Legend Rare Coin Auctions Regency Auction 27 Catalog

LOT 390 LOT 391 50C 1939-S OREGON. PCGS MS67 CAC 50C 1926 SESQUICENTENNIAL. PCGS MS65+ CACA very scarce SUPERB GEM survivor of only 3,005 minted.Sharply struck with every minute detail fully rendered--even From the Huron Hills Collection. the infant riding in the conastoga wagon is fully defined.Some very pale, pearly iridescent gold is brought out by the The Sesquicentennial half dollar is one of the hardest early strong satin-like luster. The eye appeal is very strong. halves to find nice, regardless of grade. Unlike other early commems, the silver surfaces did not tone nicely. Likewise, PCGS 120, NGC 104, CAC 66. The current PCGS Price is listed at $1,100 and these are VERY RARE any finer--PCGS the low relief design rarely comes fully struck up. Thehas graded 21 coins finer. A very pleasing SUPERB coin for presently offered PQ GEM is the flip opposite! Washington and Coolidge’s portraits are crisply defined, as are the details any 50-piece type set or 144-complete set. on the Liberty Bell reverse. Exceptionally vibrant luster for the type brings out the subtle rainbow peripheral toning. The PCGS# 9354| ESTIMATE: $1,000+ eye appeal is excellent! PCGS 377, NGC 301, CAC 90. There are only 17 coins graded MS65+ at PCGS and merely twelve graded finer. The last one to sell brought $7,500 in April 2018. Prior to that these were consistently selling in the $3,500 and $4,700 range. Keep in mind that the last PCGS/CAC MS66 to sell brought $22,325 in our December 2017 Regency Auction. This coin is destined for a SUPERB set of commemorative halves. PCGS# 9374 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ LOT 39250C 1915-S PANAMA-PACIFIC. PCGS MS66 CAC From the Huron Hills Collection.Beautifully toned! The Pan-Pac half dollar is one of the most LOT 393endearing designs of the entire series, and sometimes, they 50C 1920 PILGRIM. PCGS MS67 CACtake on a great palette of color. Blue, gold, russet, olive, andtan toning grace both sides of this PQ GEM. Well struck and From the Huron Hills Collection. very nicely preserved, this one is worthy. Outstanding eye Superb in every way. Totally original toning on both sides appeal defines this GEM. accenting a pleasing satin luster and sharply struck up devices.PCGS 307, NGC 240, CAC 113. The most recent example Free of any distracting marks, eye appeal is excellent! sold for $2,280 in March 2018. The present coin sold PCGS 53, NGC 27, CAC 23. This beautiful coin realized $2,585 previously in April 2009 for $3,220 before selling in the in October 2016, and more recently we sold one for $2,468 in 2018 FUN auction for $2,400. The current CU value is January 2017. Worthy of a premium bid to say the least! $2,750. A lovely GEM for any Classic Commem Set. PCGS# 9357 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ PCGS# 9359 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 199

LOT 394 LOT 395 50C 1936-D RHODE ISLAND. PCGS MS67 CAC 50C 1925 VANCOUOVER. PCGS MS66 We love the look of this GEM! We are not sure why CAC did Ex Paul Denby Collection. not bean it--its got great eye appeal, especially for this type! Flawless! The surfaces are clean and free of any distracting Both the obverse and reverse are framed by narrow bands of marks. The luster is bold and giving off a strong flash under intense rainbow toning. Sharply struck devices are brought out by the satiny pearlescent luster from all over. The eye the beautiful iridescent toning, which is particularly eye catching at the peripheries. Sharply struck, this coin clearly appeal is amazing. ranks among the nicest examples out there. PCGS 385, NGC 266. As is always the case with classic commemorative halves, the prices realized at auction are PCGS 71, NGC 40, CAC 32. This coin sold for $1,440 in all over the place, but the current PCGS Price Guide value December 2017, and the current CU value of $1,000 is way is $1,000. With its beautiful toning, this one should sell in too cheap. Only six coins have graded finer, including the excess of that! MS68 that we sold for a record shattering $43,475 in our May 2018 Regency Auction. PCGS# 9399 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ PCGS# 9364 | ESTIMATE: $1,300+ OUR ESTIMATES LOT 396 The estimates you see published in this catalog are based on 50C 1925 VANCOUVER. PCGS MS67+ CAC HAMMER. Keep in mind that a coin could be either low or high end for the grade, have stunning color or be dull, all of From the Huron Hills Collection. which radically affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be huge price differences within a grade, and we offer estimates as One of the FINEST graded Vancouvers and a coin truly a guide so Collector’s can have a better idea of value. One worthy of its lofty grade and accolades! A billowing, brilliant thing we will never do is offer low ball estimates in order to mint bloom sets both sides of this SUPERB coin aglow. claim stronger sales. Sharply struck up, the devices stand out against essentially These published estimates represent what Legend Rare Coin PERFECT surfaces. A dusting of original toning on both Auctions determines to be an approximate high wholesale obverse and reverse adds to the strong visual allure! value for the coin. The numbers are based upon current PCGS 78, NGC 63, CAC 34. There are only a dozen coins market values, similar trades, auction prices, published graded MS67+ at PCGS, with three finer. The only PCGS/ prices, and a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is no CAC example in 67+ to ever sell in auction realized $4,772 guarantee that the estimated prices are minimums or are exactly what you can expect to get if you attempt to resell in September 2015. This remarkable coin has a similar look, and should realize that or more. PCGS lists a value of them wholesale. $5,750. With only three coins finer, this is a great opportunity We always advise you to view the coins you are interested in to add one of the FINEST examples to your set! and calculate what you’ll pay using as much information as possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask us. We are here to help you! PCGS# 9399 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+200

LOT 397 G$1 1903 L.A. PURCHASE, MCKINLEY. PCGS MS67+ CAC A visually and technically STUNNING superb GEM. This little jewel is just oozing with rich originality. Among the finest graded by PCGS, this piece boasts a brilliant golden surface that drips with a reddish hue over exceptionally gorgeous gold color. Every tiny detail is struck up with full precision and is exacting in its definition. Even the tiny mint made die polish lines are visible in the fields, suggesting an early striking before they wore off the surface. Although 125,000 were initially authorized, the reported net mintage is listed at 17,500 and the remaining pieces were melted due to poor sales. PCGS 128, NGC 123, CAC 65. PCGS has graded 10 in MS67+ with a mere two coins finer (the most recent MS68 to sellbrought a robust $25,850 last year). The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $8,000 and this coin is truly worthy of a premium bid! If you are working on a top quality set, this coin should definitely be added to your collection! PCGS# 7444 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+LOT 398G$1 1904 LEWIS & CLARK. PCGS MS66 CACA very eye appealing, very HIGH END GEM Lewis &Clark dollar. A brilliant, vibrant mint luster swirls on bothsides. The richness of the gold color is very eye arrestingand bold as is the depth of the strike.PCGS 161, NGC 114, CAC 34. Only three PCGS/CACexamples have ever sold in auction. The most recentwas in June 2016, realizing $7,638 and there is an APRfrom January 2014 for $11,750. The current CU value is$7,000 and we know this coin will see very strong, activebidding! It is bound to end up in a SUPERB set ofgold commems!PCGS# 7447 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ LOT 399 G$1 1922 GRANT WITH STAR. PCGS MS68 A simply stunning SUPERB GEM Grant gold dollar! Tied for FINEST graded at PCGS, this coin really is a delight to behold. The surfaces are flawless. Using a strong glass all we are able to see are a few swirling mint made die lines that are common to the type. A rich frosty luster glows on both sides of this impressive example. Every detail is fully struck and the surfaces have a lovely honey orange tone. The eye appeal is amazing! PCGS 5, NGC 10. NONE ARE GRADED FINER! The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $20,000 and there areauction records from 2016 realizing $15,863 and $18,800. You cannot imagine a finer example! Bound for the FINEST set of commemorative gold coins--we will see very strong bidding when this one crosses the block!! PCGS# 7459 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 201

LOT 400 $5 C. BECHTLER 150 GRAINS, 20 CARAT. PCGS AU55 This EXTREMELY RARE Bechtler $5 was struck between 1831 and 1834 in North Carolina. This variety is K-15, which is listed as Rarity-7. It is among the finest graded examples and a variety that is not often seen! For the most part, this coin is well struck, just showing some weakness at the centers. A bold, somewhat reflective luster can be seen among the peripheral lettering which accents even the most minute scuffs. Clearly this coin was struck not long after the dies were polished. The Bechtlers were prolific in their minting of private gold coins during the first U.S. gold rush in the 1830s. Their reputation, unlike some of the firms that came around in California, was impeccable, and even when the Federal mints at Dahlonega and Charlotte opened, the Bechtlers continued to strike coins that circulated along side their Federal counterparts. This series is among the first issues produced by the firm. PCGS 6, NGC 1. This is the Dr. Seymour Dexter coin, sold in May 2013 for $64,625 and again in over December 2017 Regency Auction for $61,688. Dr. Dexter was a specialist in southern territorial gold. While no prior pedigree is noted, he was actively collecting in the 1970s. More recently in the April 2014 sale of the Riverboat Collection and coin sold for $82,250. Before this coin sold in May 2013, another example appeared in auction twice, once in 2008 for $74,750 and again in April 2012 for $78,200. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $90,000. This is a major rarity in the Territorial or Pioneer series, a variety that is rarely offered in auction. This is an opportunity not to be missed! PCGS# 10118 | ESTIMATE: $60,000+202

LOT 401 $10 1849 MOFFAT. PCGS VF35 CAC Ex S.S. Central America, SSCA6992. Kagin-5, or 5a, listed as R-6+. Lovely khaki gold shows light olive gold accents at the rim, while deeper coppery-orange patches can be seen on Liberty’s face, among the stars, and in spots on the reverse. Softness of strike, as normally seen in the central obverse portions of the design, but the peripheral details and the reverse are boldly defined. A surprising amount of luster survives in the protected areas. The eye appeal is excellent for a coin that sat over 130 years at the bottom of the ocean! PCGS 6, NGC 1, CAC 1. This is not the coin that sold for $10,063 in the 2012 FUN auction, the most recent auction sale for any Moffat $10 in any VF or XF grade. Housed in the original gold label PCGS holder. What a RARE and historically significant coin for the collector! PCGS# 10249 | ESTIMATE: $11,000+LOT 402G$1 1873/2 BG-1121.PCGS MS64A newly discovered andcertified example of thisR-7- variety. Fresh out of anold European holding, thiscoin was submitted onceto PCGS and came outTIED FOR FINEST graded.PCGS CoinFacts estimates14 examples survive in allgrades, and the 2003 updateof the Breen-Gillio referenceenumerates 12 examples.Struck by ChristopherFerdinand Mohrig in SanFrancisco, the charming design features a large Indian head on an Octagonal planchet. 1 DOLLAR in wreath CALIFORNIAGOLD above. The die was originally produced and struck with the 1872 date, and then in a very crude attempt to re-engravethe 2 to a 3. The surfaces have a stunning, flashy, prooflike luster with sharply struck devices.PCGS 2, NGC 0. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $5,750. The most recent “comp” was from August 2010where a PCGS MS63 sold for $4,313. We can see this near-GEM bringing a very strong price when it crosses the block!Good luck!PCGS# 10932 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 203

LOT 403 1936-42 PROOF SET PCGS CAC- 35 COINS 1936 PROOF SET 1937 PROOF SET 1938 PROOF SET 1939 PROOF SET 1940 PROOF SET 1941 PROOF SET 1942 PROOF SET204

LOT 4031936-42 PROOF SET PCGS CAC- 35 COINSA fantastic run of ORIGINAL Proof Sets from 1936, 1937, 1938, 1939, 1940, 1941, and 1942. While in an absolute sense,these are not rare, what is exciting here is that every coin is PCGS and CAC certified, which we rarely see. Also it is clear thatthese seven sets are from an old holding, each coin is well matched and has a very similar, totally original look.1936:1C Satin PR64 RB. Pleasing original toning over lovely near-GEM satin surfaces. PCGS # 33315C Satin PR66. Delicate pastel toning over smooth, very high end surfaces. PCGS # 399410C PR65. Glittering, brilliant mirrors shine with just a few minute toning dots. Totally original. PCGS #507125C PR63. Original, boldly reflective, and conservatively graded. PCGS # 597550C PR65. Rich, flashy mirrors beam all over on both sides. Original surfaces do not show any serious lines or flaws. PCGS #66361937:1C PR65 RD. Exquisite, brilliant RED mirrors beam from all over. No mellowing anywhere, or any spots. PCGS # 33385C PR66. Ultra reflective mirrors are the ultimate in clarity. Sharp and beautiful! PCGS # 399610C PR66. Totally original! Pleasing toning graces both sides but does not impede the strong reflection in the fields. PCGS #507225C PR66. A delicate iridescent toning dusts the ultra reflective mirrored fields. Outstanding! PCGS # 597650C PR65. A high end GEM with only the most minute toning dots seen in the fields. Strong eye appeal! PCGS # 66371938:1C PR65 RD. Deep, beaming RED color with just some microflecks. The eye appeal is very high end. PCGS # 33415C PR66. Exceptional, icy blue and clear gold color on ultra reflective mirrors. SUPERB! PCGS # 417510C PR66. Really high end! Deep, brilliant mirrors flash with just a touch of original toning. PCGS # 507325C PR66. A delicate dusting of silver-white iridescent tone. Icy-sleek mirrors beam and reflect boldly. PCGS # 597750C PR66. A GEM Proof Walker! Bold, clean, and clear mirrors beam with strong reflection. PCGS # 66381939:1C PR65 RD. A beautiful GEM original RED cent with exceptional mirrors! PCGS # 33445C Reverse of 1938. PR66. Subtle, pastel blue and rose blend over the highly reflective nickel surfaces. PCGS # 417610C PR67. Minty fresh with amazing reflective mirrored fields that really beam flawlessly. PCGS # 507425C PR66. A lovely GEM that matches the 1938 above. PCGS # 597850C PR66. SUPERB! Ultra smooth, beaming mirrors display only the most subtle toning. PCGS # 66391940:1C PR65 RD. Strong RED mirrored surfaces beam with only the most subtle dusting of iridescence. PCGS # 33475C PR66. WOW! We just love the look of this coin! PCGS # 417710C PR66. Another sumptuous GEM Proof dime with a great look! PCGS # 507525C PR66. The lightest dusting of clear gold. PCGS # 597950C PR65. Pastel gold, rose, and lilac color is brought out by the glittering mirrors. A real GEM! PCGS # 66401941:1C PR64 RD. Lightly toned, but not enough to get out of the RD category. Reflective and very pretty! PCGS # 33505C PR65. Equal in quality to the 1939 and 1940 above. PCGS # 417810C PR66. Lively mirrors and lovely toning. PCGS # 507625C PR66. Light toning at the rims, otherwise just ultra beaming mirrors. PCGS # 598050C PR66. Another GEM Proof Walker. A great looking coin. PCGS # 66411942:1C PR65 RB. High end mirrors are mostly red, with some mottled original toning, typical of what is seen. PCGS # 33525C Type 1. PR66. Another lovely Jefferson 5C with a very well matched look to the other nickels. PCGS # 417910C PR66. Delicate, iridescent pastels over reflective fields. PCGS # 507725C PR65. An originally toned reflective GEM. PCGS # 598150C PR66. Another amazing GEM. PCGS # 6642.Finding original sets from clearly an old collection intact like this is becoming harder and harder. Over the years so many setshave been broken up, this lot allows the new bidder to have the early modern Proof Set collection COMPLETE in one shot!The total combined CU value is $17,375. Do not let this opportunity pass you by!ESTIMATE: $15,000+ 205

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION Legend Rare Coin Auctions is proud to present the Chester Roche Collection. Mr. Roche focused primarily on Gold Dollars and Quarter Eagles; in all, the collection features 49 coins, 46 of which are gold. Assembled over the course of several years, these coins have been off the market for at least 15 years. Now that the time has come to sell, knowing all the options for selling at auction, Mr. Roche chose LRCA because he knew with our boutique venue, his coins would stand out. There are many green label PCGS holders. None of these have been submitted for grade reconsideration. The quality, eye appeal, and FRESHNESS of this collection is wonderful! Highlights include: G$1 1849-C Closed Wreath. PCGS MS63 G$1 1862 PCGS MS67 CAC G$1 1870-S PCGS MS64 CAC $2.50 1835 PCGS MS63 CAC $2.50 1876-S PCGS MS63 CAC $2.50 1885 PCGS MS63 $2.50 1911-D Strong D. NGC MS64 $3 1885 NGC MS64. If you collect better date gold coins, this collection surely will have something that will suit your tastes.206

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 404 G$1 1849 NO L. PCGS MS65 Here is a lovely GEM example of this first year variant without Longacre’s signature L on the bust, only 1,000 of these were struck. A bold, radiant mint luster has a bold satiny texture that stands out against the frosted devices. Well struck and truly of GEM quality. Rich two-tone golden surfaces delight the eye and are very original. Housed in an OGH. PCGS 34, NGC 23. The most recent example to sell brought $3,995 in our most recent Regency Auction and the current PCGS Price is $6,000. Prior to that one sold for $5,405 in the 2016 ANA auction. Only a dozen coins are graded finer at; the last MS66 to sell was an NGC coin that brought $9,600 in April 2018 (no PCGS MS66 has sold since 2012). A great way to start a GEM gold dollar set! PCGS# 7501 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+LOT 405G$1 1849-C CLOSEDWREATH. PCGS MS63A VERY RARE choice MintState Charlotte mint golddollar, one of the FINESTknown examples, bested byperhaps two or three coinsat most. The typical survivorencountered by collectorsgrades VF or XF.This coin is beautiful!Sharply struck deviceson both sides stand outagainst the highly lustrousdevices. The surfaces showthe typical mint made diestriations on both sides. Even with a strong glass we cannot find any major marks on the surfaces that are not of mint origin.PCGS 6, NGC 6. There has not been a MS63 graded by either service since 2010. They both sold for $12,075. Prior to that,one sold in January 2008 for $17,825. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $21,000 and considering that back in1999 and 2000 there are records around $20,000 this beauty could contest those levels. Keep in mind only a single PCGSMS64 is finer at that service, last selling in the 2015 ANA for $49,350. This Condition Census example is worthy of anyspecialized gold dollar set.PCGS# 7505 | ESTIMATE: $12,000+ 207

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 406 G$1 1850-D PCGS MS61 An extremely RARE Mint State survivor from an original mintage of 8,382, indeed it is one of the rarest, and yet underrated and undervalued Dahlonega mint gold dollars. Displaying a sharper strike than usually encountered, Liberty’s hair curls are all visible, although lacking in crispness. Utilizing the aid of a strong loupe, there are some tiny marks, but they are in no way excessive or detracting. Also of note is the bold luster that brings out the original orange-yellow gold color. PCGS 4, NGC 5. There are only five coins finer at PCGS. There has not been a PCGS MS61 sold in auction since May 2004--a coin that brought $8,913. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $11,500. Better in strike and luster than the PCGS MS62 CAC that sold for $12,338 in the 2017 FUN auction, this coin is a real prize for any advanced gold dollar or D-mint collector. Good luck! PCGS# 7511 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ LOT 407 G$1 1850-O NGC MS61 Very pleasing and very scarce. This pleasing Mint State example has a strongly defined strike and a satiny, brilliant luster. The minor ticks are accounted for in the MS61 grade. Bright yellow-gold surfaces are very eye appealing. A low mintage of only 14,000. PCGS 16, NGC 47. The most recent example to sell realized $2,640 in March 2018 and prior to that the APRs were consistently in the $2,000-$2,500 range. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $3,200. Very rare finer, only 27 coins have graded finer at NGC. We expect strong bidding for this scarce gold dollar. Just seems cheap at today’s level. PCGS# 7512 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+208

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 408 G$1 1851-D PCGS MS61 Probably the “perfect” Mint State grade for the collector, as this date is EXTREMELY RARE any finer. Only 9,882 were struck. Satiny surfaces have a rich honey-gold color. The eye appeal is very pleasing overall, even using a strong glass we cannot find any serious marks worthy of singular mention. Very eye appealing. PCGS 5, NGC 20. No PCGS MS61 has ever sold via auction, so hopefully the following comps are helpful: a PCGS MS60 realized $5,500 back in November 1995; an NGC MS61 sold in September 2017 for $4,320, and a PCGS MS62 sold for $7,638 in February 2015. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $6,200. RARE any finer and only when the gavel falls will we figure out what this grade is worth. Good luck! PCGS# 7515 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+LOT 409G$1 1852 NGC MS65EX PITTMANGleaming, brilliant, satinmint luster blooms on bothsides of this well struck andnicely pedigreed GEM. Asingle mark is noted underthe 5 in the date, otherwisethe surfaces are clean andvery attractive for the grade.PCGS 61, NGC 81. Themost recent NGC coin tosell realized $2,400 in April2018. The current Collector’sUniverse value is listed at$2,500. This one with itsrich orange-gold color should bring more! A great GEM Type 1 gold dollar for any nice gold type set.PCGS# 7517 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ 209

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 410 G$1 1852-C NGC MS63 Conditionally very scarce issue, even though it is considered one of the most “common” Charlotte mint gold dollars in an absolute sense. Only 9,434 were struck, many of which went into circulation. Sharply struck devices have a strong satiny luster on both sides. The strike is incredible for this date with fully formed hair definition, stars, dentils, and wreath. The fields show a natural roughness that is typically seen on for the date. The surfaces show a light greenish-gold overtone with rich yellow-orange gold overall. The eye appeal is very high end, unmarred by the tiny scattered ticks. For the collector who understands how this date usually comes, they will realize that the present example is a real moose! PCGS 11, NGC 12. Going back to 1994, there have been only five auction sales of a 52-C in NGC MS63. Since 2003, these have sold between $6,000 and $8,000. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $11,500 and this date is VERY RARE any finer! Remember, how important a coin this is! Good luck! PCGS# 7518 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+ LOT 411 G$1 1853 PCGS MS65 A beautiful looking, totally fresh GEM example. We think the only reason it is not beaned by CAC is a short mark on the cheek, otherwise the surfaces are wonderful quality devoid of all but the most tiny tick, and the fields show a brilliant frosty luster. PCGS 194, NGC 203. These have been spanked in the market, hard. Prior to 2014, non-CAC PCGS coins were selling all the time in the $2,500-$3,000 and more. The most recent ones have sold in the $1,600 to $2,100 range, with a current PCGS value of $2,150. Very scarce any finer. A great coin for a GEM gold type set. PCGS# 7521 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+210

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 412 G$1 1854-S TYPE 1. PCGS MS62 The final Type 1 gold dollar and a very RARE date in Mint State. From an original mintage of 14,632. It is a coin that has multiple demand levels as it is the first year issue from San Francisco and the only Type 1 gold dollar from the that mint. A bold, flashy, semi- reflective luster blooms from all over. The surfaces are unmarred by all but the most insignificant marks seen only under a strong glass. A rich golden hue is clearly original and very pleasing. Honestly we cannot see why CAC did not sticker this CHOICE example.PCGS 18, NGC 18. The most recent PCGS example sold in March 2017’s offering of the Blue Moon Collection. That coin sold for $5,875, well above the current $3,750 PCGS Price. Only 18 coins are graded finer. We think this beauty will bring a very strong price when it crosses the block. PCGS# 7527 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+LOT 413G$1 1854 TYPE 2. NGCMS61The Type 2 gold dollar is avery short lived series andalways carry a premium as atype. Pleasing and original,this BU example has alovely iridescent patina oversmooth, satiny surfaces.Some minor softness ofstrike in the central devicesis noted but the eye appealis very nice.PCGS 229, NGC 773. Themost recent NGC MS61to sell in auction realized$1,320 in April 2018, prior to that, on sold in November 2017 for $1,080. The current CU value is $1,400. A neat, freshexample for a BU type set.PCGS# 7531 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 211

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 414 G$1 1856 UPRIGHT 5. PCGS MS64 CAC Of the two variants coined in 1856, the Upright 5 is clearly the rarer. The present example borders on GEM quality. Vivid, satiny luster swirls from all over. The surfaces are generally problem free with only the slightest lines. There is some natural mint made roughness noted, but that does not affect the grade or the fresh, original eye appeal. PCGS 23, NGC 19, CAC 10. Only two PCGS/CAC MS64s have ever sold in auction, both back in 2013, both realizing $2,585. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $2,250. There are only 13 coins finer at PCGS. A rare opportunity for gold dollar specialist! PCGS# 7541 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ LOT 415 G$1 1858-S NGC MS62 Tied for FINEST at NGC, the mintage for the 1858-S gold dollar was only 10,000 and PCGS CoinFacts estimates a survival of 8 in Mint State. Garrett and Guth wrote in 2006: “In Mint State, however, the 1858-S is a serious rarity. Currently, fewer than 20 have been graded in Mint State.” Today, between PCGS and NGC there are about 25 graded in all MS grades, and most are clustered at 61 and 62, suggesting a few duplicate records. Rich, orange-gold toning is really brought out by a superb underlying satin luster that really glows. The devices are crisply rendered by a bold, exacting strike. Under close scrutiny, with a powerful glass, we do note some minor scuffs in the fields, mostly hidden by the rich toning. The eye appeal is very nice, indeed! PCGS 4, NGC 3. NONE are finer at NGC, and only four are graded higher at PCGS. The most recent MS62 to sell in auction was graded by PCGS, realizing $7,050 in June 2015 that was ten years after the most recent NGC coin sold, a coin that sold for $6,900 in May 2005. With the most recent PCGS MS63 selling for $14,100 in June 2017, and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $9,000. A very important gold dollar RARITY for the collector, and we expect very strong bidding to bring this condition census piece home. PCGS# 7550 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+212

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 416 G$1 1860-S NGC MS63 Only 13,000 were struck, and this CHOICE example ranks among the FINEST graded at either PCGS and NGC. Sharply struck and displaying a somewhat reflective, semi-Prooflike luster, this coin has a very nice eye appeal. Only under intense scrutiny with a strong loupe will you detect any marks, and they are mostly retained to a small area on the reverse. A very pleasing patina adds to the visual allure.PCGS 7, NGC 5. NGC has graded only four MS64s finer. The most recent MS63 to sell in auction brought $5,170 in the 2017 FUN auction (a PCGS coin). The last NGC coin sold in December 2011 for $4,888. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $6,250. Today, a 64 would approach the five-figure level. Good luck! PCGS# 7557 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+LOT 417G$1 1862 PCGS MS67 CACTied for FINEST gradedat PCGS, this 1862 is theepitome of SUPERB quality!One of the more availabledates, with a mintage wellin excess of 1.3 million, veryfew were saved in PRISTINEcondition during this pivotalCivil War year.An exquisitely preservedcoin, the luster is thick andglowing from all over. Thedevices are sharply struck upon both sides. The planchetshows some minor rollermarks and die striations, which don’t affect the eye appeal, which is SUPERB!PCGS 7, NGC 8, CAC 9. Only two PCGS/CAC coins have ever sold in auction, and they both happened to sell in the 2015ANA auction. The first one was the Akers/Duckor coin, which realized a record $25,850 and the other realized $10,575. CivilWar gold, especially high end PCGS/CAC examples are very highly sought and in demand, we expect very strong bidding tobring this beautiful example home! Good luck.PCGS# 7560 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 213

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 418 G$1 1866 NGC MS65 A remarkable, GEM example of this low mintage date, where only 7,100 were coined. Surprisingly there are an estimated 40 coins graded in 65 or finer based on PCGS CoinFacts estimates. The surfaces show off an rich orange-red golden toning. As you twirl the coin in a light the luster really picks up sky blue and pale lilac iridescent toning. The devices are very sharply struck from boldly clashed dies. Like many of the date, the dies clashed multiple times and the clashing is very bold with LIBERTY clear on the reverse. PCGS 10, NGC 2. Neither NGC coin ever sold in auction. In March 2018 a PCGS MS65 realized $3,600 and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $5,250. VERY RARE any finer, and rarely offered in any higher grade. PCGS# 7565 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ LOT 419 G$1 1870-S PCGS MS64 CAC The 1870-S is the final gold dollar issue struck somewhere other than Philadelphia. Only 3,000 coins were struck and today, this MS64, housed in an OGH, ranks among the highest graded survivors. A full satin gold luster swirls on both the obverse and reverse accenting the sharply struck devices. A strong glass does reveal a few ancient ticks that account for the assigned grade, none of which negatively affect the eye appeal, as evidenced by the endorsement by CAC. PCGS 7, NGC 2, CAC 3. The most recent PCGS-graded example sold in the May 2003 Superior auction, realizing $9,775. More recently an NGC/CAC coin sold in April 2013 for $10,869. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $13,000. Keep in mind there are only five coins graded finer at PCGS, the most recent PCGS MS65 CAC sold for $37,6000 in August 2015 and we sold a 65+ PCGS/CAC for $42,300 in our December 2015 Regency Auction XV. Clearly this coin deserves a spot in a very advanced gold dollar cabinet! PCGS# 7570 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+214

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 420 G$1 1871 PCGS MS65 A GEM example of this low mintage date that saw only 3,900 struck for circulation. The distinctive reflective luster beams from all over, especially so on the reverse. The devices are sharply struck and we note only few minor marks visible under a strong glass. The eye appeal is very nice. This coin, like the others in this collection are making their first auction appearance in at least 20 years, and this one is housed in an OGH. PCGS 12, NGC 6. The most recent example sold in December 2015 for $3,055. Prior to that, dating to 1995 only six examples have sold via auction generally bringing between $4,000 and $4,7000. The current PCGS Price is $4,750 and we believe that this one will end up selling in the normal range. Remember, very few have graded finer, so if you are working on a gold dollar set, do not miss this one. PCGS# 7571 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+LOT 421G$1 1872 PCGS MS65Like most of the later dategold dollars, the 1872 had alow mintage, of only 3,500.As typically seen, there is abold reflection to the luster.Sharply struck devices standout against the smoothfields. Both sides have arich, multicolored iridescenttoning, showing off some icyblue/teal at the peripheriesand deep burnt-orange anddeep rose on towards thecenters. The eye appeal iscertainly unique and willdelight any collector oftoned gold.PCGS 2, NGC 3. The last PCGS graded coin realized $4,994 in February 2013. The current PCGS value is listed at $6,000and keep in mind that the last MS66 sold for $14,950 (nearly seven years ago). We anticipate strong bidding for this uniquelytoned GEM.PCGS# 7572 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 215

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 422 G$1 1874 PCGS MS67+ CAC While one of the most common dates in the series, it is VERY RARE in such a lofty grade level. A billowing mint luster blooms on both sides of this SUPERB GEM. Bright honey-gold surfaces gleam around sharply struck devices. Even with a strong glass we cannot find any imperfections of any kind worthy of mention. The eye appeal, like the quality of this GEM is superb! PCGS 38, NGC 30, CAC 14. PCGS has graded four coins in MS67+ with a mere two coins graded finer. Only one MS67+ ever sold in auction, realizing $3,760 in the 2016 FUN auction, which took place during a low point in the current market cycle. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $4,450. Keep in mind the value in 68 jumps to $20,000! A SUPERB coin for any AMAZING gold type set. PCGS# 7575 | ESTIMATE: $3,200+ LOT 423 G$1 1875 NGC MS63 A VERY RARE date featuring one of the lowest mintages in all of American numismatics; just 400 1875 gold dollars were coined. As typically seen, the present coin has bold Prooflike reflection in the fields that really are bold and flashy. Sharply struck devices stand out against the mirrored fields. A rich golden, orange shows accents of olive and pale iridescent tones on the surfaces. A strong glass does bring to our attention a few teeny ticks, but these account for the assigned grade. PCGS 6, NGC 3. The most recent MS63 to sell in auction was a PCGS coin that sold for $11,456 in January 2013, it’s been nearly a dozen years since the last NGC-graded coin sold. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $16,000. Very rare in all grades, and this CHOICE coin should see very spirited bidding. PCGS# 7576 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+216

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 424 G$1 1877 PCGS MS66 Another low mintage rarity, with a mintage of only 3,900. We are pleased to offer this underrated rarity. Sharp in terms of strike, the devices are nicely frosted and stand out dramatically against the nearly fully prooflike luster. There is a touch of iridescent toning on the surfaces, but it is really not a distraction. Housed in an OGH. PCGS 7, NGC 6. The most recent MS66 to sell in auction was an NGC coin that appeared in a February 2007 auction, selling for $4,485. The last PCGS coin sold in November 2002 realizing $4,715. The current PCGS price is $5,750. Only a few coins are graded finer and this one will sell for a very strong price when advanced collectors duke it out to bring this GEM home. PCGS# 7578 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+LOT 425G$1 1879 PCGS MS65A GEM example from anoriginal mintage of 3,000.Fully Prooflike luster flasheson the obverse, while thereverse is wonderfully frosty.Peach, champagne, apricotand tangerine overtonesgrace both sides. The eyeappeal is quite nice.PCGS 58, NGC 33. Thelast PCGS-graded coin wasCAC approved and realized$2,280 in December 2017.The current Collector’sUniverse value is listed at$2,450. A very scarce, yet affordable GEM gold dollar.PCGS# 7580 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 217

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 426 G$1 1882 NGC MS67 CAC A SUPERB GEM in every sense of the term! Among the best known examples from an original mintage of 5,000. A brilliant luster has a satiny look, but also offers strong cartwheels that swirl from all over. Sharply struck devices do stand out with a bold, crisp definition on both the obverse and reverse. The surfaces are impeccable, devoid of any serious defects of any kind, as expected for the amazing, lofty state of preservation. PCGS 30, NGC 36, CAC 15. The only NGC/CAC coin to sell in auction realized $5,750 in December 2010 and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $5,000. There are only fifteen coins graded finer at NGC, and the most recent NGC 68 sold for $7,638 in February 2016. PCGS# 7583 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ LOT 427 G$1 1886 PCGS MS65 While the mintage for this date is low, only 5,000 were ever struck, the majority of survivors are in Mint State. This is one of those instances where circulated coins are rarer than Mint State. Fully lustrous surfaces show a bold, prooflike reflection on smooth, GEM quality surfaces. Sharply struck and very attractive with rich, golden color all over. PCGS 48, NGC 18. The most recent example to sell sold way too cheap, realizing only $823. This one in an OGH should sell for more, and keep in mind the CU value is listed at $1,150. Pretty scarce any finer! PCGS# 7587 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+218

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 428 G$1 1888 PCGS MS66 CAC Really a SUPERB example of the penultimate year of the denomination. Bold, brilliant, flashy, reflective luster blazes from all. The fully struck devices are frosty and there is a lovely contrast between the devices and the flashy fields. The surfaces are devoid of all but the most insignificant marks, and none of these affect the awesome eye appeal.PCGS 109, NGC 89, CAC 25. PCGS/CAC examples have sold in the $1,400-$1,900 range going back to 2014 and the current PCGS Price is $1,600. PCGS# 7589 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+LOT 429G$1 1889 PCGS MS67 CACA SUPERB example ofthe last gold dollar issue.Everything about this coin,housed in an OGH, isHIGH END! From the strongbillowing mint luster to thesharply struck devices to thesmooth, defect free surfaces,this coin is essentiallyFLAWLESS! The eye appealis spectacular!PCGS 245, NGC 180, CAC64. The most recent examplebrought $3,720 in the 2018FUN auction and the currentPCGS value is listed at $2,950. This is another great type coin date, being that it is available in SUPERB grades.PCGS# 7590 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 219

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 430 $2.50 1835 PCGS MS63 CAC Here is one of the most colorful Classic Head quarter eagles this cataloger has EVER seen! The eye appeal really is off the charts! It is the toning that draws the viewer’s attention. The surfaces are awash with a rich orange-gold color that blends to a dramatic magenta and rose, especially on the reverse. As you rotate this CHOICE Classic Head in a light, the subtle differences in hue really do come to life! The luster has a distinctive Prooflike flash that really contrasts against the nicely defined devices. Even using a strong loupe, all that will be revealed are a few ancient, toned over hairlines. The eye appeal really is something UNIQUE and awesome! PCGS 12, NGC 13, CAC 3. Only four coins are graded finer (none of which are CAC). Only one CAC-approved example has EVER sold in auction, the NGC-graded Green/Newman coin that realized $9,988 in November 2014 and while attractive and high end, it did not possess the awesome eye appeal this one does! A 64 would likely cost around $20,000, if you can find one (the last one sold a decade ago!). This coin will really delight any advanced toned gold collector, Classic Head $2.50 collector, or anyone just putting away really cool, sexy pieces! We know this coin will sell for a very strong price! Good luck! PCGS# 7693 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ LOT 431 $2.50 1836 SCRIPT 8. PCGS MS63 Here is a very lustrous Choice Brilliant Uncirculated Classic Head quarter eagle. Offering a strong, satiny mint brilliance on both sides, this lovely coin has a great yellow-gold color on both sides. The strike is what you normally see on the type, displaying just a touch of central softness in the central design elements. A few old scuffs account for the assigned grade, as the initial eye appeal is that of a higher grade. PCGS 36, NGC 9. The most recent PCGS coin to sell in auction realized $8,100 in September 2017 and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $8,500. Very rare any finer, PCGS has graded nothing finer than MS65+, and the majority finer are clustered at 64. A great looking coin that will see very active bidding for sure! PCGS# 7694 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+220

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 432 $2.50 1846 PCGS MS61 The Liberty Head $2.50 series is one of the longest running and is a major challenge to complete. The 1846 is a major condition rarity in this extensive series. Very few of the original mintage of 21,598 survive for collectors in Mint State grades, and most of those graded are NGC MS61s (there must be some duplication there). The devices are crisply rendered by a strong blow from the dies. Ms. Liberty’s hair details are fully defined as are the eagle’s feathers. A bold mint frost has a lively satin sheen on both sides. The eye appeal is very nice, indeed we note only the smallest marks under magnification. PCGS 5, NGC 17. There is a wide disparity between the last two examples that have sold in auction. The most recent was in the A.J. Vanderbilt Collection in March 2018, selling for $15,600. Prior to that, one sold in February 2017 for $5,640 (that coin was the first to sell since April 2007). Clearly these DO NOT appear with any frequency. The current PCGS Price Guidevalue is listed at $9,500, which we think was adjusted to an average of the last two examples sold and may be too high based on the outlier status of the Vanderbilt coin. Either way, this fresh to the market, select Mint State coin will be a delight for any student of better date gold. PCGS# 7740 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+LOT 433$2.50 1847-C PCGS MS61With a mintage of 23,226,the 1847-C is one of the more“common” Charlotte mintquarter eagles. The good thingis that it is also one of thebest struck and most lustrousexamples, and as noted byDoug Winter, “This is oneof the few Charlotte quartereagles that the date collectorcan expect to find with goodeye appeal.” This old holderedMS61 is semi-reflective onthe obverse with traces of PLcharacter to the luster, thereverse is more frosty. Very pleasing, original color drapes both sides, of this Brilliant Uncirculated and CHOICE example.While a strong glass does reveals some tiny ticks the eye appeal is excellent and so much better than the conserved examplesthat are often seen in the market.PCGS 10, NGC 8. For a coin that experts say is available, the auction data tell a different story. Only two PCGS MS61shave ever sold in auction. The one sold in the 2018 FUN auction was the first since the 1999 FUN auction. That is a 19year spread between sales! The presently offered coin is FRESH to the market and nicer than that coin, which realized only$4,320. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $7,200. A great opportunity to add a Mint Sate C-mint quartereagle to your collection.PCGS# 7745 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 221

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 434 $2.50 1849 PCGS MS62 While gold was flooding out of California, and much of it coming to the mint at Philadelphia, only 23,294 were struck, and they are VERY RARE in any Mint State grade. In fact, when David Akers did his research, the only Mint State coin he knew of was the Scalon coin bought by Harry Bass. The presently offered coin displays flashy, lustrous, prooflike surfaces on the obverse while the reverse has a more satiny frost. Very attractive orange-gold color bathes both sides. The eye appeal really pops and the golden surfaces really glitter! PCGS 5, NGC 6. The last PCGS coin to sell was back in June 2012. Only 8 coins are graded finer, an there has not been a higher grade coin sold since 2011. The current PCGS value is $4,700 and we think this coin will sell for strong money as the market for rare date gold has picked up in recent months! Good luck! PCGS# 7752 | ESTIMATE: $3,200+ LOT 435 $2.50 1853 NGC MS64 Extremely lustrous and pleasing for the grade, this lovely CHOICE quarter eagle is free of any serious marks. A neat type coin. PCGS 83, NGC 78. The most recent example brought $1,140 in March 2018 and the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $1,850. RARE any finer. A great early Lib $2.50 for any gold type set. PCGS# 7767 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+222

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 436 $2.50 1856-O PCGS MS60 A VERY RARE Mint State survivor of this lower mintage New Orleans date. There are a total of 4 Mint State coins graded by PCGS, this one, one in 61, and 2 in 62. It really is very underrated and a true sleeper. This one is truly Mint State with not even the slightest hint of friction. A few ancient ticks and marks are noted andaccount for the grade, but the rich, satiny gold surfaces are creamy and quite high end for the modest grade. Sharply struck with crisply defined devices. Very eye appealing and VERY RARE! PCGS 1, NGC 4. This coin is freshly graded, recently crossed over from an NGC MS60 holder, thus it has never appeared in auction before. The sole MS61 at PCGS has also never been in auction. Recent auction sales are few and far between for anything that can be comparable. An NGC AU58 sold in September 2017 for $4,095; an NGC MS61 sold in the 2013 ANAfor $7,050; a PCGS AU58 sold in October 2010 for $4,025; an NGC MS60 sold in March 2004 for $5,865. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $7,000 and this coin will likely sell for that or more. The only PCGS coin finer that has soldrecently was a PCGS/CA C MS62 (tied for finest known) for $35,250. What a great piece to add to your set of quarter eagles! PCGS# 7780 | ESTIMATE: $5,500+LOT 437$2.50 1876-S PCGS MS63CACTied for FINEST graded ofthis LOW MINTAGE date.Only 5,000 were struckfor circulation, and today,perhaps 400 survive in allgrades, with 20 estimated inMint State.The present coin is VERYhigh end for the grade. Arich golden bloom withbold orange accents makingthe devices stand out. Thedevices are sharply struck,which is the exception to thehow this date normally comes. The details are strongly struck, with only the slightest touch of bluntness in only a couple ofareas. Only a few minute marks are seen under a strong glass, but none detract from the exceptional eye appeal.PCGS 6, NGC 1, CAC 1. This coin has been long off the market, and is making its first auction appearance in decades. Thelast PCGS coin to sell realized $8,225 in the 2014 FUN auction. As the ONLY PCGS/CAC coin we know that there will bevery strong bidding to take home this FINEST set of Liberty quarter eagles. If this series is your specialty, prepare for recordbidding! Good luck!PCGS# 7825 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 223

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 438 $2.50 1878-S PCGS MS63 Richly toned, sharply struck, and offering a semi-reflec- tive PL luster, this lovely, choice 78-S $2.50 offers a bold, original look. A very pleasing example for the date collector! PCGS 43, NGC 46. The most recent example was CAC-approved and sold for $960. The current PCGS Price Guide value listed at $1,500. This is a date and grade that does not appear with any real frequency, there are 23 PCGS listed appearances dating back to 1993. PCGS# 7829 | ESTIMATE: $900+ LOT 439 $2.50 1879 PCGS MS65 CAC An AMAZING GEM with a rich glowing mint vibrance. Sharply struck with smooth, problem free surfaces. Pleasing yellow gold surfaces on both sides shows some richer tone on the reverse. High end and original, this coin is housed in an OGH. PCGS 24, NGC 20, CAC 8. The last PCGS/ CAC coin to sell was in September 2013--nearly five years ago--realizing $3,290. The current Collector’s Universe value is $3,900 and only 10 coins are graded finer--the most recent MS66 sold in our December 2016 Regency Auction for $7,931. A very nice GEM worthy of any high end set. PCGS# 7830 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+224

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 440 $2.50 1885 PCGS MS63 WOW! What a wonderful example of this VERY RARE Liberty quarter eagle. Demand for the denomination dropped so low in 1885 that only 800 were struck. As expected from a coin of this low mintage, the surfaces are very reflective in the luster. Sharply struck on both sides, the devices are very bold and are nicely frosted. Rich, medium gold with accents of richer orange really are a delight to behold! This coin also happens to be the current CoinFacts Plate. PCGS 4, NGC 2. There are only 10 listed as finer on the PCGS Population Report. The ONLY PCGS MS63 to sell realized $13,513 in March 2014 and keep in mind we sold a PCGS 64 in December 2014 for $20,563. A VERY RARE quarter eagle and soon to be a highlight of any high end late date quarter eagle set! For this FRESH coin, we could see record bidding! PCGS# 7837 | ESTIMATE: $8,500+LOT 441$2.50 1886 PCGS MS64CACAmong the highest gradedof this low mintage issue,only 4,000 were ever struckfor circulation. The lusteris very flashy with a superbcartwheel luster. Really ofGEM quality, the eye appealof this sharply struck beautyis amazing and high end!PCGS 4, NGC 7, CAC 2.The current PCGS PriceGuide value is listed at$7,500. There has not beenone sold in auction sinceNovember 2004. Clearly a very RARE and infrequently seen quarter eagle that is likely missing from many collections. Hereis a VERY important opportunity to add this rarity to your collection!PCGS# 7838 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 225

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 442 $2.50 1892 PCGS MS64 A very RARE, low mintage date with an original mint output of 2,440. This remarkable survivor is a borderline GEM! A fiery, semi-reflective luster is BOLD and very flashy. Crisply struck up, the devices are frosted and really do stand out. Some minor chatter can be seen in the obverse fields, but it does not detract from the AMAZING eye appeal. PCGS 19, NGC 9. We suspect there is some duplication in the Population Report. The last one to sell in auction brought only $3,120 in the 2018 FUN auction. The current PCGS value is $4,500 and that nearly doubles in MS65. A real prize for any quarter eagle collector! PCGS# 7844 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ LOT 443 $2.50 1898 PCGS MS66 CAC A frosty, superb GEM with a rich satin glow in the smooth surfaces. Hints of olive-green gold appear when rotated in a light. Like many of the later dates, the mintage was limited to 24,000 and this wonderful coin ranks high on the PCGS Population Report. The eye appeal really is very high end. PCGS 46, NGC 45, CAC 21. Our auction database shows records for only four CAC-coins, 2 PCGS and 2 NGC. The most recent was a PCGS coin sold in March 2016 for $2,820. The current PCGS value is $3,500 and this fresh to the market coin has a bold look that will certainly inspire strong bidding. PCGS# 7850 | ESTIMATE: $2,300+226

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 444 $2.50 1899 PCGS MS65 CAC Another lower mintage late date, only 27,200 were struck for circulation. Housed in an OGH, this GEM has a great original amber-honey gold color that is brought to life by a bold satin luster. Sharply struck, the eye appeal is very pleasing! PCGS 83, NGC 74, CAC 17. It is hard to believe but the only CAC-approved coin to ever sell via auction was a gold stickered NGC coin, realizing $3,290 in the 2014 ANA auction. Indeed, do not let the pops fool you, there have only been 18 auction appearances in our database going back to 1990! The current PCGS value is $1,850, and this coin will see very strong bidding for sure--we would not be surprised to see this coin bring a bid well in excess of that! PCGS# 7851 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+LOT 445$2.50 1901 PCGS MS65A lovely, lustrous two-toneGEM. Sharply struck with onlya few teeny lines seen onlyunder a strong glass. The eyeappeal is above average forsure. Housed in an OGH.PCGS 247, NGC 220. Thecurrent CU value is listed at$950 and the last one sold inDecember 2017 for $788. Thisone should see strong bidding.PCGS# 7853 | ESTIMATE: $750+ 227

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 446 $2.50 1911-D STRONG D. NGC MS64 THE key date Indian Head quarter eagle in all grades. With only 55,680 struck, it is clearly the lowest in the 15-coin series. This totally original coin has a vibrant, lustrous, satin sheen. Both the obverse and reverse are deeply impressed, with fully struck incuse devices. Using a strong glass there are only a few very insignificant lines that keep it from an even higher grade. The eye appeal is very nice--nicer than many seen on the bourse floor or in auction. PCGS 308, NGC 397. The last two examples sold for $16,450 (one in April 2017 and the other in the 2016 ANA auction). in the last five years, NGC MS64 pieces have sold in the $15,275 and $21,150 range. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $20,000. VERY RARE any finer! If you are building a high grade set of Indian Head $2.50, you owe it to yourself to view, and bid on this near-GEM! PCGS# 7943 | ESTIMATE: $14,000+ LOT 447 $2.50 1915 PCGS MS65 Satiny, frosty luster swirls around sharply struck devices. Pleasing gold coloration is noted, as are some minor marks. Housed in an old green tag holder. PCGS 190, NGC 192. The last two sold cheap, realizing only $2,350 and $2,376. Prior to those two, going back to 2015, they were selling in the $2,820 to $3,050 range. CU still lusts a value of $3,500 in the current Price Guide. Very RARE any finer, fewer than 20 coins are on the Pop report in higher graded at PCGS. PCGS# 7948 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+228

THE CHESTER ROCHE COLLECTION LOT 448 $3 1885 NGC MS64 A very flashy, semi-Prooflike luster beams from all over on this sharply struck example. Only 801 $3s were struck in 1885, making this a VERY RARE coin in any grade. The sharply struck devices do stand out against the lustrous fields. A few stray, light lines can be seen with a strong glass. The eye appeal is very nice. PCGS 25, NGC 16. There has not been an NGC graded example sold in auction in four years, a coin that realized $16,450 in April 2014. More recently a PCGS example sold for $15,000 in April 2018. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $17,500. VERY RARE any finer! This is a very nice example of this rare date. Good luck! PCGS# 8007 | ESTIMATE: $13,500+LOT 449$5 1896 PCGS MS64 CACA satiny, lustrous near-GEMexample of the date. A lowermintage issue, only 58,960were struck, and today areVERY RARE in GEM MintState, making this OGHPCGS MS64 CAC a verydesirable coin indeed!PCGS 24, NGC 34, CAC 10.The most recent PCGS/CACexample sold in February2014 for $1,880. The currentPCGS price is $1,550 andonly SEVEN coins aregraded finer at PCGS. This isa great example for anyone building a set with Motto $5 Libs. Good luck finding a finer example!PCGS# 8392 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 229

LOT 450 G$1 1853 PCGS MS66 CAC A gloriously lustrous PQ GEM! Sharply struck devices are pleasingly frosted and stand out against the fields. Even using a powerful glass we are unable to find the slightest tick or line that limits the grade. The eye appeal is exceptional and HIGH END even for this lofty grade. PCGS 59, NGC 41, CAC 27. Only four CAC-approved MS66s have ever sold, two PCGS coins, 2 NGC. The most recent sold for $5,758 in our January 2018 Regency Auction 25. The other three sold in the $7,000-$8,625 range. The current CU value is $4,500. Keep in mind the next grade up will cost triple! A great type coin! PCGS# 7521 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ LOT 451 G$1 1854 TYPE 1. PCGS MS66 CAC The final Type 1 gold dollar using James Longacre’s Liberty Head styled like the double eagle. The present PQ GEM has a brilliant, satiny mint luster that radiates with a bright golden glow. Sharply struck on both sides, every detail is crisply embossed in the tiny gold planchet. No marks (other than some minor mint made clashmarks) can be seen, even under a strong glass. The eye appeal is wonderful! PCGS 16, NGC 11, CAC 4. It is amazing to note that no CAC-approved example has ever sold in auction, and only seven PCGS graded MS66s have sold going back to May 2003! The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $5,500 but for a premium GEM like this, that level may easily be surpassed! Only a half dozen coins are finer at PCGS, making this among the finest available!. PCGS# 7525 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ OUR ESTIMATES The estimates you see published in this catalog are based on HAMMER. Keep in mind that a coin could be either low or high end for the grade, have stunning color or be dull, all of which radically affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be huge price differences within a grade, and we offer estimates as a guide so Collector’s can have a better idea of value. One thing we will never do is offer low ball estimates in order to claim stronger sales. These published estimates represent what Legend Rare Coin Auctions determines to be an approximate high wholesale value for the coin. The numbers are based upon current market values, similar trades, auction prices, published prices, and a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is no guarantee that the estimated prices are minimums or are exactly what you can expect to get if you attempt to resell them wholesale. We always advise you to view the coins you are interested in and calculate what you’ll pay using as much information as possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask us. We are here to help you!230

LOT 452G$1 1854 TYPE 2. PCGS MS65 CACA SPECTACULAR GEM Type 2! Everything about thiscoin SCREAMS originality and HIGH END quality!The first thing that catches your eye when viewingthis beauty is the vivid satiny frost. The luster is thickand presents a full radiating glow. The toning is richorange-gold with soft rose and lilac accents that comeout when twirled in the light. What really sets thiscoin apart is the strike. This cataloger has never seena Type 2 with this bold a strike. Every detail is crisplyrendered. We note lots of die rust impressed on thecoin, a feature that is very rarely seen because of thepoor quality of strike normally seen. The eye appeal isoff the charts!Conditionally rare, very few type 2 gold dollars weresaved in Mint State, and most Mint State coins existin lower grades (below MS63). In GEM, they truly areVERY RARE.PCGS 49, NGC 21, CAC 21. We suspect, especiallygiven the lack of auction appearances, that this manyMS65s do not exist, and that there is much duplication.The last PCGS/CAC coin sold in the 2012 FUN auctionrealizing $29,900. Clearly these DO NOT appear inauction with any frequency. Bid liberally to bring thisGEM to your gold type set or specialized collection ofgold dollars.PCGS# 7531 | ESTIMATE: $24,000+ 231

LOT 453 LOT 454 G$1 1857 PCGS MS66 G$1 1862 PCGS MS65 CAC Despite a relatively generous mintage of 774,789 gold A lovely GEM example of this popular Civil War date gold dollars in 1857, it is a condition rarity in GEM or finer dollar. Full, lustrous satin frost glows on both the obverse and grades. A rich satiny sheen glows through the pale golden reverse. The devices are sharply struck and the eye appeal is frost. Sharply struck and displaying only a tiny tick or two, unmarred by any serious lines or ticks. the eye appeal is very nice. RARE in this grade, and much PCGS 115, NGC 115, CAC 42. There have been only three rarer any finer. PCGS/CAC coins sold in auction based on our database, the most recent sold for $1,704 in September 2017 and before PCGS 9, NGC 7. The current Collector’s Universe value that, one sold in December 2015 for $1,880. The current CU is listed at $6,500. The last one sold over five years ago, value is listed at $1,750 and with its CAC endorsement, this and there are only a half dozen finer, and a 67 would cost $20,000. A high quality GEM like this should see strong GEM should realize more. bidding. Good luck! PCGS# 7560 | ESTIMATE: $1,700+ PCGS# 7544 | ESTIMATE: $4,600+ LOT 455 G$1 1887 PCGS PR66 CAC A real GEM and despite a mintage of over 1,000, these are quite scarce today in such lofty grades. Deep, rich golden mirrors glitter and beam from all over. The fields do show some traces of orange peal texture. The devices are sharply struck and stand out against the fields. The golden color is deep and rich and totally original. The eye appeal is wonderful and there is a trace of contrast. PCGS 8, NGC 1, CAC 4. There is only one PR67 in the non-CAM designations finer. The last PCGS graded example sold eight years ago, realizing $11,500 in April 2010. More recently a PCGS PR65 sold in the 2018 FUN auction for $16,200. Today, in PR66 the Collector’s Universe value is listed at $14,500. A very desirable Proof gold dollar with a ton of eye appeal that ranks near the top of known examples. PCGS# 7637 | ESTIMATE: $10,500+232

LOT 456 $2.50 1846-D PCGS MS61 An EXTREMELY RARE date in Mint State, PCGS has graded only 11 coins in all Mint State grades, with the finest being graded MS63. Only 19,303 were struck, and this piece is clearly among the finest. A bold, lustrous yellow gold with rich greenish accents to the surface delight the eye. Sharply struck devices stand out against the fields. A few minor ticks and scuffs are noted under a glass, but none of these are inappropriate for the assigned MS61 grade. The eye appeal really is very nice.PCGS 7, NGC 6. The most recent MS61 to sell was a PCGS coin in November 2016 that realized $9,988. The current PCGSprice is $11,500. There are only four coins finer at PCGS, and the most recent MS62 sold 14 years ago, bringing $18,400 in the 2004 FUN auction. A very important opportunity for the advanced collector of branch mint southern gold. Expect this coin to bring a strong price. PCGS# 7742 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+LOT 457$2.50 1893 PCGS MS65WOW! This coin is SUPER HIGH END. What does PCGS needin order to call it a +?Immaculate surfaces are really special. They have a thickunbroken satiny skin. Even using a strong glass all you canfind are a few microscopic frost breaks. The luster is full and isunbroken. Talk about two tone colors! This coin is an explosionof them. Magnificent original gold mixes with centers ofbold orange/pink to create such a wild combo Picasso wouldprobably give it a thumbs up. Even better, there are no spots ordiscolorations. Miss Liberty and every detail are frosted and are sharply struck. The eye appeal is one you will NEVER forget!PCGS 53, NGC 49. The last one of these to sell in auction brought $2,160 in February 2018. Does not matter, the coinoffered here is the 1893 $2.50 version of a Northern Lights toned Morgan. Throw away all the price guides on thissensation GEM!PCGS# 7845 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ LOT 458 $2.50 1899 PCGS MS67 A truly SUPERB example of this lower mintage, late date $2.50 Lib. A strong, brilliant mint luster shows off a satiny vibrance. The ultra smooth surfaces and crisply impressed design elements are both awash in a rich, orange-gold coloration. PCGS 10, NGC 6. NONE ARE FINER at PCGS. The last one to sell realized $7,050 in June 2017 and prior to that, these were selling in the general $7,500 to $8,500 range. The current PCGS price is $8,500. Worthy of a very high ranking set of quarter eagles, and this one is more than worthy of a strong bid. PCGS# 7851 | ESTIMATE: $6,250+ 233

LOT 459 $2.50 1900 PCGS PR67 DCAM CAC A VERY HIGH END and stunning SUPERB GEM piece. One look and you’ll agree why Proof Gold is considered the “caviar of numismatics.” Amazing super deep mirrors beam boldly from all over. The mirrors are remarkably clean, have intense clarity, and are of course intensely reflective. When you twirl the coin, the mirrors run like a watery river of gold from side to side. The contrast is dramatic. Both sides are a brilliant gold color; there are no spots or discolorations. Miss Liberty and the details are thickly frosted and are pinpoint sharp in strike. It looks like this coin was carved from a block of frosted gold. The eye appeal is simply breath taking! ONLY 205 minted. PCGS 7, NGC 11, CAC 10. The last PCGS CAC piece to sell in auction brought $39,950 in the 2018 FUN auction. As time goes on, Proof Gold has turned out to be one of the most difficult types of coins to find. You can’t beat buying unmessed with better gold at any premium! This coin will be a stand out in ANY GEM Proof $2.50 set or any Type set. It’s also okay just to buy as one heck of a neat coin! PCGS# 97926 | ESTIMATE: $34,000+234

LOT 460$2.50 1911-D STRONG D. NGC MS65 CACWe love everything about this unquestionable trueGEM! We do know it was sent in once for crossover.We do not know what PCGS was thinking. There isnothing wrong with this coin.At first glance, you think it’s a GEM commoner datebecause it is so nice. Save for one small obverse tick,the surfaces on BOTH sides are insanely immaculate.We cannot stress enough how clean (which is highlyunusual) the dreaded right reverse is. The luster ismoderate -but this coin is totally original and has neverbeen dipped. Both sides are en even moderate goldcolor. There are NO spots or discolorations anywhere.All of the details are sharply struck and are visible tothe naked eye. The eye appeal is great!PCGS 22, NGC 76, CAC 8. This coin brought $78,000in January 2018. The consignor is a dealer who thoughtit simply sold too cheap. A PCGS CAC piece wouldeasily bring $85-$90,000 today. We can not stressenough how incredibly crazy tight PCGS is when itcomes to grading all $2.5 and $5 Indian gold. Wereally do see no reason why this coin one day will notcross. Its not a sale pitch, inspect the coin yourself!PCGS# 7943 | ESTIMATE: $67,500+ 235

LOT 461 LOT 462 $2.50 1912 PCGS MS64 CAC $2.50 1929 PCGS MS65 A vibrant golden luster blooms on both sides of this pleasing, Lovely! Unquestionably the 1929 is a better date in the well struck, near-GEM example. Some minor contact and a series, and is popular as the final $2.50 issue. A bold satin single toning spot on the obverse but the eye appeal is very frost sets the surfaces shine in a rich golden glow. Very strong for the assigned grade. pleasing orange-gold patina swirls on both sides. Just a tiny scuff under the cheek is noted, but can be overlooked PCGS 596, NGC 642, CAC 122. The most recent PCGS/CAC considering the strong eye appeal. example to sell in auction realized $2,880 in December PCGS 215, NGC 272. No MS65 graded by either services 2017. Before that, one sold in November 2016 for $3,055. has sold yet in 2018. The most recent example we sold The current PCGS price is $2,350. Keep in mind at PCGS/ CAC MS65 will cost $11,000 or more! If you are building a was in our December 2016 Premier Sessions auction, that set of $2.50 Indians, this 1912 will fit nicely in any GEM set realized $2,310. The current PCGS Price Guide lists a value without breaking the bank. of $2,800. EXTREMELY RARE any finer! PCGS# 7944 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ PCGS# 7953 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ LOT 463 $3 1856-S PCGS MS61 A very scarce Mint State $3. With a mintage of 34,500, it is quite difficult to obtain in any grade above XF, as noted by David Akers in his survey of the series (out of 177 auction appearances, 116 of them graded VF or lower)! The present coin is a new find, fresh to the market. Pleasing, original color shows off a satin-like frost that accents a strong strike. The surfaces do show some light hairlines and an old mark on the obverse that account for the assigned grade. Delightfully eye appealing, this is a date that is rarely seen in this grade. PCGS 7, NGC 12. It has been almost four years since the last PCGS MS61 sold in auction, realizing $11,831 in November 2014. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $14,000 and keep in mind that there are only 10 coins finer at PCGS, the finest grading MS64. A real prize for the $3 gold collector! PCGS# 7975 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+236

LOT 464$3 1878 PCGS MS66A brilliant, billowing, golden frosty, satin luster glowsall over on both sides of this impressive GEM. Silkysmooth surfaces are free of all but the most minuteticks, all of which are totally OK for the assignedgrade. Sharply struck on both sides with full definitionto all the devices. The eye appeal is exceptional inevery way!PCGS 79, NGC 38. The most recent example brought$14,400 in March 2018. Comparing the two coins,the present GEM has smoother surfaces and a richergolden color. The current PCGS value is listed at$19,500 and keep in mind that there are only 14 coinsgraded finer. This GEM should see serious bidding from$3 gold collectors, or gold type specialists in general.PCGS# 8000 | ESTIMATE: $13,500+ 237

LOT 465 $3 1887 PCGS PR65+ DCAM CAC An amazing VERY HIGH END GEM. If the quality does not blow you away, the monster eye appeal will! Remarkable deep mirrors intensely beam from all over. They have strong clarity, cleanliness, and are highly reflective. When you twirl the coins, the mirrors look like brilliant highly polished mirrors of gold (which they are). The contrast is bold and gorgeous. Miss Liberty and every detail are needle sharp in strike, stand out boldly, and have world class thick gold frost. There are NO discolorations or spots anywhere. The eye appeal is breath taking! Only 160 were minted. PCGS 2, NGC 1, CAC 2. PCGS has graded only 2 in PR65+ DCAM. NONE in PR65 or PR65+ DCAM have ever been sold via auction. The current Collector’s Universe value is $45,000. Very few if any other dates have and GEM pieces sell at auction. This series in GEM Proof is much rarer than people realize. Everything about this GEM is great: it is obsolete, it is a real GEM Proof, it has killer eye appeal, and you do not see similar coins offered in any frequency. We expect strong bidding here-good luck! PCGS# 98051 | ESTIMATE: $36,000+238

LOT 466$4 1879 FLOWING HAIR. PCGS PR64 CACLegend Rare Coin Auctions is proud to offer thiswonderful, original, and near-gem quality exampleof this important rarity. The $4 or Stella gold piece istechnically a pattern coin, but its placement in theGuide Book of United States Coins, and its relativelyhigh mintage, they have traditionally been collected asa regular issue.The present beauty is nearly of GEM quality. Bothsides have bold, reflective mirrored fields surroundingwell struck devices. There are mint made die striationsthat can be seen with a strong glass, but they do notdetract from the outstanding eye appeal. Clearly thiscoin is ORIGINAL, which is a very pleasant exceptionto what is often seen: “conserved” dipped and strippedexamples with overly bright yellow gold.By 1879, for at least a decade, various proposals foran international coinage had been tested. In 1868,there was a pattern $5 / 25 francs struck; in 1874Dana Bickford proposed a $10 gold piece that had theconversions into various European currencies. None ofthese made it any further than a few coins struck.In 1879, John Kasson, the ambassador to Austriasuggested a $4 gold coin to be struck in a Metricgold composition. Kasson had connections, and theresulting proposed $4 gold piece was the closest aninternational coinage got to mass production. Twodistinct obverses were created, one with a Libertyhead with her hair flowing down, designed by CharlesBarber, and the other with Liberty’s hair coiled up onof her head by George Morgan. The 1879 is the most“common” with 425 reported struck. Legend has itthat many of these were distributed to congressmen toshow what the coin would look like and some of themended up spent in Washington brothels.PCGS 67, NGC 36, CAC 6. Only a singleCAC-approved PR64 has sold in auction, realizing$184,000 back in April 2011. PCGS-graded PR64swithout CAC have sold between $158,625 and$207,000. Anyone adding a Stella to their setsautomatically vaults their collection to ahigher stratosphere.PCGS# 8057 | ESTIMATE: $150,000+ 239

LOT 467 $5 1803/2 NGC AU58 BD-1, considered to be R-4 with perhaps 150-200 known in all grades. Pleasing khaki gold color with ample olive accents that grace both sides. Generally attractive with hints of original bloom that comes out in the protected areas of the nicely struck devices. Some old friction can be seen with a glass. The reverse was struck from a later die state with a number of bold die cracks that transect that side. PCGS 77, NGC 88. The last AU58 to sell was a PCGS coin that brought $10,800. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $14,500. A decent collector example of this early $5--perfect for a type or date collection. PCGS# 8084 | ESTIMATE: $9,500+240

LOT 468$5 1804 NGC MS62 CACBD-2, Normal Date. R-4+ with perhaps 70-90examples known in all grades.A lovely, original Brilliant Uncirculated exampleof this very scarce die marriage. Struck from a lateobverse die state, with a bisecting die crack that startsat the rim below the 0 in the date, crossing entirelythrough Liberty’s head to the rim between LI. A boldluster blooms on both sides accenting the brilliantyellow-gold color and sharply struck devices. Thereare a few mint made adjustment marks running acrossLiberty’s neck, but they are easily overlooked in light ofthe otherwise wonderful eye appeal.PCGS 21, NGC 6, CAC 5. Only one CAC-approvedcoin has ever sold in auction, realizing $17,625 backin July 2013--that is half a decade ago! The currentCollector’s Universe value is listed at $20,000. Keepingin mind that there has not been a MS63 sold in auctionsince 2011, this coin has a lot to offer many collectors!We expect strong bidding.PCGS# 8085 | ESTIMATE: $17,000+ 241

LOT 469 $5 1806 ROUND 6, 7X6 STARS. PCGS MS62 CAC BD-6, the only variety with the Round 6. This marriage was a workhorse striking perhaps 35,000-50,000 of the 64,000+ struck for the date. While available, finding a NICE example is still very tough! A soft, satin glow mingles in the fields around bluntly struck devices. The strike shows typical weakness in areas, but the overall eye appeal is excellent. PCGS 73, NGC 26, CAC 15. The most recent examples to sell in auction were in the 2017 FUN auction realizing $16,626 and $21,150. The current PCGS Price Guide price is listed at $20,000. Certainly worthy of a premium bid for its originality and good look! Worthy of any high grade early gold type or date set. PCGS# 8089 | ESTIMATE: $13,500+ LOT 470 $5 1810 LARGE DATE, LARGE 5. PCGS AU50 CAC BD-4. The ideal example for a budget minded collector that still demand PCGS-graded and CAC-approved coins. This one is more than deserving of the CAC green bean! Pleasing, original coloration is seen on lightly circulated surfaces. A rich honey-wheat color is accented by a wonderfully satiny frost. Well struck and problem free this coin really is ideal! PCGS 14, NGC 6, CAC 2. No CAC-approved example has ever sold via auction. The most recent PCGS coin to sell in auction brought $6,463 in the 2017 FUN auction and the one before that sold for $6,900 in September 2010. The current PCGS price is $8,400 and the last PCGS 53 sold more recently in the 2017 ANA auction for $8,225. A highly affordable, yet high quality early $5. PCGS# 8108 | ESTIMATE: $6,250+242

LOT 471 $5 1845-O PCGS AU58 CAC A super slider, “GEM” AU example of this very rare and underrated date. Considered RARE in AU58, this certainly scarcer than the Charlotte and Dahlonega issues that attract more attention. In all, perhaps 100-200 examples in all grades, most of which are in the VF to XF range. A sharply struck example with strongdefinition to the devices. Lustrous, semi-reflective fields display a lovely “flash” when rotated in a light. Only the slightest hintof friction on the highest points and in the fields. Rich golden-orange color with some mild olive accents. Totally original, this coin displays a wonderful eye appeal that will delight any specialist collector of southern branch gold. PCGS 6, NGC 30, CAC 8. How is this for RARE--the last PCGS AU58 sold 23 years ago! Think about that, kids graduating from college this year were not even born yet! That is RARE! The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $7,500 and with the rare date gold market as strong as it is, that level will be challenged when this GEM AU crosses the block! PCGS# 8225 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+LOT 472$5 1846-O PCGS AU58CACOne of the finest gradedexamples of this date, thereare only seven coins in allMint State grades at PCGSfiner. This is a very scarceand difficult New Orleansdate to find in such a loftygrade. To find one with anyskin or originality is evenharder. Most of the 75-85estimated to survive (perDoug Winter, 2006) are in VFand XF grades, with coins inAU grades elusive and in 58or finer extremely rare.Wonderful original gold color is brought out by a strong satiny luster. Only the lightest brush of friction on the high points canbe seen. The details are nicely rendered, showing a strong, though not quite fully defined. Some teeny marks are noted, butnone are distracting and you do need a strong glass to find them. The eye appeal is great!PCGS 10, NGC 24, CAC 5. No CAC-approved example has ever sold in auction. The most recent PCGS example was theA.J. Vanderbilt Collection coin that realized $14,400. Prior to that one selling, an example sold in June 2017 for $7,638. As aCAC-approved, and highly original example, this piece should sell in excess of the current PCGS Price Guide value of $7,500.None of the seven PCGS graded coins that are finer have ever sold in auction, the finest is MS62. A single NGC MS63 is thefinest, last sold in Stack’s 1995 sale of the Ed Milas Collection. A real prize for the New Orleans $5 specialist, good luck!PCGS# 8230 | ESTIMATE: $7,500+ 243

LOT 473 $5 1854-C PCGS MS62 CAC Legend Rare Coin Auctions is proud to have been selected to offer this amazing “discovery” piece and prize of southern branch mint gold! One of the scarcest dates from the 1850s and the typical survivor is usually in the VF to XF range. Uncirculated examples are EXTREMELY RARE. This is among the FINEST 1854-C half eagles that exists, with only two MS63s graded finer at PCGS. Exceptionally eye appealing, this fully CHOICE example has a better than average strike and a soft, supple luster that engages the viewer. Some minor weakness is seen in the central devices, but the peripheral details are sharp. Good planchet stock was used to strike this coin without the striations or laminations that are often seen on this date. Greenish- golden hues, and some dirt that clings to the reverse rims attest to the absolute originality of this important gold coin. Unlike the majority of higher grade specimens encountered in auction or on the bourse, this coin has not been dipped, or otherwise conserved. This coin is completely FRESH to the market, part of an estate, and has NEVER been offered before being consigned to Regency Auction 27. This wonderful coin also serves as the current PCGS CoinFacts Plate Coin. Other Mint State coins include the James Stack-Harry Bass PCGS MS60; the Ed Milas NGC MS62; and the Ashland City NGC MS64, sold in 2000, 1995, and 2004 respectively. PCGS 3, NGC 1, CAC 1. This is the ONLY Mint State 1854-C half eagle to receive a CAC bean. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $25,000 and the only recent PCGS Mint State example to sell was a PCGS MS63 that realized $35,250. Since NO other PCGS Mint State coin has sold in 15 years+, this is an opportunity of the UTMOST IMPORTANCE for the advanced collector--DO NOT MISS IT! We can see this remarkable coin realizing a record price. Good luck, and congratulations in advance to the winning bidder. PCGS# 8257 | ESTIMATE: $25,000+244

LOT 474 $5 1858-D NGC AU58 CAC RARE in such a high grade, most of the 15,362 coins struck went right into antebellum commerce and it is extremely difficult to locate anything graded finer than AU58 or with any sort of originality! The presently offered coin is NOT your typical dipped, stripped, conserved bright yellow half eagle! Both sides have a great look with richer golden-orange with accents of olive and rose as you rotate the surfaces in a light. Only the slightest friction and a few light lines keep this high end 58 from a Mint State holder. PCGS 22, NGC 32, CAC 5. Only two CAC coins have ever sold in auction, the most recent selling for $7,800 in the 2018 Central States auction. The current CU value is $7,000. Any Mint State coin is going to cost $10,000+. This eye appealing coin will attract strong bidding. PCGS# 8278 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+LOT 475$5 1872-CC PCGS XF40CACJust a “perfect” XF exampleof this important CarsonCity $5. Soft golden surfacesshow traces of olive-green.Problem free light wear inthe fields and on the reliefsare evidence of use in wildwest commerce. The eyeappeal, for the assignedgrade is very high end!Only 16,980 were struck andsurvival estimates range from70-80 (per Doug Winter),to 92 (PCGS CoinFacts), to125-150 (Rusty Goe). This one came “out of the woodwork” from a South American collector, as such it is totally fresh to themarket, making its probable first ever auction appearance here.PCGS 5, NGC 6, CAC 3. It has been six years (!) since the last PCGS graded coin sold in auction. That one was CAC approved,but had no where near the eye appeal of this one, and realized just a hair under $5,500. Today, PCGS lists a value of $9,500.With its great looks, we know this one will face fierce bidding competition when it crosses the block!PCGS# 8326 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 245

LOT 476 LOT 477 $5 1893-O PCGS MS62 CAC $5 1909 PCGS MS64+ A lovely, original CHOICE 93-O $5. As one of the more Sharply struck on both sides, this near-gem example has common issues from the New Orleans mint. About 100-150 a bold, satiny mint frost that brings the rich orange-gold are estimated in Mint State, most in the MS60-62 range. surfaces to life. While there are a few ancient marks noted Strictly original pieces with “skin” are quite scarce indeed. with a strong glass, none detract from the bold eye appeal. Some mild abrasions are noted, none that are singularly distracting and none harm the rich, underlying luster. PCGS 49, NGC 11. It has been nearly two years since the last MS64+ example sold in auction, realizing $2,233 in PCGS 50, NGC 66, CAC 11. The most recent CAC coin was October 2016. More recently a regular MS64 brought $1,920 an NGC coin that sold for $2,585 in June 2017 and the last in February 2018. PCGS lists a value of $2,500 and keep in PCGS coin to sell was NOT CAC realizing the same in June mind a 65 will cost well over $7,000 (there’s not been one in auction for two years). These really are difficult to come by! 2016. These jump to well over $4,000 in 63. PCGS# 8385 | ESTIMATE: $2,300+ PCGS# 8513 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ LOT 478 $10 1854 PCGS MS61 CAC A major condition rarity in the No Motto Liberty series. Between PCGS and NGC there are about two dozen Mint State coins graded, including some likely duplication. The presently offered coin has a choice look! A thick mint frost blooms with a warm glow on original surfaces. The fields and devices show some very minor ticks that account for the assigned grade. The design elements on both sides are generally crisp in definition. The eye appeal is excellent for the modest grade, and a true prize for the specialist! PCGS 6, NGC 4, CAC 2. The other CAC-approved coin sold in June 2017 for $8,225 and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $9,000. In April 2018 a PCGS/CAC coin sold for $18,000. If you are working on a set of Lib $10s, you know how RARE many dates can be, and this one will fit nicely in ANY high grade set. PCGS# 8613 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+246

LOT 479 $10 1874-S PCGS AU55 A very scarce date with a mintage of only 10,000. Most of these went into circulation where they would remain for decades. David Akers’ concluding comments on this date were: “In fact, there aren’t really many 1874-S Eagles around in any grade.” This is a fact borne out by the population figures. The present CHOICE AU coin is very pleasing, with good color and ample mint bloom that survives despite the touch of high point wear. Some bagmarks, as normallyencountered on this date do not detract from the overall strong eye appeal. Looking this coin over closely, we are not exactly sure why did didn’t sticker over at CAC; we certainly like the coin. PCGS 5, NGC 11. At PCGS there are only three AU58s graded and NONE KNOWN in Mint State! The most recent example to sell in auction realized $9,000 in March 2018 and prior to that, one sold in June 2014 for $9,400. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $10,500. Remember, NO PCGS AU58 has sold since the May 2000 sale of the Bass Collection. PCGS# 8671 | ESTIMATE: $6,250+ LOT 480 LOT 481 $10 1878 PCGS MS61 CAC $10 1901 PCGS MS66 CACA lower mintage date, that saw only 73,780 produced. High A SUPERB $10 Lib! Beautiful GEM surfaces have a boldend for the modest grade; rich golden color is brought out by brilliant luster that swirls all over with bold cartwheeling a satiny glow. For the grade the eye appeal is exceptional. luster. A razor sharp strike on both sides shows fully frosted devices that stand out against the smooth, defect free PCGS 47, NGC 69, CAC 4. The last PCGS/CAC coin to sell surfaces. Exceptional eye appeal in all ways.in auction realized $1,116 in the 2016 ANA auction and the PCGS 37, NGC 52, CAC 12. EXTREMELY RARE any finer! current CU is $1,270. Add this nice BU coin to any The current PCGS price is $7,600 and the last CAC-approved gold holding. example sold in October 2015 for $7,931. Prior to that, the PCGS# 8680 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ other two APRs are for over $8,000. Perfect for any GEM Type set! PCGS# 8747 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 247

LOT 482 $10 1906-D PCGS MS65 CAC Since handling the Hall/ Simpson Collection of $10 we have learned so much about the later dates. A lot of these later dates are far harder to find then most people realize! The coin offered here is VERY high end and looks great! This date is NOT easy to find at all in GEM. Really satiny and smooth surfaces are boldly visible. Even using a strong glass will not disappoint you. The luster is strong and glowing. Both sides are an even moderate gold color. There are zero spots or discolorations. Miss Liberty and the details are frosty and are fully struck. The eye appeal is great! PCGS 32, NGC 22, CAC 8. The last CAC piece to sell in auction brought $9,400 in February 2018.-it was NGC. The only other piece ever sold at auction brought $7,931 in August 2016. The current Collector’s Universe value is $7,500. There is a strong demand for better gold like this. Be prepared! PCGS# 8760 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ LOT 483 $10 1906-O PCGS MS63 CAC A very lovely, original fully CHOICE example of the final New Orleans mint $10. Nicely struck devices show full definition in Liberty’s hair curls and tresses. A few tiny ticks are noted on the obverse but they do not detract from the brilliant golden luster and rich orange-gold hue. PCGS 47, NGC 36, CAC 14. The most recent example to sell in auction realized $7,800 in February 2018. Prior to that, the last CAC coin to sell was an NGC MS63 that brought $7,050 over four years ago. Clearly, CAC approved coins are not commonly found in the market place. The current CU value is listed at $6,500 and since CAC-coins have brought more than that the last two times, we would expect this coin would likewise do the same! PCGS# 8761 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+248