved example sold for $4,465 in therecent ANA auction. The current CU value is $3,150. This GEM is highly appealing and will sell for a premium bid when it crosses the block. PCGS # 2434 | EST: $3,000+ LOT 14 LOT 15 1C 1912-D PCGS MS65+ RD CAC 1C 1914-D PCGS MS65 BN CAC A blazing mint red original GEM. Sharply struck and highly A premium example for sure. Most likely this coin simply sat attractive. There are only a tiny little tick or two away from a 66. undisturbed for most of its existence. Superior surface are This is NOT a mellowing red; the red is as fresh as the day this super clean and smooth. Even using a strong glass, we found NO imperfections anywhere. A good luster enhances the totally coin was struck. original colors. You can clearly see bold shades of Mint Red by the rims. The centers are a fresh even brown. A few tiny toning PCGS 121, NGC 35, CAC 21. There are only 7 graded as 65+ dots are by the rims. Lincoln and every detail are boldly struck.and there are 28 graded finer, the finest at 66+. The last PCGS/CAC MS65+ RD sold in 2014 for nearly $2,000. The PCGS listed The eye appeal is fantastic!value is $2,600 and in MS66, it is listed at $11,000. We really like the look of this coin and we think it will sell for a premium price. PCGS 14, NGC 16, CAC 7. The last PCGS MS65 BN CAC to sell in auction brought $7,638 in March 2016 and the current PCGS # 2455 | EST: $1,500+ Collectors Universe Value is $7,500. In today’s market, these seem to be overlooked. This is a great example of a very important “Key Date” for the series. PCGS # 2471 | EST: $5,500+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 13
LOT 16 1C 1914-D PCGS MS66 RB CAC This coin is scary close to full GEM Red. There is no question this coin sat undisturbed and totally protected for most its 102-year existence. We cannot imagine a finer 1914-D! We grade this coin a MS66+ RB (but make no promises PCGS ever will). Incredible surfaces are the epitome of perfection. You can use a microscope and find NO impairment of ANY size, ANY where. A strong luster (for a 14-D) enhances the totally original GEM faded Mint Red/pale golden brown colors. There are NO spots or discolorations. Lincoln and every detail are fully struck and do stand out. The eye appeal is awesome! PCSG 2, NGC 4, CAC 1. There are none graded higher. NO 1914-D MS66 RB has ever been sold via auction. We do know a pop 2 PCGS MS66 RD NO CAC once sold for a mind blowing $200,000.00+. We can NOT impress enough the grand rarity of this piece-especially in this incredible condition. This is a fresh coin to the market as well. Bidders, be prepared for strong bidding and a possibly a record price! PCGS # 2472 | Est: $22,000+14
LOT 17 15 1C 1916 PCGS MS67+ RD CAC An AMAZING fiery, mint red cent! This spectacular GEM looks as fresh today as it did the moment it came off the dies. Were it not for a couple of TINY flecks, the coin would be fully flawless. The surfaces are silky smooth-there is only a touch of texture from the dies in the fields, similar to the orange-peel texture. Hints ofreflectivity and exceptionally bold details, suggest a very early striking in the life of this obverse die. PCGS 70, NGC 9, CAC 17. While there are 11 MS67+slisted on the PCGS Population Report, it is highly doubtful many look like this! The most recent example was sold in March 2016 and was NOT CAC; it sold for $5,405. This coin was from our Regency XVII Auction, where it realized $5,288. The current CU value is $6,900. It is highly unlikely you will find a finer example. PCGS # 2488 | EST: $5,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM
LOT 18 1C 1922 NO D. STRONG REVERSE PCGS MS64 BN CAC Legend Rare Coin Auctions is proud to offer this amazing and extremely rare Lincoln Cent. The quality is all there and then some! The surfaces are ultra clean and overall are totally blemish, spot, and are problem free. Even with a strong glass there are no problems. A strong glossy luster shows off GEM even and totally original chocolate brown colors. There is faded original Mint Red in thin bands around the devices. Lincoln and all the details are well struck. The eye appeal is exceptional! PCGS 2, NGC 1, CAC 2. The last one to sell was a PCGS NON-CAC back in 2010 and even back then that coin brought $29,900. We have not seen or heard of it since. The current Collectors Universe Value is $40,000. This is one of the rarest Lincoln cents to find in above MS63 and in any color. There is a PCGS CAC MS65 BN that brought $67,563 in August 2014. Call us prejudiced, but this coin has more eye appeal! Once this prize is sold, good luck on finding any others over MS63 BN and CAC-approved. Think about it, NONE have sold at auction since 2010-that’s forever ago! Good luck and congrats to the winning bidder-this one super rare coin! PCGS # 3285 | EST: $35,000+16
LOT 19 1C 1936-D PCGS MS67+ RD CAC This SUPERB GEM looks like it just was taken off the press with cloth gloves! Blazing mint red luster bursts off both sides. The surfaces are clean and the devices are well struck. The fiery color has hints of gold that just pop in the light. This coin is very deserving of its lofty grade. PCGS 165, NGC 380, CAC 26. ONLY 16 have received the coveted “+” grade, and NONE are graded finer at PCGS. ThePCGS Price Guide value is $3,500 and the SOLE example to sell in auction was sold in April 2016 realizing $4,230. There are asmall number NGC MS68 RDs, the last selling in 2010 for $2,530. If you are in the process building a Lincoln cent Registry set, take a look at this SUPERB, tied for PCGS finest! PCGS # 2653 | EST: $2,750+ BOB SIMPSON DAVID HALL GERALD FORSYTHE PHIL FLANNIGAN HAVE ALL CONSIGNED TO LRCA, WHY HAVEN’T YOU? CONTACT JULIE ABRAMS OR GREG COHEN TO DISCUSS YOUR COINS!LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 17
LOT 20 1C 1969-S DOUBLED DIE OBVERSE. PCGS AU58 CAC One of the most important Lincoln Memorial cents, and among the KEYS in the entire series. The obverse is fully doubled. Well struck and the devices showing only the slightest rub on the high points, this PQ GEM AU is evenly toned in a mahogany-brown with some lighter brown and hints of slight blue highlights. The surfaces are smooth and show only the slightest little marks, consistent with the grade. It is a beautiful coin for the grade and would make a great addition to any advanced Lincoln cent collection. PCGS 16, NGC 2, CAC 3. The last PCGS AU58 CAC to sell in a MAJOR auction realized $30,550 at the 2016 CSNS auction, which sold previously in July 2013 for $28,200. From 2006 to 2009, these were bringing $35,000-$44,000 without CAC approval. The current PCGS value is $30,000. This is a great opportunity to acquire this major rarity. Keep in mind that a Mint State piece will run around $40,000. This is an exceptional coin that will find itself in a great collection of Lincolns. It may be a while until another comes up for sale. PCGS # 2921 | EST: $26,000+18
LOT 21 LOT 22 1C 1911 PCGS PR66+ RB CAC 1C 1912 PCGS PR66+ RB CACULTRA HIGH END. All we can say is, PCGS must have been in a Mother Nature’s masterpiece! A spectacular superb GEM, tiedsuper bad mood the day this coin came in to be graded. To us, it for the finest numerically graded by PCGS with only one other RBsure looks much better than just a PR66+. And it’s got MONSTER and 2 BNs. Mostly rich brick red satin matte surfaces. Hints of violet and green add to the exceptional color and amazing quality colors that would make a peacock blush! surfaces. Boldly struck throughout and a tiny fleck is the only flaw Incredible surfaces are flawless: they display a full Matte texture noted on the reverse. that is undisturbed. There is some luster. You will not find any PCGS 15, NGC 7, CAC 7. Only 2 are graded 66+ RB and nonespots anywhere on the surfaces that display a rich blend of totally are finer at PCGS. We sold the finest PCGS PR66 RD CAC fororiginal and electric colors of pearl green/gold/fiery violet/pale Mint a record $37,600 in our February 2016 Regency Auction. While more muted, this coin is about 90% RD and is gorgeous. This red/purple all swirl vividly on both sides. Any master artist would coin has not appeared at auction in over two years and when itgive a thumb up to this outrageous work of Mother Nature. Lincoln last sold it sold for $14,100. The current CU value is $13,500 but to see GEM is to love it, and we think it will bring a very strong and the details are needle sharp in strike and the rims are thick price. If you are putting together a great MPL set, take a close and stand out. The eye appeal is jaw droppingly tremendous! look at this coin! PCGS 21, NGC 16, CAC 8. This is the ONLY PCGS PR66+ RBand PCGS has graded only ONE coin finer. If you are building a monster MPL set-then look no further-this is your dream coin!L PCGS # 3310 | EST: $9,000+ PCGS # 3313 | EST: $10,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 19
LOT 23 1C 1916 PCGS PR67+ RB Mezermizing colors and astonishing quality and eye appeal. It is hard to imagine that a nicer looking RB 1916 Matte Proof Lincoln exists! In this coin’s case, we think the B in RB stands for blue, not brown. Rich brick red blends with magenta, violet and blue over sublime surfaces. It is the sole finest graded at PCGS, and for good reason; even after studying this MONSTER for several minutes with a strong glass, we cannot find a single fleck, tick, line, spot, or any other distraction anywhere. The Matte surfaces show a satiny sheen over the delicate sandblast surfaces. Lincoln’s portrait looks as though it was carved by hand by a very talented engraver, the details are bold, sculpted and razor sharp. Even the edges are perfect showing the high knife rim and are reflective. PCGS 1, NGC 0. This amazing survivor has never appeared at auction. There are 3 PCGS PR67 RBs, but none of these have ever sold in auction either. The most recent comparable is the PR66+ RB CAC that was in the McCullagh Collection sold at the 2014 ANA Auction for $30,550 that is now in a PR67 holder. PCGS currently has a value of $42,500 in 67+ RB, and if you demand the finest colored PR Matte cent, take a look at this superb GEM. PCGS # 3325 | EST: $30,000+20
LOT 24 21 1C 1916 PCGS PR66 RD CAC What other auction in recent memory had TWO superb16 Matte Proof cents? Each coin will appeal to a different type of collector. The presently offered jewel has a mint fresh brilliant beaming red color. The strike is about as bold as can be hoped for (you can almost count Lincoln’s whiskers). The surfaces are problem free and totally original, looking about as nice today as the day itwas lovingly removed from the coinage press. After closeinspection, we found a single tiny line on the reverse and a minute fleck or two here or there. The RED surfaces show a great satin-like sheen that makes the little facets of the sandblast finish sparkle in the light. PCGS 5, NGC 2, CAC 2. No CAC-approved PR66 RDhas ever sold in auction. The closest looking coin was on old holdered NGC PR67 RD that sold in October 2011 for $34,500. This coin is likely the finest or second finest RED Matte Proof 1916 cent, and as such should attractconsiderable bidding from advanced collectors. The CU Price is listed at $32,500 and that may prove low. PCGS # 3326 | EST: $30,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM
LOT 25 1C 1936 BRILLIANT. PCGS PR66 RD CAMEO CAC What a jaw dropping spectacular SUPERB GEM. This is a REAL cameo coin-you do not have to imagine there is contrast. We assure you, the quality and WOW factors are off the charts! Remarkable mirrors are the ultimate in depth. They also have stunning clarity, are ultra clean, and have an intense reflection. You don’t have to twirl the coin to see the mirrors roll like a flowing river. Both sides are an outrageous totally original GEM Mint Red color. Lincoln and every detail are needle sharp in strike. The frosting is heavy and clearly visible. The eye appeal is just jaw dropping! PCGS 4, NGC 2, CAC 2. The last time one of these sold was back in June 2013 and it brought $21,150, and the current Collectors Universe value is $25,000. This is NOT the same coin-the other had uneven color in the right obverse field. We cannot stress enough how “on fire” this coin is. Even the most ridiculously picky buyer would love this coin (if not, then they will never ever find one they like). We know we have only seen the other coin back in 2013. If you collect PR Lincolns, this is a dream coin! We expect strong bidding here-good luck! PCGS # 83335 | EST: 12,500+22
LOT 26 1C 1938 PCGS PR67 RD CAC Deep red mirrors reflect the light from across the room! Thesurfaces are crisp, clean, and amazing in quality and eye appeal. It is hard to imagine a nicer coin. PCGS 38, NGC 19, CAC 14. Only two are graded PR67+ RD; the only other one graded sold for $4,700 in a September 2016auction. This is NOT that coin; this one is free of the tiny flyspecksthat the other example had. The current CU value is $3,000. If you are specializing in PR Lincoln cent, bid on this gem. PCGS # 3341 | EST: $3,500+ LOT 28 LOT 27 1C 1941 PCGS PR67 RD CAC Surprisingly rare in this grade, most 1941 proofs have a very 1C 1939 PCGS PR67 RD CAC funky look from poor storage, and this one is among the finestA great looking SUPERB PR Lincoln cent, showing a blazing red graded. The color is amazing, the surface quality superb, and themirrored surface on both sides. Deep red color with hints of rich overall look sublime. Aside from a teenie fleck or two, there is not a flaw anywhere to be found on either side. The strike is bold. magenta is unimpeded by any flecks or marks. PCGS 8, NGC 9, CAC 4. In April 2016 the most recent example PCGS 42, NGC 29, CAC 17. Only a single PR67+ RD is finer. sold, realizing $14,100; the only other CAC coin to sell realized The last one to sell brought $1,528 in September 2016 and the $28,200 in November 2013. The current CU value is $17,500. This coin certainly is among the absolute finest and is definitely current CU price is $1,800. worthy of a premium bid. PCGS # 3344 | EST: $1,400+ PCGS # 3350 | EST: $12,000+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 23
LOT 30 3CS 1862/1 PCGS MS66+ CAC No question this coin deserved a full +. Save for the typical die clashing, this coin is really immaculate. Super smooth and semi satiny surfaces are boldly lustrous. Both sides are a creamy original white color. Every detail is sharply struck and does have thick frosting. You do NOT need a glass to see the details! The eye appeal is terrific! LOT 29 PCGS 74, NGC 30, CAC 27. PCGS has graded only 5 coins in MS66+. The last one to sell in auction brought $3,525 in January 3CS 1851-O PCGS MS66 CAC 2014. 3CS are a wonderful and historical series to collect and yet One of the nicer MS 3CS pieces we have ever seen. Our sister they are another area that has taken harsh market down turns. company Legend has handled EVERY one of the VERY best MS pieces that exist. On a scale of 1-10, this coin ranks a 9+. NOW is a great time to start a set. Good luck! Immaculate surfaces are smooth. Even using a strong glass, you will find NO tiny imperfections or lines. A moderate luster PCGS # 3681 | EST: $3,000+ enhances a wonderful mix of olive/golden brown/pale violet colors that swirl all over. The strike overall is impressive and the eye appeal is super! PCGS 33, NGC 17, CAC 17. The current PCGS Collectors Universe value is $7,600-which is what this coin traded for in February 2015. This will be a tremendous addition to ANY GEM set! PCGS # 3665 | EST: $6,000+24
LOT 31 25 3CS 1867 PCGS MS65 CAC This is an extremely rare and magnificent example of a 1867 MS 3CS piece. Legend Numismatics’ (our sister company) experience in 3CS pieces (PR+MS) is unequaled as they have built the #1 sets with nothing coming close. They have assured us, this date is quite rare and you won’t see many offered that are equal to this piece.Immaculate surfaces are smooth and are ultra clean. You need a microscope to see any ticks or lines. There are also traces of semi-prooflike mirrors. A very good luster enhances the moderate and totally original mix of olive/pale violet/blue/gold colors that are spread all over. This coin is NOT dull or drab. Every detail is sharply struck and has strong frost. There is NO question this piece is an MS. The eye appeal is excellent! PCGS 3, NGC 0, CAC 1. PCGS has graded 5 coins higher. An NGC MS65 sold in auction for $14,100 withno CAC bean, and prior to that the last PCGS coin sold in2010. That is a powerful statement as to this coin’s rarity! If you’re building a great MS 3CS set or even a special Type set, this coin will make a great addition. PCGS # 3687 | EST: $12,500+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM
LOT 32 3CS 1870 PCGS MS66 CAC Only 3,000 were ever minted. Not a date or grade you see offered even in major auctions! This piece is an unquestionable MS. The surfaces are smooth, have prooflike tendencies, and do emit a strong luster. There are NO noticeable problems anywhere. A beautiful mix of colors form a ring of pearl green/gold/ pale blue that opens into lighter lavender centers. This coin is NOT dull or drab. Every detail is sharply struck and has generous frost. The eye appeal is very nice! PCGS 9, NGC 7, CAC 4. The only PCGS MS67 is locked away in major a collection. The last auction sale for one was in March 2016 that brought $8,813. The current Collectors Universe Value is $9,950. This certainly is not a date or grade you see offered. Opportunity knocks loud here! PCGS # 3691 | Est: $7,500+26
LOT 33 27 3CS 1856 PCGS PR65+ CAC EX TEXAS TRIMES Our sister company, Legend Numismatics has built the TWO FINEST PR 3CS sets, so we know how these do and do NOT come. This coin is an outstanding VERY HIGH END PR65. We think PCGS is simply afraid of the die polishing lines to grade it PR66. Unusually deep, crystal clear, clean (save for the Mintmade die polishing lines) and incredibly reflective mirrors beam from all over. The mirrors make this small coin look really big! A gorgeous ORIGINAL mix of pale navy/ gold/blue colors all swirl evenly together all over. Everydetail is needle sharp in strike and has light frost. The eye appeal is BOLD! It is estimated LESS than 100 pieces were ever minted. PCGS 5, NGC 4, CAC 4. PCGS has graded only this coin in PR65+ with just 2 higher. The current Collectors Universe Value for this coin is $16,000.00. Its very high end so we could see the price exceeding that number. We’ll challenge this coins quality and eye appeal vs any PR65 and even the majority of PR66’s! You certainly won’t have many opportunities to find many of these! PCGS # 3703 | EST: $14,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM
LOT 34 3CS 1858 PCGS PR66 CAC EX TEXAS TRIMES RARE and original. Deeply toned mirrors in shades of teal and navy shine around the well struck devices. The dies were highly polished, directional die polish lines are seen on both sides of this lovely superb gem. This coin was clearly cared for since it was purchased from the mint in the first year that proof coins were struck specifically for sale to the general collecting public. Before 1858, proofs were struck but only in very limited numbers for well connected collectors or other VIPs. An estimated mintage of only 100 coins were struck. PCGS 14, NGC 18, CAC 2. This is NOT the one that we just had in our September Regency auction that sold for $14,688 on an estimate of $9,000-$10,000. The current PCGS price is $13,500. Keep in mind, the only 2 PR67s are locked up in major collections. PCGS # 3705 | EST: $10,000+28
LOT 36 3CS 1868 PCGS PR66 CAMEO CAC This coin is so nice it could reside in our #1 all-time set, the Legend Collection, it is that phenomenal! The powerful mirrors are amazing on this near miss PR67 cameo status piece. You need a glass to see it. Both sides have shimmering deep mirrors that are crystal clear, super clean, and have bold reflectivity. A heart pounding mix of original pale champagne /olive/gold colors swirl all over. the obverse. The reverse is a blue/olive color. Every detail is frosted and has a pinpoint sharp strike. The eye appeal is major WOW factor-even though it is a smaller coin! ONLY 600 pieces were ever minted. PCGS 11, NGC 4, CAC 3. PCGS has graded 3 higher (A PR67 CAC is worth around $15,000.00). The last PCGS CAC 66 CAM to sell in auction brought $3,525 in January 2016-in a weaker sale. You certainly do NOT see this date and grade offered with any frequency. Good luck! PCGS # 83718 | EST: $3,000+LOT 35 3CS 1865 NGC PR67 LOT 37Amazing, deep mirrors shine through a layer of rich, sultry toning. 3CN 1866 PCGS MS66+ CAC Multi-colored tones dazzle the eye when viewed under a light; A frosty superior quality GEM 3CN. Boldly struck from clashed green, gold, orange, red and blue shades sparkle and dance dies and very pretty. A powdery lilac and iridescent gold add towhen rotated. Even with the color, the mirrors are crisp and clear the value. and wonderfully reflective. PCGS 43, NGC 53, CAC 18. There are nine graded 66+, and Only 500 were struck. PCGS 0, NGC 7. There is only a single only 3 are graded MS67. In MS66+ the PCGS Price Guide value PR68 finer at NGC. The highest non-CAMEO designated is $3,500. The most recent example sold for $2,820 in the 2016 PR 1865 3CS graded by PCGS is a PR66+. This is NOT the ANA auction, and before that, they were selling in excess of Gardner coin that sold in October 2015 for $3,643, nor is it the $3,200. A premium coin worthy of a premium bid. PCGS PR66+ CAC that sold for $3,995 in June 2015. This coin has a better eye appeal than both of those coins. Before the PCGS # 3732 | EST: $2,800+ Gardner NGC PR67 sold, you have to look back to September 2008 to find another APR, a coin that sold for $6,325. SincePCGS does has not graded a PR67 non-CAMEO, there is no CUvalue in this grade. The eye appeal and quality should certainly speak for themselves though. A wonderful example for any PR Civil War coin set, or set of PR 3CS. PCGS # 3715 | EST: $4,500+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 29
LOT 38 LOT 39 3CN 1866 PCGS PR66 DCAM CAC 3CN 1868 PCGS PR66+ DCAM CAC Sleek deep mirrors offer a bold contrast to the deep frosty Tied for FINEST DCAM certified. Deep and very clear mirrors devices. The definition is bold and the design elements fully beam from around beautifully white frosty reliefs providing an and crisply struck. The GEM quality mirrors are PQ and the amazing contrast on both sides. There is a very light golden tone eye appeal is great. The dies were highly polished, resulting on the reverse that is quite pleasing. The quality of this superb in some minor loss of detail at the wreath bow. Overall the eye GEM holds up even under intense scrutiny with a strong glass. appeal is superb. Only 600 proofs were struck. PCGS 14, NGC 7, CAC 14. There are only FIVE examples at PR66+ DCAM at PCGS, and NONE Only 725 proofs were minted the first year of the type. PCGS 11, are finer. The last one to sell was back in August 2013 realizing NGC 8, CAC 10. The most recent PR66 DCAM CAC to sell was $4,406; the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $5,000. an NGC coin, sold in June 2016, which realized $4,465 and at This beautiful, highly contrasted superb gem will do nicely in the the low point in the recent market downturn, the last PCGS/CAC coin sold, realizing $3,760. The current CU value is $3,750 and finest set of PR 3CN. Good luck! keep in mind the last PR67 DCAM sold in our September 2016 Regency auction for a record $21,738! While the overall market PCGS # 93764 | EST: $4,000+ has improved some since February’s lows, the values of PR type coins remain very reasonable. PCGS # 93762 | EST: $3,200+30
LOT 40 LOT 41 3CN 1869 PCGS PR66+ DCAM CAC 3CN 1870 PCGS PR66+ DCAM CAC A spectacular looking DCAM 3CN! The mirrors are rich and Wow, another superlative quality GEM PR 3CN, the FINEST seendeep;undisturbed, they offer exceptional clarity. The frosty reliefs at PCGS. The mirrors are deep and clean, and can be seen fromcontrast wonderfully, and are free from any distractions. Tied for across the room. They offer crystal clear reflection with no frost orsecond finest graded at PCGS, gorgeous and destined for a fine haze. The devices are expertly rendered and beautifully frosted, set of Proof 3CN. providing much contrast with the highly reflective fields. The reverse is slightly rotated.Only 600 were struck. PCGS 20, NGC 15, CAC 16. Only 3 PR66+ DCAMs have been graded at PCGS. In August 2016, a PCGS 1,000 proofs were minted, but they were not highly polished, PR66 DCAM CAC sold for $2,115; a PCGS PR66+ DCAM sold making DCAMS extremely rare; only FOUR DCAMS havefor $3,995; and a PCGS PR67 DCAM sold for $19,975. In PR66+ been graded by PCGS. PCGS 2, NGC 0, CAC 2. This is the DCAM the CU value is $4,750. A lovely superb gem that will ONLY PR66+ DCAM. The only PR66 DCAM sold for $13,513 delight any 3CN specialist or type collector. in November 2014. If you are building a DCAM set of 3CN, this date is a stopper, and who knows, once this SUPERB coin PCGS # 93765 | EST: $4,000+ sells, when the next one will come up for sale. Do NOT take this opportunity lightly. PCGS # 93766 | EST: $12,500+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 31
LOT 43 3CN 1878 PCGS PR67+ CAM CAC Boldly struck and beautifully mirrored, this superb gem will certainly delight any collector of PR 3CN or PR Type. The boldly frosted reliefs contrast wonderfully with the icy-black mirrors. The surface quality is immaculate! LOT 42 PCGS 39, NGC 31, CAC 32. There are 6 that are graded PR67+ CAM and only a single PR68 CAM is graded finer. The only one 3CN 1876 PCGS PR66+ DCAM CAC to sell realized $2,644 in December 2015. The eye appeal on this Tied for finest honors at PCGS. It seems that the PR coins from superb coin is finer, and we think it should sell for more. PCGS the centennial year were slightly better produced. The presently lists a value of $3,750 and keep in mind that the PR68 last sold offered SUPERB gem has icy smooth mirrors and highly frosted for $10,575 in 2013. If you are building a top caliber set, of PR reliefs. The coin has sharply struck devices throughout. The eye 3CN this coin is not to be missed! appeal is amazing and superb. Obviously you will not find a better one! PCGS # 83774 | EST: $2,750+ PCGS 6, NGC 8, CAC 5. There are only 2 graded PR66+ DCAM, none finer. The last one to sell was in January 2014 which sold for $6,463. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $7,500. Another great example in this sale. If you are building a set, this is another great opportunity. PCGS # 93772 | EST: $6,500+32
LOT 44 LOT 45 3CN 1882 PCGS PR67 DCAM CAC 3CN 1884 PCGS PR67 DCAM CAC Of the 1,500 coins minted, only 3 are graded DCAM in all By the mid-1880s, the mintages went up dramatically, butgrades at PCGS, this one is tied for FINEST. The deeply mirrored the quality of striking did not. Very few survive with full DCAM fields are like liquid mercury, extremely reflective and offering contrast, and this one is tied for FINEST of those precious few.exceptional clarity! The devices are likewise exceptionally clean The deep, icy mirrors shine through the reflective surfaces andand offer a beautiful white frost that contrasts amazingly with the the reliefs are fully struck and highly frosted. The quality and reflective mirrors. The quality is unimprovable! eye appeal are AMAZING.PCGS 2, NGC 1, CAC 2. This is the only one to sell in auction, PCGS 3, NGC 2, CAC 3. The only PCGS coin to sell was NOT realizing $9,400 in the recent ANA auction. The CU value is CAC and sold for $10,575 in April 2015. There are no other$12,500. If you are building the finest set of Proof 3CN, here is comps. The CU value is $10,000. It is amazing how rare DCAM another important opportunity for you! 3CNs are. Equally as rare are the opportunities to buy one; DO PCGS # 93778 | EST: $9,000+ NOT let this one slip away! PCGS # 93780 | EST: $8,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 33
LOT 46 LOT 47 5C 1874 PCGS PR67 CAC 5C 1903 PCGS MS67 Superior quality mirrors are watery and untoned. Sharply struck Great eye appeal! Highly lustrous with satin-like cartwheels that swirl around both sides. The design elements are sharply struck and quite attractive with zero imperfections to be found. and the surfaces exceptionally clean. Among the finest half dozen Only 700 proofs were struck. PCGS 11, NGC 5, CAC 6. One of the graded by PCGS, and none are graded finer. 11 graded is a PR67+, the finest graded non-CAMEO. The last PCGS 6, NGC 3. The last PCGS coin to sell brought $4,230 in an PCGS/CAC coin sold back in July 2015 for $3,290; more recently a October 2016 auction. The current PCGS Price Guide value is non-CAC brought $2,820. PCGS assigns a value of $4,000 in their price guide. A lovely PR type coin, a date that is not always seen. $6,250. A vibrant coin worthy of strong bidding competition from the Registry collector. PCGS # 3828 | EST: $2,500+ PCGS # 3864 | EST: $3,500+ LOT 48 5C 1889 PCGS PR67 CAC LOT 49 Among the highest graded PCGS PR 1889 nickels, and it is highly doubtful that among the non-CAM issues, there can be 5C 1889 PCGS PR67 more than a few that rival this superb gem’s eye appeal.The Spectacularly toned! This superb GEM is a delight to behold. The surfaces are expertly preserved and showing a delicate gold with rainbow accents here and there. With proof nickels of the reflectivity and clean surfaces are just a part of the story here; era, the polished die finish wore away quickly, which is why coins the eye appeal is broadened by superb toning, especially on the with cameo designations are so scarce, and the finish turns to a more satiny semi-lustrous with hints of reflectivity. The devices reverse. This is Mother Nature’s gift to PR Liberty nickels! The for the most part are very crisply struck. The eye appeal is strong surfaces are clean and icy smooth and the eye appeal is wonderful. with this one. PCGS 11, NGC 21. It has been over two years since the last PCGS coin sold, realizing $2,585 in October 2014. That coin PCGS 11, NGC 21, CAC 4. The last PCGS/CAC coin to sell was could not hold a candle to this one in terms of overall eye appeal back in February 2014, realizing nearly $6,500. The last PCGS, and physical quality. The current PCGS Price Guide value is non-CAC coin also sold in 2014, in an October sale, realizing $4,500 This coin should bring a premium bid from someone $2,825. The current CU value is listed at $4,000. There are none graded finer at PCGS with the non-CAM designation, and there is assembling a set of superb toned PR Lib nickels. only 1 PR67 CAM. This is a prize for a registry collector. PCGS # 3887 | EST: $2,200+ PCGS # 3887 | EST: $2,800+34
LOT 50 5C 1892 PCGS PR67 CAM Deep mirrors shine throughout and they beam from across the room and contrast with the frosty design devices. Boldly struck throughout and display a pleasing dusting of light gold. Amongthe best graded by PCGS and should command serious attention from bidders. PCGS 5, NGC 9. There is one finer, graded 67+ CAM. This great LOT 52 coin has great eye appeal and should bring a premium price. Only 1 PR67 CAM graded by PCGS (and was CAC approved) 5C 1898 PCGS PR67 CAM has ever sold in auction, realizing $5,581 in August 2014. Aside Superb quality mirrors beam from across the room. The mirrors from that, only NGC coins have sold, the most recent selling for are like quicksilver, deep and bold. The sharply struck reliefs are frosty white and contrast beautifully with the black mirrors. The$3,760 in August 2015. Keep in mind the sole 67+ realized $8,225 surfaces are smooth and completely blemish free. A superior in November 2014. The current CU price is $3,500. This coin is exceptionally fine and belongs in a top quality set. quality GEM. PCGS # 83890 | EST: $2,750+ LOT 51 PCGS 10, NGC 2, CAC 7. Three of the PCGS coins are 67+, none are finer. The last three have sold in the $4,000 to $5,000 5C 1893 PCGS PR67+ CAMEO CAC range and the current PCGS Price Guide value is $3,650. If youWhat a tremendous borderline ULTRA black and white cameo GEM! wish to own one of the finest 1898 CAMEO proof nickels, here is your chance! Good luck. PCGS # 3732 | EST: $2,800+Borderline Ultra deep mirrors are so fine you can shave using them. They have remarkable clarity, cleanliness, and a nearly blindingreflection. The mirrors do appear black (a positive term). Miss Libertyand the details are thickly frosted and iridescent white. Everything is needle sharp in strike too. The eye appeal is jaw dropping! PCGS 15, NGC 8, CAC 13. PCGS has graded 4 coins in PR67+ Cameo - NONE have graded any higher. The current Collectors Universe Value is $5,650. These also have been smacked down hard for no reason by the market. It should be noted, the last PCGS NON-CAC to sell brought $3,760 in a July 2015 auctionsale. If you’re building a GEM black and white set or just love cool coins, this coin is a must buy! PCGS # 83891 | EST: $3,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 35
LOT 54 5C 1906 PCGS PR66 CAM A bold GEM with glorious deep mirrors and pleasing frosty reliefs. The fields and devices are free from any unsightly toning or hairlines. We note a tiny fleck or two that are on the lower obverse. LOT 53 PCGS 26, NGC 12. It has been over a year since the last PCGS graded example sold, realizing $764 and the CU price is $1,200. 5C 1901 PCGS PR67+ CAM CAC An NGC PR66* CAM sold for $1,293 in the 2016 ANA auction. A This GEM is the singular FINEST graded at PCGS, and borders on a DCAM designation. The mirrors are deep, your eye is drawn to pleasing gem. them and cannot turn away! The boldly struck devices are highly frosted and the contrast is eye arresting. The surfaces are clean, PCGS # 83904 | EST: $600+ crisp, and smooth. The quality is exceptional and unimprovable! PCGS 14, NGC 8, CAC 10. This is the ONLY PR67+ CAM graded by either service, has never sold in auction. The most recent regular PCGS/CAC PR67 CAM sold in September 2015 for $2,585, and before that, they were regularly bringing over $4,000. The current PCGS Price Guide Value of a 67+ CAM is $4,900 and keep in mind that our Regency 15 Auction had a PR67+ DCAM that sold in excess of $15,000. Opportunity knocks loud here. PCGS # 83899 | EST: $4,000+36
THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS ANGEL DEEL’S LOT 55 COLLECTION OF TONED 5C 1913 TYPE 1. PCGS MS68 CAC BUFFALO NICKELS A truly spectacular way to begin this great collection of Buffalo nickels. Virtual perfection! A bold strike has left every detail fully rendered, from BUILT OVER THE COURSE OF MANY YEARS BY the Indian’s braid and feathers. All the definition of the bison’s head, BUFFALO NICKEL SPECIALIST ANDY SKRABALAK haunches, and the mound that he stands on are seemingly chiseled they are so sharp. In addition to an amazing strike, the luster radiates AND HIS WIFE ALYNNE,THIS IS THE FINEST COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS TO a vibrant satin bloom that bursts through the soft rainbow iridescent EVER BE AUCTIONED OFF. HAVING ACCESS TO toning. This coin is about as perfect as you could hope to find in a THE FINEST BUFFALO NICKELS TO APPEAR ON circulation strike Buffalo! Not only is the technical quality all there and THE MARKET,THE SKRABALAKS AGGRESSIVELY BOUGHT THE BEST OF THE BEST TO APPEAR. AS then some, the eye appeal is nothing short of superb. FINER, OR BETTER TONED EXAMPLES APPEARED,THEY WOULD UPGRADE THEIR SET. MANY OF THE PCGS 17, NGC 13, CAC 5. There are NONE graded finer at eitherCOINS ARE AT THE TOP OF THE POPULATION AND service. It has been over two years since the last PCGS MS68 CAC ‘13 Type 1 nickel has sold in an auction sale, and that coin, which EACH IS EXQUISITELY TONED. realized $15,275 (in a September 2014 auction) had no where near the exceptional eye appeal that this monster coin has. A few months earlier THIS WONDERFUL SET IS NOW BEING BROKEN one sold for $22,325. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at UP AND SOLD AS A HIGHLIGHT COLLECTION IN $14,000, and there is almost no doubt in our minds that this coin willOUR REGENCY 19 AUCTION. ON THE EVENING OF far exceed that level. Our consignor notes that he had purchased five DECEMBER 15, COLLECTORS WILL FINALLY BE different 1913 Type 1 nickels to include in this set before finding thisABLE TO ADD THESE GREAT COINS TO THEIR SETS. one that had the absolute best color and eye appeal. As the collector THESE ARE THE COINS THAT BUFFALO NICKEL who will end up with this SUPERB GEM, be glad that he took the time COLLECTORS DREAM ABOUT, AND THIS SET HAS MADE A HUGE IMPRESSION ON COLLECTORS and effort to locate this one so you won’t have to. Good luck! WHEREVER IT WAS DISPLAYED. PCGS # 3915 | EST: $12,000+LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 37
THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 56 LOT 57 5C 1913-D TYPE 1. PCGS MS67+ CAC 5C 1913-S TYPE 1. PCGS MS67+ CAC Another spectacular Type 1. The strike is bold and strong Beautiful rings of iridescent rainbow toning grip the rims of both throughout on both sides; each device is seemingly sculpted out of the obverse and reverse of this stunning 13-S Type 1. While the the planchet. A very pretty pastel iridescent bullseye pattern shows centers are mostly nickel-silver, they are haloed by superb rings clear periwinkle around a center of a pinkish-orange rose. The of rose, orange, gold, and hints of aqua. The strike is bold, all the brilliantly satin frost truly catches the light and brings the hues to life. details on both sides are accentuated by the glowing satiny mint The technical quality of this superb gem is incredible, and this coin frost. A wonderful capstone to the 1-year only subtype; this and has a look that will make even the most jaded collector fall in love. the previous two lots would make a very special mini-collection on PCGS 71, NGC 17, CAC 25. Only 4 of the 71 MS67s at PCGS their own! have been assigned the coveted “+”, and there are none at NGC. Only three are graded MS68 combined between PCGS PCGS 26, NGC 17, CAC 10. Only TWO are graded MS67+ at and NGC (and neither is CAC approved). NO MS67+ has ever PCGS, and only a single MS68 is finer at that service (at NGC sold in auction. The most recent regular 67 sold for $2,350 in there is a single 67+ and one 68). This will be the first 67+ to sell in December 2015, and the only MS68 to sell in auction brought auction from either service. The last PCGS 67 CAC to sell brought $32,200 a dozen years ago. PCGS suggests a value of $3,750, $5,640 in May 2015, and an NGC MS68 sold for $12,650 back in but fundamentally, this seems too low, as even regular 67s have January 2012. The PCGS Price Guide value is currently listed at sold in the $4,000-$6,000 range in the last five years. This is likely $9,500. Our consignor notes that this is the best example of the the highest grade example that will be available for quite a long date that he has ever seen. Clearly this coin is very choice for the time. If you are building a top tier Registry Set of Buffalo nickels, grade. Until one day in the future the sole PCGS MS68 is sold, this or just appreciate beautiful SUPERB quality type coins, be sure to will likely be the FINEST 13-S Type 1 you will have a chance to bid bid on this amazing 13-D. on. Good luck. PCGS # 3916 | EST: $4,000+ PCGS # 3917 | EST: $8,000+38
THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 58 LOT 59 5C 1913 TYPE 2. PCGS MS67+ CAC 5C 1913-D TYPE 2. PCGS MS65 CAC Brilliant mint luster provides a backlight to the fantastic emerald, Since the TONING, along with grade and quality is the focus of therose, teal, and gold and they blend together beautifully over crisply Angel Dee’s Collection, it is not surprising that higher grade coinsstruck devices. Tied with four others for finest graded, our consignor has handled 4 out of the 5 graded 67+ and he notes that this one were passed over for this beauty. A softly glowing satin gloss has the best color. As to be expected the technical qualities are shines under a dusting of rich golden-amber color hugs the rims, while tinges of rose-gold blend throughout. Typically strike shows amazing and they eye appeal is superb. only a hint of weakness on the buffalo’s shoulder. Using a strong PCGS 28, NGC 12, CAC 10. As mentioned above, there are only glass, we cannot find any singularly distracting marks or ticks. 5 graded 67+ at PCGS and this one possesses the best color of the four that our consignor has handled. There are NONE graded PCGS 155, NGC 82, CAC 29. Don’t let the pops fool you, since higher at PCGS, and NGC has not awarded a + to any 67s and 2011, there have only been 10 PCGS/CAC MS65 13-D Type 2s there are no 68s. The only PCGS/CAC example in 67+ to sell in sold in auction, the most recent in June 2016 for $1,763 and the auction brought $14,100 in a March 2015 auction. That coin was current PCGS Price Guide is $1,450. This highly eye appealingvery nicely toned, but much darker and uneven on the reverse. This coin clearly possesses the better overall look of the two pieces. GEM is certainly worthy of a premium bid! The current PCGS Price Guide value is $10,000 and with such an PCGS # 3923 | EST: $1,300+ amazingly eye appealing coin, all bets are off! Good luck! PCGS # 3921 | EST: $10,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 39
THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 60 LOT 61 5C 1913-S TYPE 2. PCGS MS66 5C 1914 PCGS MS67 Boldly struck from clashed dies, this lovely gem shows a soft luster A brilliant SUPERB gem with an amazing eye appeal. A rich with very appealing champagne and peach on the obverse. The glossy luster accents the boldly defined devices on both sides. The dies imparted exacting detail when this coin was struck, all reverse displays a light champagne color with subtle tinges of the details of the Indian’s braid and feathers are crisp, as are tangerine hues. The strike is bold throughout and the clash marks the minute details of the buffalo’s furry hyde along the neck and haunches. But it is the combination of exacting strike, luster and add character. the wonderful subtle rainbow hues that give this coin its bold visual allure. Narrow bands of rainbow iridescent hues at the rims frame PCGS 35, NGC 13. A mere four are graded as MS67 as finest at both obverse and reverse. To look at this coin is to truly marvel at PCGS. The most recent sale of a PCGS graded MS66 13-S Type 2 was in April 2016, which realized $4,230, and was CAC-approved. the work that mother nature can do on a coin. That said, PCGS 66s have been selling $4,700 and while the PCGS 29, NGC 9. There is a single MS67+ finer at PCGS and none current PCGS Price Guide is $5,000, there are multiple examples are graded finer at NGC. Don’t let the pops fool you there have only that have sold for as much as $9,200. The last MS67 sold for been 23 auction sales of a 14-D in PCGS MS67 going back over $28,200 back in April 2014. Since most 13-S Type 2s do not have the last 13 years, that is less than 2 per year since 2003. The most recent example sold in the 2016 FUN auction, realizing $5,875 in an this kind of color, we would not be surprised if we saw strong auction that took place at the valley of the current market cycle. That bidding for this colorful gem. coin did not have nearly the lovely visual appeal this one does. The current PCGS Price Guide lists a value of $6,000. Another lovely early PCGS # 3923 | EST: $4,000+ GEM from the Angel Dee’s Collection, one that will no doubt inspire a spirited bout of bidding from advanced Buffalo nickel specialists! PCGS # 3924 | EST: $5,000+40
THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 62 LOT 63 5C 1914-D PCGS MS67 5C 1914-S PCGS MS65+ Tied for finest graded by PCGS and aside from the fine technical A vibrant glossy mint luster accentuates the delicate goldenquality of this superb gem the overall visual appeal is stunning. Swaths highlights. The color and luster truly amplify the crisply defined of rainbow patina create two beautiful halos, one on the obverse and design elements. A tough coin to find in higher mint state grades, one on the reverse. The allure is truly heavenly. Viewing this coin in a the population drops off dramatically in grades higher thanlight, the bands of colors, especially the red, green and gold really pop. MS65. The naked eye appeal is very nice it does hold up to The strike is bold and all the details are nearly full, and is essentially, save for a touch of flatness on the buffalo’s shoulder. You will be very scrutiny when viewed with a strong glass. hard pressed to find a lovelier example for the date. PCGS 4, NGC 0 (in MS65+). While there are a number of finer coins at PCGS, clearly this coin has special attributes that PCGS 8, NGC 1. The most recent PCGS MS67 example sold in December 2015 for $17,625, and that CAC approved gem did not higher grade specimens lacked when assembling the Angel have the beautiful color that this coin does, furthermore, that coin had Dee’s Collection. Only a single 65+ has sold at auction, a CAC sold in an August 2012 auction for $23,500. The current PCGS Price approved coin that realized $2,580 in March 2016. More recently Guide value is listed at $21,500. While not CAC-approved, this coin a PCGS MS65 CAC sold for $2,820 and a PCGS MS66 sold for possesses an eye arresting look that is truly beautiful. Our consignor $5,875. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $3,250. notes that the look is stunning, especially for this tough date and grade. We feel this coin is a contender for inclusion into another world A pretty coin like this should bring a solid result. class Buffalo nickel set, and we think it should see some very active bidding activity from specialists. Good luck to all the bidders, and PCGS # 3926 | EST: $2,500+ congratulations in advance to the winner! PCGS # 3925 | EST: $17,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 41
THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 64 LOT 65 5C 1915 PCGS MS67+ 5C 1915-D PCGS MS66+ Bold sunset hues frame the obverse and a satiny-lustrous sheen One of the prettiest examples of the date that can be imagined. backlights the toning. When viewed under a light, the colors are Tied for second finest certified by PCGS, there are a mere three enlivened, with rich orange and gold, with hints of violet and lilac coins graded MS67 that are numerically finer. This satiny lustrous that appear when the coin is rotated. The reverse is perhaps a touch more understated than the obverse, but its technical quality GEM displays a stunning array of multicolored toning, with is superb. Well struck and nearly flawless (we note a tiny dot on the very pretty shades of lilac, rose, pink, and sky blue iridescence lower obverse). The strike is full and is among the absolute finest dominating. A very crisp strike was imparted by an exacting strike and this coin has been lovingly cared for since the moment it fell certified by either PCGS or NGC. from the dies at the Denver mint. PCGS 5, NGC 0 (for MS67+). NONE ARE FINER. We note the last PCGS 3, NGC 0 (for MS66+). Both services count three coins example was not anywhere near as pretty as this GEM, nor was it each at MS67 as finest. Only a single MS66+ has ever sold at as well struck. It realized $4,465 in a weak auction, the 2016 FUN auction, a CAC-approved example that brought $7,050 in April 2014. No finer PCGS graded coin has ever sold in auction; there auction. The previous two MS67+s to sell were both CAC and are four records for NGC MS67s, the two most recent selling for realized $4,700 and $5,640 respectively in the 2015 FUN auction $10,350 (the most recent in April 2012). The current PCGS Price Guide values 66+ for $7,500. While no PCGS MS67 has ever sold sale, and again, neither had the very pretty toning of this coin. in auction, the PCGS value is listed at $45,000, and were one The current PCGS Price Guide value is We would expect some to appear, it would certainly generate a fierce bidding war. This could be the highest grade example to appear at auction for many competition to add this superb 1915 to any top tier set. years, so if you are need a high grade piece for your set, don’t let PCGS # 3927 | EST: $4,000+ this opportunity pass you by. PCGS # 3928 | EST: $6,000+42
THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 66 LOT 67 5C 1915-S PCGS MS65+ 5C 1916 PCGS MS67+ A richly toned example, featuring olive-gold, rose, and apricot This is the SINGLE FINEST PCGS graded example of this date! Thehues that coat well struck devices and expertly preserved fields. technical quality is all there and then some! A rich, glowing luster The details are razor sharp and seem to be chiseled out of the highlights the boldly defined design devices. A beautiful golden-planchet. A satiny mint bloom, really brings the colors to life when peach-champagne accents both sided and really brings out the rotated in a light, especially on the reverse. stunning detail and essentially pristine surfaces. One of the prettiest Buffalo nickels in this set and certainly worthy as its designation as the PCGS 4, NGC 0 (for MS65+). Only one 65+ has ever sold in auction which realized $2,585 in the 2016 FUN auction, often finest example extant.noted for its bad timing when the stock market, oil, and gold were all falling in value, creating a perfect storm that took the wind PCGS 1, NGC 0. There is a 68 on the NGC Census, and that coin, out of the market’s sails. More recently a regular PCGS MS65 which also boasted pretty toning, last sold in auction back in January sold for $2,703 and a PCGS/CAC MS66 realized $4,700. The 2012, selling for $14,375. It has been nearly two years since a regularcurrent PCGS Price Guide lists MS65+ at $3,750, perhaps as anaggregate of the recent APRs. While there are a number graded PCGS MS67 (Population of 21) sold, realizing $7,050 in February higher, we do like this coin for its gem quality and rich toning. 2015. The current PCGS Price Guide suggests a value of $12,500, a level that may well be surpassed when this SUPERB GEM crosses the PCGS # 3929 | EST: $2,500+ block. Our consignor purchased this FINEST PCGS 1916 from the late David Weygant, and it is not surprising because David had great taste in coins. Lovingly cared for since the moment it left the mint, no doubt the next owner will lovingly care for it as well. An important opportunity for the advanced Registry Set collector that demands the absolute finest graded examples. PCGS # 3930 | EST: $9,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 43
THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 68 LOT 69 5C 1916-D PCGS MS66+ CAC 5C 1916-S PCGS MS65 A superb example, tied for FINEST certified by either service. A soft Another magnificently toned GEM, which despite its modest numeric grade (in relation to the other coins in the Angel Dee’s golden-peach pastel iridescence dominates while light rose and set) this coin has a superb look. Rich rainbow toning with every magenta hues can be picked up when the sultry-lustrous surfaces shade on the spectrum, displaying pretty blues, teals, pinks and are rotated in a light. The surface quality is excellent and the strike oranges. A satin luster combines with the spectacular color and is bold and full, with complete definition throughout on both sides, surprisingly enough, as the dies had clashed and began to crack crisp strike to create a very special looking 16-S nickel. on the obverse (see the B in LIBERTY). PCGS 20, NGC 6, CAC 9. There are a mere two coins graded 66+, PCGS 96, NGC 46. The last one to sell realized $2,233 in March and none are graded finer at either service. The other 66+ was also 2016. That coin lacked the strike and beautiful color that this GEM CAC-approved and it realized nearly $25,000 back in the 2014 FUN displays. And don’t let the pops fool you, less than a handful of auction. That coin had some flecks here and there, absent on the examples sell in auction each year. The current PCGS Price Guide presently offered SUPERB GEM. Our consignor notes that this is the lists the value at $2,350, and we expect this one will realize a very nicest example of this date that he had ever seen, and we would strong price for the beauty. have to agree with him on that fact. We anticipate that the advanced PCGS # 3933 | EST: $2,000+ Registry set collectors will be out in force when this coin crosses the block, and it would not be surprising if a record price is realized when the gavel finally falls. PCGS # 3932 | EST: $20,000+44
THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 70 LOT 71 5C 1917 PCGS MS67+ 5C 1917-D PCGS MS65+ This is the consignor’s favorite coin in the entire set, and it is not Pretty in pink and green. Soft emerald and pastel pink hues arehard to see why! The beauty is mesmerizing (his words)! A beautiful joined by shades of gold and peach, primarily on the obverse.satin like luster swirls on both sides and it accentuates a rich sunset toned crescent on the obverse. Stunning orange-gold lightens to a The color is very pleasing, albeit somewhat “funky” as well.silvery-blue towards the center. Likewise on the reverse, a crescent The strike is blunt, showing the typical details for this date. The of toning, more beautiful than on the obverse shows richer shades dies were clashed before this coin was struck, perhaps part of that include violet and magenta hues. This superb gem is also displays an extremely crisp strike on both sides; the hair details on the cause of the areas of light flatness at the highpoints. The the Indian and the buffalo are fully defined. Overall the coin has a surfaces are clean and free of all but the smallest spots. The pleasing satin-like mint frost is picked up by the light and really great look, so the few microscopic ticks can be overlooked. brings out the beauty of the toning. PCGS 1, NGC 0. This is the SOLE MS67+ certified by PCGS, and only two are finer; both at MS68. We have not seen either of the 68s PCGS 5. NGC 0. None of the 65+s have sold in auction. To give some perspective, the last PCGS MS65 was CAC-approved and sold in auction. NGC has nothing graded higher than 67 on their Census. The last PCGS MS67 sold in August 2014 for $4,847. None realized $3,760 in April 2016 and a PCGS MS66 CAC sold forof the recent MS67s had any color to speak of, let alone the gorgeous $7,050 in the 2016 ANA auction. In July 2012, an NGC-66 sold color that this superb gem exhibits on both sides. The eye appeal for $5,750. The current PCGS Price Guide lists MS65+ at $3,250. is amazing. The current PCGS Price Guide for MS67 is $6,500 and in 67+ it is listed at $9,250. We suspect more than a few people will A lovely coin that should see some good activity. place bids on this coin when it crosses the block. Good luck! PCGS # 3935 | EST: $2,800+ PCGS # 3934 | EST: $5,500+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 45
THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 72 LOT 73 5C 1917-S PCGS MS65+ CAC 5C 1918 PCGS MS66 Superbly visually alluring! Deep envelope type toning in shades of Vibrant, glossy mint frost provides a pleasant backlight to the soft apricot, peach, and tangerine. Under the rich shades is a light satin lavender and periwinkle tones. In certain protected areas of the glow that makes the color sparkle under a light. Both sides are fully design a richer rose and gold hues are seen. The strike is blunt, struck and display full, crisp devices, which is rarely seen on this with some flatness of detail, but the surfaces are generally of very date. The eye appeal is great! pleasing overall quality. PCGS 88, NGC 67, CAC 9. Only three coins are graded 65+ and PCGS 62, NGC 8. There are 11 reported higher, MS67 the only 25 coins have been assigned a higher grade at PCGS, 24 are finest. The last PCGS graded MS66 to sell was in April 2016. 66 and a single 66+ stands at the apex of the Pop Report. The only That coin was CAC-approved and realized $1,763. That was a PCGS MS65+ did not have the stunning eye appeal that this gem very low price, considering that most examples sold since 2002 have sold for more than $2,000 and some have broken into the possesses, but it was also not CAC-approved. It sold for $4,406 $3,000-$4,000 range, which is why the current PCGS Price Guide in April 2014. A PCGS 65 CAC sold in April 2016 for $3,400, and value is listed at $3,150. Keep in mind that the last MS67 to sell a NON-CAC MS66 sold for $5,758 in the 2016 ANA auction. The was an NGC coin that sold for $10,575 in November 2012, and the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $5,500. If you like really last PCGS MS67 was back in February 2010, selling for $23,000. pretty toning, you will like this coin a lot. We can see this coin selling The color and luster combine for a very eye appealing gem. for a very strong price. PCGS # 3937 | EST: $1,800+ PCGS # 3936 | EST: $3,000+46
THE ANGEL DEE’SCOLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELSLOT 74 LOT 75 5C 1918-D PCGS MS66+ 5C 1918-S PCGS MS65+ CAC This coin calls you from across the room. The luster shines and The final coin needed to complete the set. That is a strongswirls along both sides and brings the pale pastel hues to life. Light testimonial to how this date comes. A bold strike is highlighted by arobin’s egg blue and soft lemon-gold tone accentuates the smooth vibrant, glossy lustrous sheen on both sides. Pleasing, light pastel surfaces and well struck features of the design. Among the TOP 3 iridescent blue and gold tones are seen all over both sides of this coins graded for the date, there is only a single MS67 graded by carefully preserved, condition rarity. This GEM sits tied for secondeither PCGS or NGC. That coin is likely long off the market, making finest certified by PCGS, and has finer eye appeal than most this nearly SUPERB coin the finest available for collectors. Ourconsignor specifically noted the great eye appeal, and he even said examples of the date. that he thought it would grade 67. PCGS 39, NGC 18, CAC 8. Only 4 are graded 65+ and a SINGLE coin is graded MS66 as finest at PCGS. This is a date that when PCGS 2, NGC 0. There are 24 regular 66s on the Pop Report as offered in gem grades, does very well in auction. This coin last sold well. It has been nearly 3 years since the other 66+ sold, realizing at auction for $24,675 in the 2015 FUN auction. This is by far the $9,518 in March 2014. That coin had some carbon flecks around most eye appealing example that is available for collectors. Keepthe buffalo’s head, a feature that is lacking on the presently offered in mind the single MS66 has not appeared at auction in a PCGSGEM. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $13,000. Until holder, and the estimated PCGS value is $100,000 should it everthe MS67 comes to market, this is the FINEST available to collectors appear. The current PCGS Price Guide value for MS65+ is $29,500. and we anticipate strong bidding from the top PCGS Registry set This coin, with its superb eye appeal, ultra-gem quality, rank ascollectors, who will all be vying to own one of the best 18-D nickels probable second finest for this condition rarity, and CAC accolades, should realize a record price. We know that any top set collectors in existence. We wish all bidders, good luck. will want to add this coin to their sets. PCGS # 3938 | EST: $9,500+ PCGS # 3940 | EST: $16,000+ LEGENDAUCTIONS.COM 47
THE ANGEL DEE’S COLLECTION OF TONED BUFFALO NICKELS LOT 76 5C 1919 PCGS MS67+ LOT 77 Va Va Voom! This coin is AMAZING. Sleek, smooth surfaces, carefully preserved over the course of nearly 100 years retain all the 5C 1919-D PCGS MS66+ full satin luster imparted by the dies at the time of striking. Clearly The SOLE FINEST graded by either PCGS or NGC! Ever so close this coin sat for years in an old album, which imparted rings of to MS67! This coin displays a wonderful eye appeal that combines rainbow tones on the peripheries of both obverse and reverse. Very well struck, this uber quality-superb gem is tied for finest graded a strong strike, a wealth of silky luster, pretty color, and clean, by PCGS. Even using a strong glass, we cannot find a single flaw. distraction free surfaces. Apricot and champagne toning blend The eye appeal is stunning, the coin’s allure captures your eye even with a hint of gold and a wealth of icy blue on the obverse and an from arm’s length. This is a date that was clearly not well preserved. arc of rainbow appears in front of the buffalo, and a peachy-rose Our consignor has a personal connection to this coin; his mother continues around the rim. With the aid of a strong glass, a solitary was born in 1919, and he felt compelled to include the absolute finest, most eye appealing example as an honor to her in his set. fleck can be spotted between the buffalo’s hind legs. This cataloger believes he was successful there. PCGS 1, NGC 0. There are 18 reported in MS66 at PCGS. None are finer than the presently offered MS66+. Going back to 2002 PCGS 2, NGC 1. There are 17 graded MS67 at PCGS without the “+”. Despite a mintage of nearly 61 million, there are fewer than 1,000 in our auction database, we have seen MS66s sell between $10,000 and $15,000 in general. With the current PCGS Price graded MS65 or higher combined by PCGS and NGC (and clearly Guide value at listed at $14,500 for MS66s and a conjectural there is duplication in the submissions). There is a single NGC MS68 $18,500 for this MS66+, we think this coin will sell for a record reported, and last sold in auction in January 2012 for $14,950. No price. If you are building the top ranking set on the PCGS PCGS MS67+ has ever sold at auction, the only 67+ was the brilliant Registry, you NEED this coin! and untoned Eric Newman coin that sold in November 2013 for PCGS # 3942 | EST: $12,500+ $11,750 (NGC/CAC). The current PCGS Price Guide lists a value of $20,000, and while that might be a tad optimistic, we think that it will certainly bring more than the Newman coin. PCGS # 3941 | EST: $12,500+48
Search
Read the Text Version
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
- 15
- 16
- 17
- 18
- 19
- 20
- 21
- 22
- 23
- 24
- 25
- 26
- 27
- 28
- 29
- 30
- 31
- 32
- 33
- 34
- 35
- 36
- 37
- 38
- 39
- 40
- 41
- 42
- 43
- 44
- 45
- 46
- 47
- 48
- 49
- 50
- 51
- 52
- 53
- 54
- 55
- 56
- 57
- 58
- 59
- 60
- 61
- 62
- 63
- 64
- 65
- 66
- 67
- 68
- 69
- 70
- 71
- 72
- 73
- 74
- 75
- 76
- 77
- 78
- 79
- 80
- 81
- 82
- 83
- 84
- 85
- 86
- 87
- 88
- 89
- 90
- 91
- 92
- 93
- 94
- 95
- 96
- 97
- 98
- 99
- 100
- 101
- 102
- 103
- 104
- 105
- 106
- 107
- 108
- 109
- 110
- 111
- 112
- 113
- 114
- 115
- 116
- 117
- 118
- 119
- 120
- 121
- 122
- 123
- 124
- 125
- 126
- 127
- 128
- 129
- 130
- 131
- 132
- 133
- 134
- 135
- 136
- 137
- 138
- 139
- 140
- 141
- 142
- 143
- 144
- 145
- 146
- 147
- 148
- 149
- 150
- 151
- 152
- 153
- 154
- 155
- 156
- 157
- 158
- 159
- 160
- 161
- 162
- 163
- 164
- 165
- 166
- 167
- 168
- 169
- 170
- 171
- 172
- 173
- 174
- 175
- 176
- 177
- 178
- 179
- 180
- 181
- 182
- 183
- 184
- 185
- 186
- 187
- 188
- 189
- 190
- 191
- 192
- 193
- 194
- 195
- 196
- 197
- 198
- 199
- 200
- 201
- 202
- 203
- 204
- 205
- 206
- 207
- 208
- 209
- 210
- 211
- 212
- 213
- 214
- 215
- 216
- 217
- 218
- 219
- 220
- 221
- 222
- 223
- 224
- 225
- 226
- 227
- 228
- 229
- 230
- 231
- 232
- 233
- 234
- 235
- 236
- 237
- 238
- 239
- 240
- 241
- 242
- 243
- 244
- 245
- 246
- 247
- 248
- 249
- 250
- 251
- 252
- 253
- 254
- 255
- 256
- 257
- 258
- 259
- 260
- 261
- 262
- 263
- 264
- 265
- 266
- 267
- 268
- 269
- 270
- 271
- 272
- 273
- 274
- 275
- 276
- 277
- 278
- 279
- 280
- 281
- 282
- 283
- 284
- 285
- 286
- 287
- 288
- 289
- 290
- 291
- 292
- 293
- 294
- 295
- 296
- 297
- 298
- 299
- 300
- 301
- 302
- 303
- 304
